Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

Re-examining the value of old quantization and the Bohr atom approach

Todd S. Garon, Nelia Mann, Ellen M. McManis

Published Jan 22, 2013• 6 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We use old quantization to predict features of the energy spectrum for bound states in spherically symmetric potentials. We review the application of this method to simple quantum mechanical systems with known analytic results and show that old quantization, while not generally capable of predicting the exact quantum-mechanical spectrum, does consistently give useful information. We then apply the method to a logarithmic potential and compare the results with a numerically calculated spectrum. Finally, we use these techniques to predict the number of bound states in the Yukawa potential and again compare the results with those obtained numerically. In all cases old quantization provides good predictive power for the main features of the true quantum-mechanical problem, and thus can serve as a “back-of-the-envelope” technique for providing rough, qualitative information about the system.

DOI
10.1119/1.4769785

Related papers

Semi-classical methods, angular momentum, and non-analytic problems

Nelia Mann, Jessica Matli, T. M. Pham

Abstract We explore the semi-classical Sommerfeld method of quantization as applied to states with nonzero angular momentum, and show that it leads to qualitatively and quantitatively useful information about systems with spherically symmetric potentials. We begin by reviewing the traditional application of this model to hydrogen, and discuss the way Einstein–Brillouin–Keller (EBK) quantization resolves a mismatch between Sommerfeld states and true quantum mechanical states. We then analyze systems with logarithmic and Yukawa potentials, and compare the results of Sommerfeld and EBK quantization to those from solving Schrödinger’s equation. We show that the semi-classical quantization techniques provide insight into the spread of energy levels associated with a given principle quantum number, as well as giving quantitatively accurate approximations for the energies. We also argue that analyzing systems in this manner involves an interesting application of numerical methods, as well as providing insight into the connections between classical and quantum mechanical physics.

arXiv:2009.01014•European Journal of Physics•Jan 14, 2021•3 citations

Quantization rules for bound states in quantum wells

M. A. F. Gomes, Sadhan K. Adhikari

An algebraic reformulation of the Bohr - Sommerfeld (BS) quantization rule is suggested and applied to the study of bound states in one-dimensional quantum wells. The energies obtained with the present quantization rule are compared to those obtained with the usual BS and WKB quantization rules and with the exact solution of the Schrödinger equation. We find that, in diverse cases of physical interest in molecular physics, the present quantization rule not only yields a good approximation to the exact solution of the Schrödinger equation, but yields more precise energies than those obtained with the usual BS and/or WKB quantization rules. Among the examples considered numerically are the Poeschl - Teller potential and several anharmonic oscillator potentials, which simulate molecular vibrational spectra and the problem of an isolated quantum well structure subject to an external electric field.

Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Dec 28, 1997•7 citations

Naïve Bohr-type quantization for power-law potentials

Jacob Katriel

The naïve Bohr quantization condition mvr=nℏ is applied to arbitrary spherically symmetric power-law potentials. The dependence of the energy eigenvalues on the principal quantum number n agrees with fully quantum mechanical results either exactly (for the hydrogen atom, the harmonic oscillator, and the infinite square well) or asymptotically (the linear potential). This naïve treatment can be used in precalculus, high-school, or “quantum theory for poets” expositions.

American Journal of Physics•May 21, 2021•0 citations

General solution of the Schrödinger equation with potential field quantization

Hasan Hüseyin Erbil

A simple procedure has been found for the general solution of the time-independent Schrödinger equation (SE) with the help of quantization of potential area in one dimension without making any approximation. Energy values are not dependent on wave functions. So, to find the energy values, it is enough to find the classic turning points of the potential function. Two different solutions were obtained, namely, symmetric and antisymmetric in bound states. These normalized wave functions are always periodic. It is enough to take the integral of the square root of the potential energy function to find the normalized wave functions. If these calculations cannot be made analytically, they should then be performed by numerical methods. The SE has been solved for a particle in many one-dimension and the spherical symmetric central potential wells as examples. Their energies and normalized wave functions were found as examples. These solutions were also applied to the theories of scattering and alpha decay. The results obtained with the experimental values were compared with the calculated values. One was seen to be very fit.

arXiv:1712.00610•TURKISH JOURNAL OF PHYSICS•Oct 12, 2018•2 citations

Auxiliary fields as a tool for computing analytical solutions of the Schrödinger equation

BERNARD SILVESTRE-BRAC, Claude Semay, Fabien Buisseret

We propose a new method to obtain approximate solutions for the Schrödinger equation with an arbitrary potential that possesses bound states. This method, relying on the auxiliary field technique, allows to find in many cases, analytical solutions. It offers a convenient way to study the qualitative features of the energy spectrum of bound states in any potential. In particular, we illustrate our method by solving the case of central potentials with power-law form and with logarithmic form. For these types of potentials, we propose very accurate analytical energy formulae which greatly improves the corresponding formulae that can be found in the literature.

