The lower-bound variational renormalization-group approximation of Kadanoff is reformulated and applied to the triangular Ising lattice. The basic inconsistencies inherent in the method are removed and the results thus obtained are in fair agreement with the exact values.
The use of variational approximations in the study and application of renormalization groups is discussed. In particular, a simple approximation is derived which yields an upper bound to the free energy of Ising models on d-dimensional lattices. The optimal transformation, which yields the least upper bound, is determined analytically. The criterion proposed by Kadanoff (1975) to determine the 'best' approximation to the fixed point is found to fail in this case. The reasons for this failure and several of the basic problems posed by variational approximations are discussed.
From a consideration of the ground states of the antiferromagnetic Ising model a weighting function is proposed. This function preserves the ground states under the renormalisation group transformation. This form of the lower bound approximation leads to results which are in excellent agreement with the exact values in two dimensions and in fair agreement with the approximate results of the series expansion in three dimensions. The implication of this approach for other real-space approximations is noted.
The renormalisation group method of Kadanoff is applied to the spin- 1 / 2 Ising model in two dimensions using a transformation applicable to both the square and triangular lattices. Two types of cluster are studied for the triangular lattice.The first cluster yields a new fixed point but the results for the critical temperature and critical exponents are in poor agreement with the known exact values. The second cluster maps directly onto the fixed point found by Kadanoff for the square lattice yielding excellent values for both the critical exponents and the critical temperature.