Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Validity of the shape-independent approximation for Bose-Einstein condensates

Brett D. Esry, Chris H. Greene

Published Aug 1, 1999• 76 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The validity of the shape-independent approximation is studied for three trapped atoms. By comparing the total ground-state energy calculated using pseudopotentials in the Hartree-Fock approximation to the exact ground-state energy, the shape-independent approximation is shown to agree quantitatively only in the low-density limit. It is also shown using configuration interaction that a Dirac $\ensuremath{\delta}$ function is not suitable as a replacement for the two-body interaction in exact theories.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.60.1451

Related papers

Shape-independent approximation for Bose-Einstein condensates interacting through a van der Waals potential

Barnali Chakrabarti, Tapan Kumar Das

We study the properties of Bose-Einstein condensates with the realistic van der Waals two-body interaction for large numbers of trapped atoms, solving the many-body Schr\"odinger equation by the potential harmonic expansion method. The effect of different ${C}_{6}$ parameters has been critically examined, starting from very few to 14 000 atoms to analyze and justify the idea of a shape-independent approximation. It is found that the condensate properties almost remain unchanged when the number of atoms are quite small $(\ensuremath{\sim}100)$, in good agreement with earlier results of Blume and Greene [Phys. Rev. A 63, 063601 (2001)], but we observe the appreciable effect of a long attractive tail when $N$ is large, even in the low-density limit. The above reference considered only 20 atoms which is far from a real experimental situation. Our calculation gives a realistic scenario which justifies the use of a shape-dependent two-body interaction in many-body theories.

Physical Review A•Dec 16, 2008•27 citations

Hartree-Fock theory for Bose-Einstein condensates and the inclusion of correlation effects

Brett D. Esry

I specialize the Hartree-Fock, random-phase, and configuration-interaction approximations to a system of interacting bosons in an external potential. This approach affords a more direct connection to the methods and language of atomic-structure calculations. The derivations and equations parallel those found in atomic structure and are contrasted with the more commonly used Bogoliubov approach for bosons. I present a numerical method for solving the Hartree-Fock and random-phase equations to obtain the low-lying excitation energies for trapped alkali-metal atoms.

Physical Review A•Feb 1, 1997•112 citations

Beyond mean-field ground-state energies and correlation properties of a trapped Bose-Einstein condensate

S. A. Sofianos, Tapan Kumar Das, Barnali Chakrabarti +3 more

A two-body correlated basis set is used to develop a many-body theory which is valid for any number of bosons in the trap. The formalism incorporates the van der Waals interaction and two-body correlations in an exact way. The theory has successfully been applied to Bose-Einstein condensates---dilute weakly interacting and also dilute but having a large scattering length. Even in the extreme dilute condition, we observe the breakdown of the shape-independent approximation and the interatomic correlation plays an important role in the large particle-number limit. This correlated many-body calculation can handle, within the two-body correlation approximation, the entire range of atom number of experimentally achieved condensates. Next we successfully push the basis function for large scattering lengths where the mean-field results are manifestly bad. The sharp increase in correlation energy clearly shows the beyond-mean-field effect. We also calculate one-particle densities for various scattering lengths and particle numbers. Our many-body calculation exhibits the finite-size effect in the one-body density.

Physical Review A•Jan 9, 2013•14 citations

Extension of the Thomas-Fermi approximation for trapped Bose-Einstein condensates with an arbitrary number of atoms

Antonio Muñoz Mateo, V. Delgado

By incorporating the zero-point energy contribution we derive simple and accurate extensions of the usual Thomas-Fermi (TF) expressions for the ground-state properties of trapped Bose-Einstein condensates that remain valid for an arbitrary number of atoms in the mean-field regime. Specifically, we obtain approximate analytical expressions for the ground-state properties of spherical, cigar-shaped, and disk-shaped condensates that reduce to the correct analytical formulas in both the TF and the perturbative regimes, and remain valid and accurate in between these two limiting cases. Mean-field quasi-one-dimensional (quasi-1D) and -2D condensates appear as simple particular cases of our formulation. The validity of our results is corroborated by an independent numerical computation based on the 3D Gross-Pitaevskii equation.

arXiv:cond-mat/0701695•Physical Review A•Dec 20, 2006•28 citations

Comparison of gapless mean-field theories for trapped Bose-Einstein condensates

Nick P. Proukakis, S. A. Morgan, Seok Jin Choi +1 more

We present two gapless mean-field theories for trapped Bose-Einstein condensates, and compare them to the better known Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov (HFB)-Popov approach. The proposed theories are based on suitable inclusion of the simplest anomalous average of the Bose field operator. This leads to an effective interaction between two atoms which is both temperature and density dependent, as opposed to the HFB-Popov approach, for which it is constant. These theories are compared to the HFB-Popov approach for a trapped one-dimensional condensate of 2000 atoms. The density profiles and excitation frequencies of the proposed theories differ from the corresponding HFB-Popov ones by at most a few percent.

