Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Modern Physics Letters A

TOPOLOGICAL MANIFESTATIONS IN CLASSICAL MECHANICS: DISCRETE ALLOWED AND FORBIDDEN STATES OF MOTION

Ram K. Varma

Published Dec 21, 1994• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Consequences of the topology of the configuration space of a Hamiltonian dynamical system are considered for a coherent system of trajectories. It is shown that when the space is multiply-connected and therefore the action integral is multivalued, the allowed states of motion (labeled by the initial data) are constrained to a discrete set by the requirement that the action be single-valued. One thus obtains a quantum-like discretization of allowed states of motion even in classical mechanics. Such discrete “allowed” and “forbidden” states have indeed been observed in the classical mechanical system of charged particles in a magnetic field. The relationship of this formalism with a Schrödinger-like formalism for the latter problem given earlier is discussed.

DOI
10.1142/s021773239400349x

Related papers

BEHAVIOR OF CHARGED PARTICLE MOTION IN A MAGNETIC FIELD AND A RETARDING POTENTIAL II – OBSERVATIONS OF THE EXISTENCE OF "FORBIDDEN STATES" AND AHARANOV-BOHM ANALOG IN CLASSICAL MECHANICAL DOMAIN

Ram K. Varma, A. M. Punithavelu

The observations made earlier1 on the existence of discrete 'forbidden' (and allowed) states in a classical mechanical system of charged particle motion in a magnetic field are extended to include the region where the applied retarding potential exceeds the potential equivalent of the electron energy. The electron current flowing to the ground from the anode of the electron gun is found to exhibit strong dips as the potential on the grid of the detector system kept at a distance along the magnetic field, is swept from a large negative value to zero. The observed anode current 'dips' are quite enigmatic since the electrons under the conditions (grid potential far exceeding the cathode potential) are unable to reach the grid, yet they respond to the grid potential changes in quite an unexpected manner. This observation is thus reminiscent of the Aharanov-Bohm effect in quantum mechanics. The dips are moreover found to fit a relation, a modified form of that given in the earlier reported results.

Modern Physics Letters A•Dec 28, 1993•11 citations

Continuous-Representation Theory. II. Generalized Relation between Quantum and Classical Dynamics

John R. Klauder

This paper discusses an application to the study of dynamics of the typical overcomplete, non-independent sets of unit vectors that characterize continuous-representation theory. It is shown in particular that the conventional, classical Hamiltonian dynamical formalism arises from an analysis of quantum dynamics restricted to an overcomplete, nonindependent set of vectors which lie in one-to-one correspondence with, and are labeled by, points in phase space. A generalized ``classical'' mechanics is then defined by the extremal of the quantum-mechanical action functional with respect to a restricted set of unit vectors whose c-number labels become the dynamical variables. This kind of ``classical'' formalism is discussed in some generality, and is applied not only to simple single-particle problems, but also to finite-spin degrees of freedom and to fermion field oscillators. These latter cases are examples of an important class of problems called exact, for which a study of the classical dynamics alone is sufficient to infer the correct quantum dynamics.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Aug 1, 1963•353 citations

BEHAVIOR OF CHARGED PARTICLE MOTION ALONG A MAGNETIC FIELD AND A RETARDING POTENTIAL-EVIDENCE FOR THE EXISTENCE OF DISCRETE ENERGY STATES IN CLASSICAL MECHANICAL DOMAIN

Ram K. Varma, A. M. Punithavelu

We report here experimental results which point to a rather unexpected, astonishing behavior of charged particle motion in a magnetic field in the presence of a retarding electric potential. An electron beam, when energy scanned with respect to its ‘parallel’ energy using a retarding potential, the response of the transmitted current as a function of the retarding potential is found to be oscillatory as against the monotonic response, expected according to the standard initial value paradigm of classical mechanics. The unexpected ‘peaks’ and ‘dips’ in the transmitted current plots are interpreted as “allowed” and “forbidden” energy states of the system. The peaks (or dips) are found to fit very well with a theoretical relationship which motivated the search for such a behavior; also “quantum numbers” for the peaks have been identified. A very astonishing aspect of the relationship is the dependence of the energies of the allowed states on the length of the box.

Modern Physics Letters A•Jan 20, 1993•17 citations

Interactions and Effective Forces Between Topological Defects in Emergent Schrödinger Dynamics

