We show that if an electromagnetic energy pulse in a multimode coherent state with average photon number
n is used to carry out the same quantum logical operation on a set of
N atoms, either simultaneously or sequentially, the overall error probability in the worst-case scenario (i.e., maximized over all the possible initial atomic states) scales as
N2∕n. This means that in order to keep the error probability bounded by
Nϵ, with $ϵ\ensuremath{\sim}1∕\overline{n}$, one needs to use
Nn photons or, equivalently,
N separate ``minimum-energy'' pulses: in this sense the pulses cannot, in general, be shared. The origin of this phenomenon is found in atom-field entanglement. These results may have important consequences for quantum logic and, in particular, for large-scale quantum computation.
A lower bound on the amount of energy needed to carry out an elementary logical operation on a qubit system, with a given accuracy and in a given time, has been recently postulated. This paper is an attempt to formalize this bound and explore the conditions under which it may be expected to hold. For a specific, important case (namely, when the control system is a quantized electromagnetic field) it is shown how one can extend this result to a generally stronger constraint on the minimum energy density required, per pulse.