Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Physics Teacher

A Bit of Quantum Mechanics

Stefano Oss, Tommaso Rosi

Published Mar 21, 2015• 13 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We have developed an app for iOS-based smart-phones/tablets that allows a 3-D, complex phase-based colorful visualization of hydrogen atom wave functions. Several important features of the quantum behavior of atomic orbitals can easily be made evident, thus making this app a useful companion in introductory modern physics classes. There are many reasons why quantum mechanical systems and phenomena are difficult both to teach and deeply understand. They are described by equations that are generally hard to visualize, and they often oppose the so-called “common sense” based on the human perception of the world, which is built on mental images such as locality and causality. Moreover students cannot have direct experience of those systems and solutions, and generally do not even have the possibility to refer to pictures, videos, or experiments to fill this gap. Teachers often encounter quite serious troubles in finding out a sensible way to speak about the wonders of quantum physics at the high school level, where complex formalisms are not accessible at all. One should however consider that this is quite a common issue in physics and, more generally, in science education. There are plenty of natural phenomena whose models (not only at microscopic and atomic levels) are of difficult, if not impossible, visualization. Just think of certain kinds of waves, fields of forces, velocities, energy, angular momentum, and so on. One should also notice that physical reality is not the same as the images we make of it. Pictures (formal, abstract ones, as well as artists' views) are a convenient bridge between these two aspects.

DOI
10.1119/1.4914565

Related papers

The Qubit as Key to Quantum Physics Part II: Physical Realizations and Applications

Wolfgang Dür, Stefan Heusler

Using the simplest possible quantum system—the qubit—the fundamental concepts of quantum physics can be introduced. This highlights the common features of many different physical systems, and provides a unifying framework when teaching quantum physics at the high school or introductory level. In a previous TPT article and in a separate paper posted online, we introduced catchy visualizations of the qubit based on the Bloch sphere or just the unit circle (see also Refs. 3–8 for other approaches highlighting the importance of the qubit). These visualizations open the way to understand basic ideas of quantum physics even without knowledge of the underlying mathematical formalism. In addition, simple mathematics can be introduced to describe the qubit as an abstract object and basic unit of quantum information. This generalizes the digital bit as a basic unit of classical information. The proposed visualizations can be used even at the high school level, while the mathematical explanations are of importance when teaching quantum physics at the undergraduate university level. This approach provides a unified framework to introduce common features of all quantum systems, such as the stochastic behavior and state change of a superposition state under measurement.

The Physics Teacher•Feb 18, 2016•27 citations

Visualization of the Invisible: The Qubit as Key to Quantum Physics

Wolfgang Dür, Stefan Heusler

Quantum mechanics is one of the pillars of modern physics, however rather difficult to teach at the introductory level due to the conceptual difficulties and the required advanced mathematics. Nevertheless, attempts to identify relevant features of quantum mechanics and to put forward concepts of how to teach it have been proposed.1–8 Here we present an approach to quantum physics based on the simplest quantum mechanical system—the quantum bit (qubit).1 Like its classical counterpart—the bit—a qubit corresponds to a two-level system, i.e., some system with a physical property that can admit two possible values. While typically a physical system has more than just one property or the property can admit more than just two values, in many situations most degrees of freedom can be considered to be fixed or frozen. Hence a variety of systems can be effectively described as a qubit. For instance, one may consider the spin of an electron or atom, with spin up and spin down as two possible values, and where other properties of the particle such as its mass or its position are fixed. Further examples include the polarization degree of freedom of a photon (horizontal and vertical polarization), two electronic degrees of freedom (i.e., two energy levels) of an atom, or the position of an atom in a double well potential (atom in left or right well). In all cases, only two states are relevant to describe the system.

