Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General

Criteria for the onset of Bose-Einstein condensation in ideal systems confined to restricted geometries

H. R. Pajkowski, Raj K. Pathria

Published Apr 1, 1977• 20 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Several authors have proposed criteria for the onset of Bose-Einstein condensation in finite systems. Using mathematical techniques developed by Pathria and collaborators (1972) these various proposals are systematically examined by applying them to an ideal Bose gas confined to a cuboidal enclosure under periodic boundary conditions. The 'transition points' thus obtained have been subjected to a comparative study, which indicates that the most useful general criterion is the macroscopic one based on the maximum of the specific heat C v .

DOI
10.1088/0305-4470/10/4/018

Related papers

Bose-Einstein condensation in finite noninteracting systems: A new law of corresponding states

Stanley Greenspoon, Raj K. Pathria

We have carried out a rigorous asymptotic analysis of the thermodynamic behavior of an ideal Bose gas confined to an arbitrary, finite cuboidal geometry under periodic boundary conditions. Our investigation, which is based on the grand canonical ensemble, leads to the construction of an abstract, thermogeometric space in which the process of Bose-Einstein condensation appears as a "collapse" of the lattice points of the space towards its origin. In an infinite geometry, the collapse is accomplished in an infinitesimally small interval of temperature; this results in the appearance of mathematical singularities in the thermodynamic functions of the system. In a finite geometry, the "collapse" proceeds gradually and is spread over a temperature range $\ensuremath{\Delta}T$ such that $\frac{\ensuremath{\Delta}T}{{T}_{0}}=O(\frac{\overline{l}}{{L}_{<}})$, where $\overline{l}$ is the mean interatomic distance while ${L}_{<}$ is the length of the shortest side of the assembly; accordingly, the thermodynamic functions of the system remain smooth throughout. Special events, such as the specific-heat maximum, occur when the "lattice parameters" of our thermogeometric space acquire certain characteristic values which depend only on the shape of the system and not on its actual size. This leads to a new law of corresponding states for Bose-Einstein systems of finite size.

Physical Review A•May 1, 1974•48 citations

Bose-Einstein condensation in a three-dimensional system at constant pressure

A. N. Chaba, Raj K. Pathria

Using techniques developed by Greenspoon and Pathria, and by Chaba and Pathria, a rigorous asymptotic analysis of the onset of Bose-Einstein condensation in a finite three-dimensional system at constant pressure, under Dirichlet boundary conditions, is carried out. Finite size corrections arising from a modification of the density of states of the system, as well as from the discreteness of the single-particle energy levels, play an important role in the critical region. At the critical temperature ${T}_{c}$, the volume of the system changes abruptly from being proportional to the total number of particles $N$ to being proportional to ${N}^{\frac{3}{4}}$, the number of particles in the condensate rises sharply from $\ensuremath{\propto}{N}^{\frac{1}{4}}$ to $\ensuremath{\propto}N$, and the specific heat ${C}_{P}$ turns out to be proportional to ${N}^{\frac{9}{8}}$. At somewhat lower temperatures, the finite size effects arising from the discreteness of the single-particle energy levels become dominant and the volume of the system, together with ${C}_{P}$, becomes $\ensuremath{\propto}{N}^{\frac{3}{5}}$.

Physical Review A•Sep 1, 1978•8 citations

Bose-Einstein condensation in a two-dimensional system at constant pressure

A. N. Chaba, Raj K. Pathria

Using techniques developed by Greenspoon and Pathria, a rigorous, asymptotic analysis of the onset of Bose-Einstein condensation in a finite two-dimensional system at constant pressure is carried out. Some of the results obtained by Imry, Bergman, and Gunther, who first considered this problem, are upheld while others get modified. In particular, a macroscopic occupation of the single-particle ground state at finite temperatures is indeed possible. As the critical region, $T\ensuremath{\simeq}{T}_{c}$, is approached from above, the volume of the system becomes subextensive, ${V}_{c}=O(\frac{N}{\mathrm{ln}N})$, which is both necessary and sufficient for the onset of Bose-Einstein condensation in the system. For instance, if the system is now cooled even at constant volume $V(={V}_{c})$, the condensate fraction gradually builds up and becomes nonnegligible as $T$ approaches ${T}_{0}\ensuremath{\simeq}\frac{({T}_{c})}{2}$; below ${T}_{0}$, it grows steadily as $(1\ensuremath{-}\frac{T}{{T}_{0}})$. On the other hand, if we continued to cool the system at constant $P$ its volume, over a thermodynamically negligible range of temperatures, would reduce to values $O({N}^{\frac{1}{2}})$ which, in turn, would be accompanied by an abrupt accumulation of practically all the particles of the system into the single-particle ground state ${\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{0}$. The specific heat ${C}_{P}$, after having passed through a maximum, would also finally reduce to subextensive values. Phase transitions of this kind may be of relevance to the physical behavior of thin helium films and helium submonolayers.