Physical Review A•Sep 1, 1998•57 citations

Bose-Einstein condensates of bosonic Thomson atoms

Tobias Schneider, R. Blümel

A system of charged particles in a harmonic trap is a realization of Thomson's raisin cake model. Therefore, we call it a Thomson atom. Bosonic, fermionic and mixed Thomson atoms exist. In this paper we focus on bosonic Thomson atoms in isotropic traps. Approximating the exact ground state by a condensate we investigate ground-state properties at temperature T = 0 using the Hartree-Fock theory for bosons. In order to assess the quality of our mean-field approach we compare the Hartree-Fock results for bosonic Thomson helium with an exact diagonalization. In contrast to the weakly interacting Bose gas (alkali vapours) mean-field calculations are reliable in the limit of large particle density. The Wigner regime (low particle density) is discussed.

Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Oct 14, 1999•10 citations
The validity of the shape-independent approximation is studied for three trapped atoms. By comparing the total ground-state energy calculated using pseudopotentials in the Hartree-Fock approximation to the exact ground-state energy, the shape-independent approximation is shown to agree quantitatively only in the low-density limit. It is also shown using configuration interaction that a Dirac \ensuremathδ\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremathδ function is not suitable as a replacement for the two-body interaction in exact theories.
We study the properties of Bose-Einstein condensates with the realistic van der Waals two-body interaction for large numbers of trapped atoms, solving the many-body Schr\"odinger equation by the potential harmonic expansion method. The effect of different C6{C}_{6}C6​ parameters has been critically examined, starting from very few to 14 000 atoms to analyze and justify the idea of a shape-independent approximation. It is found that the condensate properties almost remain unchanged when the number of atoms are quite small $(\ensuremath{\sim}100)$, in good agreement with earlier results of Blume and Greene [Phys. Rev. A 63, 063601 (2001)], but we observe the appreciable effect of a long attractive tail when NNN is large, even in the low-density limit. The above reference considered only 20 atoms which is far from a real experimental situation. Our calculation gives a realistic scenario which justifies the use of a shape-dependent two-body interaction in many-body theories.
I specialize the Hartree-Fock, random-phase, and configuration-interaction approximations to a system of interacting bosons in an external potential. This approach affords a more direct connection to the methods and language of atomic-structure calculations. The derivations and equations parallel those found in atomic structure and are contrasted with the more commonly used Bogoliubov approach for bosons. I present a numerical method for solving the Hartree-Fock and random-phase equations to obtain the low-lying excitation energies for trapped alkali-metal atoms.
A two-body correlated basis set is used to develop a many-body theory which is valid for any number of bosons in the trap. The formalism incorporates the van der Waals interaction and two-body correlations in an exact way. The theory has successfully been applied to Bose-Einstein condensates---dilute weakly interacting and also dilute but having a large scattering length. Even in the extreme dilute condition, we observe the breakdown of the shape-independent approximation and the interatomic correlation plays an important role in the large particle-number limit. This correlated many-body calculation can handle, within the two-body correlation approximation, the entire range of atom number of experimentally achieved condensates. Next we successfully push the basis function for large scattering lengths where the mean-field results are manifestly bad. The sharp increase in correlation energy clearly shows the beyond-mean-field effect. We also calculate one-particle densities for various scattering lengths and particle numbers. Our many-body calculation exhibits the finite-size effect in the one-body density.
By incorporating the zero-point energy contribution we derive simple and accurate extensions of the usual Thomas-Fermi (TF) expressions for the ground-state properties of trapped Bose-Einstein condensates that remain valid for an arbitrary number of atoms in the mean-field regime. Specifically, we obtain approximate analytical expressions for the ground-state properties of spherical, cigar-shaped, and disk-shaped condensates that reduce to the correct analytical formulas in both the TF and the perturbative regimes, and remain valid and accurate in between these two limiting cases. Mean-field quasi-one-dimensional (quasi-1D) and -2D condensates appear as simple particular cases of our formulation. The validity of our results is corroborated by an independent numerical computation based on the 3D Gross-Pitaevskii equation.
We present two gapless mean-field theories for trapped Bose-Einstein condensates, and compare them to the better known Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov (HFB)-Popov approach. The proposed theories are based on suitable inclusion of the simplest anomalous average of the Bose field operator. This leads to an effective interaction between two atoms which is both temperature and density dependent, as opposed to the HFB-Popov approach, for which it is constant. These theories are compared to the HFB-Popov approach for a trapped one-dimensional condensate of 2000 atoms. The density profiles and excitation frequencies of the proposed theories differ from the corresponding HFB-Popov ones by at most a few percent.
A system of charged particles in a harmonic trap is a realization of Thomson's raisin cake model. Therefore, we call it a Thomson atom. Bosonic, fermionic and mixed Thomson atoms exist. In this paper we focus on bosonic Thomson atoms in isotropic traps. Approximating the exact ground state by a condensate we investigate ground-state properties at temperature T = 0 using the Hartree-Fock theory for bosons. In order to assess the quality of our mean-field approach we compare the Hartree-Fock results for bosonic Thomson helium with an exact diagonalization. In contrast to the weakly interacting Bose gas (alkali vapours) mean-field calculations are reliable in the limit of large particle density. The Wigner regime (low particle density) is discussed.