The Physics Teacher•Oct 22, 2014•53 citations

Quantum Mechanics: A Simplified Approach

Shabnam Siddiqui

Quantum mechanics is one of the most challenging subjects to learn. It is challenging because quantum phenomenon is counterintuitive, and the mathematics used to explain such a phenomenon is very abstract, and difficult to grasp. This textbook is an attempt to overcome these challenges. Every chapter presents quantum ideas step- by- step in a structured way with a comparison between quantum and classical concepts. It provides a clear distinction between classical and quantum logic. Conceptual questions are provided after every important section so that the reader can test their understanding at every step. Such an approach aids in preventing misconceptions. Problem solving is not restricted to solving differential equations and integration. But it requires to systematically and creatively analyze a problem, to apply the new and powerful concepts for finding a solution and to understand the physical meaning of the solution. The tutorials on special topics are an effort to teach problem solving by actively engaging the reader in a thinking process, to apply the concepts and to understand the physical meaning of the solution. The simulations are provided for some of the topics. The simulations aid in the visualization of the quantum phenomenon, and for meaningful understanding of the mathematics. This approach may lead to development of "quantum mechanical intuition "as well as learning mathematical techniques for problem solving. Most importantly, the book is not flooded with numerous topics that makes the reader confused and distracted, rather the most important topics are discussed at a deeper level. The understanding of quantum mechanics is incomplete without understanding the early ideas and experiments that lead to the development of the quantum theory. Thus, the first two chapters of the book are dedicated to such topics. The key features of this book are: A simplified, structured, and step-by-step introduction to quantum mechanics. The simplification is attained through use of two-level system, step- by- step discussion of important topics in a simplified language at a deeper level, analogies, and visualization using illustrations and simulations A systematic arrangement of topics, and numerous worked- out examples. The presentation of the structure in the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics provides clarity in understanding complicated and abstract mathematics. It also helps to understand the distinction between the quantum mechanical and classical approaches Conceptual questions at the end of every important section. The conceptual questions can be used in a classroom as a point of discussion between an instructor and students Tutorials on special topics. Simulations on special topics aid in the visualization of the physical phenomenon, and demonstration of the application of mathematics An in-depth discussion of the wave-particle duality, measurement problem, and their philosophical implications in Chapter 2 provides an understanding of the broader meaning of quantum mechanics

CRC Press eBooks•Oct 10, 2018•1 citation

Quantum Mechanics by Computer

Dietrick E. Thomsen

Wave equations -wave functions -are the mathematical way of describing the behavior of things in quantum mechanics. The physical basis of this is that on the microscopic level every object is at the same time both a particle a bundle of waves. So the mathematics that describes dynamics on this level turns out to be the mathematics of wave functions. Wave functions are far from being the easiest things in mathematics to solve compute with. To calculate the behavior of an atomic nucleus, for instance, involves working with dozens or hundreds of wave functions (each proton neutron has its own) that are related to one another in such a way that the solution to each one depends on all the others. They cannot be solved one by one; they have to be solved ensemble, dozens or hundreds of simultaneous equations, as mathematicians would describe By hand the task is formidable, perhaps practically impossible. However, at the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, a Cray 1, one of the latest, biggest fastest of computers has now come to the rescue. Using it M. S. Weiss co-workers have been able to calculate what happens in various kinds of collisions of a krypton nucleus with a lanthanum nucleus. Then, with the latest computer graphics they are able to display these processes in an animated film. The two nuclei approach each other, collide, in some cases fuse, in others come apart, everything is decorated with bright false colors representing the density levels of matter inside the nuclei. The pictures the information in them represent the solution of 146 simultaneous wave functions, one for every two nucleons, every two particles in the two nuclei. There is one function for every two nucleons rather than every one because the mathematics contains one important approximation. Nucleons can come with two directions of spin, spin up or spin down. This theory does not distinguish between the two spin states, so each function actually represents the average of one of each. The pictures show a dozen instances, starting from a head-on collision proceeding to instances of greater greater offset between the centers of the two nuclei until they arrive at a sideswipe in which the nuclei hardly touch each other. The collisions near head-on result in fusion. A little offset contributes an angular momentum: The fusion product rotates. More offset the nuclei collide, losing a lot of energy, but retaining enough to come apart again. This is known as deep inelastic scattering. Finally, an instance where the two nuclei do not touch, but where distortions vibrations are produced in them by the force between them when they are close. Weiss says the film wakes physicists up when he shows it at the end of a talk. He mentions one experimentalist who came up said how nice it was to be able to actually see these things. At least four levels of abstraction, Weiss comments, and he talks about seeing it. Yet viewing the film, one can understand what the experimentalist meant. The calculations behind the film are quite accurate in predicting the main events of the collisions, that is what is really important. According to Weiss, they predict accurately the conditions under which fusion is likely, the proper range of deep inelastic scattering so forth. In the pictures the behavior looks like that of a fluid, liquid drops coming together. Weiss stresses that it is actually the sum of discrete motions, those 146 individual wave functions. One of the purposes of the exercise was to see whether it was possible to derive a macroscopic theory that is, one that would give a simpler mathematical expression for the over-all behavior of the nuclei, that would yield the desired predictions without having to start from the 146 individual wave functions. It turns out, Weiss says, that a macroscopic theory is possible in some particular cases, but the microscopic one, starting from the individual wave functions, remains the general one. Computation was the serious hindrance to doing it before now. As Weiss says, the theory itself was written down years ago by P. A. M. Dirac, one of the pioneer theorists of quantum mechanics. It took Weiss co-workers a year to figure out how to feed the computation to the Each of the dozen collisions which takes about 10-21 seconds in real time, but is displayed in extreme slow motion in the film-took an hour of computation time using the core of the Cray That's expensive computing, but, says Weiss, I would never try it on a lesser computer. O