arXiv:0802.3601•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jun 12, 2008•22 citations

General solution of the Schrödinger Equation with Potential Field Quantization and Some Applications

Hasan Hüseyin Erbil

A simple procedure has been found for the general solution of the time-independent Schrödinger Equation (SE) with the help of quantization of potential area in one dimension without making any approximation.Energy values are not dependent on wave functions. So, to find the energy values, it is enough to find the classic turning points of the potential function. Two different solutions were obtained, namely, symmetric and anti symmetric in bound states. These normalized wave functions are always periodic. It is enough to take the integral of the square root of the potential energy function to find the normalized wave functions. If these calculations cannot be made analytically, they should then be performed by numerical methods. The SE has been solved for a particle in many one-dimension and the spherical symmetric central potential well, the relativistic theory of Dirac as examples.

Global Journal of Human Social Science•Apr 19, 2019•0 citations
We use old quantization to predict features of the energy spectrum for bound states in spherically symmetric potentials. We review the application of this method to simple quantum mechanical systems with known analytic results and show that old quantization, while not generally capable of predicting the exact quantum-mechanical spectrum, does consistently give useful information. We then apply the method to a logarithmic potential and compare the results with a numerically calculated spectrum. Finally, we use these techniques to predict the number of bound states in the Yukawa potential and again compare the results with those obtained numerically. In all cases old quantization provides good predictive power for the main features of the true quantum-mechanical problem, and thus can serve as a “back-of-the-envelope” technique for providing rough, qualitative information about the system.
Abstract We explore the semi-classical Sommerfeld method of quantization as applied to states with nonzero angular momentum, and show that it leads to qualitatively and quantitatively useful information about systems with spherically symmetric potentials. We begin by reviewing the traditional application of this model to hydrogen, and discuss the way Einstein–Brillouin–Keller (EBK) quantization resolves a mismatch between Sommerfeld states and true quantum mechanical states. We then analyze systems with logarithmic and Yukawa potentials, and compare the results of Sommerfeld and EBK quantization to those from solving Schrödinger’s equation. We show that the semi-classical quantization techniques provide insight into the spread of energy levels associated with a given principle quantum number, as well as giving quantitatively accurate approximations for the energies. We also argue that analyzing systems in this manner involves an interesting application of numerical methods, as well as providing insight into the connections between classical and quantum mechanical physics.
An algebraic reformulation of the Bohr - Sommerfeld (BS) quantization rule is suggested and applied to the study of bound states in one-dimensional quantum wells. The energies obtained with the present quantization rule are compared to those obtained with the usual BS and WKB quantization rules and with the exact solution of the Schrödinger equation. We find that, in diverse cases of physical interest in molecular physics, the present quantization rule not only yields a good approximation to the exact solution of the Schrödinger equation, but yields more precise energies than those obtained with the usual BS and/or WKB quantization rules. Among the examples considered numerically are the Poeschl - Teller potential and several anharmonic oscillator potentials, which simulate molecular vibrational spectra and the problem of an isolated quantum well structure subject to an external electric field.
A simple procedure has been found for the general solution of the time-independent Schrödinger equation (SE) with the help of quantization of potential area in one dimension without making any approximation. Energy values are not dependent on wave functions. So, to find the energy values, it is enough to find the classic turning points of the potential function. Two different solutions were obtained, namely, symmetric and antisymmetric in bound states. These normalized wave functions are always periodic. It is enough to take the integral of the square root of the potential energy function to find the normalized wave functions. If these calculations cannot be made analytically, they should then be performed by numerical methods. The SE has been solved for a particle in many one-dimension and the spherical symmetric central potential wells as examples. Their energies and normalized wave functions were found as examples. These solutions were also applied to the theories of scattering and alpha decay. The results obtained with the experimental values were compared with the calculated values. One was seen to be very fit.
We propose a new method to obtain approximate solutions for the Schrödinger equation with an arbitrary potential that possesses bound states. This method, relying on the auxiliary field technique, allows to find in many cases, analytical solutions. It offers a convenient way to study the qualitative features of the energy spectrum of bound states in any potential. In particular, we illustrate our method by solving the case of central potentials with power-law form and with logarithmic form. For these types of potentials, we propose very accurate analytical energy formulae which greatly improves the corresponding formulae that can be found in the literature.
A simple procedure has been found for the general solution of the time-independent Schrödinger Equation (SE) with the help of quantization of potential area in one dimension without making any approximation.Energy values are not dependent on wave functions. So, to find the energy values, it is enough to find the classic turning points of the potential function. Two different solutions were obtained, namely, symmetric and anti symmetric in bound states. These normalized wave functions are always periodic. It is enough to take the integral of the square root of the potential energy function to find the normalized wave functions. If these calculations cannot be made analytically, they should then be performed by numerical methods. The SE has been solved for a particle in many one-dimension and the spherical symmetric central potential well, the relativistic theory of Dirac as examples.