Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal de physique

Symmetry breaking in the double-well model: ohmic dissipation with unrelaxed (Feynman-Vernon) initial conditions

Vladislav Čápek

Published Jan 1, 1989• 4 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The problem of asymptotic-time symmetry breaking for a particle in a symmetric double-well, interacting with phonons, is formulated for a standard minimal two-site model and for initially asymmetric particle distribution and thermal but unrelaxed phonons. The timeconvolutionless Generalized Master Equations can be handled explicitly in the Born approximation. Formally extending the solution to the infinite time, the criteria for the asymptotic-time symmetry breaking comply with those known for the relaxed initial condition.

DOI
10.1051/jphys:01989005007077500

Related papers

Quantum ohmic dissipation : particle in an asymmetric double-well potential

Claude Aslangul, No�lle Pottier, Daniel Saint-James

The real-time dynamics of a particle in a slightly asymmetric double-well potential in the presence of ohmic dissipation is analysed by using standard quantum-statistical methods. At zero temperature, the particle eventually goes towards the lower potential well; the relaxation has an overall exponential character with possibly small oscillations; at finite temperature, the particle thermalizes over the two wells; two successive exponential regimes are observed in this case. The results about the final average position of the particle agree with the detailed balance principle and are in fact independent of the ohmic assumption. For an ohmic dissipation law, the localization phenomenon which occurs in the perfectly symmetric double-well potential at zero temperature disappears when an asymmetry is present, although a precursor behaviour is displayed for very low values of the asymmetry.

Journal de physique•Jan 1, 1986•28 citations

Consistent approximations in generalized-master-equation theories: Application to the asymptotic-time symmetry-breaking problem

Vladislav C wápek, Petr Chvosta

The time-convolution as well as the time-convolutionless generalized master equations (GME) are rewritten in a simple form permitting an exact formal solution. Using this form, it is argued that possible approximations must be performed consistently on both sides of the GME in order to control deviations of the emerging approximate solution from the exact one. Arguments are given that after such consistent approximations, the initial-condition term can no longer in general be taken as proportional to (scrI-${\mathit{scrD}}_{0}$)\ensuremath{\Vert}${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\rho}}}_{0}$) (with ${\mathit{scrD}}_{0}$ being the projector used in GME). These conclusions are illustrated for the asymptotic-time symmetry-breaking problem of the spin-boson model. Although standard approximate GME approaches do indicate a possible symmetry breaking, we argue that these results are strongly influenced by the inconsistency of the approximations used. To support this statement we prove the absence of any asymptotic-time symmetry breaking in the zero-bias spin-boson model with a partial site-occupation relaxation.

Physical Review A•Mar 1, 1991•7 citations

Generalised master equation: dissipative dynamics of the double-well system

Petr Chvosta

The author applied the generalised master equation (GME) to the analysis of the object function, s(t), which describes the motion of the tunnelling particle in a double-well system coupled to a reservoir consisting of independent bosonic-type elementary excitation. First, using the 'unrelaxed' initial condition and a suitable projection operator we give the exact formal solution of the GME. Then, the memory operator in the GME is explicitly calculated in the weak-tunnelling regime and the function s(t) is obtained. An independent derivation is given which enables us to obtain the exact expansion of the function s(t) by means of a purely algebraic method. This expansion forms a basis on which this GME method and the well known functional-integral approach are compared: the GME-weak-tunnelling approximation is shown to be identical to the commonly used non-interacting-blip approximation ensuing from the functional-integral method. A new approximation is analysed which is weaker than the non-interacting-blip one.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Sep 21, 1989•7 citations

Dynamics of Symmetry Breaking during Quantum Real-Time Evolution in a Minimal Model System

Markus Heyl, Matthias Vojta C

One necessary criterion for the thermalization of a nonequilibrium quantum many-particle system is ergodicity. It is, however, not sufficient in cases where the asymptotic long-time state lies in a symmetry-broken phase but the initial state of nonequilibrium time evolution is fully symmetric with respect to this symmetry. In equilibrium, one particular symmetry-broken state is chosen as a result of an infinitesimal symmetry-breaking perturbation. From a dynamical point of view the question is: Can such an infinitesimal perturbation be sufficient for the system to establish a nonvanishing order during quantum real-time evolution? We study this question analytically for a minimal model system that can be associated with symmetry breaking, the ferromagnetic Kondo model. We show that after a quantum quench from a completely symmetric state the system is able to break its symmetry dynamically and discuss how these features can be observed experimentally.

arXiv:1401.1743•Physical Review Letters•Oct 29, 2014•3 citations

Quantum thermalization mechanism and the emergence of symmetry-breaking phases

Sebastián Gómez, Ángel L. Corps, Armando Relaño

We propose a generalization of the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis accountin g for the emergence of symmetry-breaking phases. It consists of two conditions that any system with a degenerate spectrum must fulfill in order to thermalize. The failure of each condition generates a different nonthermalizing scenario. One is due to the absence of chaos and may indicate that extra constants of motion are required to describe equilibrium states. The other one implies the existence of initial conditions evolving toward symmetry-breaking equilibrium states. If it spreads across an entire spectral region, then this region gives rise to a symmetry-breaking phase. We explore the applicability of this formalism by means of numerical experiments on a three-site Bose-Hubbard model with two noncommuting discrete symmetries.

arXiv:2506.13370•APS Open Science•May 1, 2026•3 citations

Excited-state-induced subbarrier tunnelling in the double-well model

Vladislav Čápek

Standard minimal two-state Hamiltonian (spin-boson model) for a particle in a symmetric double-well potential, interacting with a bath, is complemented by a third particle-excited state. This state is dynamically coupled (via coupling to the bath) with the lowest two states. In addition to the standard over-barrier thermally-activated transfer 1 ↔ 3 ↔ 2 (which might be easily suppressed by choosing a sufficiently low T), the third state is shown to cause excited-state-induced subbarrier tunnelling which persists even at T = 0. This new channel shows a tendency to coherent oscillations if standard (direct-tunnelling and over-barrier-transfer) channels get suppressed. These conclusions challenge the standard theory of the asymptotic symmetry breaking.

