Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Mathematical Physics

Algebraic Difficulties of Preserving Dynamical Relations When Forming Quantum-Mechanical Operators

Richard F. Arens, Donald G. Babbitt

Published Jul 1, 1965• 23 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Proofs are presented showing impossibility of assigning differential operators (quantum observables) to classical mechanical observables in such a way as to preserve the usual bracket formalism. Difficulty is shown to arise even if we limit ourselves to preserving brackets between the Hamiltonian and a rather limited set of observables. Some other algebraic difficulties inherent in the operator assignment problem are also discussed.

DOI
10.1063/1.1704370

Related papers

Nambu mechanics and its quantization

Debendranath Sahoo, M. C. Valsakumar

The algebra of observables inherent in the Nambu formalism [Phys. Rev. D 7, 2405 (1973)] for a generalization of classical Hamiltonian dynamics is investigated. A consistency requirement of time evolution of the Nambu bracket leads to a five-point identity. Two types of algebras are possible at the classical level. Their composition properties under a tensor product are considered and the physical implications are analyzed. A quantum generalization of these algebras is shown to be impossible.

Physical Review A•Oct 1, 1992•39 citations

Formulation of the Classical Mechanics in the Ring of Operators

Abdullah Verçin

By making use of the Weyl-Wigner-Groenewold-Moyal association rules, a commutative product and a new quantum bracket are constructed in the ring of operators \cal{F}(H). In this way, an isomorphism between Lie algebra of classical observables (with Poisson bracket) and the Lie algebra of quantum observables with this new bracket is established. By these observations, a formulation of the classical mechanics in \cal{F}(H} is obtained and is shown to be \hbar\to 0 limit of the Heisenberg picture formulation of the quantum mechanics.

arXiv:quant-ph/9902064•Feb 18, 1999•1 citation

The dynamics of a simple system. I. Observables

F. C. Powell

Any particular form of mechanics (e.g. classical or quantum) makes use of a particular ‘formalism’ or set of rules governing the use of the symbols representing dynamical variables and the symbols (such as +, =) representing relations between dynamical variables. In the present paper an attempt is made to examine the physical content of this formalism, particularly that of quantum mechanics. This is done by building up a formalism as the direct expression of a number of physical postulates having direct operational meaning. It is shown that, in a simple case, with any two observables A and B can be associated a unique sum observable A + B and a unique (real) symmetric product observable A.B (= B.A). It is next shown that, if, like a classical Hamiltonian system, the system has the property that the time rate of change of an observable depends linearly on some observable H when the environment in which the system moves is varied, then a (real) skew product observable A × B (= − B × A) can be defined. Finally, if the equations of motion are ‘of second order', it is possible to express the second rate of change of any observable as an algebraic function of that observable and H. This leads to algebraic identities from which it follows that ‘complex multiplication’, defined by AB = A.B + iA × B, is associative (but not commutative). Observables are thus shown to possess the properties usually ascribed to them in quantum mechanics. These properties make possible a representation by Hermitian matrices.

Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society•Jun 1, 1945•2 citations

Kochen–Specker non-contextuality through the lens of quantization

Simon Friederich, Mritunjay Tyagi

The Kochen–Specker theorem shows that it is impossible to assign sharp values to all dynamical variables in quantum mechanics in such a way that the algebraic relations among the values of dynamical variables whose self-adjoint operators commute are the same as those among the operators themselves. We point out that, for quantum theories obtained by quantizing some classical theory, this condition – Kochen–Specker non-contextuality – is implausible from the start because quantization usually changes algebraic relations. We explain why this is so, using the formalism of deformation quantization and its conception of star products , and we illustrate the relevance of this point using various examples of dynamical variables quantized via Weyl quantization and coherent state quantization. Our observations suggest that the relevance of the Kochen–Specker theorem to the question of whether one can assign sharp values to all dynamical variables is rather limited.

arXiv:2409.13071•Annals of Physics•Jan 21, 2026•1 citation

Quantum discrete phase space dynamics and its continuous limit

M. Ruzzi, D. Galetti

The main aspects of a discrete phase space formalism are presented and the discrete dynamical bracket, suitable for the description of time evolution in finite-dimensional spaces, is discussed. A set of operator bases is defined in such a way that the Weyl-Wigner formalism is shown to be obtained as a limiting case. In the same form, the Moyal bracket is shown to be the limiting case of the discrete dynamical bracket. The dynamics in quantum discrete phase spaces is shown not to be attained from discretization of the continuous case.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Feb 1, 2000•15 citations

Origin of the quantum observable operator algebra in the frame of stochastic mechanics

