Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

Interaction-free quantum measurements: A paradox?

Robert Henry Dicke

Published Oct 1, 1981• 235 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In Heisenberg’s famous discussion of the measurement of a particle’s position using a microscope, the momentum transferred to the particle by the scattered photon makes the particle’s momentum uncertain. It is shown that momentum is also transferred when the lack of a scattered photon is used to discover that the particle is absent from the field of view of the microscope (i.e., located outside the light beam). This apparent paradox, a transfer of momentum and/or energy to a missing particle by a light beam (without the scattering of a photon), is discussed and ’’resolved’’ using quantum measurement theory.

DOI
10.1119/1.12592

Related papers

On the Paradoxical Aspects of New Quantum Experiments

Lev Vaidman A

I shall discuss two recently suggested quantum experiments. These experiments lead to paradoxical situations. I will argue that in the framework of a particular Many Worlds Interpretation of quantum theory the paradoxes do not arise. The first experiment is the “interaction-free measurement” (Elitzur and Vaidman 1993). The experimental group at Innsbruck headed by Prof. Zeilinger is working now on its realization. Before describing the experiment let me discuss a general question: “How do we know that there is an object in a region of space?” The simplest case is when the object itself causes some physical changes outside the region: i) The object is charged, so there is a field outside. We can measure this field. ii) The object yields a potential outside. Aharonov and Bohm have taught us that potential even without field leads to a measurable effect. iii) The objects radiates photons or other particles.

PSA Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association•Jan 1, 1994•31 citations

Light Quantum Induces The Measurement Paradox

Antonio Puccini

We learn from Quantum Mechanics that the observation of the microscopic world, the measurement (M) of a quantum object, i.e. a particle, inexorably modifies the physical system we wish to examine. What happens is that with the M it takes place a reduction of the state vectors, that is the ‘wave function collapse’ of the measured particle. Why does it happen? No one knows. The enigma of the so-called Measurement Paradox, in our opinion, could be solved if we considered that the light quantum(LQ), as suggested by the Principle of Equivalence Mass-Energy, carries out a dynamic-mass equivalent to its energy. The LQ is indispensable to carry out a M. No M can be carried out without using the quantum of light. Calculus show that a photon of the optic band hits an electron with a momentum bigger than the mass of the electron itself. This may explain why the M induces the implosion of the quantum object observed, together with the collapse of its wave function, giving rise to the Measurement Paradox.

JOURNAL OF ADVANCES IN PHYSICS•Jan 19, 2019•11 citations

Uncertainty and Complementarity

Kurt Gottfried

The creation of quantum mechanics in the period 1924–1928 restored logical consistency to its rightful place in theoretical physics. The study of interaction between light and electrons provided most of the important clues in the development of the quantum theory. This chapter shows that in the interference experiments the statistical distribution of quanta is correctly given by the intensity of the wave field as computed from classical electromagnetic theory. It also shows that under special circumstances the classical theory also makes contact with some of the empirical facts in Compton's experiment. The chapter discusses a famous example due to W. Heisenberg, in which Compton scattered γ-rays are brought to focus by a microscope. It provides the uncertainty relations for the dynamical variables of a particle from the conservation laws and the properties of photons. Because the motion of charged particles can be deduced from their attendant fields, it is clear that fields cannot be measured to arbitrary precision.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 9, 2018•2 citations

The nature of light: a description of photon diffraction based upon virtual particle exchange

Michael J. Mobley

Any discussion of the nature of light must include a reminder that whenever we make the observation of light (photons), we only observe particle-like properties. This paper provides a reiteration that we don't need wave-like properties to scattered photons to describe phenomena such as diffraction or refraction of light. This paper updates the original ideas of Duane, later revived by Lande, which provided a description of light diffraction without making reference to a wave nature. These are updated using terminology more common to quantum electrodynamics which describes the interaction of particles in terms of the exchange of virtual photons. Diffraction is described in terms of an ensemble of distinct, probability weighted paths for the scattered photons. The scattering associated with each path results from the quantized momentum exchange with the scattering lattice attributed to the exchange or reflection of virtual photons. The probability for virtual particle exchange/reflection is dependent upon the allowed momentum states of the lattice determined by a Fourier analysis of the lattice geometry. Any scattered photon will exhibit an apparent wavelength inversely proportional to its momentum. Simplified, particle-like descriptions are developed for Young's double slit diffraction, Fraunhofer diffraction and Fresnel diffraction. This description directly accounts for the quantization of momentum transferred to the scattering lattice and the specific eigenvalues of the lattice based upon the constraints to virtual photon exchange set by the Uncertainty Principle, Δπi = h/ζi.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Aug 1, 2005•5 citations

On decoherence

Gianfausto Dell’Antonio

Using a quantum particle in R3 as a toy model, and following the rules of Schrödinger’s quantum mechanics, we discuss to which extent one may be able to use “decoherence” to view the quantum particle as a “classical” measuring apparatus to measure position. We discuss also very briefly the measurement of momentum and the case of quantum optics.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Oct 24, 2003•4 citations

Illusion or reality: The measurement process in quantum optics

Axel Schenzle

Whereas a measurement in the domain of classical physics merely collects information on the examined object, measurements on the microscopic scale unavoidably leave their traces on the measured system. Experiments with single atoms and few photons contribute to our understanding of this fundamental property of quantum mechanics.