Science News•Oct 23, 1982•2 citations

Niels Bohr’s First 1913 Paper: Still Relevant, Still Exciting, Still Puzzling

Kenneth W. Ford

Many teachers like to introduce the Bohr atom toward the end of an introductory physics course. This is an excellent idea, given the historic importance of Bohr’s 1913 work, which provided the bridge from Planck’s quantized interaction of matter and radiation (1900) to the full theory of quantum mechanics (1925-28). Unfortunately, the version of the Bohr atom that appears in many textbooks and is no doubt often presented to students is more wrong than right and may leave both teachers and students wondering why, more than a hundred years later, it is still being taught. This “pedagogic” version postulates that an electron in a stationary state moves in a circular orbit with an angular momentum that is an integral multiple of h/2π (L = nh/2π = nħ)—ħ for the lowest-energy state, 2ħ for the next state, and so on. This picture of the hydrogen atom is wrong in two senses. First it doesn’t conform to our present understanding of the hydrogen atom. This, in itself, is not a reason to scrap it, for the historical development of quantum physics is certainly of interest. But second, it doesn’t conform to the essence of what Bohr actually did. That is a reason not to teach about circular orbits and L = nħ.

The Physics Teacher•Oct 19, 2018•9 citations

Quantum Mechanics for Beginning Physics Students

Mark B. Schneider

The past two decades of attention to introductory physics education has emphasized enhanced development of conceptual understanding to accompany calculational ability. Given this, it is surprising that current texts continue to rely on the Bohr model to develop a flawed intuition, and introduce correct atomic physics on an ad hoc basis. For example, Halliday, Resnick, and Walker1 describe the origin of atomic quantum numbers as such: “The restrictions on the values of the quantum number for the hydrogen atom, as listed in Table 39-2, are not arbitrary but come out of the solution to Schrödinger's equation.” They give no further justification, but do point out the values are in conflict with the predictions of the Bohr model.

