Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

Nine formulations of quantum mechanics

Daniel F. Styer, Miranda S. Balkin, Kathryn M. Becker, Matthew R. Burns, Christopher E. Dudley, Scott T. Forth, Jeremy S. Gaumer, Mark Kramer, David C. Oertel, Leonard H. Park, M. Rinkoski, Clait T. Smith, Timothy David Wotherspoon

Published Mar 1, 2002• 233 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Nine formulations of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics are reviewed. These are the wavefunction, matrix, path integral, phase space, density matrix, second quantization, variational, pilot wave, and Hamilton–Jacobi formulations. Also mentioned are the many-worlds and transactional interpretations. The various formulations differ dramatically in mathematical and conceptual overview, yet each one makes identical predictions for all experimental results.

DOI
10.1119/1.1445404

Related papers

A comparative review of four formulations of noncommutative quantum mechanics

Laure Gouba

Four formulations of quantum mechanics on noncommutative Moyal phase spaces are reviewed. These are the canonical, path-integral, Weyl–Wigner and systematic formulations. Although all these formulations represent quantum mechanics on a phase space with the same deformed Heisenberg algebra, there are mathematical and conceptual differences which we discuss.

arXiv:1603.07176•International Journal of Modern Physics A•Jul 7, 2016•103 citations

The Phase Space Quantum Mechanics Formalism and SUSYQM

So far we have encountered two ways of quantizing physical systems: the canonical way and the Quantum Hamilton Jacobi formalism. Currently, there are four independent paths to quantization. In chronological order, the first, the canonical way, is the quantization formalism based on Schrödinger’s equation, or equivalently, using operators acting on a Hilbert space. The second way is the path integral formalism, which we won’t address in this book. The third way of doing quantum mechanics is the Quantum Hamilton Jacobi formalism, which we discussed in Chapter 15. A fourth path to quantization is the phase space quantization, also known as the deformation quantization formalism, which is the subject of this chapter.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Oct 22, 2017•0 citations

Current State of Quantum Theory

Shiv R. Vatsya

Standard and path integral formulations of quantum mechanics are reviewed briefly followed by the formulations based on the gauge transformations, which are Wheeler's formulation and another one founded upon an extension of Hamilton's action principle.Various interpretations of quantum mechanics are discussed and compared.Recent developments in quantum field theory are commented on.

Physics & Astronomy International Journal•Oct 17, 2017•3 citations

Extended Quantum Mechanics

Pavel Bóna

We are dealing in this work with such formal and conceptual extensions of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics (QM) which contain QM with its standard formalism and interpretation as a subtheory. QM is here primarily equivalently reformulated in the form of a Poisson system on the infinite-dimensional phase space consisting of all density matrices. It is shown that inclusion of additional ("nonlinear") symmetry generators (i.e. "Hamiltonians") into this reformulation of (linear) QM leads to a considerable extension of the theory: two kinds of quantum "mixed states" should be distinguished, and operator - valued functions of density matrices should be used in the role of "nonlinear observables". A general framework for physical theories is obtained in this way, containing various nonlinear versions of QM, as well as some of "approximations" to standard QM as subtheories. Questions of interpretation are considered and formally consistently solved. Specifications and illustrations, as well as mathematical Appendices and two functioning Indexes are included, making the text almost selfcontained.

arXiv:math-ph/9909022•Sep 17, 1999•13 citations

EXTENDED QUANTUM MECHANICS

B Pavel

The work can be considered as an essay on mathematical and conceptual structure of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics (QM) which is related here to some other (more general, but also to more special and “approximative”) theories. QM is here primarily reformulated in an equivalent form of a Poisson system on the phase space consisting of density matrices, where the “observables”, as well as “symmetry generators” are represented by a specific type of real valued (densely defined) functions, namely the usual quantum expectations of corresponding selfadjoint operators. It is shown in this paper that inclusion of additional (“nonlinear”) symmetry generators (i.e. “Hamiltonians”) into this reformulation of (linear) QM leads to a considerable extension of the theory: two kinds of quantum “mixed states” should be distinguished, and operator ‐ valued functions of density matrices should be used in the r ˆ ole of “nonlinear observables”. A general framework for physical theories is obtained in this way: By different choices of the sets of “nonlinear observables” we obtain, as special cases, e.g. classical mechanics on homogeneous spaces of kinematical symmetry groups, standard (linear) QM, or nonlinear extensions of QM; also various “quasiclassical approximations” to QM are all subtheories of the presented extension of QM - a version of the extended quantum mechanics (EQM). A general interpretation scheme of EQM extending the usual statistical interpretation of QM is also proposed. Eventually, EQM is shown to be (included into) a C -algebraic (hence linear) quantum theory. Mathematical formulation of these theories is presented. The presentation includes an analysis of problems connected with differentiation on infinite ‐ dimensional manifolds, as well as a solution of some problems connected with the work with only densely defined unbounded real‐valued functions on the (infinite dimensional) “phase space” which correspond to unbounded operators (generators) and to their nonlinear generalizations. Also “nonlinear deformations” of unitary representations of kinematical symmetry Lie groups are introduced. Possible applications are briefly discussed, and some specific examples are presented. The text contains also brief reviews of Hamiltonian classical mechanics, as well as of QM. Mathematical appendices make the paper nearly selfcontained.

