Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

S Matrix and Causality Condition. II. Nonrelativistic Particles

N. G. van Kampen

Published Sep 1, 1953• 118 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The application of the "causality condition" to the $S$ matrix for nonrelativistic particles encounters several difficulties: (a) there is no maximum velocity; (b) the interference of ingoing and outgoing waves has to be taken into account; (c) wave packets with a sharp front do not exist. The condition is therefore reformulated as follows: At any time the total probability of finding the particle outside the scattering center shall not be greater than 1, for every form of the incident wave packet. From this follows for spherical waves that $S$, as a function of the momentum $p$, is analytic and holomorphic in the first quadrant and that ${e}^{2iap}S(p)$ (where $a$ is the radius of the scattering center) has an imaginary part \ensuremath{\leqslant} 1. That suffices to give an explicit integral representation and a product expansion for $S$, but these permit a more general form for $S$ than is usually envisaged. If, however, the usual symmetry relation $S(\ensuremath{-}p)=S{(p)}^{*}$ is assumed in addition to the causality condition, more specific equations can be derived, which are direct generalizations of those in Part I. In particular, integral relations between the real and imaginary parts of $S$, and the properties that Wigner found for the $R$ matrix can be deduced.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.91.1267

Related papers

Dispersion Relation for Nonrelativistic Particles

David Y. Wong

It is shown that if the wave function of a nonrelativistic particle satisfies the Schr\"odinger equation with a velocity-independent potential, then its scattering amplitudes (and the $S$ matrix in general) satisfy the same dispersion formulas as those derived for the scattering of light. In the present derivation, the validity of a perturbation expansion and certain integrability of the potential are assumed, and the requirement of the outgoing wave Green's function replaces the condition of strict causality for the scattering of light. The scattering amplitude for fixed momentum transfer is also shown to satisfy the dispersion relations. Together with the unitarity of the $S$ matrix, the complete $S$ matrix is determined by the Fourier transform of the potential through an iterative procedure using the dispersion relations. If the potential possesses bound states, then all the dispersion formulas are modified to include residue terms corresponding to singularities on the positive imaginary axis of the momentum plane. The necessity of these modifications is related to the divergence of the perturbation series for small wave numbers. Essential singularities of the $S$ matrix due to exponentially damped potentials give no additional contribution to the dispersion formulas.

Physical Review•Jul 1, 1957•10 citations

Causality in Nonrelativistic Quantum Scattering

H. M. Nussenzveig

A new formulation of the causality condition, in terms of the total wave function at a finite distance from the scatterer, is given. This condition is employed to derive all known analytic properties of the scattering amplitude in both variables (energy and scattering angle or momentum transfer) for a scatterer of finite radius. It is shown that all the assumptions are valid in the particular case of scattering by a local potential. The relations between causality, Wigner's inequality, and completeness are discussed.

Physical Review•Jan 25, 1969•12 citations

Causality and Analyticity in Formal Scattering Theory

Gerald N. Minerbo

The connection between causality and analyticity in scattering theory is formulated in terms of Hilbertspace concepts. The usual rules of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics are assumed to hold for the "in" and "out" states of the scattering system. We show that there is a (physically verifiable) causality condition which implies that each diagonal $S$-matrix element ${S}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\alpha}}(E)$ must be the limit of an analytic function of the energy $E$, regular in $\mathrm{Im}E>0$. The implications for partial-wave amplitudes and for the forward scattering amplitude in elastic two-body collisions are discussed.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Feb 15, 1971•6 citations

