Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation

Barrier Heights in Quantum Monte Carlo with Linear-Scaling Generalized-Valence-Bond Wave Functions

F. David Fracchia, Claudia Filippi, C. Amovilli

Published Jul 10, 2013• 18 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We investigate here the performance of our recently developed linear-scaling Jastrow-generalized-valence-bond (J-LGVB) wave functions based on localized orbitals, for the quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) calculation of the barrier heights and reaction energies of five prototypical chemical reactions. Using the geometrical parameters from the Minnesota database collection, we consider three hydrogen-exchanges, one heavy-atom exchange, and one association reaction and compare our results with the best available experimental and theoretical data. For the three hydrogen-exchange reactions, we find that the J-LGVB wave functions yield excellent QMC results, with average deviations from the reference values below 0.5 kcal/mol. For the heavy-atom exchange and association reactions, additional resonance structures are important, and we therefore extend our original formulation to include multiple coupling schemes characterized by different sets of localized orbitals. We denote these wave functions as J-MC-LGVB, where MC indicates the multiconfiguration generalization, and show that such a form leads to very accurate barrier heights and reaction energies also for the last two reactions. We can therefore conclude that the J-LGVB theory for constructing QMC wave functions, with its multiconfiguration generalization, is valid for the study of large portions of ground-state potential energy surfaces including, in particular, the region of transition states.

DOI
10.1021/ct400395u

Related papers

H + H2 reaction barrier: A fixed-node quantum Monte Carlo study

R. N. Barnett, PETER J. REYNOLDS, William A. Lester

The classical barrier height for the H+H2 exchange reaction, as well as the energies at two other points along the reaction path, are calculated using fixed-node quantum Monte Carlo (FNQMC). Several single-determinant importance functions are used at the saddle point in order to relate the quality of the importance function to the accuracy and precision of the final result. The computed barrier is an upper bound since the energy of H and of H2 is obtained exactly by FNQMC. Our best upper bound (9.70±0.13 kcal/mol) has a mean within 0.1 kcal/mol of the presumed exact value. This best bound is obtained with a single determinant, double-zeta basis importance function. Contrary to experience with expansion methods, it is found that an importance function with a basis set of near Hartree–Fock quality, as well as one derived from a spin-unrestricted SCF calculation, are among the least efficient and least accurate of the importance functions used. Specifically, a nodal surface appearing in the lowest energy molecular orbital in these functions apparently increases the FNQMC energy. The FNQMC energy at the two other points along the reaction path is found to agree with the most accurate CI results of Liu to within statistical error.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Mar 15, 1985•69 citations

FIXED-NODE QUANTUM MONTE CARLO STUDY OF THE CLASSICAL BARRIER HEIGHT FOR THE H + H2 EXCHANGE REACTION

Will Lester

The classical barrier height for the H + H 2 exchange reaction, as well as the energies at two other points along the reaction path, are calculated using fixed-node quantum Monte Carlo (FNQMC).Several single-determinant importance functions are used at the saddle-point in order to relate the quality of the importance function to the accuracy and precision of the final result.The computed barrier is an upper bound since the energy of H and of H 2 is obtained exactly by FNQMC.Our best upper bound, 9.70 ~ 0.13 kcal/mole, has a mean within 0.1 kcal/mole of the presumed exact value.This best bound is obtained with a single determinant, double-zeta basis importance function.Contrary to experience with expansion methods, it is found that an importance function with a basis set of near Hartree-Fock quality, as well as one derived from a spin-unrestricted SCF calculation, are among the least efficient and least accurate of the importance functions used.Specifically, a nodal surface appearing in the lowest energy molecular orbital in these functions apparently increases the FNQMC energy.The FNQMC energy at the two other points along the reaction path is found to agree with the most accurate CI results of Liu to within statistical error.

