Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)

On the complexity of verifiable secret sharing and multiparty computation

Ronald Cramer, Ivan Damgård, Stefan Dziembowski

Published May 1, 2000• 52 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We first study the problem of doing Verifiable Secret Sharing (VSS) information theoretically secure for a general access structure.We do it in the model where private channels between players and a broadcast channel is given, and where an active, adaptive adversary can corrupt any set of players not in the access structure.In particular, we consider the complexity of protocols for this problem, as a function of the access structure and the number of players.For all access structures where VSS is possible at all, we show that, up to a polynomial time black-box reduction, the complexity of adaptively secure VSS is the same as that of ordinary secret sharing (SS), where security is only required against a passive, static adversary.Previously, such a connection was only known for linear secret sharing and VSS schemes.We then show an impossibility result indicating that a similar equivalence does hot hold for Multiparty Computation (MPC): we show that even if protocols are given black-box access for free to an idealized secret sharing scheme secure for the access structure in question, it is not possible to handle all relevant access structures efficiently, not even if the adversary is passive and static.In other words, general MPC can only be black-box reduced efficiently to secret sharing if extra properties of the secret sharing scheme used (such as linearity) are assumed.

DOI
10.1145/335305.335343

Related papers

On the Complexity of Verifiable Secret Sharing and Multi-Party Computation.

Ronald Cramer, Ivan Damgård, Stefan Dziembowski

We first study the problem of doing Verifiable Secret Sharing (VSS) information theoretically secure for a general access structure. We do it in the model where private channels between players and a broadcast channel is given, and where an active, adaptive adversary can corrupt any set of players not in the access structure. In particular, we consider the complexity of protocols for this problem, as a function of the access structure and the number of players. For all access structures where VSS is possible at all, we show that, up to a polynomial time black-box reduction, the complexity of adaptively secure VSS is the same as that of ordinary secret sharing (SS), where security is only required against a passive, static adversary. Previously, such a connection was only known for linear secret sharing and VSS schemes. We then show an impossibility result indicating that a similar equivalence does not hold for Multiparty Computation (MPC): we show that even if protocols are given blac...

•Jan 1, 2000•4 citations

Multiparty Computations Information-Theoretically Secure Against an Adaptive Adversary

Stefan Dziembowski

In this thesis we study a problem of doing Verifiable Secret Sharing (VSS) and Multiparty Computations (MPC) in a model where private channels between the players and a broadcast channel is available. The adversary is active, adaptive and has an unbounded computing power. The thesis is based on two papers [CDD00, CDD 99]. In [CDD00] we assume that the adversary can corrupt any set from a given adversary structure. In this setting we study a problem of doing efficient VSS and MPC given an access to a secret sharing scheme (SS). For all adversary structures where VSS is possible at all, we show that, up to a polynomial time black-box reduction, the complexity of adaptively secure VSS is the same as that of ordinary secret sharing (SS), where security is only required against a passive, static adversary. Previously, such a connection was only known for linear secret sharing and VSS schemes. We then show

•Jan 1, 2002•0 citations

Efficient Multiparty Computations with Dishonest Minority

Ronald Cramer, Ivan Damgård, Stefan Dziembowski +2 more

We consider verifiable secret sharing (VSS) and multiparty computation (MPC) in the secure channels model, where a broadcast channel is given and a non-zero error probability is allowed. In this model Rabin and Ben-Or proposed VSS and MPC protocols, secure against an adversary that can corrupt any minority of the players. In this paper, we rst observe that a subprotocol of theirs, known as weak secret sharing (WSS), is not secure against an adaptive adversary, contrary to what was believed earlier. We then propose new and adaptively secure protocols for WSS, VSS and MPC that are substantially more efficient than the original ones. Our protocols generalize easily to provide security against general Q2 adversaries.

