In this note I discuss briefly a rather unusual example of the use of the variational principle, which perhaps is interesting for someone who studies or teaches quantum mechanics.
Abstract Richard Feynman famously asserted that in order to simulate a quantum mechanical system, a computer itself operating on the principles of quantum mechanics would be required. In this chapter, we see that gate-based quantum computers indeed fulfil this vision for many quantum systems of interest. From the perspective of scientific computing, this is perhaps the most important and natural application of quantum computing, and three approaches have emerged as most eminent: Trotterisation, using a linear combination of unitaries to simulate a truncated Taylor series; and quantum signal processing (the analysis of which is deferred to the later chapter on the closely-related quantum singular value transformation). The ground state energy problem is also introduced as one of the most important real-world applications of Hamiltonian simulation – for example in quantum chemistry and condensed matter physics. The variational quantum eigensolver is also briefly discussed as a near-term algorithm for the ground state energy problem.
For many years we have advocated a form of quantum mechanics based on the application of sum rule methods (completeness) to the equations of motion and to the commutation relations, i.e., to Heisenberg matrix mechanics. Sporadically we have discussed or alluded to a variational foundation for this method. In this paper we present a series of variational principles applicable to a range of systems from one-dimensional quantum mechanics to quantum fields. The common thread is that the stationary quantity is the trace of the Hamiltonian over Hilbert space (or over a subspace of interest in an approximation) expressed as a functional of matrix elements of the elementary operators of the theory. These parameters are constrained by the kinematical relations of the theory introduced by the method of Lagrange multipliers. For the field theories, variational principles in which matrix elements of the density operators are chosen as fundamental are also developed. A qualitative discussion of applications is presented.
A general perturbation theory of the statistics of spin interactions is developed in the form of a linked cluster expansion with particular emphasis on the Ising model. The theory applies to the evaluation of the expectation value of arbitrary spin functions as well as of the free energy. The thermodynamical consistency of the perturbation expansion is shown to arise from (1) variational principles satisfied by the free energy after a "renormalization procedure" has been carried out and (2) a generalized "Ward Identity" between renormalized quantities. These results are used to discuss inconsistencies in recent high-density theories of ferromagnetism and an improved theory obtained by the summation of all the convolution diagrams (nodal expansion) is briefly presented. The applicability of the method to general quantum mechanical many-body problems, including the theory of the Heisenberg model of ferromagnetism, is shown.