•Oct 1, 1984•0 citations

Multi‐level quantum monte Carlo wave functions for complex reactions: The decomposition of α‐hydroxy‐dimethylnitrosamine

F. David Fracchia, Claudia Filippi, C. Amovilli

We present here several novel features of our recently proposed Jastrow linear generalized valence bond (J-LGVB) wave functions, which allow a consistently accurate description of complex potential energy surfaces (PES) of medium-large systems within quantum Monte Carlo (QMC). In particular, we develop a multilevel scheme to treat different regions of the molecule at different levels of the theory. As prototypical study case, we investigate the decomposition of α-hydroxy-dimethylnitrosamine, a carcinogenic metabolite of dimethylnitrosamine (NDMA), through a two-step mechanism of isomerization followed by a retro-ene reaction. We compute a reliable reaction path with the quadratic configuration interaction method and employ QMC for the calculation of the electronic energies. We show that the use of multideterminantal wave functions is very important to correctly describe the critical points of this PES within QMC, and that our multilevel J-LGVB approach is an effective tool to significantly reduce the cost of QMC calculations without loss of accuracy. As regards the complex PES of α-hydroxy-dimethylnitrosamine, the accurate energies computed with our approach allows us to confirm the validity of the two-step reaction mechanism of decomposition originally proposed within density functional theory, but with some important differences in the barrier heights of the individual steps.

Journal of Computational Chemistry•Oct 21, 2013•6 citations

Linear-scaling quantum Monte Carlo calculations

Andrew Williamson, Randolph Q. Hood, Jeffrey C. Grossman

Abstract This study demonstrates linear scaling with system size in fixednode diffusion QMC calculations with pseudopotentials for carbon fullerenes and for hydrogenated silicon clusters with nearly 1000 valence electrons. The range covered is C20 to C18o and SiH4 to Si211H140, The calculations were carried out with standard pseudopotentials (leaving four electrons per C or Si atom) and Slater Jastrow trial functions with orbitals from LDA density functional calculations. The key elements leading to linear scaling were constructions of sparse determinants and simplification of orbital functions. The LDA orbitals were obtained with a plane-wave basis set which was transformed to yield Wannier functions with maximum localization. These functions were then fitted to cubic spline expressions with a limited number of grid points and cut-off distances matching those of the plane-wave orbitals. The computational effort for evaluating trial functions of this type was clearly seen to behave in a linear fashion. Exploration of the effects of variation of cut-off radius revealed that energies, sensitive only to node structures, increased rapidly for cut-offs less than 7 bohr but were unaffected for cutoffs greater than 7 bohr. The accuracies of the calculations were checked in other ways. These included comparison calculations for SiH3 and Si5H12 using Gaussian, original plane-wave, and Wannier function basis sets which gave close agreement for energies.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jun 18, 2007•0 citations

Benchmark all-electron ab initio quantum Monte Carlo calculations for small molecules

Norbert Nemec, Michael D. Towler, Richard J. Needs

We study the efficiency, precision and accuracy of all-electron variational and diffusion quantum Monte Carlo calculations using Slater basis sets. Starting from wave functions generated by Hartree-Fock and density functional theory, we describe an algorithm to enforce the electron-nucleus cusp condition by linear projection. For the 55 molecules in the G2 set, the diffusion quantum Monte Carlo calculations recovers an average of 95% of the correlation energy and reproduces bond energies to a mean absolute deviation of 3.2 kcal/mol. Comparing the individual total energies with essentially exact values, we investigate the error cancellation in atomization and chemical reaction path energies, giving additional insight into the sizes of nodal surface errors.

arXiv:0908.2041•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jan 21, 2010•82 citations

Quantum Monte Carlo study of the classical barrier height for the H + H2 exchange reaction: Restricted versus unrestricted trial functions

