Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

HIDDEN MEASUREMENTS FROM CONTEXTUAL AXIOMATICS

Sven Aerts

Published Jun 1, 2002• 9 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The hidden measurement approach was originally proposed to show how the tenet of determinism can be upheld in quantum mechanics if one allows the outcome of a measurement to be decided not only by the state of the entity under observation, but also by unkown parameters in the experimental setup. In this paper we show that the structure of hidden measurements is uniquely recovered from three simple axioms and that the state of the entity can be partially defined by the intersection of the sets formed by the closure of each set of measurements that gives rise to a certain outcome.

DOI
10.1142/9789812778024_0007

Related papers

On Hidden Variables and Quantum Mechanical Probabilities

Eugene Paul Wigner

An argument, due originally to J. S. Bell, is somewhat simplified and made more specific. It deals primarily with a quantum mechanical system consisting of the spins of two spin-12 particles. It shows that a description of the quantum mechanical measurement of the spin components of these two particles by means of hidden parameters is impossible if we assume that the parameters determining the outcome of the measurement of the spin of each particle are independent of the direction in which we decide to measure the spin of the other particle. The mathematical reason for the impossibility is analyzed.

American Journal of Physics•Aug 1, 1970•496 citations

Simulating quantum mechanics by non-contextual hidden variables

Rob Clifton, Adrian Kent

No physical measurement can be performed with infinite precision. This leaves a loophole in the standard no–go arguments against non–contextual hidden variables. All such arguments rely on choosing special sets of quantum–mechanical observables with measurement outcomes that cannot be simulated non–contextually. As a consequence, these arguments do not exclude the hypothesis that the class of physical measurements in fact corresponds to a dense subset of all theoretically possible measurements with outcomes and quantum probabilities that can be recovered from a non–contextual hidden–variable model. We show here by explicit construction that there are indeed such non–contextual hidden–variable models, both for projection–valued and positive–operator–valued measurements.

arXiv:quant-ph/9908031•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Sep 8, 2000•99 citations

On the discrimination of contexts in equivalent quantum measurements

Sara Delgado Buiza

This work aims to extend the concept of contextuality (originally arising from hidden variable theories) within the standard formalism of quantum mechanics, with a particular focus on the theory of measurement. A theoretical framework is proposed in which contextuality serves as a tool that allows a deeper understanding of the measurement process. To this end, a thought experiment is introduced to illustrate how, by measuring the same degenerate observable through three different paths (understanding a path as a certain set of commuting observables), it is possible to determine the specific path (or context) followed based on the final state after the measurement. Additionally, although the work is primarily a bibliographic review, it also includes a novel thought experiment as a potential application for quantum key generation and transmission. In summary, the work proposes a reinterpretation of the phenomenon of contextuality, beyond its original formulation in the Bell and Kochen-Specker theorems, that allows for its integration into the standard formalism of quantum mechanics, with particular relevance in the theory of measurement.

Scientia Insularum Revista de Ciencias Naturales en islas•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Quantum contextuality in the Mermin-Peres square: A hidden-variable perspective

Brian R. La Cour

The question of a hidden variable interpretation of quantum contextuality in the Mermin-Peres square is considered. The Kochen-Specker theorem implies that quantum mechanics may be interpreted as a contextual hidden-variable theory. It is shown that such a hidden-variable description can be viewed as either contextual in the random variables mapping hidden states to observable outcomes or in the probability measure on the hidden state space. The latter view suggests that this apparent contextuality may be interpreted as a simple consequence of measurement disturbance, wherein the initial hidden state is altered through interaction with the measuring device, thereby giving rise to a possibly different final hidden-variable state from which the measurement outcome is obtained. In light of this observation, a less restrictive and, arguably, more reasonable definition of noncontextuality is suggested. To prove that such a description is possible, an explicit and, in this sense, noncontextual hidden-variable model is constructed, which reproduces all quantum theoretic predictions for the Mermin-Peres square. A critical analysis of some recent and proposed experimental tests of contextuality is also provided. Although the discussion is restricted to a four-dimensional Hilbert space, the approach and conclusions are expected to generalize to any Hilbert space.

