Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Foundations of probability and physics

ORIGIN OF QUANTUM PROBABILITIES

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

Published Dec 1, 2001• 22 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We demonstrate that the origin of the quantum probabilistic rule (which differs from the conventional Bayes' formula by the presence of cos θ-factor) might be explained by perturbation effects of preparation and measurement procedures. The main consequence of our investigation is that interference could be produced by purely corpuscular objects. In particular, the quantum rule for probabilities (with nontrivial cos θ-factor) could be simulated for macroscopic physical systems via preparation procedures producing statistical deviations of a special form. We discuss preparation and measurement procedures which may produce probabilistic rules which are neither classical nor quantum; in particular, hyperbolic 'quantum theory.'

DOI
10.1142/9789812810809_0014

Related papers

Ensemble fluctuations and the origin of quantum probabilistic rule

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We demonstrate that the origin of the so-called quantum probabilistic rule (which differs from the classical Bayes’ formula by the presence of cos θ-factor) might be explained in the framework of ensemble fluctuations which are induced by preparation procedures. In particular, quantum rule for probabilities (with nontrivial cos θ-factor) could be simulated for macroscopic physical systems via preparation procedures producing ensemble fluctuations of a special form. We discuss preparation and measurement procedures which may produce probabilistic rules which are neither classical nor quantum; in particular, hyperbolic “quantum theory.”

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Feb 1, 2002•36 citations

On the mystery of quantum probabilistic rule: trigonometric and hyperbolic probabilistic behaviours

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We demonstrate the quantum probabilistic rule (which differ from classical Bayes' formula by the cosinus factor) can be obtained on purely classical basis as a consequence of the perturbation effect of preparation procedures. In any case the interference can be easily simulated for macrosystems. Moreover, we obtain the classification of all possible transformations of probablities which can arise via perturbation effects. There are two main transformation classes: with trigonometric and hyperbolic ("interference") perturbations of classical Bayes' formula. Quantum probabilistic rule is just a particular case of trigonometric probablistic behaviour. Hyperbolic probablistic behaviour can be easily simulated. However, the question of its observation for "real physical phenomena" is open.

arXiv:quant-ph/0011104•Nov 25, 2000•0 citations

Quantum statistics via perturbation effects of preparation procedures

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We study the following problem: Is it possible to explain the quantum interference of probabilities in the purely corpuscular model for elementary particles? We demonstrate that (by taking into account perturbation effects of measurement and preparation procedures) we can obtain $\cosθ$-perturbation (interference term) in probabilistic rule connecting preparation procedures for purely corpuscular objects. On one hand, our investigation demonstrated that there is nothing special in so called `quantum probabilities': the right choice of statistical ensembles gives the possibility to escape all `pathologies'. On the other hand, we found that the standard trigonometric interference of alternatives (observed, in particular, in quantum mechanics) is not the unique possibility to extend (disturb) the conventional probabilistic rule for addition of alternatives. There exist two other probabilistic rules that connect three preparation procedures: hyperbolic and hyper-trigonometric interferences.

arXiv:quant-ph/0103065•Mar 13, 2001•12 citations

`Quantum probabilities' as context depending probabilities

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We study transformations of conventional (`classical') probabilities induced by context transitions. It is demonstrated that the transition from one complex of conditions to another induces a perturbation of the classical rule for the addition of probabilistic alternatives. We classify such perturbations. It is shown that there are two classes of perturbations: (a) trigonometric interference; (b) hyperbolic interference. In particular, the well known `quantum interference of probabilistic alternatives' can be obtained in classical (but contextual) probabilistic framework. Therefore we need not apply to wave arguments (or consider superposition principle) to get Quantum Statistics. In particular, interference could be a feature of experiments with purely corpuscular objects.

arXiv:quant-ph/0106073•Jun 13, 2001•15 citations

On the notion of a macroscopic quantum system

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

It is proposed to define "quantumness" of a system (micro or macroscopic, physical, biological, social, political) by starting with understanding that quantum mechanics is a statistical theory. It says us only about probability distributions. The only possible criteria of quantum behaviour are statistical ones. Therefore I propose to consider any system which produces quantum statistics as quantum ("quantumlike"). A possible test is based on the interference of probabilities. I was mainly interested in using such an approach to "quantumness" to extend the domain of applications of quantum mathematical formalism and especially to apply it to cognitive sciences. There were done experiments on interference of probabilities for ensembles of students and a nontrivial interference was really found. One could say that the quantum statistical behaviour might be expected. But the problem was not so trivial. Yes, we might expect nonclassical statistics, but there was no reason to get the quantum one, i.e., cos-interference. But we got it!

arXiv:quant-ph/0408164•Aug 26, 2004•0 citations

A Formula of Total Probability with the Interference Term and the Hilbert Space Representation of the Contextual Kolmogorovian Model

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We compare the classical Kolmogorov and quantum probability models. We show that the gap between these models is not so huge as was commonly believed. The main structures of quantum theory (interference of probabilities, Born's rule, complex probabilistic amplitudes, Hilbert state space, representation of observables by operators) are present in a latent form in the Kolmogorov model. In particular, we obtain “interference of probabilities” without appealing to the Hilbert space formalism. We interpret “interference of probabilities” as a perturbation (by a cos-term) of the conventional formula of total probability. Our classical derivation of quantum probabilistic formalism can stimulate applications of quantum methods outside of the microworld, for instance, in psychology, biology, economy, and other domains of science.