Journal de physique•Jan 1, 1989•6 citations
The problem of asymptotic-time symmetry breaking for a particle in a symmetric double-well, interacting with phonons, is formulated for a standard minimal two-site model and for initially asymmetric particle distribution and thermal but unrelaxed phonons. The timeconvolutionless Generalized Master Equations can be handled explicitly in the Born approximation. Formally extending the solution to the infinite time, the criteria for the asymptotic-time symmetry breaking comply with those known for the relaxed initial condition.
The real-time dynamics of a particle in a slightly asymmetric double-well potential in the presence of ohmic dissipation is analysed by using standard quantum-statistical methods. At zero temperature, the particle eventually goes towards the lower potential well; the relaxation has an overall exponential character with possibly small oscillations; at finite temperature, the particle thermalizes over the two wells; two successive exponential regimes are observed in this case. The results about the final average position of the particle agree with the detailed balance principle and are in fact independent of the ohmic assumption. For an ohmic dissipation law, the localization phenomenon which occurs in the perfectly symmetric double-well potential at zero temperature disappears when an asymmetry is present, although a precursor behaviour is displayed for very low values of the asymmetry.
The time-convolution as well as the time-convolutionless generalized master equations (GME) are rewritten in a simple form permitting an exact formal solution. Using this form, it is argued that possible approximations must be performed consistently on both sides of the GME in order to control deviations of the emerging approximate solution from the exact one. Arguments are given that after such consistent approximations, the initial-condition term can no longer in general be taken as proportional to (scrI-scrD0{\mathit{scrD}}_{0}scrD0​)\ensuremath{\Vert}${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\rho}}}_{0}$) (with scrD0{\mathit{scrD}}_{0}scrD0​ being the projector used in GME). These conclusions are illustrated for the asymptotic-time symmetry-breaking problem of the spin-boson model. Although standard approximate GME approaches do indicate a possible symmetry breaking, we argue that these results are strongly influenced by the inconsistency of the approximations used. To support this statement we prove the absence of any asymptotic-time symmetry breaking in the zero-bias spin-boson model with a partial site-occupation relaxation.
The author applied the generalised master equation (GME) to the analysis of the object function, s(t), which describes the motion of the tunnelling particle in a double-well system coupled to a reservoir consisting of independent bosonic-type elementary excitation. First, using the 'unrelaxed' initial condition and a suitable projection operator we give the exact formal solution of the GME. Then, the memory operator in the GME is explicitly calculated in the weak-tunnelling regime and the function s(t) is obtained. An independent derivation is given which enables us to obtain the exact expansion of the function s(t) by means of a purely algebraic method. This expansion forms a basis on which this GME method and the well known functional-integral approach are compared: the GME-weak-tunnelling approximation is shown to be identical to the commonly used non-interacting-blip approximation ensuing from the functional-integral method. A new approximation is analysed which is weaker than the non-interacting-blip one.
One necessary criterion for the thermalization of a nonequilibrium quantum many-particle system is ergodicity. It is, however, not sufficient in cases where the asymptotic long-time state lies in a symmetry-broken phase but the initial state of nonequilibrium time evolution is fully symmetric with respect to this symmetry. In equilibrium, one particular symmetry-broken state is chosen as a result of an infinitesimal symmetry-breaking perturbation. From a dynamical point of view the question is: Can such an infinitesimal perturbation be sufficient for the system to establish a nonvanishing order during quantum real-time evolution? We study this question analytically for a minimal model system that can be associated with symmetry breaking, the ferromagnetic Kondo model. We show that after a quantum quench from a completely symmetric state the system is able to break its symmetry dynamically and discuss how these features can be observed experimentally.
We propose a generalization of the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis accountin g for the emergence of symmetry-breaking phases. It consists of two conditions that any system with a degenerate spectrum must fulfill in order to thermalize. The failure of each condition generates a different nonthermalizing scenario. One is due to the absence of chaos and may indicate that extra constants of motion are required to describe equilibrium states. The other one implies the existence of initial conditions evolving toward symmetry-breaking equilibrium states. If it spreads across an entire spectral region, then this region gives rise to a symmetry-breaking phase. We explore the applicability of this formalism by means of numerical experiments on a three-site Bose-Hubbard model with two noncommuting discrete symmetries.
Standard minimal two-state Hamiltonian (spin-boson model) for a particle in a symmetric double-well potential, interacting with a bath, is complemented by a third particle-excited state. This state is dynamically coupled (via coupling to the bath) with the lowest two states. In addition to the standard over-barrier thermally-activated transfer 1 ↔ 3 ↔ 2 (which might be easily suppressed by choosing a sufficiently low T), the third state is shown to cause excited-state-induced subbarrier tunnelling which persists even at T = 0. This new channel shows a tendency to coherent oscillations if standard (direct-tunnelling and over-barrier-transfer) channels get suppressed. These conclusions challenge the standard theory of the asymptotic symmetry breaking.