Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Natural Computing

Algorithms on ensemble quantum computers

P. Oscar Boykin, Tal Mor, Vwani Roychowdhury, Farrokh Vatan

Published May 29, 2009• 16 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In ensemble (or bulk) quantum computation, all computations are performed on an ensemble of computers rather than on a single computer. Measurements of qubits in an individual computer cannot be performed; instead, only expectation values (over the complete ensemble of computers) can be measured. As a result of this limitation on the model of computation, many algorithms cannot be processed directly on such computers, and must be modified, as the common strategy of delaying the measurements usually does not resolve this ensemble-measurement problem. Here we present several new strategies for resolving this problem. Based on these strategies we provide new versions of some of the most important quantum algorithms, versions that are suitable for implementing on ensemble quantum computers, e.g., on liquid NMR quantum computers. These algorithms are Shor's factorization algorithm, Grover's search algorithm (with several marked items), and an algorithm for quantum fault-tolerant computation. The first two algorithms are simply modified using a randomizing and a sorting strategies. For the last algorithm, we develop a classical-quantum hybrid strategy for removing measurements. We use it to present a novel quantum fault-tolerant scheme. More explicitly, we present schemes for fault-tolerant measurement-free implementation of Toffoli and σ(z)(¼) as these operations cannot be implemented "bitwise", and their standard fault-tolerant implementations require measurement.

DOI
10.1007/s11047-009-9133-0

Related papers

Algorithms on Ensemble Quantum Computers

P. Oscar Boykin, Tal Mor, Vwani Roychowdhury +1 more

In ensemble (or bulk) quantum computation, measurements of qubits in an individual computer cannot be performed. Instead, only expectation values can be measured. As a result of this limitation on the model of computation, various important algorithms cannot be processed directly on such computers, and must be modified. We provide modifications of various existing protocols, including algorithms for universal fault--tolerant computation, Shor's factorization algorithm (which can be extended to any algorithm computing an NP function), and some search algorithms to enable processing them on ensemble quantum computers.

arXiv:quant-ph/9907067•Jul 21, 1999•7 citations

Fault tolerant computation on ensemble quantum computers

P. Oscar Boykin, C.P. Roychowdhury, Tal Mor +1 more

In ensemble (or bulk) quantum computation, all computations are performed on an ensemble of computers rather than on a single computer. Measurements of qubits in an individual computer cannot be performed; instead, only expectation values (over the complete ensemble of computers) can be measured. As a result of this limitation on the model of computation, many algorithms cannot be processed directly on such computers, and must be modified. We provide modification of the fault tolerant quantum computation protocols to enable processing on ensemble quantum computers.

International Conference on Dependable Systems & Networks/Proceedings•Jan 1, 2004•8 citations

Shortening Grover's search algorithm for an expectation value quantum computer

David C. Collins

Quantum algorithms are conventionally formulated for implementation on a single system of qubits amenable to projective measurements. However, in expectation value quantum computation, such as nuclear magnetic resonance realizations, the computer consists of an ensemble of identical qubit-systems amenable only to expectation value measurements. The prevalent strategy in such expectation value implementations of quantum algorithms has been to retain the conventional formulation's unitary operations but modify its initialization and measurement steps appropriately. This naive approach is not optimal for Grover's algorithm and a shortened version for expectation value quantum computers is presented.

arXiv:quant-ph/0209148•Sep 26, 2002•1 citation

Modified Grover’s algorithm for an expectation-value quantum computer

David C. Collins

The translation of Grover's search algorithm from its standard version, designed for implementation on a single quantum system amenable to projective measurements, into one suitable for an ensemble of quantum computers, whose outputs are expectation values of observables on individual qubits, is described in detail. A filtering scheme, which effectively determines expectation values on a limited portion of the quantum state, is presented and used to locate a single item for searches involving more than one marked item. A truncated version of Grover's algorithm, requiring fewer steps than the translated standard version but locating marked items just as successfully, is proposed. For quantum computational devices that only return expectation values, the truncated version is superior to its standard counterpart. This indicates that it is possible to modify quantum algorithms so as to reduce the required temporal resources by using the ensemble's spatial resources.

arXiv:quant-ph/0111108•Physical Review A•May 7, 2002•13 citations

Quantum computing under real-world constraints: efficiency of an ensemble quantum algorithm and fighting decoherence by gate design

