Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Nature of quantum jumps

Arthur A. Broyles

Published Apr 1, 1992• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Recent experiments have found abrupt changes in the intensity of laser light scattered off single ions and atoms. These abrupt changes have been interpreted as resulting from Bohr's ``quantum jumps'' of the ion or atom from one state to another. In Bohr's description, such quantum jumps are not predicted by the Schr\"odinger equation and are introduced by additional postulates into quantum theory. We consider here an alternative explanation of these experiments using only properties of solutions of the Schr\"odinger equation and avoiding Bohr's added postulate.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.45.4925

Related papers

Exact quasiclassical asymptotic beyond Maslov canonical operator and quantum jumps nature

Jaykov Foukzon, Alexander A. Potapov, Подосенов Станислав Александрович

A number of experiments on trapped single ions or atoms have been performed in recent years [1,2,3,4]. Monitoring the intensity of scattered laser light off of such systems has shown abrupt changes that have been cited as evidence of between states of the scattered ion or atom . The existence of such jumps was required by Bohr in his theory of the atom. Bohr’s quantum jumps between atomic states [5] were the first form of quantum dynamics to be postulated. He assumed that an atom remained in an atomic eigenstate until it made an instantaneous jump to another state with the emission or absorption of a photon. Since these jumps do not appear to occur in solutions of the Schrodinger equation, something similar to Bohr's idea has been added as an extra postulate in modern quantum mechanics. Stochastic quantum jump equations [6], [7],[8]were introduced as a tool for simulating the dynamics of a dissipative system with a large Hilbert space and their links with quantum measurement the or were also noted [9],[10],[11],[12],[13].This measurement interpretation is generally known as quantum trajectory theory [14].By adding filter cavities as part of the apparatus, even the quantum jumps in the dressed state model can be interpreted as approximations to measurement-induced jumps [15]. The question arises whether an explanation of these jumps can be found to result from an Colombeau solution [16]-[18](Ψe(x, t;ħ))e of the Schrodinger equation alone without additional postulates. We found exact quasi-classical asymptotic of the quantum averages

•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

Quantum Jumps: Schrödinger’s Objections and the Contemporary Points of View

Sotirios A. Sakkopoulos

In 1913, when Bohr’s atom allowed electron jumps between discrete orbits, it was impossible to experiment on single atoms and study individually these jumps. Many people considered them not real, but something artificial for the explanation of the linear spectra of atoms. Especially Schrödinger rejected the image of negatively charged electrons orbiting around the nucleus and in particular their jumps from orbit to orbit. Finally, in 1986 single atoms (ions) laser cooled and confined in an electromagnetic trap gave the possibility to investigate experimentally electron jumps to and fro a metastable state. Recently, physicists experimenting on a macroscopic superconducting circuit with discrete quantum states analogous to a natural atom were able to halt and reverse quantum jumps mid-flight revealing very interesting details of them.

Sumerianz Journal of Scientific Research•Dec 17, 2021•0 citations

Quantum jumps, superpositions, and the continuous evolution of quantum states

Rainer Dick

The apparent dichotomy between quantum jumps on the one hand, and continuous time evolution according to wave equations on the other hand, provided a challenge to Bohr's proposal of quantum jumps in atoms. Furthermore, Schrödinger's time-dependent equation also seemed to require a modification of the explanation for the origin of line spectra due to the apparent possibility of superpositions of energy eigenstates for different energy levels. Indeed, Schrödinger himself proposed a quantum beat mechanism for the generation of discrete line spectra from superpositions of eigenstates with different energies. However, these issues between old quantum theory and Schrödinger's wave mechanics were correctly resolved only after the development and full implementation of photon quantization. The second quantized scattering matrix formalism reconciles quantum jumps with continuous time evolution through the identification of quantum jumps with transitions between different sectors of Fock space. The continuous evolution of quantum states is then recognized as a sum over continually evolving jump amplitudes between different sectors in Fock space. In today's terminology, this suggests that linear combinations of scattering matrix elements are epistemic sums over ontic states. Insights from the resolution of the dichotomy between quantum jumps and continuous time evolution therefore hold important lessons for modern research both on interpretations of quantum mechanics and on the foundations of quantum computing. They demonstrate that discussions of interpretations of quantum theory necessarily need to take into account field quantization. They also demonstrate the limitations of the role of wave equations in quantum theory, and caution us that superpositions of quantum states for the formation of qubits may be more limited than usually expected.

arXiv:1703.06230•Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics•Dec 3, 2016•10 citations

Precise test of quantum jump theory

Randall G. Hulet, David J. Wineland, Jonas Bergquist +1 more

Quantum jumps due solely to spontaneous Raman scattering between the Zeeman sublevels of a single $^{24}\mathrm{Mg}^{+}$ ion have been observed in the fluorescence emitted by the ion. A theory of quantum jumps for this system predicts that coherences between excited levels cause the ratio of the mean duration of the "fluorescence-on periods" to the mean duration of the "fluorescence-off periods" to be independent of laser intensity. The measured value agrees with the predicted one to within the measurement precision of 2%. The distribution of the durations of the off periods also agrees with theory.

