Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry

A density functional representation of quantum chemistry. II. Local quantum field theories of molecular matter in terms of the charge density operator do not work

Hans Primas, M. Schleicher

Published Sep 1, 1975• 8 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract A comprehensive review of the attempts to rephrase molecular quantum mechanics in terms of the particle density operator and the current density or phase density operator is given. All pertinent investigations which have come to our attention suffer from severe mathematical inconsistencies and are not adequate to the few‐body problem of quantum chemistry. The origin of the failure of these attempts is investigated and it is shown that a realization of a local quantum field theory of molecular matter in terms of observables would presuppose the solution of many highly nontrivial mathematical problems.

DOI
10.1002/qua.560090509

Related papers

A density functional representation of quantum chemistry. III. Rigorous realization of the program in lattice space

M. Schleicher, Hans Primas

Abstract A mathematically rigorous reformulation of molecular quantum mechanics in terms of the particle density operator and a canonically conjugated phase field is given. Using a momentum cutoff, it is shown that the usual molecular Hamiltonian can be expressed in terms of the particle density operator and a rigorously defined phase operator. It is shown that this Hamiltonian converges strongly to the cutoff‐free Hamiltonian. In spite of the fact that this Hamiltonian is of second order in the phase operators, all hitherto published expressions are not correct. Unfortunately, the correct formulation destroys the intuitive appeal of using the particle density operator as a coordinate for the many‐body problems of quantum chemistry. Unless somebody provides an essential new and clever idea, we propose to resist the fascination of a local quantum field theory of molecular matter in terms of the particle density operator.

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Sep 1, 1975•1 citation

A density functional representation of quantum chemistry. I. Motivation and general formalism

Hans Primas

Abstract The molecular N‐electron problem is formulated in terms of the particle density 𝔔(r) = ∑σ(r − qn) and its canonically conjugated field. Weyl's representation of the canonical commutation relations is used and a characteristic functional of the molecular system is introduced as the expectation value of Weyl's functional exp {i(α, Q) + i(β, P)}. The Hamiltonian equation of motion for the characteristic functional is derived and its cumulant approximation is discussed. The first paper is restricted to a general discussion, independent of a special choice of the Hamiltonian. The density functional representation may be considered as a step towards a formulation of a renormalized quantum chemistry. The lowest order cumulants of the characteristic functional are accessible to actual precision measurements; on the other hand, most experiments are correctly represented by a characteristic functional of the Gaussian type. The significance of the higher order correlations is neither theoretically nor experimentally disclosed yet, their possible importance for biological systems is mentioned, and the question is raised of how far quantum mechanics is empirically confirmed for extremely complex systems.

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Jul 1, 1967•20 citations

MATHEMATICAL DENSITY AND DENSITY MATRIX FUNCTIONAL THEORY (DFT AND DMFT)

Volker Bach

These notes give a survey on mathematical results concerning approximations to the ground state and the ground state energy of large atoms and molecules in terms of density functional theory of density matrix functional theory. In particular, stability of matter is proved, as well as, the asymptotic validity of the Hartree-Fock approximation in the limit of large nuclear charges. The latter requires the use of correlation in-equalities which are derived here and related to some notions from the theory of N -representability, such as the G, P, and Q conditions and also Erdahl's T 1 and T 2 conditions. The latter have recently drawn a lot of attention in quantum chemistry.

Lecture notes series, Institute For Mathematical Sciences•Jun 19, 2013•2 citations

Zur Theorie grosser Molekeln. I. Revision der Grundlagen der Quantenchemie

Hans Primas

Abstract The present day quantum chemistry is mathematically based on von NEUMANN'S formulation of quantum mechanics and therefore not able to deal correctly with anomal quantum states. A general theory of large molecules and large molecular systems has to be founded on quantum field theory allowing for inequivalent irreducible representations. It is proposed to formulate quantum chemistry in the framework of the B*‐algebra of the observables. The paradox of molecular systems having an infinite number of degrees of freedom is discussed, and the possible significance of anomal molecular quantum states for molecular biology is pointed out.

Helvetica Chimica Acta•Jul 10, 1968•7 citations

Mathematical Methods in Quantum Chemistry

Geneviève Dusson, Michael F. Herbst, Benjamin Stamm

Quantum chemistry focuses on modelling and simulating the behaviour of molecular systems using the fundamental principles of quantum mechanics. However, the underlying equations, such as the Schrödinger equation for computing the ground state of N electrons, which is a partial differential equation defined on \mathbb{R}^{3N} , suffer from the curse of dimensionality. As a result, simulating even moderately sized molecules demands advanced techniques in analysis, approximation and reduced-order modelling for overcoming the naive computational complexity. In this workshop, the rapidly growing mathematical community working in the field together with several quantum chemists and physicists were gathered to discuss recent advances in areas such as (1) the mathematical and numerical analysis of standard models used in the field, including Density Functional Theory, Coupled Cluster, and the Density Matrix Renormalization Group (2) the development of efficient numerical methods, relying e.g. on the development of error bounds and (3) the opportunities of recent data-driven methods towards the approximation of wavefunctions or density matrices.