Physical review. B, Solid state•Nov 1, 1975•14 citations

Bose-Einstein condensation of a finite number of particles confined to harmonic traps

Raj K. Pathria

The onset of Bose-Einstein condensation in a sample of N atoms confined to harmonic traps is critically examined. The monotonic growth of the condensate fraction f and the nonmonotic variation of the specific heat C of the sample are studied in fine detail. While no temperature is truly critical, our analysis does provide a strong theoretical basis for recognizing a temperature ${T}^{*},$ that has been identified and advocated by previous authors, as the transition temperature of the system. The specific-heat maximum ${T}_{m}$ (which happens to be another important ``marker'' in this transition), the value of the specific heat at ${T=T}_{m},$ and the ``jump'' in the specific heat of the system when the number N becomes very large are all explicitly evaluated. Wherever comparison is possible, our analytical results are found to be in perfect agreement with the ones obtained numerically by Kirsten and Toms [Phys. Rev. A 54, 4188 (1996)] and by Haugerud, Haugest, and Ravndal [Phys. Lett. A 225, 18 (1997)].

Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1998•58 citations

Bose-Einstein condensation in finite noninteracting systems: A relativistic gas with pair production. II

Surjit Singh, Raj K. Pathria

An asymptotic evaluation of the specific heat of an ideal relativistic Bose gas confined to a cuboidal enclosure (${L}_{1}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{L}_{2}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{L}_{3}$) is carried out, under periodic boundary conditions, taking into account the possibility of particle-antiparticle pair production in the system. Finite-size corrections to the standard bulk behavior are calculated explicitly in the regions $t>0$ and $t<0$, where $t=\frac{(T\ensuremath{-}{T}_{c})}{{T}_{c}}$, such that $|t|\ensuremath{\ll}1$ and $|{L}_{i}t|\ensuremath{\gg}1$. While for $t>0$ finite-size corrections turn out to be exponential for all geometries, for $t<0$ this is true only in the case of a film; for other geometries, such as a cuboid or a rectangular channel, these corrections conform to a power law instead. Finally, we consider the situation in the core region, where $|{L}_{i}t|=O(1)$, and examine the location ${t}^{*}$ and the height ${c}_{\ensuremath{\rho}}^{*}$ of the specific-heat maximum; finite-size corrections in this region turn out to be $O({L}_{<}^{\ensuremath{-}1})$, where ${L}_{<}$ denotes the shortest side of the enclosure.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1984•12 citations

Finite Geometries and Ideal Bose Gases

David A. Krueger

It is shown that the lack of condensation in partially finite geometries is not dependent on the use of periodic boundary conditions or the symmetry-breaking technique for a class of independent-particle Bose-gas models. Condensation in an ideal Bose gas in a finite geometry is studied for one-, two-, and three-dimensional systems. Explicit expressions for the chemical potential in terms of the number of particles, the temperature, and the dimensions of the system are obtained by using a contour-integration technique to express sums as integrals plus corrections. Even though there is no true condensation, the range of the reduced density matrix for an ideal Bose gas in a thick slab (${L}_{1}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{L}_{2}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{L}_{3}$ with ${L}_{1}$, ${L}_{2}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$ and $\ensuremath{\infty}>{L}_{3}\ensuremath{\gg}{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{T}=\mathrm{the}\mathrm{thermal}\mathrm{wavelength}$) is found to go from order $\frac{{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{T}{T}_{\mathrm{cB}}}{(T\ensuremath{-}{T}_{\mathrm{cB}})}$ to order ${L}_{3}\mathrm{exp}{\frac{1}{2}\sqrt{\ensuremath{\pi}}{\ensuremath{\zeta}}_{\frac{3}{2}}(\frac{{L}_{3}}{{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{T}})[{(\frac{{T}_{\mathrm{cB}}}{T})}^{\frac{3}{2}}\ensuremath{-}1]}$ as the temperature is lowered through the bulk critical temperature ${T}_{\mathrm{cB}}\ifmmode\cdot\else\textperiodcentered\fi{}({\ensuremath{\zeta}}_{\ensuremath{\chi}} \mathrm{is}\mathrm{the}\mathrm{Riemann} \ensuremath{\zeta} \mathrm{function}.)$ The range exhibits a spatial asymmetry. The onset of this extremely long-range order is found to be reflected in PVT diagrams and the specific heat in a manner very similar to that in bulk condensation. It is conjectured that in calculations for infinite systems the existence of a long- but finite-range order may be a more relevant criterion for superfluidity and superconductivity than the usual criterion of an infinitely long-range order.