Jakob Viñas Solé

Title:Interactions and Effective Forces Between Topological Defects in Emergent Schrödinger Dynamics Publication type:Preprint / Working Paper Description: This paper investigates the emergence of particle interactions in a classical wave system through topological defects. Building on previous work establishing an emergent Schrödinger equation in classical elastic media, we show how multiple particle-like excitations—identified as topological phase singularities—interact via phase-mediated mechanisms without introducing fundamental force laws. Key findings: Defect interactions arise automatically from the shared global wavefield, with no explicit interaction terms in the underlying wave equation. The interaction is long-ranged and geometry-driven, with like topological charges repelling and opposite charges attracting in a Coulomb-like manner. Inertia emerges from the distributed kinetic energy of the wavefield, yielding an effective mass that depends on the defect structure and system geometry. The dynamics exhibits deterministic scattering and bound-state behavior governed entirely by wave-mediated topology. Despite structural similarities to quantum mechanics, the framework remains fully classical and deterministic, with no superposition of trajectories, entanglement, or quantum statistics. Theoretical framework: The analysis is formulated within classical continuum mechanics, where an effective Schrödinger equation governs the envelope dynamics of elastic waves. Particle-like excitations correspond to phase singularities whose motion is constrained by a guidance equation. Multi-defect configurations are encoded within a single global wavefield whose phase topology captures all interactions. Significance: This work demonstrates how concepts typically regarded as fundamental—particles, mass, forces, and interactions—can emerge from continuous classical fields through topological constraints. The model provides a concrete and physically transparent example of emergence in physics, with implications for understanding: the relationship between wave and particle descriptions, geometric origins of effective forces, classical analogs of quantum-like behavior, and the role of topology in dynamical systems. Mathematical approach: The paper employs tools from: topological field theory (phase singularities, winding numbers), differential geometry (phase gradient and velocity fields), classical mechanics (effective mass, scattering dynamics), and continuum mechanics (elastic wave equations). Relation to existing work: This study completes a self-consistent framework connecting wave dynamics, particle motion, and interactions within classical physics. It relates to vortex dynamics in fluids, pilot-wave hydrodynamics, and emergent phenomena in condensed matter systems, while maintaining clear conceptual and physical distinctions from quantum mechanics.

•Jan 24, 2026•0 citations

The Emergence of the Quantum State Space from the Dynamics of a Constrained Continuum

S. Conde

The mathematical framework of quantum mechanics is conventionally founded upon a set of abstract axioms governing a Hilbert space. This work investigates whether this formalism can be derived as the effective description of a deeper, deterministic physical reality. We propose a mechanical model wherein a fundamental particle is treated as a 1-dimensional elastic defect (a string-like oscillator) topologically anchored to a background medium. By analyzing the dynamics of this system in the linear regime, we demonstrate that the core tenets of quantum theory emerge as necessary theorems of classical wave mechanicssubject to geometric constraints. Specifically, we show that: (1) the quantization of energy levels is a direct consequence of boundary conditions and resonance; (2) the Hilbert space structure is the natural mathematical arena for describing the superposition of stable vibrational modes; and (3) the momentum and energy operators, along with the Schrödinger equation, arise uniquely from the definition of observables and the conservation of energy. This approach grounds the quantum formalism in the mechanics of a continuous medium, suggesting that quantum behavior is not a break from classical physics, but the natural manifestation of wave dynamics in a confined topology.

•Dec 29, 2025•0 citations

Topological changes of wave functions associated with Hamiltonian monodromy

Chen Chen, J. B. Delos

Almost everything that happens in classical mechanics also shows up in quantum mechanics when we know where to look for it. A phenomenon in classical mechanics involves topological changes in action-angle loops as a result of passage around a "monodromy circuit." This phenomenon is known by the short name "Hamiltonian monodromy" (or, more ponderously, "nontrivial monodromy of action and angle variables in integrable Hamiltonian systems"). In this paper, we show a corresponding change in quantum wave functions: These wave functions change their topological structure in the same way that the corresponding classical action-angle loops change.

