Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Validity and significance of time-dependent Hartree approximation for a one-dimensional system of bosons with attractive δ -function interactions

Abraham Klein, Franz R. Krejs

Published Oct 1, 1978• 4 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The Hartree (mean-field) approximation to the description of the scattering of two heavy bound states is studied in a model consisting of bosons with attractive $\ensuremath{\delta}$-function interactions. The approximation is derived from matrix elements of the Heisenberg equations of motion of the system and requires careful enumeration of all necessary approximations. The arguments made are verified by comparison of exact and approximate scattering amplitudes. The derivation also yields the physical significance of the amplitude which satisfies the Hartree approximation; it is a Fourier sum over amplitudes for different channels, which can in prinicple be recovered individually. The approach is not restricted to the model studied.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.18.1343

Related papers

Time-dependent Hartree approximation for a one-dimensional system of bosons with attractive δ -function interactions

B. Yoon, John W. Negele

The time-dependent Hartree approximation is compared with an exact solution for the scattering between two $N$-particle bound states in the case of a 1-dimensional system of bosons with attractive $\ensuremath{\delta}$-function interactions. It is shown that to leading order in $N$, the approximation is exact, and arguments are presented relating this asymptotic agreement to the nonsaturation of the bound states.

Physical Review A•Oct 1, 1977•70 citations

Time-dependent mean-field theory and quantized bound states

Shimon Levit, John W. Negele, Zvi Paltiel

A theory is presented in which approximations to quantum observables are obtained by applying the stationary-phase approximation to an exact functional integral representation of the many-body evolution operator. The requirement that the leading correction to the stationary-phase approximation vanish leads to a time-dependent Hartree-Fock mean field. Application of the theory to the Fourier transform of the trace of the evolution operator and the study of its poles yields quantized bound states with large amplitude. The theory is shown to reproduce the familiar static Hartree-Fock and random-phase approximations in the appropriate limits and yields an excellent approximation to the entire spectrum of the exactly solvable Lipkin model.NUCLEAR STRUCTURE Derivation of time-dependent mean-field theory from functional integral representation. Quantum theory of large amplitude collective motion. Application to Lipkin model.

Physical Review C•Apr 1, 1980•79 citations

An exactly soluble Hartree problem in an external potential

J.C. Gunn, J M F Gunn

The problem of N bosons interacting with each other via repulsive delta-function interactions and with an external, attractive, delta-function potential is solved, within the Hartree approximation, exactly. If the interparticle interactions are above a certain value, there is no bound state. Thus the bound state does not just expand to compensate for the increase in the repulsive Hartree potential. Moreover as the interaction strength is increased to that value, the ground-state wavefunction develops a pole at the position of the attractive potential.

European Journal of Physics•Jan 1, 1988•11 citations

Time-dependent mean-field approximation for nuclear dynamical problems

Shimon Levit

A general method for a microscopic description of nuclear dynamical problems is discussed. The method is based on a functional integral representation for the many-body time evolution operator $U({t}_{f},{t}_{i})$. In the stationary phase limit, a time-dependent mean-field approximation for the matrix elements of $U$ is obtained. Using standard procedures this allows for extraction of quantum mechanical information about bound states, tunneling, or scattering phenomena in a many-nucleon system. The approximation represents a natural generalization of the time-dependent Hartree-Fock method.NUCLEAR STRUCTURE, NUCLEAR REACTIONS derived mean-field approximation for matrix elements of $\mathrm{exp}(\ensuremath{-}iHt)$ from exact functional integral; discussed relation to static HF, TDHF, and scattering calculations.