Physical Review A•Jun 1, 1988•26 citations

Continuous Coherent Flight Alternative to Quantum Jumps-Reassessing the Bohr–Einstein Discontinuity Postulate in Light of Continuous Quantum Trajectory Theory and Continuous-Monitoring Experiments

P. P. Afxenti

•Jul 13, 2026•0 citations

Observation of Quantum Jumps

Thilo Sauter, Werner Neuhauser, R. Blatt +1 more

We have recorded the laser-excited resonance fluorescence of one to three ${\mathrm{Ba}}^{+}$ ions and observed Bohr's "quantum jumps" when an ion decayed to the metastable $^{2}D_{\frac{5}{2}}$ state, suddenly quenching its fluorescence. Most of the jumps mark Raman-Stokes scattering from the $^{2}S_{\frac{1}{2}}$ and $^{2}D_{\frac{3}{2}}$ levels.

Physical Review Letters•Oct 6, 1986•658 citations
Recent experiments have found abrupt changes in the intensity of laser light scattered off single ions and atoms. These abrupt changes have been interpreted as resulting from Bohr's ``quantum jumps'' of the ion or atom from one state to another. In Bohr's description, such quantum jumps are not predicted by the Schr"odinger equation and are introduced by additional postulates into quantum theory. We consider here an alternative explanation of these experiments using only properties of solutions of the Schr"odinger equation and avoiding Bohr's added postulate.
A number of experiments on trapped single ions or atoms have been performed in recent years [1,2,3,4]. Monitoring the intensity of scattered laser light off of such systems has shown abrupt changes that have been cited as evidence of between states of the scattered ion or atom . The existence of such jumps was required by Bohr in his theory of the atom. Bohr’s quantum jumps between atomic states [5] were the first form of quantum dynamics to be postulated. He assumed that an atom remained in an atomic eigenstate until it made an instantaneous jump to another state with the emission or absorption of a photon. Since these jumps do not appear to occur in solutions of the Schrodinger equation, something similar to Bohr's idea has been added as an extra postulate in modern quantum mechanics. Stochastic quantum jump equations [6], [7],[8]were introduced as a tool for simulating the dynamics of a dissipative system with a large Hilbert space and their links with quantum measurement the or were also noted [9],[10],[11],[12],[13].This measurement interpretation is generally known as quantum trajectory theory [14].By adding filter cavities as part of the apparatus, even the quantum jumps in the dressed state model can be interpreted as approximations to measurement-induced jumps [15]. The question arises whether an explanation of these jumps can be found to result from an Colombeau solution [16]-[18](Ψe(x, t;ħ))e of the Schrodinger equation alone without additional postulates. We found exact quasi-classical asymptotic of the quantum averages
In 1913, when Bohr’s atom allowed electron jumps between discrete orbits, it was impossible to experiment on single atoms and study individually these jumps. Many people considered them not real, but something artificial for the explanation of the linear spectra of atoms. Especially Schrödinger rejected the image of negatively charged electrons orbiting around the nucleus and in particular their jumps from orbit to orbit. Finally, in 1986 single atoms (ions) laser cooled and confined in an electromagnetic trap gave the possibility to investigate experimentally electron jumps to and fro a metastable state. Recently, physicists experimenting on a macroscopic superconducting circuit with discrete quantum states analogous to a natural atom were able to halt and reverse quantum jumps mid-flight revealing very interesting details of them.
The apparent dichotomy between quantum jumps on the one hand, and continuous time evolution according to wave equations on the other hand, provided a challenge to Bohr's proposal of quantum jumps in atoms. Furthermore, Schrödinger's time-dependent equation also seemed to require a modification of the explanation for the origin of line spectra due to the apparent possibility of superpositions of energy eigenstates for different energy levels. Indeed, Schrödinger himself proposed a quantum beat mechanism for the generation of discrete line spectra from superpositions of eigenstates with different energies. However, these issues between old quantum theory and Schrödinger's wave mechanics were correctly resolved only after the development and full implementation of photon quantization. The second quantized scattering matrix formalism reconciles quantum jumps with continuous time evolution through the identification of quantum jumps with transitions between different sectors of Fock space. The continuous evolution of quantum states is then recognized as a sum over continually evolving jump amplitudes between different sectors in Fock space. In today's terminology, this suggests that linear combinations of scattering matrix elements are epistemic sums over ontic states. Insights from the resolution of the dichotomy between quantum jumps and continuous time evolution therefore hold important lessons for modern research both on interpretations of quantum mechanics and on the foundations of quantum computing. They demonstrate that discussions of interpretations of quantum theory necessarily need to take into account field quantization. They also demonstrate the limitations of the role of wave equations in quantum theory, and caution us that superpositions of quantum states for the formation of qubits may be more limited than usually expected.
Quantum jumps due solely to spontaneous Raman scattering between the Zeeman sublevels of a single 24Mg+^{24}\mathrm{Mg}^{+}24Mg+ ion have been observed in the fluorescence emitted by the ion. A theory of quantum jumps for this system predicts that coherences between excited levels cause the ratio of the mean duration of the "fluorescence-on periods" to the mean duration of the "fluorescence-off periods" to be independent of laser intensity. The measured value agrees with the predicted one to within the measurement precision of 2%. The distribution of the durations of the off periods also agrees with theory.
We have recorded the laser-excited resonance fluorescence of one to three Ba+{\mathrm{Ba}}^{+}Ba+ ions and observed Bohr's "quantum jumps" when an ion decayed to the metastable 2D52^{2}D_{\frac{5}{2}}2D25​​ state, suddenly quenching its fluorescence. Most of the jumps mark Raman-Stokes scattering from the 2S12^{2}S_{\frac{1}{2}}2S21​​ and 2D32^{2}D_{\frac{3}{2}}2D23​​ levels.