Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Quantized Vortices in an Imperfect Bose Gas and the Breakdown of Superfluidity in Liquid Helium II

M. P. Kawatra, Raj K. Pathria

Published Nov 4, 1966• 31 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The energy and momentum associated with vortex formation in an imperfect Bose gas have been computed quantum mechanically. In the computation, explicit account is taken of the boundary condition to be satisfied by the wave function at the walls surrounding the fluid. Numerical estimates of the critical velocity obtained thereby throw considerable light on the question of the most favorable location (relative to the walls) for the formation of the vortex. It is concluded that the optimum location for this formation could be well within the fluid---significantly away from the walls.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.151.132

Related papers

Vortices in an Imperfect Bose Gas. I. The Condensate

Alexander L. Fetter

A theoretical study of rectilinear vortices in an imperfect Bose gas shows a close correspondence with classical hydrodynamics. The energy and momentum of a vortex pair in an unbounded fluid are calculated. The similarity between a vortex pair and a vortex ring leads to an estimate of the critical velocity ${v}_{c}$ of liquid He II in a tube of radius $R$ that includes the effect of the walls ${v}_{c}=\frac{C\ensuremath{\hbar}}{2mR}$, where $C$ is a constant of order unity. A variational treatment of a system of many identical vortices in a container shows that the energy is lowest for a uniform distribution, and that the number of vortices per unit area $\ensuremath{\nu}$ agrees with Feyman's result $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{2m\ensuremath{\omega}}{h}$. In the classical limit ($h\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$), the angular momentum and energy approach the values for solid-body rotation.

Physical Review•Apr 19, 1965•149 citations

Vortices in an Imperfect Bose Gas. IV. Translational Velocity

Alexander L. Fetter

The translational velocity of a vortex with circulation $\frac{h}{m}$ in an imperfect Bose gas is calculated by considering the time dependence of the condensate wave function corresponding to a given initial configuration of vortices. Each vortex in a system of rectilinear vortices is shown to move with the local fluid velocity at its core; a vortex ring of radius $R$ is shown to move with velocity $(\frac{h}{4\ensuremath{\pi}\mathrm{mR}})\mathrm{ln}(\frac{8R}{\ensuremath{\alpha}})$, where $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ is a length the order of the core size. Both results agree with the predictions of classical hydrodynamics.

Physical Review•Nov 4, 1966•85 citations

Hydrodynamics of a Superfluid Condensate

Eugene P. Gross

The theory of the condensate of a weakly interacting Bose gas is developed. The condensate is described by a wavefunction ψ(x, t) normalized to the number of particles. It obeys a nonlinear self-consistent field equation. The solution in the presence of a rigid wall with the boundary condition of vanishing wavefunction involves a de Broglie length. This length depends on the mean potential energy per particle. The self-consistent field term keeps the density uniform except in localized spatial regions. In the hydrodynamical version, a key role is played by the quantum potential. A theory of quantized vortices and of general potential flows follows immediately. In contrast to classical hydrodynamics, the cores of vortices are completely determined by the de Broglie length and all energies are finite. Nonstationary disturbances of the condensate correspond to phonons, rotons, vortex waves etc. They can exchange momentum with rigid boundaries. This is compatible with the vanishing of the wavefunction at a boundary. This condition fully determines the dynamics of the system. These points are illustrated by considering the motion of a foreign ion in a Bose gas, a rotating container of fluid, and the Landau criterion for superfluidity.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Feb 1, 1963•992 citations

Vortices and vortex lattices at finite temperatures

Allan Griffin, Tetsuro Nikuni, E. Zaremba

The goal of creating and observing quantized vortices in trapped Bose gases arose almost immediately following the first achievements of Bose–Einstein condensation. The motivation for doing so was the obvious analogy with vortices in liquid helium and in type-II superconductors, and the fact that the quantization of circulation is directly associated with superfluid flow. It was recognized that the observation of quantized vortices could be taken as indisputable evidence for the existence of superfluidity in these systems.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 19, 2009•1 citation