Physical review. E•Jun 22, 2018•3 citations
Consequences of the topology of the configuration space of a Hamiltonian dynamical system are considered for a coherent system of trajectories. It is shown that when the space is multiply-connected and therefore the action integral is multivalued, the allowed states of motion (labeled by the initial data) are constrained to a discrete set by the requirement that the action be single-valued. One thus obtains a quantum-like discretization of allowed states of motion even in classical mechanics. Such discrete “allowed” and “forbidden” states have indeed been observed in the classical mechanical system of charged particles in a magnetic field. The relationship of this formalism with a Schrödinger-like formalism for the latter problem given earlier is discussed.
The observations made earlier1 on the existence of discrete 'forbidden' (and allowed) states in a classical mechanical system of charged particle motion in a magnetic field are extended to include the region where the applied retarding potential exceeds the potential equivalent of the electron energy. The electron current flowing to the ground from the anode of the electron gun is found to exhibit strong dips as the potential on the grid of the detector system kept at a distance along the magnetic field, is swept from a large negative value to zero. The observed anode current 'dips' are quite enigmatic since the electrons under the conditions (grid potential far exceeding the cathode potential) are unable to reach the grid, yet they respond to the grid potential changes in quite an unexpected manner. This observation is thus reminiscent of the Aharanov-Bohm effect in quantum mechanics. The dips are moreover found to fit a relation, a modified form of that given in the earlier reported results.
This paper discusses an application to the study of dynamics of the typical overcomplete, non-independent sets of unit vectors that characterize continuous-representation theory. It is shown in particular that the conventional, classical Hamiltonian dynamical formalism arises from an analysis of quantum dynamics restricted to an overcomplete, nonindependent set of vectors which lie in one-to-one correspondence with, and are labeled by, points in phase space. A generalized ``classical'' mechanics is then defined by the extremal of the quantum-mechanical action functional with respect to a restricted set of unit vectors whose c-number labels become the dynamical variables. This kind of ``classical'' formalism is discussed in some generality, and is applied not only to simple single-particle problems, but also to finite-spin degrees of freedom and to fermion field oscillators. These latter cases are examples of an important class of problems called exact, for which a study of the classical dynamics alone is sufficient to infer the correct quantum dynamics.
We report here experimental results which point to a rather unexpected, astonishing behavior of charged particle motion in a magnetic field in the presence of a retarding electric potential. An electron beam, when energy scanned with respect to its ‘parallel’ energy using a retarding potential, the response of the transmitted current as a function of the retarding potential is found to be oscillatory as against the monotonic response, expected according to the standard initial value paradigm of classical mechanics. The unexpected ‘peaks’ and ‘dips’ in the transmitted current plots are interpreted as “allowed” and “forbidden” energy states of the system. The peaks (or dips) are found to fit very well with a theoretical relationship which motivated the search for such a behavior; also “quantum numbers” for the peaks have been identified. A very astonishing aspect of the relationship is the dependence of the energies of the allowed states on the length of the box.
Title:Interactions and Effective Forces Between Topological Defects in Emergent Schrödinger Dynamics Publication type:Preprint / Working Paper Description: This paper investigates the emergence of particle interactions in a classical wave system through topological defects. Building on previous work establishing an emergent Schrödinger equation in classical elastic media, we show how multiple particle-like excitations—identified as topological phase singularities—interact via phase-mediated mechanisms without introducing fundamental force laws. Key findings: Defect interactions arise automatically from the shared global wavefield, with no explicit interaction terms in the underlying wave equation. The interaction is long-ranged and geometry-driven, with like topological charges repelling and opposite charges attracting in a Coulomb-like manner. Inertia emerges from the distributed kinetic energy of the wavefield, yielding an effective mass that depends on the defect structure and system geometry. The dynamics exhibits deterministic scattering and bound-state behavior governed entirely by wave-mediated topology. Despite structural similarities to quantum mechanics, the framework remains fully classical and deterministic, with no superposition of trajectories, entanglement, or quantum statistics. Theoretical framework: The analysis is formulated within classical continuum mechanics, where an effective Schrödinger equation governs the envelope dynamics of elastic waves. Particle-like excitations correspond to phase singularities whose motion is constrained by a guidance equation. Multi-defect configurations are encoded within a single global wavefield whose phase topology captures all interactions. Significance: This work demonstrates how concepts typically regarded as fundamental—particles, mass, forces, and interactions—can emerge from continuous classical fields through topological constraints. The model provides a concrete and physically transparent example of emergence in physics, with implications for understanding: the relationship between wave and particle descriptions, geometric origins of effective forces, classical analogs of quantum-like behavior, and the role of topology in dynamical systems. Mathematical approach: The paper employs tools from: topological field theory (phase singularities, winding numbers), differential geometry (phase gradient and velocity fields), classical mechanics (effective mass, scattering dynamics), and continuum mechanics (elastic wave equations). Relation to existing work: This study completes a self-consistent framework connecting wave dynamics, particle motion, and interactions within classical physics. It relates to vortex dynamics in fluids, pilot-wave hydrodynamics, and emergent phenomena in condensed matter systems, while maintaining clear conceptual and physical distinctions from quantum mechanics.
The mathematical framework of quantum mechanics is conventionally founded upon a set of abstract axioms governing a Hilbert space. This work investigates whether this formalism can be derived as the effective description of a deeper, deterministic physical reality. We propose a mechanical model wherein a fundamental particle is treated as a 1-dimensional elastic defect (a string-like oscillator) topologically anchored to a background medium. By analyzing the dynamics of this system in the linear regime, we demonstrate that the core tenets of quantum theory emerge as necessary theorems of classical wave mechanicssubject to geometric constraints. Specifically, we show that: (1) the quantization of energy levels is a direct consequence of boundary conditions and resonance; (2) the Hilbert space structure is the natural mathematical arena for describing the superposition of stable vibrational modes; and (3) the momentum and energy operators, along with the Schrödinger equation, arise uniquely from the definition of observables and the conservation of energy. This approach grounds the quantum formalism in the mechanics of a continuous medium, suggesting that quantum behavior is not a break from classical physics, but the natural manifestation of wave dynamics in a confined topology.
Almost everything that happens in classical mechanics also shows up in quantum mechanics when we know where to look for it. A phenomenon in classical mechanics involves topological changes in action-angle loops as a result of passage around a "monodromy circuit." This phenomenon is known by the short name "Hamiltonian monodromy" (or, more ponderously, "nontrivial monodromy of action and angle variables in integrable Hamiltonian systems"). In this paper, we show a corresponding change in quantum wave functions: These wave functions change their topological structure in the same way that the corresponding classical action-angle loops change.