Physical Review•Aug 5, 1968•30 citations
Several authors have proposed criteria for the onset of Bose-Einstein condensation in finite systems. Using mathematical techniques developed by Pathria and collaborators (1972) these various proposals are systematically examined by applying them to an ideal Bose gas confined to a cuboidal enclosure under periodic boundary conditions. The 'transition points' thus obtained have been subjected to a comparative study, which indicates that the most useful general criterion is the macroscopic one based on the maximum of the specific heat C v .
We have carried out a rigorous asymptotic analysis of the thermodynamic behavior of an ideal Bose gas confined to an arbitrary, finite cuboidal geometry under periodic boundary conditions. Our investigation, which is based on the grand canonical ensemble, leads to the construction of an abstract, thermogeometric space in which the process of Bose-Einstein condensation appears as a "collapse" of the lattice points of the space towards its origin. In an infinite geometry, the collapse is accomplished in an infinitesimally small interval of temperature; this results in the appearance of mathematical singularities in the thermodynamic functions of the system. In a finite geometry, the "collapse" proceeds gradually and is spread over a temperature range $\ensuremath{\Delta}T$ such that $\frac{\ensuremath{\Delta}T}{{T}_{0}}=O(\frac{\overline{l}}{{L}_{<}})$, where l‾\overline{l}l is the mean interatomic distance while L<{L}_{<}L<​ is the length of the shortest side of the assembly; accordingly, the thermodynamic functions of the system remain smooth throughout. Special events, such as the specific-heat maximum, occur when the "lattice parameters" of our thermogeometric space acquire certain characteristic values which depend only on the shape of the system and not on its actual size. This leads to a new law of corresponding states for Bose-Einstein systems of finite size.
Using techniques developed by Greenspoon and Pathria, and by Chaba and Pathria, a rigorous asymptotic analysis of the onset of Bose-Einstein condensation in a finite three-dimensional system at constant pressure, under Dirichlet boundary conditions, is carried out. Finite size corrections arising from a modification of the density of states of the system, as well as from the discreteness of the single-particle energy levels, play an important role in the critical region. At the critical temperature Tc{T}_{c}Tc​, the volume of the system changes abruptly from being proportional to the total number of particles NNN to being proportional to N34{N}^{\frac{3}{4}}N43​, the number of particles in the condensate rises sharply from $\ensuremath{\propto}{N}^{\frac{1}{4}}$ to $\ensuremath{\propto}N$, and the specific heat CP{C}_{P}CP​ turns out to be proportional to N98{N}^{\frac{9}{8}}N89​. At somewhat lower temperatures, the finite size effects arising from the discreteness of the single-particle energy levels become dominant and the volume of the system, together with CP{C}_{P}CP​, becomes $\ensuremath{\propto}{N}^{\frac{3}{5}}$.
Using techniques developed by Greenspoon and Pathria, a rigorous, asymptotic analysis of the onset of Bose-Einstein condensation in a finite two-dimensional system at constant pressure is carried out. Some of the results obtained by Imry, Bergman, and Gunther, who first considered this problem, are upheld while others get modified. In particular, a macroscopic occupation of the single-particle ground state at finite temperatures is indeed possible. As the critical region, $T\ensuremath{\simeq}{T}_{c}$, is approached from above, the volume of the system becomes subextensive, Vc=O(NlnN){V}_{c}=O(\frac{N}{\mathrm{ln}N})Vc​=O(lnNN​), which is both necessary and sufficient for the onset of Bose-Einstein condensation in the system. For instance, if the system is now cooled even at constant volume V(=Vc)V(={V}_{c})V(=Vc​), the condensate fraction gradually builds up and becomes nonnegligible as TTT approaches ${T}_{0}\ensuremath{\simeq}\frac{({T}_{c})}{2}$; below T0{T}_{0}T0​, it grows steadily as $(1\ensuremath{-}\frac{T}{{T}_{0}})$. On the other hand, if we continued to cool the system at constant PPP its volume, over a thermodynamically negligible range of temperatures, would reduce to values O(N12)O({N}^{\frac{1}{2}})O(N21​) which, in turn, would be accompanied by an abrupt accumulation of practically all the particles of the system into the single-particle ground state ${\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{0}$. The specific heat CP{C}_{P}CP​, after having passed through a maximum, would also finally reduce to subextensive values. Phase transitions of this kind may be of relevance to the physical behavior of thin helium films and helium submonolayers.