The Physics Teacher•Sep 17, 2010•7 citations
We have developed an app for iOS-based smart-phones/tablets that allows a 3-D, complex phase-based colorful visualization of hydrogen atom wave functions. Several important features of the quantum behavior of atomic orbitals can easily be made evident, thus making this app a useful companion in introductory modern physics classes. There are many reasons why quantum mechanical systems and phenomena are difficult both to teach and deeply understand. They are described by equations that are generally hard to visualize, and they often oppose the so-called “common sense” based on the human perception of the world, which is built on mental images such as locality and causality. Moreover students cannot have direct experience of those systems and solutions, and generally do not even have the possibility to refer to pictures, videos, or experiments to fill this gap. Teachers often encounter quite serious troubles in finding out a sensible way to speak about the wonders of quantum physics at the high school level, where complex formalisms are not accessible at all. One should however consider that this is quite a common issue in physics and, more generally, in science education. There are plenty of natural phenomena whose models (not only at microscopic and atomic levels) are of difficult, if not impossible, visualization. Just think of certain kinds of waves, fields of forces, velocities, energy, angular momentum, and so on. One should also notice that physical reality is not the same as the images we make of it. Pictures (formal, abstract ones, as well as artists' views) are a convenient bridge between these two aspects.
Using the simplest possible quantum system—the qubit—the fundamental concepts of quantum physics can be introduced. This highlights the common features of many different physical systems, and provides a unifying framework when teaching quantum physics at the high school or introductory level. In a previous TPT article and in a separate paper posted online, we introduced catchy visualizations of the qubit based on the Bloch sphere or just the unit circle (see also Refs. 3–8 for other approaches highlighting the importance of the qubit). These visualizations open the way to understand basic ideas of quantum physics even without knowledge of the underlying mathematical formalism. In addition, simple mathematics can be introduced to describe the qubit as an abstract object and basic unit of quantum information. This generalizes the digital bit as a basic unit of classical information. The proposed visualizations can be used even at the high school level, while the mathematical explanations are of importance when teaching quantum physics at the undergraduate university level. This approach provides a unified framework to introduce common features of all quantum systems, such as the stochastic behavior and state change of a superposition state under measurement.
Quantum mechanics is one of the pillars of modern physics, however rather difficult to teach at the introductory level due to the conceptual difficulties and the required advanced mathematics. Nevertheless, attempts to identify relevant features of quantum mechanics and to put forward concepts of how to teach it have been proposed.1–8 Here we present an approach to quantum physics based on the simplest quantum mechanical system—the quantum bit (qubit).1 Like its classical counterpart—the bit—a qubit corresponds to a two-level system, i.e., some system with a physical property that can admit two possible values. While typically a physical system has more than just one property or the property can admit more than just two values, in many situations most degrees of freedom can be considered to be fixed or frozen. Hence a variety of systems can be effectively described as a qubit. For instance, one may consider the spin of an electron or atom, with spin up and spin down as two possible values, and where other properties of the particle such as its mass or its position are fixed. Further examples include the polarization degree of freedom of a photon (horizontal and vertical polarization), two electronic degrees of freedom (i.e., two energy levels) of an atom, or the position of an atom in a double well potential (atom in left or right well). In all cases, only two states are relevant to describe the system.
Quantum mechanics is one of the most challenging subjects to learn. It is challenging because quantum phenomenon is counterintuitive, and the mathematics used to explain such a phenomenon is very abstract, and difficult to grasp. This textbook is an attempt to overcome these challenges. Every chapter presents quantum ideas step- by- step in a structured way with a comparison between quantum and classical concepts. It provides a clear distinction between classical and quantum logic. Conceptual questions are provided after every important section so that the reader can test their understanding at every step. Such an approach aids in preventing misconceptions. Problem solving is not restricted to solving differential equations and integration. But it requires to systematically and creatively analyze a problem, to apply the new and powerful concepts for finding a solution and to understand the physical meaning of the solution. The tutorials on special topics are an effort to teach problem solving by actively engaging the reader in a thinking process, to apply the concepts and to understand the physical meaning of the solution. The simulations are provided for some of the topics. The simulations aid in the visualization of the quantum phenomenon, and for meaningful understanding of the mathematics. This approach may lead to development of "quantum mechanical intuition "as well as learning mathematical techniques for problem solving. Most importantly, the book is not flooded with numerous topics that makes the reader confused and distracted, rather the most important topics are discussed at a deeper level. The understanding of quantum mechanics is incomplete without understanding the early ideas and experiments that lead to the development of the quantum theory. Thus, the first two chapters of the book are dedicated to such topics. The key features of this book are: A simplified, structured, and step-by-step introduction to quantum mechanics. The simplification is attained through use of two-level system, step- by- step discussion of important topics in a simplified language at a deeper level, analogies, and visualization using illustrations and simulations A systematic arrangement of topics, and numerous worked- out examples. The presentation of the structure in the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics provides clarity in understanding complicated and abstract mathematics. It also helps to understand the distinction between the quantum mechanical and classical approaches Conceptual questions at the end of every important section. The conceptual questions can be used in a classroom as a point of discussion between an instructor and students Tutorials on special topics. Simulations on special topics aid in the visualization of the physical phenomenon, and demonstration of the application of mathematics An in-depth discussion of the wave-particle duality, measurement problem, and their philosophical implications in Chapter 2 provides an understanding of the broader meaning of quantum mechanics