BRICS Report Series•Jun 6, 1998•35 citations

Secure Multi-Player Protocols: Fundamentals, Generality, and Efficiency

Serge Fehr

While classically cryptography is concerned with the problem of private communication among two entities, say players, in modern cryptography multi-player protocols play an important role.And among these, it is probably fair to say that secret sharing, and its stronger version verifiable secret sharing (VSS), as well as multi-party computation (MPC) belong to the most appealing and/or useful ones.The former two are basic tools to achieve better robustness of cryptographic schemes against malfunction or misuse by "decentralizing" the security from one single to a whole group of individuals (captured by the term threshold cryptography).The latter allows-at least in principle-to execute any collaboration among a group of players in a secure way that guarantees the correctness of the outcome but simultaneously respects the privacy of the participants.In this work, we study three aspects of secret sharing, VSS and MPC, which we denote by fundamentals, generality, and efficiency.By fundamentals we mean the quest for understanding why a protocol works and is secure in abstract (and hopefully simple) mathematical terms.By generality we mean generality with respect to the underlying mathematical structure, in other words, minimizing the mathematical axioms required to do some task.And efficiency of course deals with the improvement of protocols with respect to some meaningful complexity measure.We briefly summarize our main results.(1) We give a complete characterization of blackbox secret sharing in terms of simple algebraic conditions on the integer sharing coefficients, and we propose a black-box secret sharing scheme with minimal expansion factor.Note that, in contrast to the classical field-based secret sharing schemes, a black-box secret sharing scheme allows to share a secret sampled from an arbitrary Abelian group and requires only black-box access to the group operations and to random group elements.Such a scheme may be very useful in the construction of threshold cryptosystems based on groups with secret order (like RSA).(2) We show that without loss of efficiency, MPC can be based on arbitrary finite rings.This is in sharp contrast to the literature where essentially all MPC protocols require a much stronger mathematical structure, namely a field.Apart from its theoretical value, this can lead to efficiency improvements since it allows a greater freedom in the (mathematical) representation of the task that needs to be securely executed.(3) We propose a unified treatment of perfectly secure linear VSS and distributed commitments (a weaker version of the former), and we show that the security of such a scheme can be reduced to a linear algebra condition.The security of all known schemes follows as corollaries whose proofs are pure linear algebra arguments, in contrast v to some hybrid arguments used in the literature.(4) We construct a new unconditionally secure VSS scheme with minimized reconstruction complexity in the setting of a dishonest minority.This improves on the reconstruction complexity of the previously best known scheme without affecting the (asymptotic) complexity of the sharing phase.In the context of MPC with pre-processing, our scheme allows to improve the computation phase of earlier protocols without increasing the complexity of the pre-processing.(5) Finally, we consider commitment multiplication proofs, which allow to prove a multiplicative relation among three commitments, and which play a crucial role in computationally secure MPC.We study a non-interactive solution which works in a distributed-verifier setting and essentially consists of a few executions of Pedersen's VSS.We simplify and improve the protocol, and we point out a (previously overlooked) property which helps to construct non-interactive proofs of partial knowledge in this setting.This allows for instance to prove the knowledge of ℓ out of m given secrets, without revealing which ones.We also construct a noninteractive distributed-verifier proof of circuit satisfiability, which-in principle-allows to prove anything that can be proven without giving away the proof.

•Jan 1, 2003•2 citations

Broadcast and verifiable secret sharing: new security models and round optimal constructions

