Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Modern Optics

Beyond the heisenberg uncertainty

Yanhua H. Shih

Published Nov 1, 2004• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

An entangled EPR two-particle system is characterized by Δ(p 1 + p 2) = 0 and Δ(x 1 - x 2) = 0, simultaneously, with the momentum and position of each individual particle completely undefined. Statistically, however, the uncertainty of the correlation measurements on the two individual particles must obey Δ(p1 + p 2) > Δp 1,2 and Δ(x 1 - x 2) > Δx 1,2. While one sees the measurements of p 1 + p 2 and x 1 - x 2 of the two individual particles satisfying the EPR δ-function, and believes the classical statistical inequality, one might easily be trapped into concluding either there is a violation of the uncertainty principle or there exists action-at-a-distance. Through the analysis of three typical EPR experiments, we show that the measurement of p 1 + p 2 and x 1 - x 2 for an entangled system can indeed violate the classical statistical inequality. Based on the experimental results, we emphasize, again, the surprising physics of quantum coherent two-particle superposition. Although questions regarding fundamental issues of quantum theory still exist, quantum entanglement has brought us a novel concept in non-local timing and positioning measurements with ultra-high accuracy, even beyond the classical limit.

DOI
10.1080/09500340408231796

Related papers

Quantum entanglement and the uncertainty relations

Yanhua H. Shih

Abstract Entangled EPR two‐particle system is characterized by Δ(p1+p2) = 0 and Δ (x1‐ x2) = 0, simultaneous. Even the momentum and position of each individual particle are completely undefined: Δ pj ∼ ∞, Δ xj ∼∞. This remarkable feature does not violate the uncertainty principle of quantum theory. It is the result of the surprising two‐particle quantum coherent superposition. Although questions regarding fundamental issues of quantum theory still exist, quantum entanglement has brought about a novel concept in nonlocal timing and positioning measurements with ultra‐high accuracy, even beyond the classical limit.

Fortschritte der Physik•Oct 11, 2004•0 citations

Beyond the Heisenberg uncertainty

Milena D’Angelo, Yanhua H. Shih

Following Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen (EPR) original argument, we derive a pair of inequalities for the uncertainties in the sum of the momenta and in the difference of the positions of an entangled two-particle system. We prove that only entangled systems can satisfy both EPR-inequalities, in violation of the limits imposed by classical statistics. We propose an operational approach that allows applying the EPR inequalities to two-photon systems, as well. In particular, we demonstrate a scheme that allows implementing the EPR gedanken-experiment and verifying the EPR inequalities on systems of pairs of photons. We report the experimental results obtained in this kind of quantum interference and imaging experiment: SPDC two-photon system satisfies both EPR inequalities. The experimental verification of the EPR inequalities represents a practical way to experimentally distinguish entanglement from classical correlation in momentum and/or position variables for systems of two particles/photons. We emphasize the practical consequences of the EPR inequalities: only entanglement allows one to go beyond the limitations imposed by Heisenberg uncertainty on systems of classically correlated particles/photons. In this context we review a recent experiment of two-photon diffraction and quantum lithography.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Oct 19, 2004•0 citations

EPR inequalities: a practical tool to identify entanglement and go beyond Heisenberg uncertainty

Milena D’Angelo, Morton H. Rubin, Yanhua H. Shih

We prove the EPRs inequalities allow distinguishing (experimentally) entanglement from classical correlation in momentum and position variables for two particles/photons systems. We discuss the connection between EPR inequalities and uncertainty principle and conclude that only entanglement allows going beyond the limitations imposed by Heisenberg uncertainty on classically correlated systems.

Frontiers in Optics•Jan 1, 2004•0 citations

On Quantum Entanglement and Nonlocality

Uddin, Mafiz

EPR showed that two particles emitted from a source can be entangled by a shared wavefunction where two non-commuting observables (position, momentum) can be simultaneously real, leading to a contradiction with quantum mechanics (two non-commuting variables can not be simultaneously real). John Bell derived an inequality where any local hidden variables prediction is bounded and quantum mechanics can violate the inequality. Bell tests on correlated photon pairs showed a clear violation of the Bell inequality and agreement with quantum mechanics. This study revealed that the Bell inequality holds at any individual instances in a given system but it does not hold over the entire population. The Bell inequality is not an incompatibility criterion for local hidden variables vs quantum mechanics rather it is a criterion for an individual nature vs population dynamics. The nonlocality prediction given by wavefunction is a system approximation and local causality (photon polarization) provides a complete description of the Bell tests. The paper concludes with great satisfaction that the measurement of two correlated photons at a distance was a local cause (photon-filter interaction did not violate the special theory of relativity).

arXiv:2506.00366•May 31, 2025•0 citations

Correlated observables in single-particle systems

Ian T. Durham

Bell-type experiments that test correlated observables typically involve measurements of spin or polarization on multi-particle systems in singlet states. These observables are all non-commuting and satisfy an uncertainty relation. Theoretically, the non-commuting nature should be independent of whether the singlet state consists of multiple particles or a single particle. In addition, if Bell-type inequalities can be found for experiments involving spin and polarization, the same should be true for experiments involving other non-commuting observables such as position and momentum. In fact the original EPR paper used position and momentum, though in a different experimental situation. As such, an experiment is proposed to measure (quantum mechanically) position and momentum for a single oscillator as a means for deriving a Bell-type inequality for these correlated observables. The experiment, if realizable, would shed light on the basic nature of matter, perhaps pointing to some form of self-entanglement, and would also help to further elucidate a possible mechanism behind the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. Violation of these inequalities would, in fact, offer yet another confirmation of the principle.