Oberwolfach Reports•Aug 29, 2025•0 citations

Density matrices and density functionals : proceedings of the A. John Coleman symposium

Alan Coleman, Robert Erdahl, Vedene H. Smith

A Tribute to A. John Coleman - The Tame Mathematician.- Reduced Density Matrices: 1929-1989.- Some Aspects on the Development of the Theory of Reduced Density Matrices and the Representability Problem.- Representability Conditions.- On the Diagonal N-Representability Problem.- Fermion N-Representability Conditions Generated by a Decomposition of the 1-Particle Identity Operator onto Mutually Orthogonal Projection Operators.- The Unitarily Invariant Decomposition of Hermitian Operators.- Building Up N-Electron States with Symplectic Symmetry.- Time Dependent Antisymmetrized Geminal Power Theory Using a Coherent State Formulation.- Griffiths Inequalities for Fermion Systems.- Entropy of Reduced Density Matrices.- A Lower Bound to the Ground State Energy of a Boson System With Fermion Source.- Reduced Density Operators, Their Related von Neumann Density Operators, Close Cousins of These, and Their Physical Interpretation.- Theory and Practice of the Spin-Adapted Reduced Hamiltonians (SRH).- Variational Principle with Built-In Pure State N-Representability Conditions. The N-Electron Case.- Wigner Distributions as Representations of the Density Matrix.- Inter-Relationships Between Various Representations of One-Matrices and Related Densities: A Road Map and an Example ..- Current Problems in Density Functional Theory.- The Interface Between Reduced Density Matrices and Density Functional Theory.- The Physics Underlying the Langreth-Mehl Scheme for Non-Uniform Systems.- Understanding Energy Differences in Density Functional Theory.- Density Functional Calculations of Molecular Bond Energies.- Non-Local Effects on Atomic and Molecular Correlation Energies Studied with a Gradient-Corrected Density Functional.- An Evaluation of Local Electron Correlation Corrections and Non-Local Exchange Corrections to the Hartree-Fock-Slater Method from Calculations on Bond Energies and Electronic Spectra of Molecular Systems.- Correlation Energy Functionals of One-Matrices and Hartree-Fock Densities.- Some Remarks on Scaling Relations in Density Functional Theory.- Deduction of Semiempirical MO Methods from Density Functional Theory.- Charge and Spin Densities in Molecular Solids: Local Density Functional Calculations Versus Experiment.- A Functional of the Two-Particle Density Matrix for the Approximate Calculation of the Electronic Correlation Energy.- Extracules, Intracules, Correlation Holes, Potentials, Coefficients and All That.- The Exact Schroedinger Equation for the Electron Density.- Adiabatic Separation, Broken Symmetries and Geometry Optimization.- Asymptotic Results for Density Matrices and Electron Density in Atoms and Nearly Spherical Molecules.- An Algorithm for Calculating Isoelectronic Changes in Energies, Densities, and One-Matrices.- Atoms and Ions in the Limit of Large Nuclear Charge.- Improved Thomas-Fermi Theory for Atoms.- A Bond Energy from Quantum Mechanics.- Measured Electron Densities and Band Structure Calculations.- X-ray Orthonormal Orbital Model for Crystallography.