•Jan 1, 2000•20 citations

Hamiltonian Path-Integral Methods

Claude Garrod

A path-integral formulation of quantum mechanics is investigated which is closely related to that of Feynman. It differs from Feynman's formulation in that it involves the Hamiltonian function of the canonically conjugate coordinates and momenta. The classical limit yields the variational principle: $\ensuremath{\delta}ff(p\ifmmode\ddagger\else\textdaggerdbl\fi{}\ensuremath{-}N)dt=0$. A path-integral formula is also obtained for the energy eigenstate projection operator associated with the time-independent Schr\"odinger equation. The classical limit of the projection operator formula yields a modified form of the well-known variational principle for the phase-space orbit of given energy. Relativistically covariant Hamiltonian variational principles are analyzed and lead naturally to a relativistic scalar wave equation which involves a proper time variable which is canonically conjugate to the mass in the same manner as the ordinary time variable is conjugate to the energy in nonrelativistic quantum theory.

Reviews of Modern Physics•Jul 1, 1966•161 citations
Nine formulations of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics are reviewed. These are the wavefunction, matrix, path integral, phase space, density matrix, second quantization, variational, pilot wave, and Hamilton–Jacobi formulations. Also mentioned are the many-worlds and transactional interpretations. The various formulations differ dramatically in mathematical and conceptual overview, yet each one makes identical predictions for all experimental results.
So far we have encountered two ways of quantizing physical systems: the canonical way and the Quantum Hamilton Jacobi formalism. Currently, there are four independent paths to quantization. In chronological order, the first, the canonical way, is the quantization formalism based on Schrödinger’s equation, or equivalently, using operators acting on a Hilbert space. The second way is the path integral formalism, which we won’t address in this book. The third way of doing quantum mechanics is the Quantum Hamilton Jacobi formalism, which we discussed in Chapter 15. A fourth path to quantization is the phase space quantization, also known as the deformation quantization formalism, which is the subject of this chapter.
We are dealing in this work with such formal and conceptual extensions of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics (QM) which contain QM with its standard formalism and interpretation as a subtheory. QM is here primarily equivalently reformulated in the form of a Poisson system on the infinite-dimensional phase space consisting of all density matrices. It is shown that inclusion of additional ("nonlinear") symmetry generators (i.e. "Hamiltonians") into this reformulation of (linear) QM leads to a considerable extension of the theory: two kinds of quantum "mixed states" should be distinguished, and operator - valued functions of density matrices should be used in the role of "nonlinear observables". A general framework for physical theories is obtained in this way, containing various nonlinear versions of QM, as well as some of "approximations" to standard QM as subtheories. Questions of interpretation are considered and formally consistently solved. Specifications and illustrations, as well as mathematical Appendices and two functioning Indexes are included, making the text almost selfcontained.
The work can be considered as an essay on mathematical and conceptual structure of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics (QM) which is related here to some other (more general, but also to more special and “approximative”) theories. QM is here primarily reformulated in an equivalent form of a Poisson system on the phase space consisting of density matrices, where the “observables”, as well as “symmetry generators” are represented by a specific type of real valued (densely defined) functions, namely the usual quantum expectations of corresponding selfadjoint operators. It is shown in this paper that inclusion of additional (“nonlinear”) symmetry generators (i.e. “Hamiltonians”) into this reformulation of (linear) QM leads to a considerable extension of the theory: two kinds of quantum “mixed states” should be distinguished, and operator ‐ valued functions of density matrices should be used in the r ˆ ole of “nonlinear observables”. A general framework for physical theories is obtained in this way: By different choices of the sets of “nonlinear observables” we obtain, as special cases, e.g. classical mechanics on homogeneous spaces of kinematical symmetry groups, standard (linear) QM, or nonlinear extensions of QM; also various “quasiclassical approximations” to QM are all subtheories of the presented extension of QM - a version of the extended quantum mechanics (EQM). A general interpretation scheme of EQM extending the usual statistical interpretation of QM is also proposed. Eventually, EQM is shown to be (included into) a C -algebraic (hence linear) quantum theory. Mathematical formulation of these theories is presented. The presentation includes an analysis of problems connected with differentiation on infinite ‐ dimensional manifolds, as well as a solution of some problems connected with the work with only densely defined unbounded real‐valued functions on the (infinite dimensional) “phase space” which correspond to unbounded operators (generators) and to their nonlinear generalizations. Also “nonlinear deformations” of unitary representations of kinematical symmetry Lie groups are introduced. Possible applications are briefly discussed, and some specific examples are presented. The text contains also brief reviews of Hamiltonian classical mechanics, as well as of QM. Mathematical appendices make the paper nearly selfcontained.
A path-integral formulation of quantum mechanics is investigated which is closely related to that of Feynman. It differs from Feynman's formulation in that it involves the Hamiltonian function of the canonically conjugate coordinates and momenta. The classical limit yields the variational principle: $\ensuremath{\delta}ff(p\ifmmode\ddagger\else\textdaggerdbl\fi{}\ensuremath{-}N)dt=0$. A path-integral formula is also obtained for the energy eigenstate projection operator associated with the time-independent Schr\"odinger equation. The classical limit of the projection operator formula yields a modified form of the well-known variational principle for the phase-space orbit of given energy. Relativistically covariant Hamiltonian variational principles are analyzed and lead naturally to a relativistic scalar wave equation which involves a proper time variable which is canonically conjugate to the mass in the same manner as the ordinary time variable is conjugate to the energy in nonrelativistic quantum theory.