Physical Review C•Apr 1, 1980•64 citations

Failure of the mean-field Hartree approximation for a bosonic many-body system with non-Hermitian Hamiltonian

Matias Ginzburg, Simone Rademacher, Giacomo De Palma

Mean-field Hartree theory is a central tool for reducing many-body dynamics to an effective one-particle evolution. This approximation has been employed when the Hamiltonian governing the many-body dynamics is not Hermitian. Indeed, non-Hermitian Hamiltonians model particle gain/loss or the evolution of open quantum systems between consecutive quantum jumps. Furthermore, the validity of the Hartree approximation for generic non-Hermitian Hamiltonians lies at the basis of a quantum algorithm for nonlinear differential equations. In this work, we show that this approximation can fail. First, we consider the most general bosonic mean-field Hamiltonian with two-body interactions and we prove that, for non-Hermitian Hamiltonian, the Hartree equation does not capture the correct second time derivative of the one-particle marginal state at $t=0$ in the thermodynamic limit. Then, we analytically solve a model of $N$ bosonic qubits with a purely anti-Hermitian Hamiltonian, compute the limit for $N\to\infty$ of the one-particle marginal state and show that it does not agree with the solution of the non-Hermitian Hartree equation. We further show that there exists an initial condition such that the exact one-particle marginal state undergoes a finite-time transition to a mixed state, a phenomenon that is completely absent in the case of Hermitian Hamiltonians. Finally, we simulate a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian with real spectrum and show that, also in this case, there are initial conditions for which the Hartree equation does not reproduce the correct one-particle marginal state in the limit $N\to\infty$. Our findings challenge the validity of the mean-field Hartree approximation for non-Hermitian Hamiltonians, and call for additional conditions for the validity of the mean-field regime to model the dynamics of particle gain and loss and the open-system dynamics in bosonic many-body systems.

quant-pharXiv:2601.13038•Quantum•Jan 20, 2026•1 citation

Calculation of the propagation amplitude in the case of a Coulomb interaction via time-independent mean-field theory

Rabia Yekken, Feriel Mekideche

The exact study of many-body microscopic systems is impossible when the number of particles is large (N ≥ 3). Approximate methods are then used. The time-independent mean-field (TIMF) approximation has been proposed for the description of collisions in many-body systems. Collision amplitudes are derived by the use of a variational principle and the choice of trial functions as products of single-particle orbitals. Resulting mean-field equations with a nonvanishing right-hand side turn out to be a generalization of the traditional Hartree or Hatree–Fock type equations. These TIMF equations are successfully solved numerically for the case of short-range forces. In this paper, we test the validity of this theory for the Coulomb interaction between two particles, that is, a long-range interaction. A numerical comparison between the exact and the mean-field solutions is conducted PACS Nos.: 31.15.Ne, 31.15.Pf, 21.45.+v,25.10.-i