Vortices in dilute Bose-Einstein condensates

Tapio Simula

Bose-Einstein condensation, first predicted by Bose and Einstein in 1924, was finally realized in dilute, weakly interacting gases of alkali atoms in 1995. A few years later, quantized vortices - intimately related to the phenomenon of superfluidity - were created and observed in these novel quantum many-body systems.\n\nIn this Thesis, vortices in dilute atomic Bose-Einstein condensates are studied theoretically and computationally using microscopic mean-field theory formalisms. Special emphasis is on the structure and the stability of vortices at finite temperatures. The formation of quantized circulation in Bose-Einstein condensates is investigated, as well as multiply quantized vorticity and the adiabaticity of the precessing motion of a vortex.\n\nThis research strongly relies on numerically solving the Gross-Pitaevskii equation for the macroscopic condensate wavefunction and the coupled Bogoliubov equations and their variants for the collective quasiparticle excitation eigenmodes. The computed elementary excitation spectra are used, for instance, in determining the local stability of various condensate states. The vortex formation process is studied at finite temperatures in terms of the surface modes of the condensate providing the Landau critical velocities for the breakdown of superfluidity. Free energy calculations are used for determining the thermodynamic equilibrium states.\n\nSingly quantized, axisymmetric vortex states are found to be locally energetically stable even in the zero-temperature limit within the self-consistent finite-temperature approximations. This would imply for the vortex a precession direction opposite to that observed in the experiment. Adiabatic approximation of quantum mechanics is formulated for Bose-Einstein condensed systems and is applied to a case of a moving vortex line. The experimentally observed precessing motion of the vortex is found to be nonadiabatic. A method to create stable multiply quantized vortices using an additional pinning potential is presented. The computed critical trap rotation frequencies for vortex nucleation at finite temperatures are in agreement with experiments and the predictions of zero-temperature field theories.

•Jan 10, 2003•0 citations

Formation, dynamics, and decay of quantized vortices in Bose-Einstein condensates: Elements of quantum turbulence

Tyler W. Neely

Turbulence in classical fluids has been the subject of scientific study for centuries, yet there is still no complete general theory of classical turbulence connecting microscopic physics to macroscopic fluid flows, and this remains one of the open problems in physics. In contrast, the phenomenon of quantum turbulence in superfluids has well-defined theoretical descriptions, based on first principles and microscopic physics, and represents a realm of physics that can connect the classical and quantum worlds. Studies of quantum turbulence may thus be viewed as a path for progress on the long-standing problem of turbulence.A dilute-gas Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) is, in most cases, a superfluid that supports quantized vortices, the primary structural elements of quantum turbulence. BECs are particularly convenient systems for the study of vortices, as standard techniques allow the microscopic structure and dynamics of the vortices to be investigated. Vortices in BECs can be created and manipulated using a variety of techniques, hence BECs are potentially powerful systems for the microscopic study of quantum turbulence.This dissertation focuses on quantized vortices in BECs, specifically experimental and numerical studies of their formation, dynamics, and decay, in an effort to understand the microscopic nature of vortices as elements of quantum turbulence. Four main experiments were performed, and are described in the main chapters of this dissertation, after introductions to vortices, experimental methods, and turbulence are presented. These experiments were aimed at understanding various aspects of how vortices are created and behave in a superfluid system. They involved vortex dipole nucleation in the breakdown of superfluidity, persistent current generation from a turbulent state in the presence of energy dissipation, decay of angular momentum of a BEC due to trapping potential impurities, and exploration of the spontaneous formation of vortices during the BEC phase transition. These experiments represent progress towards enhanced understanding of the formation, dynamics, and decay of vortices in BECs and thus may be foundational to more general studies of quantum turbulence in superfluids.