arXiv:2105.00940•Physical Review A•Jan 5, 2009•25 citations

A Suggested Interpretation of the Quantum Theory in Terms of "Hidden" Variables. II

David Böhm

In this paper, we shall show how the theory of measurements is to be understood from the point of view of a physical interpretation of the quantum theory in terms of "hidden" variables, developed in a previous paper. We find that in principle, these "hidden" variables determine the precise results of each individual measurement process. In practice, however, in measurements that we now know how to carry out, the observing apparatus disturbs the observed system in an unpredictable and uncontrollable way, so that the uncertainty principle is obtained as a practical limitation on the possible precision of measurements. This limitation is not, however, inherent in the conceptual structure of our interpretation. We shall see, for example, that simultaneous measurements of position and momentum having unlimited precision would in principle be possible if, as suggested in the previous paper, the mathematical formulation of the quantum theory needs to be modified at very short distances in certain ways that are consistent with our interpretation but not with the usual interpretation.We give a simple explanation of the origin of quantum-mechanical correlations of distant objects in the hypothetical experiment of Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen, which was suggested by these authors as a criticism of the usual interpretation.Finally, we show that von Neumann's proof that quantum theory is not consistent with hidden variables does not apply to our interpretation, because the hidden variables contemplated here depend both on the state of the measuring apparatus and the observed system and therefore go beyond certain of von Neumann's assumptions.In two appendixes, we treat the problem of the electromagnetic field in our interpretation and answer certain additional objections which have arisen in the attempt to give a precise description for an individual system at the quantum level.

Physical Review•Jan 15, 1952•2,107 citations

A Proposed Solution of the Measurement Problem in Quantum Mechanics by a Hidden Variable Theory

David Böhm, Jeffrey Bub

The measurement problem in quantum mechanics is re-examined and it is shown that it cannot really be solved in a satisfactory way, within the framework of the usual interpretation of the theory. We then discuss von Neumann's attempts to prove that quantum mechanics is incompatible with the introduction of hidden variables, and develop a more detailed form of Bell's argument, showing that von Neumann's analysis is invalid. Using certain ideas that are implicit in the "differential-space" theory of Wiener and Siegel, we go on to propose a new deterministic equation of motion, describing a kind of coupling of the measuring instrument to the observed system that explains in detail how the wave packet is "reduced" during a measurement in a continuous and causally determined way. By averaging over the hidden parameters, we then recover the usual statistical results of quantum mechanics as a special case. However, a more detailed analysis of the theory shows that new experimental and theoretical questions can now be raised, which go outside the framework of the quantum theory as it is now formulated. These questions are examined briefly.