The relativistic quantum mechanics of the elementary particles

H. S. Green

The search for a theory of the elementary particles which is founded on the well-established principles of quantum mechanics and conforms at the same time with the requirements of the principle of relativity has, in recent years, taken several divergent directions. On the one hand, the second quantization of wave fields derived from a Lagrangian by a variational procedure(1) has succeeded in accounting for the existence and most of the properties of the electron, the photon, and the meson. On the other hand, many generalizations of the Dirac wave equation of the electron(2) have been attempted, with applications to the meson(3) and the proton(4). Heisenberg(5) has considered the much more difficult problem of the interaction between different particles, and has found that the key to the situation is the so-called ‘scattering matrix’, which is nothing other than a limiting form of the relativistic density matrix, as defined in § 2 of this paper. It seems probable that the relativistic density matrix ρ; or statistical operator, as it may be called without reference to representation, will play an important part in relativistic quantum mechanics in the future. It satisfies the same equation as the wave function, but differs from it in being a real linear operator, or a dynamical variable, in the terminology of Dirac.

Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society•Apr 1, 1949•5 citations

The Scattering Theory of the Schrödinger Equation

David Park

The Schrödinger equation for the scattered particle is converted into an integral equation, in which the kernel is obtained by the use of the condition that the events described by the solutions of the equation must be causally related, i.e., that causes must always precede the effects which they produce. The integral equation is iterated once, and it is found that its solution corresponds to the usual description of a scattering process in terms of an undeflected wave traversing the system plus a radially scattered wave moving outwards. In the second part, it is shown that a simple relation exists between solutions of Schrödinger's equation of the sort just described and the solution of the initial-value problem associated with the equation of motion for a free particle. By this means a solution of the scattering problem is set up which describes how the wave function develops as the wave which it describes propagates through the system. The series which results was first given by Feynman. As an example, the first Born approximation for the scattering problem is developed by each approach.

American Journal of Physics•May 1, 1952•1 citation

Scattering of Wave Packets

Eyvind H. Wichmann

The elastic scattering of spinless particles from a spherically symmetric stationary target is considered. The main idea is to describe the incident beam of particles as a certain statistical ensemble of one-particle wave packets, and to define the differential cross section in terms of the average scattering of the particles in this ensemble. The physical significance of this mode of description is discussed, and arguments are presented as to why it should be regarded as a realistic description of typical scattering experiments. The discussion is general, and not restricted to potential scattering. It is based on the notion of the S matrix, and the most basic ideas of the S matrix are discussed. A simple derivation of the partial wave expansion is given within the framework of S matrix theory. The aim of this paper is mainly pedagogical, and the final results obtained are old and well established.

