Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Interpretational difficulties in quantum field theory

Piotr Krekora, Qichang C. Su, R. Grobe

Published Feb 23, 2006• 40 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Based on space-time-resolved solutions to relativistic quantum field theory we illustrate interpretational difficulties in associating field-theoretical quantities with properties of particles. These difficulties are related to the fact that the definition of the spatial probability density of particles depends on the choice of the Hilbert subspace on which the field operator is projected. We illustrate these problems by analyzing pair-production probabilities and spatial densities for the electron-positron dynamics associated with a spatially localized subcritical potential that is turned on and off in time.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.73.022114

Related papers

Space-time resolved quantum field theory

Piotr Krekora, Qichang C. Su, R. Grobe

Using space-time resolved solutions in relativistic quantum field theory we analyze the electron-positron pair creation process from vacuum and resolve the Klein-paradox. We show that there are in principle no limitations to the localization length of an electron and demonstrate that its spatial probability density can be much narrower than the Compton wavelength. We also argue that quantum field theory prohibits the occurrence of Zitterbewegung for an electron in contrast to claims found in textbooks.

Frontiers in Optics•Jan 1, 2004•0 citations

Relativistic Electron Localization and the Lack ofZitterbewegung

Piotr Krekora, Qichang C. Su, R. Grobe

Using space-time resolved solutions to relativistic quantum field theory we analyze the electron-positron pair creation process from vacuum. For early times the entangled electron-positron wave function can be obtained analytically. We show that there are, in principle, no limitations to the localization length of an electron and demonstrate that its spatial probability density can be much narrower than the Compton wavelength. We also find that quantum field theory prohibits the occurrence of Zitterbewegung for an electron.

Physical Review Letters•Jul 23, 2004•103 citations

Localization of particles in quantum field theory

W. Westra

We put forward an interpretation of scalar quantum field theory as relativistic quantum mechanics by curing well known problems related to locality. A probabilistic interpretation of quantum field theory similar to quantum mechanics is difficult if particle localization is defined using the Newton-Wigner position operator as it is non-local and non-covariant. An alternative bilinear covariant position operator is discussed which incorporates a time operator that can be exponentiated to a unitary operator. Moreover, it satisfies an algebra that unifies special relativity and quantum mechanics and has the same form for particles with spin. Higher power position operators are derived which yield Heisenberg's uncertainty relations. Our ideas are illustrated with a relativistic wave function whose probability density can be perfectly localized.

arXiv:1012.3472•Dec 15, 2010•7 citations

Quantum time and spatial localization in relativistic quantum mechanics

Von Zuben, Francis Stephen Geisler

Two related problems in relativistic quantum mechanics, the apparent superluminal propagation of initially localized particles, and the dependence of their localization on the motion of the observer, are analyzed in the context of the theory of constraints. Time and energy operators are introduced for the free relativistic particle, and a parametrization invariant formulation is obtained through Dirac constraint theory. The resulting description is of a system constrained in momentum and energy, but not in position or time, for which observables are constants of the motion. The Klein-Gordon equation is recovered on a physical Hilbert space, constructed via integration over the proper time from an augmented Hilbert space, wherein time and energy are dynamical variables...

•Nov 1, 1999•2 citations

A realistic interpretation of the density matrix

A. Raiteri

A realistic interpretation of Schroedinger and Dirac equations for density matrices is proposed, in which the difference between the position arguments of the density matrix is considered as an "objective" extra space dimension. "Particle" solutions are found, which are perfectly localized both in position space and in momentum space (the position and momentum operators commute in the density matrix representation); definitions for all observable quantities are given and the values associated to the "particle" solutions are the correct ones, both for the non-relativistic and the relativistic case. Finally, a non-linear interaction (the electromagnetic one) is introduced in an attempt to single out the "particle" solutions of the Dirac equation from all other solutions; the dynamical evolution of the electromagnetic field is described by the classical (unquantized) Maxwell equations.