D. Reidel Pub. Co. eBooks•Jan 1, 1987•19 citations
Abstract A comprehensive review of the attempts to rephrase molecular quantum mechanics in terms of the particle density operator and the current density or phase density operator is given. All pertinent investigations which have come to our attention suffer from severe mathematical inconsistencies and are not adequate to the few‐body problem of quantum chemistry. The origin of the failure of these attempts is investigated and it is shown that a realization of a local quantum field theory of molecular matter in terms of observables would presuppose the solution of many highly nontrivial mathematical problems.
Abstract A mathematically rigorous reformulation of molecular quantum mechanics in terms of the particle density operator and a canonically conjugated phase field is given. Using a momentum cutoff, it is shown that the usual molecular Hamiltonian can be expressed in terms of the particle density operator and a rigorously defined phase operator. It is shown that this Hamiltonian converges strongly to the cutoff‐free Hamiltonian. In spite of the fact that this Hamiltonian is of second order in the phase operators, all hitherto published expressions are not correct. Unfortunately, the correct formulation destroys the intuitive appeal of using the particle density operator as a coordinate for the many‐body problems of quantum chemistry. Unless somebody provides an essential new and clever idea, we propose to resist the fascination of a local quantum field theory of molecular matter in terms of the particle density operator.
Abstract The molecular N‐electron problem is formulated in terms of the particle density 𝔔(r) = ∑σ(r − qn) and its canonically conjugated field. Weyl's representation of the canonical commutation relations is used and a characteristic functional of the molecular system is introduced as the expectation value of Weyl's functional exp {i(α, Q) + i(β, P)}. The Hamiltonian equation of motion for the characteristic functional is derived and its cumulant approximation is discussed. The first paper is restricted to a general discussion, independent of a special choice of the Hamiltonian. The density functional representation may be considered as a step towards a formulation of a renormalized quantum chemistry. The lowest order cumulants of the characteristic functional are accessible to actual precision measurements; on the other hand, most experiments are correctly represented by a characteristic functional of the Gaussian type. The significance of the higher order correlations is neither theoretically nor experimentally disclosed yet, their possible importance for biological systems is mentioned, and the question is raised of how far quantum mechanics is empirically confirmed for extremely complex systems.
These notes give a survey on mathematical results concerning approximations to the ground state and the ground state energy of large atoms and molecules in terms of density functional theory of density matrix functional theory. In particular, stability of matter is proved, as well as, the asymptotic validity of the Hartree-Fock approximation in the limit of large nuclear charges. The latter requires the use of correlation in-equalities which are derived here and related to some notions from the theory of N -representability, such as the G, P, and Q conditions and also Erdahl's T 1 and T 2 conditions. The latter have recently drawn a lot of attention in quantum chemistry.
Abstract The present day quantum chemistry is mathematically based on von NEUMANN'S formulation of quantum mechanics and therefore not able to deal correctly with anomal quantum states. A general theory of large molecules and large molecular systems has to be founded on quantum field theory allowing for inequivalent irreducible representations. It is proposed to formulate quantum chemistry in the framework of the B*‐algebra of the observables. The paradox of molecular systems having an infinite number of degrees of freedom is discussed, and the possible significance of anomal molecular quantum states for molecular biology is pointed out.
Quantum chemistry focuses on modelling and simulating the behaviour of molecular systems using the fundamental principles of quantum mechanics. However, the underlying equations, such as the Schrödinger equation for computing the ground state of N electrons, which is a partial differential equation defined on \mathbb{R}^{3N} , suffer from the curse of dimensionality. As a result, simulating even moderately sized molecules demands advanced techniques in analysis, approximation and reduced-order modelling for overcoming the naive computational complexity. In this workshop, the rapidly growing mathematical community working in the field together with several quantum chemists and physicists were gathered to discuss recent advances in areas such as (1) the mathematical and numerical analysis of standard models used in the field, including Density Functional Theory, Coupled Cluster, and the Density Matrix Renormalization Group (2) the development of efficient numerical methods, relying e.g. on the development of error bounds and (3) the opportunities of recent data-driven methods towards the approximation of wavefunctions or density matrices.
A Tribute to A. John Coleman - The Tame Mathematician.- Reduced Density Matrices: 1929-1989.- Some Aspects on the Development of the Theory of Reduced Density Matrices and the Representability Problem.- Representability Conditions.- On the Diagonal N-Representability Problem.- Fermion N-Representability Conditions Generated by a Decomposition of the 1-Particle Identity Operator onto Mutually Orthogonal Projection Operators.- The Unitarily Invariant Decomposition of Hermitian Operators.- Building Up N-Electron States with Symplectic Symmetry.- Time Dependent Antisymmetrized Geminal Power Theory Using a Coherent State Formulation.- Griffiths Inequalities for Fermion Systems.- Entropy of Reduced Density Matrices.- A Lower Bound to the Ground State Energy of a Boson System With Fermion Source.- Reduced Density Operators, Their Related von Neumann Density Operators, Close Cousins of These, and Their Physical Interpretation.- Theory and Practice of the Spin-Adapted Reduced Hamiltonians (SRH).- Variational Principle with Built-In Pure State N-Representability Conditions. The N-Electron Case.- Wigner Distributions as Representations of the Density Matrix.- Inter-Relationships Between Various Representations of One-Matrices and Related Densities: A Road Map and an Example ..- Current Problems in Density Functional Theory.- The Interface Between Reduced Density Matrices and Density Functional Theory.- The Physics Underlying the Langreth-Mehl Scheme for Non-Uniform Systems.- Understanding Energy Differences in Density Functional Theory.- Density Functional Calculations of Molecular Bond Energies.- Non-Local Effects on Atomic and Molecular Correlation Energies Studied with a Gradient-Corrected Density Functional.- An Evaluation of Local Electron Correlation Corrections and Non-Local Exchange Corrections to the Hartree-Fock-Slater Method from Calculations on Bond Energies and Electronic Spectra of Molecular Systems.- Correlation Energy Functionals of One-Matrices and Hartree-Fock Densities.- Some Remarks on Scaling Relations in Density Functional Theory.- Deduction of Semiempirical MO Methods from Density Functional Theory.- Charge and Spin Densities in Molecular Solids: Local Density Functional Calculations Versus Experiment.- A Functional of the Two-Particle Density Matrix for the Approximate Calculation of the Electronic Correlation Energy.- Extracules, Intracules, Correlation Holes, Potentials, Coefficients and All That.- The Exact Schroedinger Equation for the Electron Density.- Adiabatic Separation, Broken Symmetries and Geometry Optimization.- Asymptotic Results for Density Matrices and Electron Density in Atoms and Nearly Spherical Molecules.- An Algorithm for Calculating Isoelectronic Changes in Energies, Densities, and One-Matrices.- Atoms and Ions in the Limit of Large Nuclear Charge.- Improved Thomas-Fermi Theory for Atoms.- A Bond Energy from Quantum Mechanics.- Measured Electron Densities and Band Structure Calculations.- X-ray Orthonormal Orbital Model for Crystallography.