Canadian Journal of Physics•Jul 1, 2007•0 citations
The Hartree (mean-field) approximation to the description of the scattering of two heavy bound states is studied in a model consisting of bosons with attractive \ensuremathδ\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremathδ-function interactions. The approximation is derived from matrix elements of the Heisenberg equations of motion of the system and requires careful enumeration of all necessary approximations. The arguments made are verified by comparison of exact and approximate scattering amplitudes. The derivation also yields the physical significance of the amplitude which satisfies the Hartree approximation; it is a Fourier sum over amplitudes for different channels, which can in prinicple be recovered individually. The approach is not restricted to the model studied.
The time-dependent Hartree approximation is compared with an exact solution for the scattering between two NNN-particle bound states in the case of a 1-dimensional system of bosons with attractive $\ensuremath{\delta}$-function interactions. It is shown that to leading order in NNN, the approximation is exact, and arguments are presented relating this asymptotic agreement to the nonsaturation of the bound states.
A theory is presented in which approximations to quantum observables are obtained by applying the stationary-phase approximation to an exact functional integral representation of the many-body evolution operator. The requirement that the leading correction to the stationary-phase approximation vanish leads to a time-dependent Hartree-Fock mean field. Application of the theory to the Fourier transform of the trace of the evolution operator and the study of its poles yields quantized bound states with large amplitude. The theory is shown to reproduce the familiar static Hartree-Fock and random-phase approximations in the appropriate limits and yields an excellent approximation to the entire spectrum of the exactly solvable Lipkin model.NUCLEAR STRUCTURE Derivation of time-dependent mean-field theory from functional integral representation. Quantum theory of large amplitude collective motion. Application to Lipkin model.
The problem of N bosons interacting with each other via repulsive delta-function interactions and with an external, attractive, delta-function potential is solved, within the Hartree approximation, exactly. If the interparticle interactions are above a certain value, there is no bound state. Thus the bound state does not just expand to compensate for the increase in the repulsive Hartree potential. Moreover as the interaction strength is increased to that value, the ground-state wavefunction develops a pole at the position of the attractive potential.
A general method for a microscopic description of nuclear dynamical problems is discussed. The method is based on a functional integral representation for the many-body time evolution operator U(tf,ti)U({t}_{f},{t}_{i})U(tf​,ti​). In the stationary phase limit, a time-dependent mean-field approximation for the matrix elements of UUU is obtained. Using standard procedures this allows for extraction of quantum mechanical information about bound states, tunneling, or scattering phenomena in a many-nucleon system. The approximation represents a natural generalization of the time-dependent Hartree-Fock method.NUCLEAR STRUCTURE, NUCLEAR REACTIONS derived mean-field approximation for matrix elements of $\mathrm{exp}(\ensuremath{-}iHt)$ from exact functional integral; discussed relation to static HF, TDHF, and scattering calculations.
Mean-field Hartree theory is a central tool for reducing many-body dynamics to an effective one-particle evolution. This approximation has been employed when the Hamiltonian governing the many-body dynamics is not Hermitian. Indeed, non-Hermitian Hamiltonians model particle gain/loss or the evolution of open quantum systems between consecutive quantum jumps. Furthermore, the validity of the Hartree approximation for generic non-Hermitian Hamiltonians lies at the basis of a quantum algorithm for nonlinear differential equations. In this work, we show that this approximation can fail. First, we consider the most general bosonic mean-field Hamiltonian with two-body interactions and we prove that, for non-Hermitian Hamiltonian, the Hartree equation does not capture the correct second time derivative of the one-particle marginal state at t=0t=0t=0 in the thermodynamic limit. Then, we analytically solve a model of NNN bosonic qubits with a purely anti-Hermitian Hamiltonian, compute the limit for N→∞N\to\inftyN→∞ of the one-particle marginal state and show that it does not agree with the solution of the non-Hermitian Hartree equation. We further show that there exists an initial condition such that the exact one-particle marginal state undergoes a finite-time transition to a mixed state, a phenomenon that is completely absent in the case of Hermitian Hamiltonians. Finally, we simulate a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian with real spectrum and show that, also in this case, there are initial conditions for which the Hartree equation does not reproduce the correct one-particle marginal state in the limit N→∞N\to\inftyN→∞. Our findings challenge the validity of the mean-field Hartree approximation for non-Hermitian Hamiltonians, and call for additional conditions for the validity of the mean-field regime to model the dynamics of particle gain and loss and the open-system dynamics in bosonic many-body systems.
The exact study of many-body microscopic systems is impossible when the number of particles is large (N ≥ 3). Approximate methods are then used. The time-independent mean-field (TIMF) approximation has been proposed for the description of collisions in many-body systems. Collision amplitudes are derived by the use of a variational principle and the choice of trial functions as products of single-particle orbitals. Resulting mean-field equations with a nonvanishing right-hand side turn out to be a generalization of the traditional Hartree or Hatree–Fock type equations. These TIMF equations are successfully solved numerically for the case of short-range forces. In this paper, we test the validity of this theory for the Coulomb interaction between two particles, that is, a long-range interaction. A numerical comparison between the exact and the mean-field solutions is conducted PACS Nos.: 31.15.Ne, 31.15.Pf, 21.45.+v,25.10.-i