Theory of Probability and Its Applications•Jan 1, 2007•8 citations
We demonstrate that the origin of the quantum probabilistic rule (which differs from the conventional Bayes' formula by the presence of cos θ-factor) might be explained by perturbation effects of preparation and measurement procedures. The main consequence of our investigation is that interference could be produced by purely corpuscular objects. In particular, the quantum rule for probabilities (with nontrivial cos θ-factor) could be simulated for macroscopic physical systems via preparation procedures producing statistical deviations of a special form. We discuss preparation and measurement procedures which may produce probabilistic rules which are neither classical nor quantum; in particular, hyperbolic 'quantum theory.'
We demonstrate that the origin of the so-called quantum probabilistic rule (which differs from the classical Bayes’ formula by the presence of cos θ-factor) might be explained in the framework of ensemble fluctuations which are induced by preparation procedures. In particular, quantum rule for probabilities (with nontrivial cos θ-factor) could be simulated for macroscopic physical systems via preparation procedures producing ensemble fluctuations of a special form. We discuss preparation and measurement procedures which may produce probabilistic rules which are neither classical nor quantum; in particular, hyperbolic “quantum theory.”
We demonstrate the quantum probabilistic rule (which differ from classical Bayes' formula by the cosinus factor) can be obtained on purely classical basis as a consequence of the perturbation effect of preparation procedures. In any case the interference can be easily simulated for macrosystems. Moreover, we obtain the classification of all possible transformations of probablities which can arise via perturbation effects. There are two main transformation classes: with trigonometric and hyperbolic ("interference") perturbations of classical Bayes' formula. Quantum probabilistic rule is just a particular case of trigonometric probablistic behaviour. Hyperbolic probablistic behaviour can be easily simulated. However, the question of its observation for "real physical phenomena" is open.
We study the following problem: Is it possible to explain the quantum interference of probabilities in the purely corpuscular model for elementary particles? We demonstrate that (by taking into account perturbation effects of measurement and preparation procedures) we can obtain cos⁡θ\cosθcosθ-perturbation (interference term) in probabilistic rule connecting preparation procedures for purely corpuscular objects. On one hand, our investigation demonstrated that there is nothing special in so called `quantum probabilities': the right choice of statistical ensembles gives the possibility to escape all `pathologies'. On the other hand, we found that the standard trigonometric interference of alternatives (observed, in particular, in quantum mechanics) is not the unique possibility to extend (disturb) the conventional probabilistic rule for addition of alternatives. There exist two other probabilistic rules that connect three preparation procedures: hyperbolic and hyper-trigonometric interferences.
We study transformations of conventional (`classical') probabilities induced by context transitions. It is demonstrated that the transition from one complex of conditions to another induces a perturbation of the classical rule for the addition of probabilistic alternatives. We classify such perturbations. It is shown that there are two classes of perturbations: (a) trigonometric interference; (b) hyperbolic interference. In particular, the well known `quantum interference of probabilistic alternatives' can be obtained in classical (but contextual) probabilistic framework. Therefore we need not apply to wave arguments (or consider superposition principle) to get Quantum Statistics. In particular, interference could be a feature of experiments with purely corpuscular objects.
It is proposed to define "quantumness" of a system (micro or macroscopic, physical, biological, social, political) by starting with understanding that quantum mechanics is a statistical theory. It says us only about probability distributions. The only possible criteria of quantum behaviour are statistical ones. Therefore I propose to consider any system which produces quantum statistics as quantum ("quantumlike"). A possible test is based on the interference of probabilities. I was mainly interested in using such an approach to "quantumness" to extend the domain of applications of quantum mathematical formalism and especially to apply it to cognitive sciences. There were done experiments on interference of probabilities for ensembles of students and a nontrivial interference was really found. One could say that the quantum statistical behaviour might be expected. But the problem was not so trivial. Yes, we might expect nonclassical statistics, but there was no reason to get the quantum one, i.e., cos-interference. But we got it!
We compare the classical Kolmogorov and quantum probability models. We show that the gap between these models is not so huge as was commonly believed. The main structures of quantum theory (interference of probabilities, Born's rule, complex probabilistic amplitudes, Hilbert state space, representation of observables by operators) are present in a latent form in the Kolmogorov model. In particular, we obtain “interference of probabilities” without appealing to the Hilbert space formalism. We interpret “interference of probabilities” as a perturbation (by a cos-term) of the conventional formula of total probability. Our classical derivation of quantum probabilistic formalism can stimulate applications of quantum methods outside of the microworld, for instance, in psychology, biology, economy, and other domains of science.