PETER J. REYNOLDS, R. N. Barnett, W. A. Lester

The fixed-node quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) method is used to obtain the classical barrier height for the H + H2 exchange reaction. Using a spin-restricted, single-determinant trial function ΨT, the authors find that the reaction barrier Eb is less than 9.69 ± 0.25 kcal/mol. This mean value is below the calculated energy barrier obtained by Liu in the most extensive CI calculations on this system. Furthermore, the QMC saddle-point energy of – 1.65903 ± 0.00040 hartrees at the CI-determined geometry lies 0.00027 a.u. (0.17 kcal/mol) below Liu's best CI value. Finally, spinrestricted and spin-unrestricted single-determinant trial functions are contrasted. Although the variational energy 〈ΨT|H|ΨT〉 for an SCF ΨT must be lower for the unrestricted case, this is not true generally for QMC. In fact, we show that if the unrestricted SCF ΨT has the lower QMC energy, then there exists another spin-restricted, single-determinant ΨT whose QMC energy is lower than the QMC energy of the spin-restricted SCF ΨT.

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Mar 1, 1984•15 citations
We investigate here the performance of our recently developed linear-scaling Jastrow-generalized-valence-bond (J-LGVB) wave functions based on localized orbitals, for the quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) calculation of the barrier heights and reaction energies of five prototypical chemical reactions. Using the geometrical parameters from the Minnesota database collection, we consider three hydrogen-exchanges, one heavy-atom exchange, and one association reaction and compare our results with the best available experimental and theoretical data. For the three hydrogen-exchange reactions, we find that the J-LGVB wave functions yield excellent QMC results, with average deviations from the reference values below 0.5 kcal/mol. For the heavy-atom exchange and association reactions, additional resonance structures are important, and we therefore extend our original formulation to include multiple coupling schemes characterized by different sets of localized orbitals. We denote these wave functions as J-MC-LGVB, where MC indicates the multiconfiguration generalization, and show that such a form leads to very accurate barrier heights and reaction energies also for the last two reactions. We can therefore conclude that the J-LGVB theory for constructing QMC wave functions, with its multiconfiguration generalization, is valid for the study of large portions of ground-state potential energy surfaces including, in particular, the region of transition states.
The classical barrier height for the H+H2 exchange reaction, as well as the energies at two other points along the reaction path, are calculated using fixed-node quantum Monte Carlo (FNQMC). Several single-determinant importance functions are used at the saddle point in order to relate the quality of the importance function to the accuracy and precision of the final result. The computed barrier is an upper bound since the energy of H and of H2 is obtained exactly by FNQMC. Our best upper bound (9.70±0.13 kcal/mol) has a mean within 0.1 kcal/mol of the presumed exact value. This best bound is obtained with a single determinant, double-zeta basis importance function. Contrary to experience with expansion methods, it is found that an importance function with a basis set of near Hartree–Fock quality, as well as one derived from a spin-unrestricted SCF calculation, are among the least efficient and least accurate of the importance functions used. Specifically, a nodal surface appearing in the lowest energy molecular orbital in these functions apparently increases the FNQMC energy. The FNQMC energy at the two other points along the reaction path is found to agree with the most accurate CI results of Liu to within statistical error.
The classical barrier height for the H + H 2 exchange reaction, as well as the energies at two other points along the reaction path, are calculated using fixed-node quantum Monte Carlo (FNQMC).Several single-determinant importance functions are used at the saddle-point in order to relate the quality of the importance function to the accuracy and precision of the final result.The computed barrier is an upper bound since the energy of H and of H 2 is obtained exactly by FNQMC.Our best upper bound, 9.70 ~ 0.13 kcal/mole, has a mean within 0.1 kcal/mole of the presumed exact value.This best bound is obtained with a single determinant, double-zeta basis importance function.Contrary to experience with expansion methods, it is found that an importance function with a basis set of near Hartree-Fock quality, as well as one derived from a spin-unrestricted SCF calculation, are among the least efficient and least accurate of the importance functions used.Specifically, a nodal surface appearing in the lowest energy molecular orbital in these functions apparently increases the FNQMC energy.The FNQMC energy at the two other points along the reaction path is found to agree with the most accurate CI results of Liu to within statistical error.