•Jan 1, 2010•4 citations
The energy and momentum associated with vortex formation in an imperfect Bose gas have been computed quantum mechanically. In the computation, explicit account is taken of the boundary condition to be satisfied by the wave function at the walls surrounding the fluid. Numerical estimates of the critical velocity obtained thereby throw considerable light on the question of the most favorable location (relative to the walls) for the formation of the vortex. It is concluded that the optimum location for this formation could be well within the fluid---significantly away from the walls.
A theoretical study of rectilinear vortices in an imperfect Bose gas shows a close correspondence with classical hydrodynamics. The energy and momentum of a vortex pair in an unbounded fluid are calculated. The similarity between a vortex pair and a vortex ring leads to an estimate of the critical velocity vc{v}_{c}vc​ of liquid He II in a tube of radius RRR that includes the effect of the walls ${v}_{c}=\frac{C\ensuremath{\hbar}}{2mR}$, where CCC is a constant of order unity. A variational treatment of a system of many identical vortices in a container shows that the energy is lowest for a uniform distribution, and that the number of vortices per unit area $\ensuremath{\nu}$ agrees with Feyman's result $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{2m\ensuremath{\omega}}{h}$. In the classical limit ($h\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$), the angular momentum and energy approach the values for solid-body rotation.
The translational velocity of a vortex with circulation hm\frac{h}{m}mh​ in an imperfect Bose gas is calculated by considering the time dependence of the condensate wave function corresponding to a given initial configuration of vortices. Each vortex in a system of rectilinear vortices is shown to move with the local fluid velocity at its core; a vortex ring of radius RRR is shown to move with velocity $(\frac{h}{4\ensuremath{\pi}\mathrm{mR}})\mathrm{ln}(\frac{8R}{\ensuremath{\alpha}})$, where $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ is a length the order of the core size. Both results agree with the predictions of classical hydrodynamics.
The theory of the condensate of a weakly interacting Bose gas is developed. The condensate is described by a wavefunction ψ(x, t) normalized to the number of particles. It obeys a nonlinear self-consistent field equation. The solution in the presence of a rigid wall with the boundary condition of vanishing wavefunction involves a de Broglie length. This length depends on the mean potential energy per particle. The self-consistent field term keeps the density uniform except in localized spatial regions. In the hydrodynamical version, a key role is played by the quantum potential. A theory of quantized vortices and of general potential flows follows immediately. In contrast to classical hydrodynamics, the cores of vortices are completely determined by the de Broglie length and all energies are finite. Nonstationary disturbances of the condensate correspond to phonons, rotons, vortex waves etc. They can exchange momentum with rigid boundaries. This is compatible with the vanishing of the wavefunction at a boundary. This condition fully determines the dynamics of the system. These points are illustrated by considering the motion of a foreign ion in a Bose gas, a rotating container of fluid, and the Landau criterion for superfluidity.
The goal of creating and observing quantized vortices in trapped Bose gases arose almost immediately following the first achievements of Bose–Einstein condensation. The motivation for doing so was the obvious analogy with vortices in liquid helium and in type-II superconductors, and the fact that the quantization of circulation is directly associated with superfluid flow. It was recognized that the observation of quantized vortices could be taken as indisputable evidence for the existence of superfluidity in these systems.
Bose-Einstein condensation, first predicted by Bose and Einstein in 1924, was finally realized in dilute, weakly interacting gases of alkali atoms in 1995. A few years later, quantized vortices - intimately related to the phenomenon of superfluidity - were created and observed in these novel quantum many-body systems.\n\nIn this Thesis, vortices in dilute atomic Bose-Einstein condensates are studied theoretically and computationally using microscopic mean-field theory formalisms. Special emphasis is on the structure and the stability of vortices at finite temperatures. The formation of quantized circulation in Bose-Einstein condensates is investigated, as well as multiply quantized vorticity and the adiabaticity of the precessing motion of a vortex.\n\nThis research strongly relies on numerically solving the Gross-Pitaevskii equation for the macroscopic condensate wavefunction and the coupled Bogoliubov equations and their variants for the collective quasiparticle excitation eigenmodes. The computed elementary excitation spectra are used, for instance, in determining the local stability of various condensate states. The vortex formation process is studied at finite temperatures in terms of the surface modes of the condensate providing the Landau critical velocities for the breakdown of superfluidity. Free energy calculations are used for determining the thermodynamic equilibrium states.\n\nSingly quantized, axisymmetric vortex states are found to be locally energetically stable even in the zero-temperature limit within the self-consistent finite-temperature approximations. This would imply for the vortex a precession direction opposite to that observed in the experiment. Adiabatic approximation of quantum mechanics is formulated for Bose-Einstein condensed systems and is applied to a case of a moving vortex line. The experimentally observed precessing motion of the vortex is found to be nonadiabatic. A method to create stable multiply quantized vortices using an additional pinning potential is presented. The computed critical trap rotation frequencies for vortex nucleation at finite temperatures are in agreement with experiments and the predictions of zero-temperature field theories.
Turbulence in classical fluids has been the subject of scientific study for centuries, yet there is still no complete general theory of classical turbulence connecting microscopic physics to macroscopic fluid flows, and this remains one of the open problems in physics. In contrast, the phenomenon of quantum turbulence in superfluids has well-defined theoretical descriptions, based on first principles and microscopic physics, and represents a realm of physics that can connect the classical and quantum worlds. Studies of quantum turbulence may thus be viewed as a path for progress on the long-standing problem of turbulence.A dilute-gas Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) is, in most cases, a superfluid that supports quantized vortices, the primary structural elements of quantum turbulence. BECs are particularly convenient systems for the study of vortices, as standard techniques allow the microscopic structure and dynamics of the vortices to be investigated. Vortices in BECs can be created and manipulated using a variety of techniques, hence BECs are potentially powerful systems for the microscopic study of quantum turbulence.This dissertation focuses on quantized vortices in BECs, specifically experimental and numerical studies of their formation, dynamics, and decay, in an effort to understand the microscopic nature of vortices as elements of quantum turbulence. Four main experiments were performed, and are described in the main chapters of this dissertation, after introductions to vortices, experimental methods, and turbulence are presented. These experiments were aimed at understanding various aspects of how vortices are created and behave in a superfluid system. They involved vortex dipole nucleation in the breakdown of superfluidity, persistent current generation from a turbulent state in the presence of energy dissipation, decay of angular momentum of a BEC due to trapping potential impurities, and exploration of the spontaneous formation of vortices during the BEC phase transition. These experiments represent progress towards enhanced understanding of the formation, dynamics, and decay of vortices in BECs and thus may be foundational to more general studies of quantum turbulence in superfluids.