•Nov 6, 2005•0 citations

THE EPR ARGUMENT AND QUANTUM NONLOCALITY

Bidyut Kumar Datta, V. de Sabbata, Renuka Datta

We view the final remark of the EPR paper : “one would not be able to arrive at the above conclusion if two or more physical quantities are regarded as simultaneous elements of reality only when they can be simultaneously measured or predicted”. On this point of view, because of the collapse of the wave function of the combined system, the EPR entangled relations (or correlations) of momenta and positions belonging to two spatially separated particles considered in the first part of the paper do not hold good simultaneously for two separate measurements. This case does not reconcile with the locality principle and hence exhibits quantum nonlocality. Moreover, it is quite compatible with uncertainty principle. It is concluded that the EPR argument does not exhibit any paradox.

•Aug 1, 2000•0 citations
An entangled EPR two-particle system is characterized by Δ(p 1 + p 2) = 0 and Δ(x 1 - x 2) = 0, simultaneously, with the momentum and position of each individual particle completely undefined. Statistically, however, the uncertainty of the correlation measurements on the two individual particles must obey Δ(p1 + p 2) > Δp 1,2 and Δ(x 1 - x 2) > Δx 1,2. While one sees the measurements of p 1 + p 2 and x 1 - x 2 of the two individual particles satisfying the EPR δ-function, and believes the classical statistical inequality, one might easily be trapped into concluding either there is a violation of the uncertainty principle or there exists action-at-a-distance. Through the analysis of three typical EPR experiments, we show that the measurement of p 1 + p 2 and x 1 - x 2 for an entangled system can indeed violate the classical statistical inequality. Based on the experimental results, we emphasize, again, the surprising physics of quantum coherent two-particle superposition. Although questions regarding fundamental issues of quantum theory still exist, quantum entanglement has brought us a novel concept in non-local timing and positioning measurements with ultra-high accuracy, even beyond the classical limit.
Abstract Entangled EPR two‐particle system is characterized by Δ(p1+p2) = 0 and Δ (x1‐ x2) = 0, simultaneous. Even the momentum and position of each individual particle are completely undefined: Δ pj ∼ ∞, Δ xj ∼∞. This remarkable feature does not violate the uncertainty principle of quantum theory. It is the result of the surprising two‐particle quantum coherent superposition. Although questions regarding fundamental issues of quantum theory still exist, quantum entanglement has brought about a novel concept in nonlocal timing and positioning measurements with ultra‐high accuracy, even beyond the classical limit.
Following Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen (EPR) original argument, we derive a pair of inequalities for the uncertainties in the sum of the momenta and in the difference of the positions of an entangled two-particle system. We prove that only entangled systems can satisfy both EPR-inequalities, in violation of the limits imposed by classical statistics. We propose an operational approach that allows applying the EPR inequalities to two-photon systems, as well. In particular, we demonstrate a scheme that allows implementing the EPR gedanken-experiment and verifying the EPR inequalities on systems of pairs of photons. We report the experimental results obtained in this kind of quantum interference and imaging experiment: SPDC two-photon system satisfies both EPR inequalities. The experimental verification of the EPR inequalities represents a practical way to experimentally distinguish entanglement from classical correlation in momentum and/or position variables for systems of two particles/photons. We emphasize the practical consequences of the EPR inequalities: only entanglement allows one to go beyond the limitations imposed by Heisenberg uncertainty on systems of classically correlated particles/photons. In this context we review a recent experiment of two-photon diffraction and quantum lithography.
EPR showed that two particles emitted from a source can be entangled by a shared wavefunction where two non-commuting observables (position, momentum) can be simultaneously real, leading to a contradiction with quantum mechanics (two non-commuting variables can not be simultaneously real). John Bell derived an inequality where any local hidden variables prediction is bounded and quantum mechanics can violate the inequality. Bell tests on correlated photon pairs showed a clear violation of the Bell inequality and agreement with quantum mechanics. This study revealed that the Bell inequality holds at any individual instances in a given system but it does not hold over the entire population. The Bell inequality is not an incompatibility criterion for local hidden variables vs quantum mechanics rather it is a criterion for an individual nature vs population dynamics. The nonlocality prediction given by wavefunction is a system approximation and local causality (photon polarization) provides a complete description of the Bell tests. The paper concludes with great satisfaction that the measurement of two correlated photons at a distance was a local cause (photon-filter interaction did not violate the special theory of relativity).
Bell-type experiments that test correlated observables typically involve measurements of spin or polarization on multi-particle systems in singlet states. These observables are all non-commuting and satisfy an uncertainty relation. Theoretically, the non-commuting nature should be independent of whether the singlet state consists of multiple particles or a single particle. In addition, if Bell-type inequalities can be found for experiments involving spin and polarization, the same should be true for experiments involving other non-commuting observables such as position and momentum. In fact the original EPR paper used position and momentum, though in a different experimental situation. As such, an experiment is proposed to measure (quantum mechanically) position and momentum for a single oscillator as a means for deriving a Bell-type inequality for these correlated observables. The experiment, if realizable, would shed light on the basic nature of matter, perhaps pointing to some form of self-entanglement, and would also help to further elucidate a possible mechanism behind the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. Violation of these inequalities would, in fact, offer yet another confirmation of the principle.
We view the final remark of the EPR paper : “one would not be able to arrive at the above conclusion if two or more physical quantities are regarded as simultaneous elements of reality only when they can be simultaneously measured or predicted”. On this point of view, because of the collapse of the wave function of the combined system, the EPR entangled relations (or correlations) of momenta and positions belonging to two spatially separated particles considered in the first part of the paper do not hold good simultaneously for two separate measurements. This case does not reconcile with the locality principle and hence exhibits quantum nonlocality. Moreover, it is quite compatible with uncertainty principle. It is concluded that the EPR argument does not exhibit any paradox.