Fermion mean-field solutions for the Heisenberg and the t-J models have been obtained by considering particle-hole correlations and carrying out the mean-field-theory calculations in momentum space. At half-filling the solutions have mixed (s\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}d)-wave-like symmetry and have a lower ground-state energy than the s (uniform phase) and the d phases. On doping, the solutions with mixed s and d symmetry still have lower ground-state energy than the uniform phase. In the presence of doping, the density of states at the Fermi level in the mixed phases is depressed from its value in the uniform phase and is in good agreement with the experimental data.
Whether a lightly doped Mott insulator on the square lattice supports robust
d-wave superconductivity remains a central question in strongly correlated physics and in the microscopic theory of cuprate superconductivity. Experiments and numerical studies reveal a pronounced particle-hole asymmetry, pointing to a delicate competition among
d-wave superconductivity, pair-density wave (PDW), stripe, charge-density wave (CDW), and antiferromagnetic correlations. Here we combine large-scale DMRG and finite-size PEPS to study the square-lattice
t-
J model at low doping,
δ≤0.1, while tuning the next-nearest-neighbor hopping
t′ from the electron-like (
t′>0) to the hole-like (
t′<0) regime. The electron-like side supports robust, nearly uniform
d-wave pairing, whereas decreasing
t′ induces a period-two plaquette modulation and ultimately produces, on the hole-like side, a charge-dominated state with a strongly suppressed static pairing amplitude. DMRG calculations on open strips and squares, together with PEPS calculations on open squares up to
16×16 sites, support this evolution. On squares with
C4-symmetric Hamiltonians, both methods find that the pair correlations of the hole-like state select the plaquette momenta
(π,0) and
(0,π) and decay within a few lattice spacings, while the dominant charge-density modulation forms a bidirectional checkerboard whose period extrapolates to about
4a0, close to that observed in lightly doped Bi-2201. These observations establish a fluctuating plaquette PDW in the lightly doped hole-like regime, in which local pairs carry finite momentum but lack phase coherence. Our results firmly establish particle-hole asymmetry as a central organizing principle for competing pairing tendencies in the lightly doped
t-
J model.