A transfer-matrix version of a mean-field approximation is proposed which leads to the exact critical temperatures for the S =1/2 Ising model on the square, triangular, honeycomb, and centered square lattices. The estimations of critical temperatures for more complicated models are also shown to be very accurate.
A new graphical method is developed to calculate the critical temperature of 2- and 3-dimensional Ising models as well as that of the 2-dimensional Potts models. This method is based on the transfer matrix method and using the limited lattice for the calculation. The reduced internal energy per site has been accurately calculated for different 2-D Ising and Potts models using different size-limited lattices. All calculated energies intersect at a single point when plotted versus the reduced temperature. The reduced temperature at the intersection is 0.4407, 0.2746, and 0.6585 for the square, triangular, and honeycombs Ising lattices and 1.0050, 0.6309, and 1.4848 for the square, triangular, and honeycombs Potts lattices, respectively. These values are exactly the same as the critical temperatures reported in the literature, except for the honeycomb Potts lattice. For the two-dimensional Ising model, we have shown that the existence of such an intersection point is due to the duality relation. The method is then extended to the simple cubic Ising model, in which the intersection point is found to be dependent on the lattice sizes. We have found a linear relation between the lattice size and the intersection point. This relation is used to obtain the critical temperature of the unlimited simple cubic lattice. The obtained result, 0.221(2), is in a good agreement with the accurate value of 0.22165 reported by others.
We analyse in some detail a recently proposed transfer matrix mean-field approximation which yields the exact critical point for several two-dimensional nearest-neighbour Ising models. For the square lattice model we show explicitly that this approximation yields not only the exact critical point, but also the exact boundary magnetization of a semi-infinite Ising model, independent of the size of the strips used. Then we develop a new mean-field renormalization-group strategy based on this approximation and make connections with finite size scaling. Applying our strategy to the quadratic Ising and three-state Potts models we obtain results for the critical exponents which are in very good agreement with the exact ones. In this way we also clarify some advantages and limitations of the mean field renormalization group approach.
The recently proposed multi-interaction mean-field renormalization technique [C. N. Likos and A. Maritan, Phys. Rev. E 53, 3303 (1996)] is applied to the Ising model on a triangular lattice with equal couplings in two directions and a different coupling in the third, a model equivalent to a square Ising model with additional second-neighbor interactions along a single diagonal direction. Three different clusters are considered and the possible mappings between them are discussed. The estimates for critical couplings and exponents are in satisfactory agreement with exact results. An explanation of the way in which the finite-size features of the method bring about a systematic overestimation of the critical temperature is also given.