Y. Yamamoto, Cyrus P. Master

Quantum algorithms for problems such as integer factorization and database search have spurred great interest in quantum computation. However, the construction of scalable quantum computers has proved to be extremely difficult. Among the challenging requirements that must be fulfilled in the “standard model” of quantum computation, one must be able to initialize qubits into known pure states. In addition, quantum computers must be protected from noise due to unwanted interactions with their environment. This work is concerned with two theoretical issues motivated by these difficulties. First, I analyze the efficiency of an algorithm for an alternate model for quantum computation that is motivated by bulk nuclear magnetic resonance. In such ensemble systems, the initial state is not a fiducial pure state, but is instead a maximally-mixed density operator. The algorithm that I consider allows one to estimate the free energy of arbitrary spin-1/2 lattice models. To determine the efficiency of this algorithm, I calculate the computation time required to estimate the free energy to bounded error as a function of the lattice size. In the absence of stochastic fluctuations in the measurement output, it is found that the algorithm is efficient. However, evidence is presented that suggests that the algorithm becomes exponentially sensitive to fluctuations as the lattice size increases. While techniques such as quantum error-correcting codes and decoherence-free subsystem encodings have been devised to mitigate errors due to unwanted environmental couplings, these methods require many additional qubits or complicated encodings. Here, I investigate a simple approach to reduce errors in the quantum search algorithm due to a collective decoherence model. This method takes advantage of the freedom inherent in compiling the search algorithm into fundamental gates. Transition rate calculations and more rigorous quantum master equation simulations are carried out for small-qubit instances to contrast the performance of the original and modified algorithm. It is shown that the expected computational effort can be reduced by 22% for selected five-bit instances of the quantum search algorithm. While this approach does not constitute a general strategy for quantum error-correction, it illustrates the importance of judicious gate design in mitigating decoherence.

•Jan 1, 2005•4 citations

Ensemble quantum computing by NMR spectroscopy

David G. Cory, Amr F. Fahmy, Timothy F. Havel

A quantum computer (QC) can operate in parallel on all its possible inputs at once, but the amount of information that can be extracted from the result is limited by the phenomenon of wave function collapse. We present a new computational model, which differs from a QC only in that the result of a measurement is the expectation value of the observable, rather than a random eigenvalue thereof. Such an expectation value QC can solve nondeterministic polynomial-time complete problems in polynomial time. This observation is significant precisely because the computational model can be realized, to a certain extent, by NMR spectroscopy on macroscopic ensembles of quantum spins, namely molecules in a test tube. This is made possible by identifying a manifold of statistical spin states, called pseudo-pure states, the mathematical description of which is isomorphic to that of an isolated spin system. The result is a novel NMR computer that can be programmed much like a QC, but in other respects more closely resembles a DNA computer. Most notably, when applied to intractable combinatorial problems, an NMR computer can use an amount of sample, rather than time, which grows exponentially with the size of the problem. Although NMR computers will be limited by current technology to exhaustive searches over only 15 to 20 bits, searches over as much as 50 bits are in principle possible, and more advanced algorithms could greatly extend the range of applicability of such machines.