Contemporary Physics•Jul 1, 1996•11 citations
In Heisenberg’s famous discussion of the measurement of a particle’s position using a microscope, the momentum transferred to the particle by the scattered photon makes the particle’s momentum uncertain. It is shown that momentum is also transferred when the lack of a scattered photon is used to discover that the particle is absent from the field of view of the microscope (i.e., located outside the light beam). This apparent paradox, a transfer of momentum and/or energy to a missing particle by a light beam (without the scattering of a photon), is discussed and ’’resolved’’ using quantum measurement theory.
I shall discuss two recently suggested quantum experiments. These experiments lead to paradoxical situations. I will argue that in the framework of a particular Many Worlds Interpretation of quantum theory the paradoxes do not arise. The first experiment is the “interaction-free measurement” (Elitzur and Vaidman 1993). The experimental group at Innsbruck headed by Prof. Zeilinger is working now on its realization. Before describing the experiment let me discuss a general question: “How do we know that there is an object in a region of space?” The simplest case is when the object itself causes some physical changes outside the region: i) The object is charged, so there is a field outside. We can measure this field. ii) The object yields a potential outside. Aharonov and Bohm have taught us that potential even without field leads to a measurable effect. iii) The objects radiates photons or other particles.
We learn from Quantum Mechanics that the observation of the microscopic world, the measurement (M) of a quantum object, i.e. a particle, inexorably modifies the physical system we wish to examine. What happens is that with the M it takes place a reduction of the state vectors, that is the ‘wave function collapse’ of the measured particle. Why does it happen? No one knows. The enigma of the so-called Measurement Paradox, in our opinion, could be solved if we considered that the light quantum(LQ), as suggested by the Principle of Equivalence Mass-Energy, carries out a dynamic-mass equivalent to its energy. The LQ is indispensable to carry out a M. No M can be carried out without using the quantum of light. Calculus show that a photon of the optic band hits an electron with a momentum bigger than the mass of the electron itself. This may explain why the M induces the implosion of the quantum object observed, together with the collapse of its wave function, giving rise to the Measurement Paradox.
The creation of quantum mechanics in the period 1924–1928 restored logical consistency to its rightful place in theoretical physics. The study of interaction between light and electrons provided most of the important clues in the development of the quantum theory. This chapter shows that in the interference experiments the statistical distribution of quanta is correctly given by the intensity of the wave field as computed from classical electromagnetic theory. It also shows that under special circumstances the classical theory also makes contact with some of the empirical facts in Compton's experiment. The chapter discusses a famous example due to W. Heisenberg, in which Compton scattered γ-rays are brought to focus by a microscope. It provides the uncertainty relations for the dynamical variables of a particle from the conservation laws and the properties of photons. Because the motion of charged particles can be deduced from their attendant fields, it is clear that fields cannot be measured to arbitrary precision.
Any discussion of the nature of light must include a reminder that whenever we make the observation of light (photons), we only observe particle-like properties. This paper provides a reiteration that we don't need wave-like properties to scattered photons to describe phenomena such as diffraction or refraction of light. This paper updates the original ideas of Duane, later revived by Lande, which provided a description of light diffraction without making reference to a wave nature. These are updated using terminology more common to quantum electrodynamics which describes the interaction of particles in terms of the exchange of virtual photons. Diffraction is described in terms of an ensemble of distinct, probability weighted paths for the scattered photons. The scattering associated with each path results from the quantized momentum exchange with the scattering lattice attributed to the exchange or reflection of virtual photons. The probability for virtual particle exchange/reflection is dependent upon the allowed momentum states of the lattice determined by a Fourier analysis of the lattice geometry. Any scattered photon will exhibit an apparent wavelength inversely proportional to its momentum. Simplified, particle-like descriptions are developed for Young's double slit diffraction, Fraunhofer diffraction and Fresnel diffraction. This description directly accounts for the quantization of momentum transferred to the scattering lattice and the specific eigenvalues of the lattice based upon the constraints to virtual photon exchange set by the Uncertainty Principle, Δπi = h/ζi.