American Journal of Physics•Jan 1, 1965•11 citations
The application of the "causality condition" to the SSS matrix for nonrelativistic particles encounters several difficulties: (a) there is no maximum velocity; (b) the interference of ingoing and outgoing waves has to be taken into account; (c) wave packets with a sharp front do not exist. The condition is therefore reformulated as follows: At any time the total probability of finding the particle outside the scattering center shall not be greater than 1, for every form of the incident wave packet. From this follows for spherical waves that SSS, as a function of the momentum ppp, is analytic and holomorphic in the first quadrant and that e2iapS(p){e}^{2iap}S(p)e2iapS(p) (where aaa is the radius of the scattering center) has an imaginary part \ensuremath{\leqslant} 1. That suffices to give an explicit integral representation and a product expansion for SSS, but these permit a more general form for SSS than is usually envisaged. If, however, the usual symmetry relation S(\ensuremath−p)=S(p)∗S(\ensuremath{-}p)=S{(p)}^{*}S(\ensuremath−p)=S(p)∗ is assumed in addition to the causality condition, more specific equations can be derived, which are direct generalizations of those in Part I. In particular, integral relations between the real and imaginary parts of SSS, and the properties that Wigner found for the RRR matrix can be deduced.
It is shown that if the wave function of a nonrelativistic particle satisfies the Schr\"odinger equation with a velocity-independent potential, then its scattering amplitudes (and the SSS matrix in general) satisfy the same dispersion formulas as those derived for the scattering of light. In the present derivation, the validity of a perturbation expansion and certain integrability of the potential are assumed, and the requirement of the outgoing wave Green's function replaces the condition of strict causality for the scattering of light. The scattering amplitude for fixed momentum transfer is also shown to satisfy the dispersion relations. Together with the unitarity of the SSS matrix, the complete SSS matrix is determined by the Fourier transform of the potential through an iterative procedure using the dispersion relations. If the potential possesses bound states, then all the dispersion formulas are modified to include residue terms corresponding to singularities on the positive imaginary axis of the momentum plane. The necessity of these modifications is related to the divergence of the perturbation series for small wave numbers. Essential singularities of the SSS matrix due to exponentially damped potentials give no additional contribution to the dispersion formulas.
A new formulation of the causality condition, in terms of the total wave function at a finite distance from the scatterer, is given. This condition is employed to derive all known analytic properties of the scattering amplitude in both variables (energy and scattering angle or momentum transfer) for a scatterer of finite radius. It is shown that all the assumptions are valid in the particular case of scattering by a local potential. The relations between causality, Wigner's inequality, and completeness are discussed.
The connection between causality and analyticity in scattering theory is formulated in terms of Hilbertspace concepts. The usual rules of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics are assumed to hold for the "in" and "out" states of the scattering system. We show that there is a (physically verifiable) causality condition which implies that each diagonal SSS-matrix element ${S}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\alpha}}(E)$ must be the limit of an analytic function of the energy EEE, regular in ImE>0\mathrm{Im}E>0ImE>0. The implications for partial-wave amplitudes and for the forward scattering amplitude in elastic two-body collisions are discussed.
The search for a theory of the elementary particles which is founded on the well-established principles of quantum mechanics and conforms at the same time with the requirements of the principle of relativity has, in recent years, taken several divergent directions. On the one hand, the second quantization of wave fields derived from a Lagrangian by a variational procedure(1) has succeeded in accounting for the existence and most of the properties of the electron, the photon, and the meson. On the other hand, many generalizations of the Dirac wave equation of the electron(2) have been attempted, with applications to the meson(3) and the proton(4). Heisenberg(5) has considered the much more difficult problem of the interaction between different particles, and has found that the key to the situation is the so-called ‘scattering matrix’, which is nothing other than a limiting form of the relativistic density matrix, as defined in § 2 of this paper. It seems probable that the relativistic density matrix ρ; or statistical operator, as it may be called without reference to representation, will play an important part in relativistic quantum mechanics in the future. It satisfies the same equation as the wave function, but differs from it in being a real linear operator, or a dynamical variable, in the terminology of Dirac.
The Schrödinger equation for the scattered particle is converted into an integral equation, in which the kernel is obtained by the use of the condition that the events described by the solutions of the equation must be causally related, i.e., that causes must always precede the effects which they produce. The integral equation is iterated once, and it is found that its solution corresponds to the usual description of a scattering process in terms of an undeflected wave traversing the system plus a radially scattered wave moving outwards. In the second part, it is shown that a simple relation exists between solutions of Schrödinger's equation of the sort just described and the solution of the initial-value problem associated with the equation of motion for a free particle. By this means a solution of the scattering problem is set up which describes how the wave function develops as the wave which it describes propagates through the system. The series which results was first given by Feynman. As an example, the first Born approximation for the scattering problem is developed by each approach.
The elastic scattering of spinless particles from a spherically symmetric stationary target is considered. The main idea is to describe the incident beam of particles as a certain statistical ensemble of one-particle wave packets, and to define the differential cross section in terms of the average scattering of the particles in this ensemble. The physical significance of this mode of description is discussed, and arguments are presented as to why it should be regarded as a realistic description of typical scattering experiments. The discussion is general, and not restricted to potential scattering. It is based on the notion of the S matrix, and the most basic ideas of the S matrix are discussed. A simple derivation of the partial wave expansion is given within the framework of S matrix theory. The aim of this paper is mainly pedagogical, and the final results obtained are old and well established.