We present here several novel features of our recently proposed Jastrow linear generalized valence bond (J-LGVB) wave functions, which allow a consistently accurate description of complex potential energy surfaces (PES) of medium-large systems within quantum Monte Carlo (QMC). In particular, we develop a multilevel scheme to treat different regions of the molecule at different levels of the theory. As prototypical study case, we investigate the decomposition of α-hydroxy-dimethylnitrosamine, a carcinogenic metabolite of dimethylnitrosamine (NDMA), through a two-step mechanism of isomerization followed by a retro-ene reaction. We compute a reliable reaction path with the quadratic configuration interaction method and employ QMC for the calculation of the electronic energies. We show that the use of multideterminantal wave functions is very important to correctly describe the critical points of this PES within QMC, and that our multilevel J-LGVB approach is an effective tool to significantly reduce the cost of QMC calculations without loss of accuracy. As regards the complex PES of α-hydroxy-dimethylnitrosamine, the accurate energies computed with our approach allows us to confirm the validity of the two-step reaction mechanism of decomposition originally proposed within density functional theory, but with some important differences in the barrier heights of the individual steps.
Abstract This study demonstrates linear scaling with system size in fixednode diffusion QMC calculations with pseudopotentials for carbon fullerenes and for hydrogenated silicon clusters with nearly 1000 valence electrons. The range covered is C20 to C18o and SiH4 to Si211H140, The calculations were carried out with standard pseudopotentials (leaving four electrons per C or Si atom) and Slater Jastrow trial functions with orbitals from LDA density functional calculations. The key elements leading to linear scaling were constructions of sparse determinants and simplification of orbital functions. The LDA orbitals were obtained with a plane-wave basis set which was transformed to yield Wannier functions with maximum localization. These functions were then fitted to cubic spline expressions with a limited number of grid points and cut-off distances matching those of the plane-wave orbitals. The computational effort for evaluating trial functions of this type was clearly seen to behave in a linear fashion. Exploration of the effects of variation of cut-off radius revealed that energies, sensitive only to node structures, increased rapidly for cut-offs less than 7 bohr but were unaffected for cutoffs greater than 7 bohr. The accuracies of the calculations were checked in other ways. These included comparison calculations for SiH3 and Si5H12 using Gaussian, original plane-wave, and Wannier function basis sets which gave close agreement for energies.
We study the efficiency, precision and accuracy of all-electron variational and diffusion quantum Monte Carlo calculations using Slater basis sets. Starting from wave functions generated by Hartree-Fock and density functional theory, we describe an algorithm to enforce the electron-nucleus cusp condition by linear projection. For the 55 molecules in the G2 set, the diffusion quantum Monte Carlo calculations recovers an average of 95% of the correlation energy and reproduces bond energies to a mean absolute deviation of 3.2 kcal/mol. Comparing the individual total energies with essentially exact values, we investigate the error cancellation in atomization and chemical reaction path energies, giving additional insight into the sizes of nodal surface errors.
The fixed-node quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) method is used to obtain the classical barrier height for the H + H2 exchange reaction. Using a spin-restricted, single-determinant trial function ΨT, the authors find that the reaction barrier Eb is less than 9.69 ± 0.25 kcal/mol. This mean value is below the calculated energy barrier obtained by Liu in the most extensive CI calculations on this system. Furthermore, the QMC saddle-point energy of – 1.65903 ± 0.00040 hartrees at the CI-determined geometry lies 0.00027 a.u. (0.17 kcal/mol) below Liu's best CI value. Finally, spinrestricted and spin-unrestricted single-determinant trial functions are contrasted. Although the variational energy 〈ΨT|H|ΨT〉 for an SCF ΨT must be lower for the unrestricted case, this is not true generally for QMC. In fact, we show that if the unrestricted SCF ΨT has the lower QMC energy, then there exists another spin-restricted, single-determinant ΨT whose QMC energy is lower than the QMC energy of the spin-restricted SCF ΨT.