Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Chemical Education

The Particle Inside a Ring: A Two-Dimensional Quantum Problem Visualized by Scanning Tunneling Microscopy

Mark D. Ellison

Published Sep 1, 2008• 9 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The one-dimensional particle-in-a-box model used to introduce quantum mechanics to students suffers from a tenuous connection to a real physical system. This article presents a two-dimensional model, the particle confined within a ring, that directly corresponds to observations of surface electrons in a metal trapped inside a circular barrier. This model involves the solution of the Schrödinger equation in two dimensions, separation of variables, and known solutions to an established differential equation. Because of the striking visual nature of the probability distributions arising from this model, it is likely to captivate student interest. Close agreement between experimental data and this model provides further support for the wave nature of matter and establishes the accuracy of the model.

DOI
10.1021/ed085p1282

Related papers

Solving the Schrödinger equation

Tony Hey, Patrick Walters

This appendix is intended for readers with some knowledge of calculus – mainly how to differentiate and integrate sines and cosines. We consider the problem of finding the quantum probability amplitudes for a particle ‘in a box’. This involves solving the Schrödinger equation for a particle of some energy E , confined to a certain region by an electrical potential V : We consider the case where the electron can only move in one space dimension, rather than in three dimensions as in real life. In spite of the apparent artificiality of this situation, this example illustrates many of the features that occur in more realistic problems. A straightforward three-dimensional generalization of this example can be used to illustrate many features of the quantum physics not only of electrons in a metal, but also of neutrons and protons in the nucleus. The one-dimensional box potential is shown in Fig. 4.8. Outside the box the potential is assumed to be infinitely high so that there is no probability of finding the particle in these regions. The particle is constrained to be within the box, i.e. the quantum amplitude can only be non-zero between x = 0 and x = L , the two ends of the box. Inside this region, the particle can move freely: in other words, the quantum amplitude for the particle in the box is determined by the Schrödinger equation with no potential term: To see what form of solution is allowed, we first ‘tidy up’ the equation by introducing the new variable k : In terms of k , the Schrödinger equation for the particle in the box now reads: which shows the mathematical structure more clearly.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Oct 23, 2003•0 citations

Leading to a Better Understanding of the Particle-in-a-Quantum-Corral Model

Rahime Yağmur Ağcalı, Bahar Atik, Ecenaz Bilgen +2 more

Understanding the concepts of quantum mechanics has always been a challenge for undergraduate students. This is especially so because many of the introductory (analytically solvable) systems and problems discussed in textbooks are seemingly abstract. Using approximate experimental demonstrations of such systems and problems have been shown to be very helpful in teaching and illustrating the basic concepts of quantum mechanics. One such system is the particle-inside-a-ring system, whose experimental demonstration was achieved 25 years ago in the form of a “quantum corral” of iron atoms arranged in a ring on a copper surface by using scanning tunneling microscopy. However, this system, which can be a very good model to demonstrate the concepts of quantum mechanics, has not been treated in depth in the literature or in quantum-chemistry textbooks from an educational point of view. Here, we examine the particle-inside-a-ring system and its experimental demonstration in order to elucidate the difference between the superposition and statistical-mixture concepts and to provide an explicit description of how experimental data can be related (fitted) to a theoretical model.

Journal of Chemical Education•Dec 19, 2018•3 citations

STM Rounds up Electron Waves at the QM Corral

Graham P. Collins

Everyone who has completed an elementary quantum mechanics course has seen plots of solutions of the Schrödinger equation for the archetypal “particle in a box.” Now IBM researchers have used scanning tunneling microscopy to image the rippled density of states of electrons inside a “corral” built with a few dozen carefully positioned iron atoms on a copper surface. (See the cover of this issue.) The spectacular results closely match theoretical models of the system.