Reviews of Modern Physics•Jul 1, 1966•431 citations
The hidden measurement approach was originally proposed to show how the tenet of determinism can be upheld in quantum mechanics if one allows the outcome of a measurement to be decided not only by the state of the entity under observation, but also by unkown parameters in the experimental setup. In this paper we show that the structure of hidden measurements is uniquely recovered from three simple axioms and that the state of the entity can be partially defined by the intersection of the sets formed by the closure of each set of measurements that gives rise to a certain outcome.
An argument, due originally to J. S. Bell, is somewhat simplified and made more specific. It deals primarily with a quantum mechanical system consisting of the spins of two spin-12 particles. It shows that a description of the quantum mechanical measurement of the spin components of these two particles by means of hidden parameters is impossible if we assume that the parameters determining the outcome of the measurement of the spin of each particle are independent of the direction in which we decide to measure the spin of the other particle. The mathematical reason for the impossibility is analyzed.
No physical measurement can be performed with infinite precision. This leaves a loophole in the standard no–go arguments against non–contextual hidden variables. All such arguments rely on choosing special sets of quantum–mechanical observables with measurement outcomes that cannot be simulated non–contextually. As a consequence, these arguments do not exclude the hypothesis that the class of physical measurements in fact corresponds to a dense subset of all theoretically possible measurements with outcomes and quantum probabilities that can be recovered from a non–contextual hidden–variable model. We show here by explicit construction that there are indeed such non–contextual hidden–variable models, both for projection–valued and positive–operator–valued measurements.
This work aims to extend the concept of contextuality (originally arising from hidden variable theories) within the standard formalism of quantum mechanics, with a particular focus on the theory of measurement. A theoretical framework is proposed in which contextuality serves as a tool that allows a deeper understanding of the measurement process. To this end, a thought experiment is introduced to illustrate how, by measuring the same degenerate observable through three different paths (understanding a path as a certain set of commuting observables), it is possible to determine the specific path (or context) followed based on the final state after the measurement. Additionally, although the work is primarily a bibliographic review, it also includes a novel thought experiment as a potential application for quantum key generation and transmission. In summary, the work proposes a reinterpretation of the phenomenon of contextuality, beyond its original formulation in the Bell and Kochen-Specker theorems, that allows for its integration into the standard formalism of quantum mechanics, with particular relevance in the theory of measurement.
The question of a hidden variable interpretation of quantum contextuality in the Mermin-Peres square is considered. The Kochen-Specker theorem implies that quantum mechanics may be interpreted as a contextual hidden-variable theory. It is shown that such a hidden-variable description can be viewed as either contextual in the random variables mapping hidden states to observable outcomes or in the probability measure on the hidden state space. The latter view suggests that this apparent contextuality may be interpreted as a simple consequence of measurement disturbance, wherein the initial hidden state is altered through interaction with the measuring device, thereby giving rise to a possibly different final hidden-variable state from which the measurement outcome is obtained. In light of this observation, a less restrictive and, arguably, more reasonable definition of noncontextuality is suggested. To prove that such a description is possible, an explicit and, in this sense, noncontextual hidden-variable model is constructed, which reproduces all quantum theoretic predictions for the Mermin-Peres square. A critical analysis of some recent and proposed experimental tests of contextuality is also provided. Although the discussion is restricted to a four-dimensional Hilbert space, the approach and conclusions are expected to generalize to any Hilbert space.
In this paper, we shall show how the theory of measurements is to be understood from the point of view of a physical interpretation of the quantum theory in terms of "hidden" variables, developed in a previous paper. We find that in principle, these "hidden" variables determine the precise results of each individual measurement process. In practice, however, in measurements that we now know how to carry out, the observing apparatus disturbs the observed system in an unpredictable and uncontrollable way, so that the uncertainty principle is obtained as a practical limitation on the possible precision of measurements. This limitation is not, however, inherent in the conceptual structure of our interpretation. We shall see, for example, that simultaneous measurements of position and momentum having unlimited precision would in principle be possible if, as suggested in the previous paper, the mathematical formulation of the quantum theory needs to be modified at very short distances in certain ways that are consistent with our interpretation but not with the usual interpretation.We give a simple explanation of the origin of quantum-mechanical correlations of distant objects in the hypothetical experiment of Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen, which was suggested by these authors as a criticism of the usual interpretation.Finally, we show that von Neumann's proof that quantum theory is not consistent with hidden variables does not apply to our interpretation, because the hidden variables contemplated here depend both on the state of the measuring apparatus and the observed system and therefore go beyond certain of von Neumann's assumptions.In two appendixes, we treat the problem of the electromagnetic field in our interpretation and answer certain additional objections which have arisen in the attempt to give a precise description for an individual system at the quantum level.
The measurement problem in quantum mechanics is re-examined and it is shown that it cannot really be solved in a satisfactory way, within the framework of the usual interpretation of the theory. We then discuss von Neumann's attempts to prove that quantum mechanics is incompatible with the introduction of hidden variables, and develop a more detailed form of Bell's argument, showing that von Neumann's analysis is invalid. Using certain ideas that are implicit in the "differential-space" theory of Wiener and Siegel, we go on to propose a new deterministic equation of motion, describing a kind of coupling of the measuring instrument to the observed system that explains in detail how the wave packet is "reduced" during a measurement in a continuous and causally determined way. By averaging over the hidden parameters, we then recover the usual statistical results of quantum mechanics as a special case. However, a more detailed analysis of the theory shows that new experimental and theoretical questions can now be raised, which go outside the framework of the quantum theory as it is now formulated. These questions are examined briefly.