Jonathan I. Katz, Ranjit Kumaresan

Broadcast and verifiable secret sharing (VSS) are central building blocks for secure multi-party computation. These protocols are required to be resilient against a Byzantine adversary who controls at most t out of the n parties running the protocol. In this dissertation, we consider the design of fault-tolerant protocols for broadcast and verifiable secret sharing with stronger security guarantees and improved round complexity. Broadcast allows a party to send the same message to all parties, and all parties are assured they have received identical messages. Given a public-key infrastructure (PKI) and digital signatures, it is possible to construct broadcast protocols tolerating any number of corrupted parties. We address two important issues related to broadcast: (1) Almost all existing protocols do not distinguish between corrupted parties (who do not follow the protocol) and honest parties whose secret (signing) keys have been compromised (but who continue to behave honestly); (2) all existing protocols for broadcast are insecure against an adaptive adversary who can choose which parties to corrupt as the protocol progresses. We propose new security models that capture these issues, and present tight feasibility and impossibility results. In the problem of verifiable secret sharing, there is a designated player who shares a secret during an initial sharing phase such that the secret is hidden from an adversary that corrupts at most t parties. In a subsequent reconstruction phase of the protocol, a unique secret, well-defined by the view of honest players in the sharing phase, is reconstructed. The round complexity of VSS protocols is a very important metric of their efficiency. We show two improvements regarding the round complexity of information-theoretic VSS. First, we construct an efficient perfectly secure VSS protocol tolerating t < n/3 corrupted parties that is simultaneously optimal in both the number of rounds and the number of invocations of broadcast. Second, we construct a statistically secure VSS protocol tolerating t < n/2 corrupted parties that has optimal round complexity, and an efficient statistical VSS protocol tolerating t < n/2 corrupted parties that requires one additional round.

•Jan 1, 2012•1 citation

Probabilistic Verifiable Secret Sharing Tolerating Adaptive Adversary.

Arpita Patra, Ashish Choudhary, B. V. Ashwinkumar +1 more

In this work we focus on two basic secure distributed computation tasks- Probabilistic Weak Secret Sharing (PWSS) and Probabilistic Verifiable Secret Sharing (PVSS). PVSS allows a dealer to share a secret among several players in a way that would later allow a unique reconstruction of the secret with negligible error probability. PWSS is slightly weaker version of PVSS where the dealer can choose not to disclose his secret later. Both of them are well-studied problems. While PVSS is used as a building block in every general probabilistic secure multiparty computation, PWSS can be used as a building block for PVSS protocols. Both these problems can be parameterized by the number of players (n) and the fault tolerance threshold (t) which bounds the total number of malicious (Byzantine) players having unbounded computing power. We focus on the standard secure channel model, where all players have access to secure point-topoint channels and a common broadcast medium. We show the following for PVSS: (a) 1-round PVSS is possible iff t = 1 and n> 3 (b) 2-round PVSS is possible if n> 3t (c) 4-round PVSS is possible if n> 2t. For the PWSS we show the following: (a) 1-round PWSS is possible iff n> 3t and (b) 3-round PWSS is possible if n> 2t. All our protocols are efficient. Comparing our results with the existing trade-off results for perfect (zero error probability) VSS and WSS, we find that probabilistically relaxing the conditions of VSS/WSS helps to increase fault tolerance significantly.