•Dec 4, 1998•0 citations

Space-Time Position Operators

Arthur A. Broyles

A formalism is presented giving the development of $\ensuremath{\psi}(\overline{x})$ in time with the interpretation that $\ensuremath{\psi}(\overline{x})$ is the probability amplitude for observing an event at a space-time point $\overline{x}$. No properties other than the four space-time coordinates are associated with an event. A Hilbert space is defined in which $\ensuremath{\psi}(\overline{x})$ is the result of a scalar product. The space-time position operators defined in this Hilbert space have no association with particle properties, such as mass. These operators cannot be defined in the Hilbert space spanned by solutions of a Schr\"odinger equation, since the operators lead out of the Hilbert subspace belonging to a given mass. It is shown that state vectors in Hilbert space that are eigenvectors of ${P}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}{P}^{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ produce position amplitudes satisfying the Klein-Gordon equation. The relation between this Hilbert space and the one introduced by Dirac is discussed. Spin is not considered.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Feb 15, 1970•22 citations
Based on space-time-resolved solutions to relativistic quantum field theory we illustrate interpretational difficulties in associating field-theoretical quantities with properties of particles. These difficulties are related to the fact that the definition of the spatial probability density of particles depends on the choice of the Hilbert subspace on which the field operator is projected. We illustrate these problems by analyzing pair-production probabilities and spatial densities for the electron-positron dynamics associated with a spatially localized subcritical potential that is turned on and off in time.
Using space-time resolved solutions in relativistic quantum field theory we analyze the electron-positron pair creation process from vacuum and resolve the Klein-paradox. We show that there are in principle no limitations to the localization length of an electron and demonstrate that its spatial probability density can be much narrower than the Compton wavelength. We also argue that quantum field theory prohibits the occurrence of Zitterbewegung for an electron in contrast to claims found in textbooks.
Using space-time resolved solutions to relativistic quantum field theory we analyze the electron-positron pair creation process from vacuum. For early times the entangled electron-positron wave function can be obtained analytically. We show that there are, in principle, no limitations to the localization length of an electron and demonstrate that its spatial probability density can be much narrower than the Compton wavelength. We also find that quantum field theory prohibits the occurrence of Zitterbewegung for an electron.
We put forward an interpretation of scalar quantum field theory as relativistic quantum mechanics by curing well known problems related to locality. A probabilistic interpretation of quantum field theory similar to quantum mechanics is difficult if particle localization is defined using the Newton-Wigner position operator as it is non-local and non-covariant. An alternative bilinear covariant position operator is discussed which incorporates a time operator that can be exponentiated to a unitary operator. Moreover, it satisfies an algebra that unifies special relativity and quantum mechanics and has the same form for particles with spin. Higher power position operators are derived which yield Heisenberg's uncertainty relations. Our ideas are illustrated with a relativistic wave function whose probability density can be perfectly localized.
Two related problems in relativistic quantum mechanics, the apparent superluminal propagation of initially localized particles, and the dependence of their localization on the motion of the observer, are analyzed in the context of the theory of constraints. Time and energy operators are introduced for the free relativistic particle, and a parametrization invariant formulation is obtained through Dirac constraint theory. The resulting description is of a system constrained in momentum and energy, but not in position or time, for which observables are constants of the motion. The Klein-Gordon equation is recovered on a physical Hilbert space, constructed via integration over the proper time from an augmented Hilbert space, wherein time and energy are dynamical variables...
A realistic interpretation of Schroedinger and Dirac equations for density matrices is proposed, in which the difference between the position arguments of the density matrix is considered as an "objective" extra space dimension. "Particle" solutions are found, which are perfectly localized both in position space and in momentum space (the position and momentum operators commute in the density matrix representation); definitions for all observable quantities are given and the values associated to the "particle" solutions are the correct ones, both for the non-relativistic and the relativistic case. Finally, a non-linear interaction (the electromagnetic one) is introduced in an attempt to single out the "particle" solutions of the Dirac equation from all other solutions; the dynamical evolution of the electromagnetic field is described by the classical (unquantized) Maxwell equations.
A formalism is presented giving the development of $\ensuremath{\psi}(\overline{x})$ in time with the interpretation that $\ensuremath{\psi}(\overline{x})$ is the probability amplitude for observing an event at a space-time point x‾\overline{x}x. No properties other than the four space-time coordinates are associated with an event. A Hilbert space is defined in which $\ensuremath{\psi}(\overline{x})$ is the result of a scalar product. The space-time position operators defined in this Hilbert space have no association with particle properties, such as mass. These operators cannot be defined in the Hilbert space spanned by solutions of a Schr\"odinger equation, since the operators lead out of the Hilbert subspace belonging to a given mass. It is shown that state vectors in Hilbert space that are eigenvectors of ${P}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}{P}^{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ produce position amplitudes satisfying the Klein-Gordon equation. The relation between this Hilbert space and the one introduced by Dirac is discussed. Spin is not considered.