The onset of Bose-Einstein condensation in a sample of N atoms confined to harmonic traps is critically examined. The monotonic growth of the condensate fraction f and the nonmonotic variation of the specific heat C of the sample are studied in fine detail. While no temperature is truly critical, our analysis does provide a strong theoretical basis for recognizing a temperature T∗,{T}^{*},T∗, that has been identified and advocated by previous authors, as the transition temperature of the system. The specific-heat maximum Tm{T}_{m}Tm​ (which happens to be another important ``marker'' in this transition), the value of the specific heat at T=Tm,{T=T}_{m},T=Tm​, and the ``jump'' in the specific heat of the system when the number N becomes very large are all explicitly evaluated. Wherever comparison is possible, our analytical results are found to be in perfect agreement with the ones obtained numerically by Kirsten and Toms [Phys. Rev. A 54, 4188 (1996)] and by Haugerud, Haugest, and Ravndal [Phys. Lett. A 225, 18 (1997)].
An asymptotic evaluation of the specific heat of an ideal relativistic Bose gas confined to a cuboidal enclosure (${L}_{1}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{L}_{2}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{L}_{3}$) is carried out, under periodic boundary conditions, taking into account the possibility of particle-antiparticle pair production in the system. Finite-size corrections to the standard bulk behavior are calculated explicitly in the regions t>0t>0t>0 and t<0t<0t<0, where $t=\frac{(T\ensuremath{-}{T}_{c})}{{T}_{c}}$, such that $|t|\ensuremath{\ll}1$ and $|{L}_{i}t|\ensuremath{\gg}1$. While for t>0t>0t>0 finite-size corrections turn out to be exponential for all geometries, for t<0t<0t<0 this is true only in the case of a film; for other geometries, such as a cuboid or a rectangular channel, these corrections conform to a power law instead. Finally, we consider the situation in the core region, where ∣Lit∣=O(1)|{L}_{i}t|=O(1)∣Li​t∣=O(1), and examine the location t∗{t}^{*}t∗ and the height ${c}_{\ensuremath{\rho}}^{*}$ of the specific-heat maximum; finite-size corrections in this region turn out to be $O({L}_{<}^{\ensuremath{-}1})$, where L<{L}_{<}L<​ denotes the shortest side of the enclosure.
It is shown that the lack of condensation in partially finite geometries is not dependent on the use of periodic boundary conditions or the symmetry-breaking technique for a class of independent-particle Bose-gas models. Condensation in an ideal Bose gas in a finite geometry is studied for one-, two-, and three-dimensional systems. Explicit expressions for the chemical potential in terms of the number of particles, the temperature, and the dimensions of the system are obtained by using a contour-integration technique to express sums as integrals plus corrections. Even though there is no true condensation, the range of the reduced density matrix for an ideal Bose gas in a thick slab (${L}_{1}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{L}_{2}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{L}_{3}$ with L1{L}_{1}L1​, ${L}_{2}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$ and $\ensuremath{\infty}>{L}_{3}\ensuremath{\gg}{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{T}=\mathrm{the}\mathrm{thermal}\mathrm{wavelength}$) is found to go from order $\frac{{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{T}{T}_{\mathrm{cB}}}{(T\ensuremath{-}{T}_{\mathrm{cB}})}$ to order ${L}_{3}\mathrm{exp}{\frac{1}{2}\sqrt{\ensuremath{\pi}}{\ensuremath{\zeta}}_{\frac{3}{2}}(\frac{{L}_{3}}{{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{T}})[{(\frac{{T}_{\mathrm{cB}}}{T})}^{\frac{3}{2}}\ensuremath{-}1]}$ as the temperature is lowered through the bulk critical temperature ${T}_{\mathrm{cB}}\ifmmode\cdot\else\textperiodcentered\fi{}({\ensuremath{\zeta}}_{\ensuremath{\chi}} \mathrm{is}\mathrm{the}\mathrm{Riemann} \ensuremath{\zeta} \mathrm{function}.)$ The range exhibits a spatial asymmetry. The onset of this extremely long-range order is found to be reflected in PVT diagrams and the specific heat in a manner very similar to that in bulk condensation. It is conjectured that in calculations for infinite systems the existence of a long- but finite-range order may be a more relevant criterion for superfluidity and superconductivity than the usual criterion of an infinitely long-range order.