Physics Today•Nov 1, 1993•18 citations

CLASSICAL VS. QUANTUM BEHAVIOR IN THE PARTICLE-IN-A-BOX MODEL

Yinuo Guo

This paper examines the particle-in-a-box model as a simple but powerful example that highlights the fundamental differences between classical and quantum physics. In classical mechanics, a particle confined between two rigid walls moves with constant velocity and has a uniform probability of being found anywhere in the box; its energy can take any continuous value. In contrast, solving the Schrödinger equation for an infinite potential well yields standing-wave solutions whose wavelengths must satisfy fixed boundary conditions. These constraints produce discrete, quantized energy levels and non-uniform probability distributions, features with no classical analog. Through analytical derivations and numerical simulations using Python, we visualize wave functions, probability densities, and the statistical convergence of random samples toward the theoretical quantum distributions. Comparisons with the classical uniform distribution emphasize how quantum mechanics replaces certainty with probability and continuity with quantization. Finally, we connect the model to real physical systems—such as electrons confined in atoms—to show how this idealized system provides essential insight into the structure and stability of matter.

MATTER International Journal of Science and Technology•Jun 17, 2026•0 citations

Particle in a Box

Caio Lima Firme

This chapter discusses the problem of one particle in a one-dimensional box free of the potential energy inside the box, that is, no external force is exerted on the particle inside the box. The corresponding Schrödinger equation is given along with the boundary conditions which yields an elliptic second-order differential equation and the solutions are given next: the wave function, quantum numbers and corresponding energy. The normalized wave function is also given which is similar to that of the one-particle harmonic oscillator. Afterwards, the Hamiltonian function of the particle in a bidimensional box is given along with its wave function that is the product of two wave function of the particle in a one-dimensional box and the energy is the sum of two energy components, x and y, of the particle in a one-dimensional box. Finally, there is a couple of exercises to plot the wave functions of a rectangular box to find the probability density of the wave function for a symmetrical box. (164 words).