•Jan 1, 2008•2 citations
We first study the problem of doing Verifiable Secret Sharing (VSS) information theoretically secure for a general access structure.We do it in the model where private channels between players and a broadcast channel is given, and where an active, adaptive adversary can corrupt any set of players not in the access structure.In particular, we consider the complexity of protocols for this problem, as a function of the access structure and the number of players.For all access structures where VSS is possible at all, we show that, up to a polynomial time black-box reduction, the complexity of adaptively secure VSS is the same as that of ordinary secret sharing (SS), where security is only required against a passive, static adversary.Previously, such a connection was only known for linear secret sharing and VSS schemes.We then show an impossibility result indicating that a similar equivalence does hot hold for Multiparty Computation (MPC): we show that even if protocols are given black-box access for free to an idealized secret sharing scheme secure for the access structure in question, it is not possible to handle all relevant access structures efficiently, not even if the adversary is passive and static.In other words, general MPC can only be black-box reduced efficiently to secret sharing if extra properties of the secret sharing scheme used (such as linearity) are assumed.
We first study the problem of doing Verifiable Secret Sharing (VSS) information theoretically secure for a general access structure. We do it in the model where private channels between players and a broadcast channel is given, and where an active, adaptive adversary can corrupt any set of players not in the access structure. In particular, we consider the complexity of protocols for this problem, as a function of the access structure and the number of players. For all access structures where VSS is possible at all, we show that, up to a polynomial time black-box reduction, the complexity of adaptively secure VSS is the same as that of ordinary secret sharing (SS), where security is only required against a passive, static adversary. Previously, such a connection was only known for linear secret sharing and VSS schemes. We then show an impossibility result indicating that a similar equivalence does not hold for Multiparty Computation (MPC): we show that even if protocols are given blac...
In this thesis we study a problem of doing Verifiable Secret Sharing (VSS) and Multiparty Computations (MPC) in a model where private channels between the players and a broadcast channel is available. The adversary is active, adaptive and has an unbounded computing power. The thesis is based on two papers [CDD00, CDD 99]. In [CDD00] we assume that the adversary can corrupt any set from a given adversary structure. In this setting we study a problem of doing efficient VSS and MPC given an access to a secret sharing scheme (SS). For all adversary structures where VSS is possible at all, we show that, up to a polynomial time black-box reduction, the complexity of adaptively secure VSS is the same as that of ordinary secret sharing (SS), where security is only required against a passive, static adversary. Previously, such a connection was only known for linear secret sharing and VSS schemes. We then show
We consider verifiable secret sharing (VSS) and multiparty computation (MPC) in the secure channels model, where a broadcast channel is given and a non-zero error probability is allowed. In this model Rabin and Ben-Or proposed VSS and MPC protocols, secure against an adversary that can corrupt any minority of the players. In this paper, we rst observe that a subprotocol of theirs, known as weak secret sharing (WSS), is not secure against an adaptive adversary, contrary to what was believed earlier. We then propose new and adaptively secure protocols for WSS, VSS and MPC that are substantially more efficient than the original ones. Our protocols generalize easily to provide security against general Q2 adversaries.
While classically cryptography is concerned with the problem of private communication among two entities, say players, in modern cryptography multi-player protocols play an important role.And among these, it is probably fair to say that secret sharing, and its stronger version verifiable secret sharing (VSS), as well as multi-party computation (MPC) belong to the most appealing and/or useful ones.The former two are basic tools to achieve better robustness of cryptographic schemes against malfunction or misuse by "decentralizing" the security from one single to a whole group of individuals (captured by the term threshold cryptography).The latter allows-at least in principle-to execute any collaboration among a group of players in a secure way that guarantees the correctness of the outcome but simultaneously respects the privacy of the participants.In this work, we study three aspects of secret sharing, VSS and MPC, which we denote by fundamentals, generality, and efficiency.By fundamentals we mean the quest for understanding why a protocol works and is secure in abstract (and hopefully simple) mathematical terms.By generality we mean generality with respect to the underlying mathematical structure, in other words, minimizing the mathematical axioms required to do some task.And efficiency of course deals with the improvement of protocols with respect to some meaningful complexity measure.We briefly summarize our main results.(1) We give a complete characterization of blackbox secret sharing in terms of simple algebraic conditions on the integer sharing coefficients, and we propose a black-box secret sharing scheme with minimal expansion factor.Note that, in contrast to the classical field-based secret sharing schemes, a black-box secret sharing scheme allows to share a secret sampled from an arbitrary Abelian group and requires only black-box access to the group operations and to random group elements.Such a scheme may be very useful in the construction of threshold cryptosystems based on groups with secret order (like RSA).