Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Philosophy of Science

Quantum Mechanics and Interpretations of Probability Theory

Neal Grossman

Published Dec 1, 1972• 6 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Several philosophers of science have claimed that the conceptual difficulties of quantum mechanics can be resolved by appealing to a particular interpretation of probability theory. For example, Popper bases his treatment of quantum mechanics on the propensity interpretation of probability, and Margenau bases his treatment of quantum mechanics on the frequency interpretation of probability. The purpose of this paper is (i) to consider and reject such claims, and (ii) to discuss the question of whether the ψ-function refers to an individual system or to an ensemble of systems.

DOI
10.1086/288467

Related papers

Popperの傾向性解釈 : その欠点と現代的意義

友也 高村, Tomoya Takamura

The propensity interpretation of probability is introduced faithfully with Popper's original description. It is shown that the propensity interpretation itself has little to do with the central problem of quantum mechanics. Nevertheless, some insights of Popper seem to have meanings in modern interpretations of quantum mechanics. Especially, the relation to stochastic mechanics and stochastic interpretation of quantum mechanics is considered. Many respects of the propensity interpretation are on Popper's intention or almost accidentally same with the stochastic interpretation when the stochasticity is considered to be objective. We give also some details to be supplemented for the realistic interpretation of quantum mechanics by means of the stochastic interpretation, most of which are neglected in Popper's consideration.

•Jan 1, 2009•0 citations

A short report on a probability-based interpretation of quantum mechanics

Paolo Rocchi

Abstract This study calls attention to the current state of the probability ( P ) domain which presents weak points at the mathematical level and more significant flaws at the application level. Popper noticed how fundamental issues raised in quantum mechanics (QM) directly derive from unresolved probabilistic questions. Endless philosophical debates create more problems than solutions, so the author of this research suggests going directly to the root of the issues and searching for the probability theory which formalizes the multifold nature of P . This study offers a brief overview of the structural theory of probability , recently published in a book, and applies it to QM in order to show its completeness. The whole probability-based interpretation of QM goes beyond the limits of a paper and these pages condense a few aspects of this theoretical scheme. The double slit experiment is used to corroborate the theorems presented here.

arXiv:2311.04233•Open Physics•Jan 1, 2024•1 citation

A New Enhanced Version of The Ensemble Interpretation

Raed M. Shaiia

The different interpretations of quantum mechanics yield the same experimental results, which may give the impression that the question of what interpretation is the true one, is a philosophical question, not a scientific one. But in this paper, we will see that we can actually prove one interpretation, in particular, a version of the ensemble interpretation, as the natural interpretation of quantum mechanics. Furthermore, we will prove the axioms of quantum mechanics, without the need of anything beyond probability theory.

arXiv:2003.05283•Mar 3, 2020•1 citation

Individual aspects of quantum measurements

Paul Busch, PEKKA J. LAHTI

The following two claims have been put forward in support of an individual interpretation of quantum mechanics: within the framework of quantum measurement theory, (i) the concept of measurement of a sharp observable can be completely characterized in terms of the notion of calibration, and (ii) the frequency interpretation of probability (of a measurement outcome) can be founded on the notion of a property of an individual system. Here we set out to generalize these results to measurement schemes which may be unitary or non-unitary and to object and pointer observables which may be sharp or unsharp.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Sep 21, 1996•5 citations

The Propensity Approach to Quantum Systems

Friedel Weinert

The purpose of this paper is to revisit a neglected understanding of quantum mechanics, the so-called propensity theory and to propose a amended version of it. According to this version, the causal-structural approach adopted here, a quantum system has a physical structure, consisting of relata (components, say electrons) and relations (determining the interrelations between the components). This structure is mathematically encoded in wave functions and forms the base, on which propensities supervene. This paper proposes that propensities or intrinsic dispositions supervene on the structural properties of the system. A propensity is a disposition of a quantum system to display selective aspects in response to an encounter with a measurement situation. The selective propensities manifest themselves as probabilities, in accordance with the application of the Born rule to respective wave functions.

•Dec 13, 2025•0 citations

Probability interpretation of quantum mechanics

Roger G. Newton

The paper draws attention to the frequency meaning of the probability concept and its implications for quantum mechanics. It emphasizes that the very meaning of probability implies the ensemble interpretation of both pure and mixed states. As a result some of the ’’paradoxical’’ aspects of quantum mechanics lose their counterintuitive character.

American Journal of Physics•Dec 1, 1980•23 citations
Several philosophers of science have claimed that the conceptual difficulties of quantum mechanics can be resolved by appealing to a particular interpretation of probability theory. For example, Popper bases his treatment of quantum mechanics on the propensity interpretation of probability, and Margenau bases his treatment of quantum mechanics on the frequency interpretation of probability. The purpose of this paper is (i) to consider and reject such claims, and (ii) to discuss the question of whether the ψ-function refers to an individual system or to an ensemble of systems.
The propensity interpretation of probability is introduced faithfully with Popper's original description. It is shown that the propensity interpretation itself has little to do with the central problem of quantum mechanics. Nevertheless, some insights of Popper seem to have meanings in modern interpretations of quantum mechanics. Especially, the relation to stochastic mechanics and stochastic interpretation of quantum mechanics is considered. Many respects of the propensity interpretation are on Popper's intention or almost accidentally same with the stochastic interpretation when the stochasticity is considered to be objective. We give also some details to be supplemented for the realistic interpretation of quantum mechanics by means of the stochastic interpretation, most of which are neglected in Popper's consideration.
Abstract This study calls attention to the current state of the probability ( P ) domain which presents weak points at the mathematical level and more significant flaws at the application level. Popper noticed how fundamental issues raised in quantum mechanics (QM) directly derive from unresolved probabilistic questions. Endless philosophical debates create more problems than solutions, so the author of this research suggests going directly to the root of the issues and searching for the probability theory which formalizes the multifold nature of P . This study offers a brief overview of the structural theory of probability , recently published in a book, and applies it to QM in order to show its completeness. The whole probability-based interpretation of QM goes beyond the limits of a paper and these pages condense a few aspects of this theoretical scheme. The double slit experiment is used to corroborate the theorems presented here.
The different interpretations of quantum mechanics yield the same experimental results, which may give the impression that the question of what interpretation is the true one, is a philosophical question, not a scientific one. But in this paper, we will see that we can actually prove one interpretation, in particular, a version of the ensemble interpretation, as the natural interpretation of quantum mechanics. Furthermore, we will prove the axioms of quantum mechanics, without the need of anything beyond probability theory.
The following two claims have been put forward in support of an individual interpretation of quantum mechanics: within the framework of quantum measurement theory, (i) the concept of measurement of a sharp observable can be completely characterized in terms of the notion of calibration, and (ii) the frequency interpretation of probability (of a measurement outcome) can be founded on the notion of a property of an individual system. Here we set out to generalize these results to measurement schemes which may be unitary or non-unitary and to object and pointer observables which may be sharp or unsharp.
The purpose of this paper is to revisit a neglected understanding of quantum mechanics, the so-called propensity theory and to propose a amended version of it. According to this version, the causal-structural approach adopted here, a quantum system has a physical structure, consisting of relata (components, say electrons) and relations (determining the interrelations between the components). This structure is mathematically encoded in wave functions and forms the base, on which propensities supervene. This paper proposes that propensities or intrinsic dispositions supervene on the structural properties of the system. A propensity is a disposition of a quantum system to display selective aspects in response to an encounter with a measurement situation. The selective propensities manifest themselves as probabilities, in accordance with the application of the Born rule to respective wave functions.