Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)

On achieving the "best of both worlds" in secure multiparty computation

Jonathan I. Katz

Published Jun 11, 2007• 70 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Two settings are typically considered for secure multipartycomputation, depending on whether or not a majority of the partiesare assumed to be honest. Protocols designed under this assumptionprovide "full security" (and, in particular, guarantee outputdelivery and fairness) when this assumption is correct; however, if half or more of the parties are dishonest then security iscompletely compromised. On the other hand, protocols toleratingarbitrarily-many faults do not provide fairness or guaranteed output delivery even if only a single party is dishonest. It isnatural to wonder whether it is possible to achieve the "best ofboth worlds" : namely, a single protocol that simultaneouslyachieves the best possible security in both the above settings. Ishai, et al. (Crypto 2006) recently addressed this question, andruled out constant-round protocols of this type.

DOI
10.1145/1250790.1250793

Related papers

On Achieving the “Best of Both Worlds” in Secure Multiparty Computation

Yuval Ishai, Jonathan I. Katz, Eyal Kushilevitz +2 more

Two settings are traditionally considered for secure multiparty computation, depending on whether or not a majority of the parties are assumed to be honest. Existing protocols that assume an honest majority provide “full security” (and, in particular, guarantee output delivery and fairness) when this assumption holds, but are completely insecure if this assumption is violated. On the other hand, known protocols tolerating an arbitrary number of corruptions do not guarantee fairness or output delivery even if only a single party is dishonest. It is natural to wonder whether it is possible to achieve the “best of both worlds”: namely, a single protocol that simultaneously achieves the best possible security in both the above settings. Here, we rule out this possibility (at least for general functionalities) and show some positive results regarding what can be achieved.

SIAM Journal on Computing•Jan 1, 2011•32 citations

On Achieving “Best-in-the-Multiverse” MPC

Anasuya Acharya, Carmit Hazay, Muthuramakrishnan Venkitasubramaniam

The notion of Best-of-Both-Worlds introduced in the work of Ishai et al. (CRYPTO 2006) investigated whether an MPC protocol can simultaneously provide two incomparable security guarantees: guaranteed output delivery against an honest majority and security with abort against a dishonest majority and provided tight upper and lower bounds in the presence of computationally bounded, i.e., PPT adversaries. Another line of works starting from the work of Chaum (CRYPTO 1989) considered protocols that simultaneously achieved security against an unbounded adversary corrupting a minority of the parties and security against arbitrary corruption by a PPT adversary. In this work, we generalize previous work to investigate a fundamental challenge of designing an MPC in a multiverse where security is specified with respect to (1) GOD, (2) fairness, (3) security w.r.t. unbounded adversaries, and (4) security with abort. The work of Lucas et al. (PODC 2010) resolved this question when considering threshold adversaries; however, the case of general adversary structures remains open. Our main result completely characterizes when a protocol can simultaneously achieve all properties. Namely, given adversary structures $$\mathcal{Z}_{\textsf{GOD}}, \mathcal{Z}_{\textsf{fair}},\mathcal{Z}_{\textsf{S}}$$ and $$\mathcal{Z}_{\textsf{C}}$$ , we provide tight upper and lower bounds for when an MPC protocol can provide GOD, fairness, and security with abort respectively for unbounded and PPT adversaries w.r.t. these adversary structures.

