Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Rochester Conferences on Coherence and Quantum Optics and the Quantum Information and Measurement meeting

J-C Theory with Radiation Reaction: Neoclassical Theory

Carlos R. Stroud

Published Jan 1, 2013• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The Jaynes-Cummings paper treats the problem of one-atom interacting with one cavity mode with two alternative theories: quantum electrodynamics and semiclassical theory, and compares the predictions. The semiclassical theory was later extended to treat a single atom in free space interacting with a classical field including radiation reaction. The resulting theory was called Neoclassical theory, and is described by nonlinear optical Bloch equations. These nonlinear equations have shown up in a number of physical systems and were the subject of the famous Jaynes-Franken bet that was a prominent feature of the early Rochester Coherence and Quantum Optics Conferences. We will touch on all of these topics in a historical review.

DOI
10.1364/cqo.2013.m1.5

Related papers

Jaynes–Cummings theory out of the box

Elizabeth Groves, B. D. Clader, Joseph H. Eberly

We report new results in neoclassical quantum optics by applying the central theme of the Jaynes–Cummings paper of 1963. This theme, which Jaynes and Cummings emphasized in several ways, is the key role that must be assigned to radiative back reaction in quantum radiation dynamics. Its consequences are well known in subjects related to cavity quantum electrodynamics, and its influence on optical pulse evolution theory is equally strong. Here we provide a new solitonic extension of the radiation reaction theme to short-pulse broad-bandwidth propagation theory. We report a single formula encapsulating a three-pulse scenario in which the stable imprint of signal-pulse coherence, placed in an atomic medium at a predictable location by an initial pulse pair, is subsequently transferred by a third pulse to a different location. This is analysed by reference to our new analytic solution of the nonlinearly coupled density matrix equations that incorporate the radiation reaction fields obtained from the Maxwell equations for the pulses in the atomic medium.

Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Nov 7, 2013•8 citations

Neoclassicism challenges QED

Some physicists are questioning the necessity of quantum electrodynamics in quantum optics and perhaps elsewhere. A lively discussion on possible alternatives developed during the Third Rochester Conference on Coherence and Quantum Optics at the end of June. The most widely discussed alternative was the neoclassical theory of Edwin Jaynes and his collaborators (Washington University in St. Louis). This theory regards the Maxwell equations as describing the radiation field while the Schrödinger equation is applied to the atoms. The charge and current sources of the Maxwell field are taken to be given by the corresponding probability densities of wave mechanics. Jaynes contends that these nonlinear equations describe physical phenomena better than has been appreciated in earlier times.

Physics Today•Oct 1, 1972•0 citations

Interaction between Light and Atoms

Claude Fabre, Rodrigo G. Cortiñas

Appendix G: interaction between a monochromatic field and two-level atom. The problem is treated first in the case of a classical field and a quantum two-level system (semiclassical approach): It is characterised by a rotation of the Bloch vector (Rabi ocillation) and allows us to generate any qubit state by applying a field of well-controlled duration and amplitude. One then includes spontaneous emission to the model, and finally obtains the set of Bloch equations that are used in many different problems of light–matter interaction. One then considers the full quantum case of cavity quantum electrodynamics (CQED), where the field is single mode and fully quantum: this is the Jaynes–Cummings Hamiltonian approach, which is fully solvable when one negelcts spontaneous emission: quantum oscillations and revivals are predicted. Damping is then introduced in the model, and two regimes of strong and weak couplings are predicted in this case.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jul 27, 2023•0 citations

Self-Consistent Radiation Reaction in Quantum Optics – Jaynes' Influence and a New Example in Cavity QED

Joseph H. Eberly

. It is pointed out that the self-consistent treatment of radiation reaction is a common feature of many Ph.D. theses of E. T. Jaynes' students and “grandstudents” in the 30-year period 1962 - 1992. In this way they are all descended from Microwave Laboratory Report 502, written by Jaynes at Stanford in 1958. A number of examples are described briefly, and a new example that extends the framework laid down in M. L. 502 is presented. Microwave Laboratory Report 502 In 1958 E. T. Jaynes wrote a paper entitled Some Aspects of Maser Theory that was issued as Microwave Laboratory Report No. 502 at Stanford University. The cover of the report is shown in Fig. 1. In the Abstract of M. L. 502 Jaynes identified the work as an examination of the relation between quantum electrodynamics and the semiclassical theory of radiation. M. L. 502 was intended to serve as a preliminary step in a study of the ultimate limitations on noise figure and frequency stability in molecular-beam masers. The Abstract says, among other things, that “the semiclassical theory, as extended here, is a far more reliable means of calculating radiation processes than usually supposed.” In the present author's view, M. L. 502 reported the first examination of dynamical questions that are now associated with the field of cavity quantum electrodynamics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 2, 1993•1 citation

Implications of radiative equilibrium in neoclassical theory

Franklin R. Nash, J. P. Gordon

We discuss some implications of the description of spontaneous emission of radiation which has been offered by Jaynes and his collaborators in their "neoclassical" extension of semiclassical electrodynamics. In particular, we examine the thermal-equilibrium condition of radiation interacting with a tenuous gas of atoms. We argue that rate equations may be used to describe the interaction of such atoms with the chaotic thermal radiation field. For this situation the neoclassical spontaneous emission rate is incompatible with the well-secured laws of Boltzmann and Planck. Experimental evidence bearing on the accuracy of those laws as well as on the accepted level population dependence of the induced emission rate is reviewed.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1975•6 citations