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 21, 2022•0 citations

Wave Function Penetration, Tunneling, and Quantum Wells

Uri Peskin

Scanning tunneling microscopy is introduced as an analytic tool for characterizing nanostructures and dynamics on the nanoscale. To analyze the underlying tunneling phenomenon, the Schrödinger equation is solved for a particle confined between finite potential energy steps. For a single potential energy well, the proper solutions to the Schrödinger equation are similar to those of a particle in an infinite box, except for the emerging “tails” of the stationary wave functions in the “classically forbidden” regions of the external confining potentials. For a symmetric double well potential, wave function penetration of the stationary solutions manifests in their even distribution among the wells. An attempt to localize the particle in one of them would lead to periodic oscillations between the wells, as if the particle can “tunnel” under the separating energy barrier. The wave function penetration and tunneling phenomena are discussed also in relation to energy band formation in periodic lattices.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•May 11, 2023•0 citations
The one-dimensional particle-in-a-box model used to introduce quantum mechanics to students suffers from a tenuous connection to a real physical system. This article presents a two-dimensional model, the particle confined within a ring, that directly corresponds to observations of surface electrons in a metal trapped inside a circular barrier. This model involves the solution of the Schrödinger equation in two dimensions, separation of variables, and known solutions to an established differential equation. Because of the striking visual nature of the probability distributions arising from this model, it is likely to captivate student interest. Close agreement between experimental data and this model provides further support for the wave nature of matter and establishes the accuracy of the model.
This appendix is intended for readers with some knowledge of calculus – mainly how to differentiate and integrate sines and cosines. We consider the problem of finding the quantum probability amplitudes for a particle ‘in a box’. This involves solving the Schrödinger equation for a particle of some energy E , confined to a certain region by an electrical potential V : We consider the case where the electron can only move in one space dimension, rather than in three dimensions as in real life. In spite of the apparent artificiality of this situation, this example illustrates many of the features that occur in more realistic problems. A straightforward three-dimensional generalization of this example can be used to illustrate many features of the quantum physics not only of electrons in a metal, but also of neutrons and protons in the nucleus. The one-dimensional box potential is shown in Fig. 4.8. Outside the box the potential is assumed to be infinitely high so that there is no probability of finding the particle in these regions. The particle is constrained to be within the box, i.e. the quantum amplitude can only be non-zero between x = 0 and x = L , the two ends of the box. Inside this region, the particle can move freely: in other words, the quantum amplitude for the particle in the box is determined by the Schrödinger equation with no potential term: To see what form of solution is allowed, we first ‘tidy up’ the equation by introducing the new variable k : In terms of k , the Schrödinger equation for the particle in the box now reads: which shows the mathematical structure more clearly.
Understanding the concepts of quantum mechanics has always been a challenge for undergraduate students. This is especially so because many of the introductory (analytically solvable) systems and problems discussed in textbooks are seemingly abstract. Using approximate experimental demonstrations of such systems and problems have been shown to be very helpful in teaching and illustrating the basic concepts of quantum mechanics. One such system is the particle-inside-a-ring system, whose experimental demonstration was achieved 25 years ago in the form of a “quantum corral” of iron atoms arranged in a ring on a copper surface by using scanning tunneling microscopy. However, this system, which can be a very good model to demonstrate the concepts of quantum mechanics, has not been treated in depth in the literature or in quantum-chemistry textbooks from an educational point of view. Here, we examine the particle-inside-a-ring system and its experimental demonstration in order to elucidate the difference between the superposition and statistical-mixture concepts and to provide an explicit description of how experimental data can be related (fitted) to a theoretical model.
This paper examines the particle-in-a-box model as a simple but powerful example that highlights the fundamental differences between classical and quantum physics. In classical mechanics, a particle confined between two rigid walls moves with constant velocity and has a uniform probability of being found anywhere in the box; its energy can take any continuous value. In contrast, solving the Schrödinger equation for an infinite potential well yields standing-wave solutions whose wavelengths must satisfy fixed boundary conditions. These constraints produce discrete, quantized energy levels and non-uniform probability distributions, features with no classical analog. Through analytical derivations and numerical simulations using Python, we visualize wave functions, probability densities, and the statistical convergence of random samples toward the theoretical quantum distributions. Comparisons with the classical uniform distribution emphasize how quantum mechanics replaces certainty with probability and continuity with quantization. Finally, we connect the model to real physical systems—such as electrons confined in atoms—to show how this idealized system provides essential insight into the structure and stability of matter.
This chapter discusses the problem of one particle in a one-dimensional box free of the potential energy inside the box, that is, no external force is exerted on the particle inside the box. The corresponding Schrödinger equation is given along with the boundary conditions which yields an elliptic second-order differential equation and the solutions are given next: the wave function, quantum numbers and corresponding energy. The normalized wave function is also given which is similar to that of the one-particle harmonic oscillator. Afterwards, the Hamiltonian function of the particle in a bidimensional box is given along with its wave function that is the product of two wave function of the particle in a one-dimensional box and the energy is the sum of two energy components, x and y, of the particle in a one-dimensional box. Finally, there is a couple of exercises to plot the wave functions of a rectangular box to find the probability density of the wave function for a symmetrical box. (164 words).
Scanning tunneling microscopy is introduced as an analytic tool for characterizing nanostructures and dynamics on the nanoscale. To analyze the underlying tunneling phenomenon, the Schrödinger equation is solved for a particle confined between finite potential energy steps. For a single potential energy well, the proper solutions to the Schrödinger equation are similar to those of a particle in an infinite box, except for the emerging “tails” of the stationary wave functions in the “classically forbidden” regions of the external confining potentials. For a symmetric double well potential, wave function penetration of the stationary solutions manifests in their even distribution among the wells. An attempt to localize the particle in one of them would lead to periodic oscillations between the wells, as if the particle can “tunnel” under the separating energy barrier. The wave function penetration and tunneling phenomena are discussed also in relation to energy band formation in periodic lattices.