Francesco Guerra, R. Marra

In previous work the approach to stochastic quantization, originally proposed by Nelson, has been formulated in the frame of the stochastic variational principles of control theory. Then the Hamilton-Jacobi-Madelung equation is interpreted as the programming equation of the controlled problem, to be associated with the hydrodynamical continuity equation. Here we point out explicitly the canonical Hamiltonian structure of these equations, by introducing a suitable symplectic structure on the underlying phase space in various representations. One possible representation leads to the Schr\"odinger equation, which, together with its complex conjugate, can be recognized as a particular form of the Hamilton canonical equations in this frame. Then a suitably selected time-invariant subalgebra of the classical hydrodynamical algebra, closed under Poisson bracket pairing, is shown to be connected to the standard quantum observable operator algebra. In this correspondence Poisson brackets for hydrodynamical observables become averages of quantum observables in the given state. From this point of view stochastic quantization can be interpreted as giving an explanation for the standard quantization procedure of replacing the classical particle (or field) observables with operators, according to the scheme $p\ensuremath{\rightarrow}(\frac{h}{i})\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}}{\ensuremath{\partial}x}$, $l\ensuremath{\rightarrow}(\frac{h}{i})\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}}{\ensuremath{\partial}\ensuremath{\varphi}}$, etc. This discussion shows also the relevance of the canonical symplectic structure of the quantum state space, a feature which seems to have been overlooked in the axiomatic approaches to quantum mechanics.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Oct 15, 1983•36 citations
Proofs are presented showing impossibility of assigning differential operators (quantum observables) to classical mechanical observables in such a way as to preserve the usual bracket formalism. Difficulty is shown to arise even if we limit ourselves to preserving brackets between the Hamiltonian and a rather limited set of observables. Some other algebraic difficulties inherent in the operator assignment problem are also discussed.
By making use of the Weyl-Wigner-Groenewold-Moyal association rules, a commutative product and a new quantum bracket are constructed in the ring of operators \cal{F}(H). In this way, an isomorphism between Lie algebra of classical observables (with Poisson bracket) and the Lie algebra of quantum observables with this new bracket is established. By these observations, a formulation of the classical mechanics in \cal{F}(H} is obtained and is shown to be \hbar\to 0 limit of the Heisenberg picture formulation of the quantum mechanics.
Any particular form of mechanics (e.g. classical or quantum) makes use of a particular ‘formalism’ or set of rules governing the use of the symbols representing dynamical variables and the symbols (such as +, =) representing relations between dynamical variables. In the present paper an attempt is made to examine the physical content of this formalism, particularly that of quantum mechanics. This is done by building up a formalism as the direct expression of a number of physical postulates having direct operational meaning. It is shown that, in a simple case, with any two observables A and B can be associated a unique sum observable A + B and a unique (real) symmetric product observable A.B (= B.A). It is next shown that, if, like a classical Hamiltonian system, the system has the property that the time rate of change of an observable depends linearly on some observable H when the environment in which the system moves is varied, then a (real) skew product observable A × B (= − B × A) can be defined. Finally, if the equations of motion are ‘of second order', it is possible to express the second rate of change of any observable as an algebraic function of that observable and H. This leads to algebraic identities from which it follows that ‘complex multiplication’, defined by AB = A.B + iA × B, is associative (but not commutative). Observables are thus shown to possess the properties usually ascribed to them in quantum mechanics. These properties make possible a representation by Hermitian matrices.
The Kochen–Specker theorem shows that it is impossible to assign sharp values to all dynamical variables in quantum mechanics in such a way that the algebraic relations among the values of dynamical variables whose self-adjoint operators commute are the same as those among the operators themselves. We point out that, for quantum theories obtained by quantizing some classical theory, this condition – Kochen–Specker non-contextuality – is implausible from the start because quantization usually changes algebraic relations. We explain why this is so, using the formalism of deformation quantization and its conception of star products , and we illustrate the relevance of this point using various examples of dynamical variables quantized via Weyl quantization and coherent state quantization. Our observations suggest that the relevance of the Kochen–Specker theorem to the question of whether one can assign sharp values to all dynamical variables is rather limited.
The main aspects of a discrete phase space formalism are presented and the discrete dynamical bracket, suitable for the description of time evolution in finite-dimensional spaces, is discussed. A set of operator bases is defined in such a way that the Weyl-Wigner formalism is shown to be obtained as a limiting case. In the same form, the Moyal bracket is shown to be the limiting case of the discrete dynamical bracket. The dynamics in quantum discrete phase spaces is shown not to be attained from discretization of the continuous case.
In previous work the approach to stochastic quantization, originally proposed by Nelson, has been formulated in the frame of the stochastic variational principles of control theory. Then the Hamilton-Jacobi-Madelung equation is interpreted as the programming equation of the controlled problem, to be associated with the hydrodynamical continuity equation. Here we point out explicitly the canonical Hamiltonian structure of these equations, by introducing a suitable symplectic structure on the underlying phase space in various representations. One possible representation leads to the Schr\"odinger equation, which, together with its complex conjugate, can be recognized as a particular form of the Hamilton canonical equations in this frame. Then a suitably selected time-invariant subalgebra of the classical hydrodynamical algebra, closed under Poisson bracket pairing, is shown to be connected to the standard quantum observable operator algebra. In this correspondence Poisson brackets for hydrodynamical observables become averages of quantum observables in the given state. From this point of view stochastic quantization can be interpreted as giving an explanation for the standard quantization procedure of replacing the classical particle (or field) observables with operators, according to the scheme $p\ensuremath{\rightarrow}(\frac{h}{i})\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}}{\ensuremath{\partial}x}$, $l\ensuremath{\rightarrow}(\frac{h}{i})\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}}{\ensuremath{\partial}\ensuremath{\varphi}}$, etc. This discussion shows also the relevance of the canonical symplectic structure of the quantum state space, a feature which seems to have been overlooked in the axiomatic approaches to quantum mechanics.