Neoclassical physics and blackbody radiation

J. P. Gordon

The neoclassical theory of the interaction of radiation with matter, introduced by its authors as a potentially viable alternative to quantum electrodynamics, is examined in the case of a multilevel atom interacting with blackbody radiation. The stationary statistical states of the atom and the field are derived, and two independently untenable results emerge. First, the stationary blackbody law turns out to be that of Rayleigh and Jeans, rather than that of Planck. Second, the mean energy of a harmonic oscillator, which interacts with the field only near a single frequency, turns out to be infinite. These results are discussed in the light of the neoclassical description of spontaneous emission.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1975•8 citations
The Jaynes-Cummings paper treats the problem of one-atom interacting with one cavity mode with two alternative theories: quantum electrodynamics and semiclassical theory, and compares the predictions. The semiclassical theory was later extended to treat a single atom in free space interacting with a classical field including radiation reaction. The resulting theory was called Neoclassical theory, and is described by nonlinear optical Bloch equations. These nonlinear equations have shown up in a number of physical systems and were the subject of the famous Jaynes-Franken bet that was a prominent feature of the early Rochester Coherence and Quantum Optics Conferences. We will touch on all of these topics in a historical review.
We report new results in neoclassical quantum optics by applying the central theme of the Jaynes–Cummings paper of 1963. This theme, which Jaynes and Cummings emphasized in several ways, is the key role that must be assigned to radiative back reaction in quantum radiation dynamics. Its consequences are well known in subjects related to cavity quantum electrodynamics, and its influence on optical pulse evolution theory is equally strong. Here we provide a new solitonic extension of the radiation reaction theme to short-pulse broad-bandwidth propagation theory. We report a single formula encapsulating a three-pulse scenario in which the stable imprint of signal-pulse coherence, placed in an atomic medium at a predictable location by an initial pulse pair, is subsequently transferred by a third pulse to a different location. This is analysed by reference to our new analytic solution of the nonlinearly coupled density matrix equations that incorporate the radiation reaction fields obtained from the Maxwell equations for the pulses in the atomic medium.
Some physicists are questioning the necessity of quantum electrodynamics in quantum optics and perhaps elsewhere. A lively discussion on possible alternatives developed during the Third Rochester Conference on Coherence and Quantum Optics at the end of June. The most widely discussed alternative was the neoclassical theory of Edwin Jaynes and his collaborators (Washington University in St. Louis). This theory regards the Maxwell equations as describing the radiation field while the Schrödinger equation is applied to the atoms. The charge and current sources of the Maxwell field are taken to be given by the corresponding probability densities of wave mechanics. Jaynes contends that these nonlinear equations describe physical phenomena better than has been appreciated in earlier times.
Appendix G: interaction between a monochromatic field and two-level atom. The problem is treated first in the case of a classical field and a quantum two-level system (semiclassical approach): It is characterised by a rotation of the Bloch vector (Rabi ocillation) and allows us to generate any qubit state by applying a field of well-controlled duration and amplitude. One then includes spontaneous emission to the model, and finally obtains the set of Bloch equations that are used in many different problems of light–matter interaction. One then considers the full quantum case of cavity quantum electrodynamics (CQED), where the field is single mode and fully quantum: this is the Jaynes–Cummings Hamiltonian approach, which is fully solvable when one negelcts spontaneous emission: quantum oscillations and revivals are predicted. Damping is then introduced in the model, and two regimes of strong and weak couplings are predicted in this case.
. It is pointed out that the self-consistent treatment of radiation reaction is a common feature of many Ph.D. theses of E. T. Jaynes' students and “grandstudents” in the 30-year period 1962 - 1992. In this way they are all descended from Microwave Laboratory Report 502, written by Jaynes at Stanford in 1958. A number of examples are described briefly, and a new example that extends the framework laid down in M. L. 502 is presented. Microwave Laboratory Report 502 In 1958 E. T. Jaynes wrote a paper entitled Some Aspects of Maser Theory that was issued as Microwave Laboratory Report No. 502 at Stanford University. The cover of the report is shown in Fig. 1. In the Abstract of M. L. 502 Jaynes identified the work as an examination of the relation between quantum electrodynamics and the semiclassical theory of radiation. M. L. 502 was intended to serve as a preliminary step in a study of the ultimate limitations on noise figure and frequency stability in molecular-beam masers. The Abstract says, among other things, that “the semiclassical theory, as extended here, is a far more reliable means of calculating radiation processes than usually supposed.” In the present author's view, M. L. 502 reported the first examination of dynamical questions that are now associated with the field of cavity quantum electrodynamics.
We discuss some implications of the description of spontaneous emission of radiation which has been offered by Jaynes and his collaborators in their "neoclassical" extension of semiclassical electrodynamics. In particular, we examine the thermal-equilibrium condition of radiation interacting with a tenuous gas of atoms. We argue that rate equations may be used to describe the interaction of such atoms with the chaotic thermal radiation field. For this situation the neoclassical spontaneous emission rate is incompatible with the well-secured laws of Boltzmann and Planck. Experimental evidence bearing on the accuracy of those laws as well as on the accepted level population dependence of the induced emission rate is reviewed.
The neoclassical theory of the interaction of radiation with matter, introduced by its authors as a potentially viable alternative to quantum electrodynamics, is examined in the case of a multilevel atom interacting with blackbody radiation. The stationary statistical states of the atom and the field are derived, and two independently untenable results emerge. First, the stationary blackbody law turns out to be that of Rayleigh and Jeans, rather than that of Planck. Second, the mean energy of a harmonic oscillator, which interacts with the field only near a single frequency, turns out to be infinite. These results are discussed in the light of the neoclassical description of spontaneous emission.