Wave equations -wave functions -are the mathematical way of describing the behavior of things in quantum mechanics. The physical basis of this is that on the microscopic level every object is at the same time both a particle a bundle of waves. So the mathematics that describes dynamics on this level turns out to be the mathematics of wave functions. Wave functions are far from being the easiest things in mathematics to solve compute with. To calculate the behavior of an atomic nucleus, for instance, involves working with dozens or hundreds of wave functions (each proton neutron has its own) that are related to one another in such a way that the solution to each one depends on all the others. They cannot be solved one by one; they have to be solved ensemble, dozens or hundreds of simultaneous equations, as mathematicians would describe By hand the task is formidable, perhaps practically impossible. However, at the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, a Cray 1, one of the latest, biggest fastest of computers has now come to the rescue. Using it M. S. Weiss co-workers have been able to calculate what happens in various kinds of collisions of a krypton nucleus with a lanthanum nucleus. Then, with the latest computer graphics they are able to display these processes in an animated film. The two nuclei approach each other, collide, in some cases fuse, in others come apart, everything is decorated with bright false colors representing the density levels of matter inside the nuclei. The pictures the information in them represent the solution of 146 simultaneous wave functions, one for every two nucleons, every two particles in the two nuclei. There is one function for every two nucleons rather than every one because the mathematics contains one important approximation. Nucleons can come with two directions of spin, spin up or spin down. This theory does not distinguish between the two spin states, so each function actually represents the average of one of each. The pictures show a dozen instances, starting from a head-on collision proceeding to instances of greater greater offset between the centers of the two nuclei until they arrive at a sideswipe in which the nuclei hardly touch each other. The collisions near head-on result in fusion. A little offset contributes an angular momentum: The fusion product rotates. More offset the nuclei collide, losing a lot of energy, but retaining enough to come apart again. This is known as deep inelastic scattering. Finally, an instance where the two nuclei do not touch, but where distortions vibrations are produced in them by the force between them when they are close. Weiss says the film wakes physicists up when he shows it at the end of a talk. He mentions one experimentalist who came up said how nice it was to be able to actually see these things. At least four levels of abstraction, Weiss comments, and he talks about seeing it. Yet viewing the film, one can understand what the experimentalist meant. The calculations behind the film are quite accurate in predicting the main events of the collisions, that is what is really important. According to Weiss, they predict accurately the conditions under which fusion is likely, the proper range of deep inelastic scattering so forth. In the pictures the behavior looks like that of a fluid, liquid drops coming together. Weiss stresses that it is actually the sum of discrete motions, those 146 individual wave functions. One of the purposes of the exercise was to see whether it was possible to derive a macroscopic theory that is, one that would give a simpler mathematical expression for the over-all behavior of the nuclei, that would yield the desired predictions without having to start from the 146 individual wave functions. It turns out, Weiss says, that a macroscopic theory is possible in some particular cases, but the microscopic one, starting from the individual wave functions, remains the general one. Computation was the serious hindrance to doing it before now. As Weiss says, the theory itself was written down years ago by P. A. M. Dirac, one of the pioneer theorists of quantum mechanics. It took Weiss co-workers a year to figure out how to feed the computation to the Each of the dozen collisions which takes about 10-21 seconds in real time, but is displayed in extreme slow motion in the film-took an hour of computation time using the core of the Cray That's expensive computing, but, says Weiss, I would never try it on a lesser computer. O
Many teachers like to introduce the Bohr atom toward the end of an introductory physics course. This is an excellent idea, given the historic importance of Bohr’s 1913 work, which provided the bridge from Planck’s quantized interaction of matter and radiation (1900) to the full theory of quantum mechanics (1925-28). Unfortunately, the version of the Bohr atom that appears in many textbooks and is no doubt often presented to students is more wrong than right and may leave both teachers and students wondering why, more than a hundred years later, it is still being taught. This “pedagogic” version postulates that an electron in a stationary state moves in a circular orbit with an angular momentum that is an integral multiple of h/2π (L = nh/2π = nħ)—ħ for the lowest-energy state, 2ħ for the next state, and so on. This picture of the hydrogen atom is wrong in two senses. First it doesn’t conform to our present understanding of the hydrogen atom. This, in itself, is not a reason to scrap it, for the historical development of quantum physics is certainly of interest. But second, it doesn’t conform to the essence of what Bohr actually did. That is a reason not to teach about circular orbits and L = nħ.
The past two decades of attention to introductory physics education has emphasized enhanced development of conceptual understanding to accompany calculational ability. Given this, it is surprising that current texts continue to rely on the Bohr model to develop a flawed intuition, and introduce correct atomic physics on an ad hoc basis. For example, Halliday, Resnick, and Walker1 describe the origin of atomic quantum numbers as such: “The restrictions on the values of the quantum number for the hydrogen atom, as listed in Table 39-2, are not arbitrary but come out of the solution to Schrödinger's equation.” They give no further justification, but do point out the values are in conflict with the predictions of the Bohr model.