The following views regarding the mode of transmission of light are of so unorthodox a character that I set them down with some reluctance; but it seems to be generally admitted that the paradox of quantum theory cannot be resolved without doing violence to one or more of our cherished common notions.Some of the consequences of the theory that I am going to advance are repugnant to common sense, yet, searching in vain for an alternative and finding no physical fact of optics or of thermodynamics in opposition to the theory, I have come to regard it as a natural and indeed inevitable extension of Einstein's principle of relativity.Let me start with two statemefits which seem now to be well supported by experiment, although perhaps not entirely demonstrated.They are, however, the postulates upon which the following theory is built.
The following views regarding the mode of transmission of light are of so unorthodox a character that I set them down with some reluctance; but it seems to be generally admitted that the paradox of quantum theory cannot be resolved without doing violence to one or more of our cherished common notions.Some of the consequences of the theory that I am going to advance are repugnant to common sense, yet, searching in vain for an alternative and finding no physical fact of optics or of thermodynamics in opposition to the theory, I have come to regard it as a natural and indeed inevitable extension of Einstein's principle of relativity.Let me start with two statemefits which seem now to be well supported by experiment, although perhaps not entirely demonstrated.They are, however, the postulates upon which the following theory is built.
In a recent article in these Proceedings (1) Professor G. N. Lewis has suggested that the conflict between the quantum theory of light and the known facts of interference might be resolved by assuming that an atom never emits a quantum of light except to another atom, the possibility of transmission of the quantum being determined by the nature of the paths connecting the two atoms in such a manner that the transmission will not occur if forbidden by the known laws of interference. The idea is made more plausible by describing such transmissions with the help of Minkowski's four-dimensional geometry of relativity.
When a theory is framed trying to explain a discrepant system of facts, it is a necessary process of thought to take some branch of the theory as more completely true than the rest, and to adjust the remaining parts in such a way that they will fit in with this base, though they may still conflict with one another. This has certainly been true of the quantum theory; the speculations connected with it have as their base the law of the conservation of energy. Now a critical examination of fundamentals does not by any means justify this faith. It is of course a fact of observation that in the gross energy is conserved, but this only means an averaged energy; and as pure dynamics has failed to explain many atomic phenomena there seems no reason to maintain the exact conservation of energy, which is only one of the consequences of the dynamical equations. Indeed it is hardly too much to say that had the photoelectric effect been discovered a century ago, it is probable that no one would ever have suggested that the status of the first law of thermodynamics was in any way different from that of the second. On the other hand, Bohr's theory, and especially Sommerfeld's extension of it, have given great encouragement to the belief that in dynamics lay the way to the complete truth, so that in consequence of the triumphs of that theory there has been little thought in other directions. Another impediment is that our whole ideas are saturated with the principles of energy, so that denying it leaves hardly any foundation from which to start.
We argue that the double-slit experiment can be understood much better by considering it as an experiment whereby
one uses electrons to study the set-up rather than an experiment whereby we use a set-up to study the behaviour of electrons.
We also show that the concept of undecidability (like e.g. occurs in G\odel's theorem) can be used in an intuitive way to make sense of the double-slit experiment
and the quantum rules for calculating coherent and incoherent probabilities. We meet here a situation where the electrons always behave in a fully
deterministic way, while the detailed design of the set-up may render the question about the way they move through the set-up experimentally undecidable.
It is very important to make a distinction in quantum mechanics
between the determinism of nature (Einstein)
and the decidability of a question within an experimental set-up (Bohr).
The former is about the absolute truth of an answer to a yes or no question, and follows binary logic
(true or false),
the latter about what an experimental set-up
can decide and tell about the truth of that answer, and follows ternary logic (true, false or undecidable).
Binary and ternary logic are incompatible.
The viewpoints of Bohr and Einstein are thus operating on different levels and it is only by confusing these two levels
that these two viewpoints seem to be irreconcilable.
We show that the expression ψ1+ψ2 for the wave function of the double-slit experiment is numerically correct, but logically flawed. It has to be replaced in the interference region
by the logically correct expression ψ1′+ψ2′, which has the same numerical value as
ψ1+ψ2, such that ψ1′+ψ2′=ψ1+ψ2,
but with ψ1′=2ψ1+ψ2e4π=ψ1 and
ψ2′=2ψ1+ψ2e−4π=ψ2.
Here ψ1′ and ψ2′ are the correct
contributions from the slits to the total wave function ψ1′+ψ2′.
We have then $p = |\psi'_{1} + \psi'_{2}|^{2} = |\psi'_{1}|^{2} + |\psi'_{2}|^{2} = p_{1}+p_{2} $ such that the paradox
that quantum mechanics (QM) would not follow the traditional rules of probability calculus disappears.
The paradox is rooted in the wrong intuition that ψ1 and ψ2 would be the true physical contributions to
ψ1′+ψ2′=ψ1+ψ2 like in the case of waves in a water tank.
The solution proposed here is not {\em ad hoc} but based on an extensive analysis of the geometrical meaning of spinors within group representation theory
and its application to QM. Working further on the argument one can even show that an interference pattern is the only way to satisfy simultaneously
two conditions: The condition obeying binary logic (in the spirit of Einstein) that the electron has only two mutually exclusive options to get to the detector (viz. going through slit S1 or going through slit S2) and the condition obeying ternary logic (in the spirit of Bohr)
that the question which one of these two options the electron has taken is experimentally undecidable.
A very important element in the analysis is the problem of the non-existence of {\em common} probability distributions for different experimental set-ups.
And this is a recurrent theme in other situations that are felt as paradoxical.
The CHSH inequality used in the experiments of Aspect {\em et al.}
clashes with quantum mechanics because it
is based on the assumption that there would exist a {\em common} probability distribution for the
hidden variables in the different experiments that have to be made to determine the various quantities that intervene in the inequality.
That common probability distribution for measured quantities does not exist is well known from quantum mechanics itself (because the operators that come into play do not commute and therefore do not have common eigenstates, i.e.
common probability amplitudes). But this non-existence of common probability distributions applies also to certain variables in the set-ups of the different experiments and the latter fact
can also be explained by purely classical reasoning.
A physical principle that has consequences for the topology of a relativistic space-time is the principle of Einstein-Weyl causality. We show that these consequences also have quantum mechanical manifestations. Borchers and Sen have rigorously investigated the mathematical implications of Einstein-Weyl causality, regarded as a partial order, for the underlying spaces. This partial order was axiomatized by them and shown to admit Q^2 as an ordered space. They subsequently proved that, given certain topological assumptions, these spaces satisfying Einstein-Weyl causality are densely imbedded in spaces that have locally the structure of differentiable manifolds. They were left, however, with important philosophical paradoxes regarding the nature of the physical real line E, e.g., whether E = R, the real line of mathematics. We can view their original result, without further assumptions, as an insight into a denumerable space-time. This would suggest an investigation into a constructible foundation for relativistic physics. A set theoretical foundation is proposed including an axiom of countable constructibility. We first show that this constructible theory actually contains polynomial functions which are locally homeomorphic with a dense, denumerable metric space R*. Eigenfunctions governing fields can then be effectively obtained by iteration. Postulating a Lagrangian for fields in a compactified space-time, we get a general field description of which the Schrodinger equation is a special case. From these results we can then also show that this denumerable space-time is relational (in the sense that space is not infinitesimally small if and only if it contains a quantized field) and that, since Q^2 is imbedded in R*^2, it directly fulfills the strict topological requirements for Einstein-Weyl causality. Therefore, the theory predicts that E = R*.