Lecture notes in computer science•Dec 1, 2025•1 citation

Fairness Versus Guaranteed Output Delivery in Secure Multiparty Computation

Ran Cohen, Yehuda Lindell

Journal of Cryptology•Sep 23, 2016•45 citations

Fast Secure Computation for Small Population over the Internet

Megha Byali, Arun Antony Joseph, Arpita Patra +1 more

Secure Multi-Party Computation (MPC) with small number of parties is an interesting area of research, primarily due to its ability to model most real-life MPC applications and the simplicity and efficiency of the resulting protocols. In this work, we present efficient, constant-round 3-party (3PC) and 4-party (4PC) protocols in the honest-majority setting that achieve strong security notions of fairness (corrupted parties receive their output only if all honest parties receive output) and guaranteed output delivery (corrupted parties cannot prevent honest parties from receiving their output). Being constant-round, our constructions are suitable for Internet-like high-latency networks and are built from garbled circuits (GC). Assuming the minimal model of pairwise-private channels, we present two protocols that involve computation and communication of a single GC-- (a) a 4-round 3PC with fairness, (b) a 5-round 4PC with guaranteed output delivery. Empirically, our protocols are on par with the best known 3PC protocol of Mohassel et al. [CCS 2015] that only achieves security with selective abort, in terms of the computation time, LAN runtime, WAN runtime and communication cost. In fact, our 4PC outperforms the 3PC of Mohassel et al. significantly in terms of per-party computation and communication cost. With an extra GC, we improve the round complexity of our 4PC to four rounds. The only 4PC in our setting, given by Ishai et al. [CRYPTO 2015], involves 12 GCs. Assuming an additional broadcast channel, we present a 5-round 3PC with guaranteed output delivery that involves computation and communication of a single GC. A broadcast channel is inevitable in this setting for achieving guaranteed output delivery, owing to an impossibility result in the literature. The overall broadcast communication of our protocol is nominal and most importantly, is independent of the circuit size. This protocol too induces a nominal overhead compared to the protocol of Mohassel et al.

ACM SIGSAC Conference on Computer and Communications Security (CCS)•Oct 15, 2018•22 citations

Fairness versus Guaranteed Output Delivery in Secure Multiparty Computation

Ran Cohen, Yehuda Lindell

Lecture notes in computer science•Jan 1, 2014•39 citations

Asterisk: Super-fast MPC with a Friend

Banashri Karmakar, Nishat Koti, Arpita Patra +3 more

Secure multiparty computation (MPC) enables privacy-preserving collaborative computation over sensitive data held by multiple mutually distrusting parties. Unfortunately, in the most natural setting where a majority of the parties are maliciously corrupt (also called the dishonest majority setting), traditional MPC protocols incur high overheads and offer weaker security guarantees than are desirable for practical applications. In this paper, we explore the possibility of circumventing these drawbacks and achieving practically efficient dishonest majority MPC protocols with strong security guarantees by assuming an additional semi-honest, non-colluding helper party HP .1We believe that this is a more realistic alternative to assuming an honest majority, since many real-world applications of MPC involving potentially large numbers of parties (such as dark pools) are typically enabled by a central governing entity that can be modeled as the HP.In the above model, we are the first to design, implement and benchmark a practically-efficient and general multi-party framework, Asterisk. Our framework requires invoking HP only a constant number of times, achieves the strong security guarantee of fairness (either all parties learn the output or none do), scales to hundreds of parties, outperforms all existing dishonest majority MPC protocols, and is, in fact, competitive with state-of-the-art honest majority MPC protocols. Our experiments show that Asterisk achieves 228 – 288× speedup in preprocessing as compared to the best dishonest majority MPC protocol. With respect to online time, Asterisk supports 100-party evaluation of a circuit with 106multiplication gates in approximately 20 seconds. We also implement and benchmark practically efficient and highly scalable dark pool instances using Asterisk. The corresponding run times showcase the effectiveness of Asterisk in enabling efficient realizations of real-world privacy-preserving applications with strong security guarantees.

IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy (S&P)•May 19, 2024•10 citations
Two settings are typically considered for secure multipartycomputation, depending on whether or not a majority of the partiesare assumed to be honest. Protocols designed under this assumptionprovide "full security" (and, in particular, guarantee outputdelivery and fairness) when this assumption is correct; however, if half or more of the parties are dishonest then security iscompletely compromised. On the other hand, protocols toleratingarbitrarily-many faults do not provide fairness or guaranteed output delivery even if only a single party is dishonest. It isnatural to wonder whether it is possible to achieve the "best ofboth worlds" : namely, a single protocol that simultaneouslyachieves the best possible security in both the above settings. Ishai, et al. (Crypto 2006) recently addressed this question, andruled out constant-round protocols of this type.
Two settings are traditionally considered for secure multiparty computation, depending on whether or not a majority of the parties are assumed to be honest. Existing protocols that assume an honest majority provide “full security” (and, in particular, guarantee output delivery and fairness) when this assumption holds, but are completely insecure if this assumption is violated. On the other hand, known protocols tolerating an arbitrary number of corruptions do not guarantee fairness or output delivery even if only a single party is dishonest. It is natural to wonder whether it is possible to achieve the “best of both worlds”: namely, a single protocol that simultaneously achieves the best possible security in both the above settings. Here, we rule out this possibility (at least for general functionalities) and show some positive results regarding what can be achieved.
The notion of Best-of-Both-Worlds introduced in the work of Ishai et al. (CRYPTO 2006) investigated whether an MPC protocol can simultaneously provide two incomparable security guarantees: guaranteed output delivery against an honest majority and security with abort against a dishonest majority and provided tight upper and lower bounds in the presence of computationally bounded, i.e., PPT adversaries. Another line of works starting from the work of Chaum (CRYPTO 1989) considered protocols that simultaneously achieved security against an unbounded adversary corrupting a minority of the parties and security against arbitrary corruption by a PPT adversary. In this work, we generalize previous work to investigate a fundamental challenge of designing an MPC in a multiverse where security is specified with respect to (1) GOD, (2) fairness, (3) security w.r.t. unbounded adversaries, and (4) security with abort. The work of Lucas et al. (PODC 2010) resolved this question when considering threshold adversaries; however, the case of general adversary structures remains open. Our main result completely characterizes when a protocol can simultaneously achieve all properties. Namely, given adversary structures ZGOD,Zfair,ZS\mathcal{Z}_{\textsf{GOD}}, \mathcal{Z}_{\textsf{fair}},\mathcal{Z}_{\textsf{S}}ZGOD​,Zfair​,ZS​ and ZC\mathcal{Z}_{\textsf{C}}ZC​ , we provide tight upper and lower bounds for when an MPC protocol can provide GOD, fairness, and security with abort respectively for unbounded and PPT adversaries w.r.t. these adversary structures.
Secure Multi-Party Computation (MPC) with small number of parties is an interesting area of research, primarily due to its ability to model most real-life MPC applications and the simplicity and efficiency of the resulting protocols. In this work, we present efficient, constant-round 3-party (3PC) and 4-party (4PC) protocols in the honest-majority setting that achieve strong security notions of fairness (corrupted parties receive their output only if all honest parties receive output) and guaranteed output delivery (corrupted parties cannot prevent honest parties from receiving their output). Being constant-round, our constructions are suitable for Internet-like high-latency networks and are built from garbled circuits (GC). Assuming the minimal model of pairwise-private channels, we present two protocols that involve computation and communication of a single GC-- (a) a 4-round 3PC with fairness, (b) a 5-round 4PC with guaranteed output delivery. Empirically, our protocols are on par with the best known 3PC protocol of Mohassel et al. [CCS 2015] that only achieves security with selective abort, in terms of the computation time, LAN runtime, WAN runtime and communication cost. In fact, our 4PC outperforms the 3PC of Mohassel et al. significantly in terms of per-party computation and communication cost. With an extra GC, we improve the round complexity of our 4PC to four rounds. The only 4PC in our setting, given by Ishai et al. [CRYPTO 2015], involves 12 GCs. Assuming an additional broadcast channel, we present a 5-round 3PC with guaranteed output delivery that involves computation and communication of a single GC. A broadcast channel is inevitable in this setting for achieving guaranteed output delivery, owing to an impossibility result in the literature. The overall broadcast communication of our protocol is nominal and most importantly, is independent of the circuit size. This protocol too induces a nominal overhead compared to the protocol of Mohassel et al.
Secure multiparty computation (MPC) enables privacy-preserving collaborative computation over sensitive data held by multiple mutually distrusting parties. Unfortunately, in the most natural setting where a majority of the parties are maliciously corrupt (also called the dishonest majority setting), traditional MPC protocols incur high overheads and offer weaker security guarantees than are desirable for practical applications. In this paper, we explore the possibility of circumventing these drawbacks and achieving practically efficient dishonest majority MPC protocols with strong security guarantees by assuming an additional semi-honest, non-colluding helper party HP .1We believe that this is a more realistic alternative to assuming an honest majority, since many real-world applications of MPC involving potentially large numbers of parties (such as dark pools) are typically enabled by a central governing entity that can be modeled as the HP.In the above model, we are the first to design, implement and benchmark a practically-efficient and general multi-party framework, Asterisk. Our framework requires invoking HP only a constant number of times, achieves the strong security guarantee of fairness (either all parties learn the output or none do), scales to hundreds of parties, outperforms all existing dishonest majority MPC protocols, and is, in fact, competitive with state-of-the-art honest majority MPC protocols. Our experiments show that Asterisk achieves 228 – 288× speedup in preprocessing as compared to the best dishonest majority MPC protocol. With respect to online time, Asterisk supports 100-party evaluation of a circuit with 106multiplication gates in approximately 20 seconds. We also implement and benchmark practically efficient and highly scalable dark pool instances using Asterisk. The corresponding run times showcase the effectiveness of Asterisk in enabling efficient realizations of real-world privacy-preserving applications with strong security guarantees.