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Mar 4, 1997•956 citations
In ensemble (or bulk) quantum computation, all computations are performed on an ensemble of computers rather than on a single computer. Measurements of qubits in an individual computer cannot be performed; instead, only expectation values (over the complete ensemble of computers) can be measured. As a result of this limitation on the model of computation, many algorithms cannot be processed directly on such computers, and must be modified, as the common strategy of delaying the measurements usually does not resolve this ensemble-measurement problem. Here we present several new strategies for resolving this problem. Based on these strategies we provide new versions of some of the most important quantum algorithms, versions that are suitable for implementing on ensemble quantum computers, e.g., on liquid NMR quantum computers. These algorithms are Shor's factorization algorithm, Grover's search algorithm (with several marked items), and an algorithm for quantum fault-tolerant computation. The first two algorithms are simply modified using a randomizing and a sorting strategies. For the last algorithm, we develop a classical-quantum hybrid strategy for removing measurements. We use it to present a novel quantum fault-tolerant scheme. More explicitly, we present schemes for fault-tolerant measurement-free implementation of Toffoli and σ(z)(¼) as these operations cannot be implemented "bitwise", and their standard fault-tolerant implementations require measurement.
In ensemble (or bulk) quantum computation, measurements of qubits in an individual computer cannot be performed. Instead, only expectation values can be measured. As a result of this limitation on the model of computation, various important algorithms cannot be processed directly on such computers, and must be modified. We provide modifications of various existing protocols, including algorithms for universal fault--tolerant computation, Shor's factorization algorithm (which can be extended to any algorithm computing an NP function), and some search algorithms to enable processing them on ensemble quantum computers.
In ensemble (or bulk) quantum computation, all computations are performed on an ensemble of computers rather than on a single computer. Measurements of qubits in an individual computer cannot be performed; instead, only expectation values (over the complete ensemble of computers) can be measured. As a result of this limitation on the model of computation, many algorithms cannot be processed directly on such computers, and must be modified. We provide modification of the fault tolerant quantum computation protocols to enable processing on ensemble quantum computers.
Quantum algorithms are conventionally formulated for implementation on a single system of qubits amenable to projective measurements. However, in expectation value quantum computation, such as nuclear magnetic resonance realizations, the computer consists of an ensemble of identical qubit-systems amenable only to expectation value measurements. The prevalent strategy in such expectation value implementations of quantum algorithms has been to retain the conventional formulation's unitary operations but modify its initialization and measurement steps appropriately. This naive approach is not optimal for Grover's algorithm and a shortened version for expectation value quantum computers is presented.
The translation of Grover's search algorithm from its standard version, designed for implementation on a single quantum system amenable to projective measurements, into one suitable for an ensemble of quantum computers, whose outputs are expectation values of observables on individual qubits, is described in detail. A filtering scheme, which effectively determines expectation values on a limited portion of the quantum state, is presented and used to locate a single item for searches involving more than one marked item. A truncated version of Grover's algorithm, requiring fewer steps than the translated standard version but locating marked items just as successfully, is proposed. For quantum computational devices that only return expectation values, the truncated version is superior to its standard counterpart. This indicates that it is possible to modify quantum algorithms so as to reduce the required temporal resources by using the ensemble's spatial resources.
Quantum algorithms for problems such as integer factorization and database search have spurred great interest in quantum computation. However, the construction of scalable quantum computers has proved to be extremely difficult. Among the challenging requirements that must be fulfilled in the “standard model” of quantum computation, one must be able to initialize qubits into known pure states. In addition, quantum computers must be protected from noise due to unwanted interactions with their environment. This work is concerned with two theoretical issues motivated by these difficulties. First, I analyze the efficiency of an algorithm for an alternate model for quantum computation that is motivated by bulk nuclear magnetic resonance. In such ensemble systems, the initial state is not a fiducial pure state, but is instead a maximally-mixed density operator. The algorithm that I consider allows one to estimate the free energy of arbitrary spin-1/2 lattice models. To determine the efficiency of this algorithm, I calculate the computation time required to estimate the free energy to bounded error as a function of the lattice size. In the absence of stochastic fluctuations in the measurement output, it is found that the algorithm is efficient. However, evidence is presented that suggests that the algorithm becomes exponentially sensitive to fluctuations as the lattice size increases. While techniques such as quantum error-correcting codes and decoherence-free subsystem encodings have been devised to mitigate errors due to unwanted environmental couplings, these methods require many additional qubits or complicated encodings. Here, I investigate a simple approach to reduce errors in the quantum search algorithm due to a collective decoherence model. This method takes advantage of the freedom inherent in compiling the search algorithm into fundamental gates. Transition rate calculations and more rigorous quantum master equation simulations are carried out for small-qubit instances to contrast the performance of the original and modified algorithm. It is shown that the expected computational effort can be reduced by 22% for selected five-bit instances of the quantum search algorithm. While this approach does not constitute a general strategy for quantum error-correction, it illustrates the importance of judicious gate design in mitigating decoherence.
A quantum computer (QC) can operate in parallel on all its possible inputs at once, but the amount of information that can be extracted from the result is limited by the phenomenon of wave function collapse. We present a new computational model, which differs from a QC only in that the result of a measurement is the expectation value of the observable, rather than a random eigenvalue thereof. Such an expectation value QC can solve nondeterministic polynomial-time complete problems in polynomial time. This observation is significant precisely because the computational model can be realized, to a certain extent, by NMR spectroscopy on macroscopic ensembles of quantum spins, namely molecules in a test tube. This is made possible by identifying a manifold of statistical spin states, called pseudo-pure states, the mathematical description of which is isomorphic to that of an isolated spin system. The result is a novel NMR computer that can be programmed much like a QC, but in other respects more closely resembles a DNA computer. Most notably, when applied to intractable combinatorial problems, an NMR computer can use an amount of sample, rather than time, which grows exponentially with the size of the problem. Although NMR computers will be limited by current technology to exhaustive searches over only 15 to 20 bits, searches over as much as 50 bits are in principle possible, and more advanced algorithms could greatly extend the range of applicability of such machines.