(2) We show that without loss of efficiency, MPC can be based on arbitrary finite rings.This is in sharp contrast to the literature where essentially all MPC protocols require a much stronger mathematical structure, namely a field.Apart from its theoretical value, this can lead to efficiency improvements since it allows a greater freedom in the (mathematical) representation of the task that needs to be securely executed.(3) We propose a unified treatment of perfectly secure linear VSS and distributed commitments (a weaker version of the former), and we show that the security of such a scheme can be reduced to a linear algebra condition.The security of all known schemes follows as corollaries whose proofs are pure linear algebra arguments, in contrast v to some hybrid arguments used in the literature.(4) We construct a new unconditionally secure VSS scheme with minimized reconstruction complexity in the setting of a dishonest minority.This improves on the reconstruction complexity of the previously best known scheme without affecting the (asymptotic) complexity of the sharing phase.In the context of MPC with pre-processing, our scheme allows to improve the computation phase of earlier protocols without increasing the complexity of the pre-processing.(5) Finally, we consider commitment multiplication proofs, which allow to prove a multiplicative relation among three commitments, and which play a crucial role in computationally secure MPC.We study a non-interactive solution which works in a distributed-verifier setting and essentially consists of a few executions of Pedersen's VSS.We simplify and improve the protocol, and we point out a (previously overlooked) property which helps to construct non-interactive proofs of partial knowledge in this setting.This allows for instance to prove the knowledge of ℓ out of m given secrets, without revealing which ones.We also construct a noninteractive distributed-verifier proof of circuit satisfiability, which-in principle-allows to prove anything that can be proven without giving away the proof.
Broadcast and verifiable secret sharing (VSS) are central building blocks for secure multi-party computation. These protocols are required to be resilient against a Byzantine adversary who controls at most t out of the n parties running the protocol. In this dissertation, we consider the design of fault-tolerant protocols for broadcast and verifiable secret sharing with stronger security guarantees and improved round complexity. Broadcast allows a party to send the same message to all parties, and all parties are assured they have received identical messages. Given a public-key infrastructure (PKI) and digital signatures, it is possible to construct broadcast protocols tolerating any number of corrupted parties. We address two important issues related to broadcast: (1) Almost all existing protocols do not distinguish between corrupted parties (who do not follow the protocol) and honest parties whose secret (signing) keys have been compromised (but who continue to behave honestly); (2) all existing protocols for broadcast are insecure against an adaptive adversary who can choose which parties to corrupt as the protocol progresses. We propose new security models that capture these issues, and present tight feasibility and impossibility results. In the problem of verifiable secret sharing, there is a designated player who shares a secret during an initial sharing phase such that the secret is hidden from an adversary that corrupts at most t parties. In a subsequent reconstruction phase of the protocol, a unique secret, well-defined by the view of honest players in the sharing phase, is reconstructed. The round complexity of VSS protocols is a very important metric of their efficiency. We show two improvements regarding the round complexity of information-theoretic VSS. First, we construct an efficient perfectly secure VSS protocol tolerating t < n/3 corrupted parties that is simultaneously optimal in both the number of rounds and the number of invocations of broadcast. Second, we construct a statistically secure VSS protocol tolerating t < n/2 corrupted parties that has optimal round complexity, and an efficient statistical VSS protocol tolerating t < n/2 corrupted parties that requires one additional round.
In this work we focus on two basic secure distributed computation tasks- Probabilistic Weak Secret Sharing (PWSS) and Probabilistic Verifiable Secret Sharing (PVSS). PVSS allows a dealer to share a secret among several players in a way that would later allow a unique reconstruction of the secret with negligible error probability. PWSS is slightly weaker version of PVSS where the dealer can choose not to disclose his secret later. Both of them are well-studied problems. While PVSS is used as a building block in every general probabilistic secure multiparty computation, PWSS can be used as a building block for PVSS protocols. Both these problems can be parameterized by the number of players (n) and the fault tolerance threshold (t) which bounds the total number of malicious (Byzantine) players having unbounded computing power. We focus on the standard secure channel model, where all players have access to secure point-topoint channels and a common broadcast medium. We show the following for PVSS: (a) 1-round PVSS is possible iff t = 1 and n> 3 (b) 2-round PVSS is possible if n> 3t (c) 4-round PVSS is possible if n> 2t. For the PWSS we show the following: (a) 1-round PWSS is possible iff n> 3t and (b) 3-round PWSS is possible if n> 2t. All our protocols are efficient. Comparing our results with the existing trade-off results for perfect (zero error probability) VSS and WSS, we find that probabilistically relaxing the conditions of VSS/WSS helps to increase fault tolerance significantly.