Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

Acceptable Solutions and Boundary Conditions for the Schrödinger and Dirac Equations

Baxter H. Armstrong, Edwin Albert Power

Published Apr 1, 1963• 16 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It is shown that the condition of finiteness at the origin, usually imposed on solutions to the nonrelativistic Schrödinger equation for the hydrogen atom (and some other systems) is not necessary. The quadratically integrable l = 0 “anomalous” solution which is usually excluded in this fashion is not a solution to the Schrödinger equation at the origin, and consequently does not need to be excluded by a boundary or other type condition. The relativistic generalization through the Dirac equation of this anomalous solution is not quadratically integrable. The solution generalized according to the relativistic Schrödinger equation is quadratically integrable and obeys the equation at the origin. Consequently, a boundary or other type condition may still be needed in a general relativistic theory.

DOI
10.1119/1.1969428

Related papers

Acceptable solutions of the radial Schrödinger equation for a particle in a central potential

J. Etxebarría

We revisit the discussion about the boundary condition at the origin in the Schrödinger radial equation for central potentials. We give a transparent and convincing reason for demanding the radial part R(r) of the wave function to be finite at r = 0, showing that if R(0) diverges the complete wave function ψ does not satisfy the full Schrödinger equation. If R(r) is singular, we show that the corresponding ψ follows an equation similar to Schrödinger's, but with an additional term involving the Dirac delta function or its derivatives at the origin. Although, in general, understanding some of our arguments requires certain knowledge of the theory of distributions, the important case of a behavior R ∝ 1/r near r = 0, which gives rise to a normalizable ψ, is especially simple: The origin of the Dirac delta term is clearly demonstrated by using a slight modification of the usual spherical coordinates. The argument can be easily followed by undergraduate physics students.

American Journal of Physics•Sep 21, 2023•0 citations

Dirac’s reduced radial equations and the problem of additional solutions

Anzor Khelashvili, Teimuraz Nadareishvili

We show that additional solutions must be ignored (in differences of the Schrödinger and Klein–Gordon equations) in the Dirac equation, where usually the second-order radial equation is passed, called the reduced equation, instead of a system. Analogously to the Schrödinger equation, in this process, the Dirac’s delta function appears, which was unnoted during the full history of quantum mechanics. This unphysical term we remove by a boundary condition at the origin. However, the distribution theory imposes on the radial function strong restriction and by this reason practically for all potentials, even regular, use of these reduced equations is not permissible. At the end, we include consideration in the framework of two-dimensional Dirac equation. We show that even here the additional solution does not survive as a result of usual physical requirements.

arXiv:1610.07936•International Journal of Modern Physics E•Jul 1, 2017•12 citations

On the appearance of a Dirac delta term at the origin in the Schroedinger radial equation

J. Etxebarria

We revisit a recent discussion about the boundary condition at the origin in the Schroedinger radial equation for central potentials. Using a slight modification of the usual spherical coordinates, the origin of a previously reported Dirac delta function term at the origin is clearly shown up. As a consequence, a vanishing boundary condition at the origin must be imposed in solving the radial equation, regardless the kind of potential.

arXiv:1305.2782•May 13, 2013•0 citations

On the singular solution of Schrödinger equation for the hydrogen atom

A. I. Haysak, I. I. Haysak

Purpose. The authors of known for us textbooks on quantum mechanics pay attention only to the first regular solution of Schrodinger equation for the hydrogen atom. To exclude the second linearly independent solution from the general solution, different textbooks give various arguments such as invalid boundary condition in the coordinate origin, the appearance of Dirac delta function or divergence of the kinetic energy in the origin. Methods. Using the power series method, we obtained an exact analytic expression for the second independent solution of Schrodinger equation for the hydrogen atom. Results. The solution consists of a sum of two parts, one of which increases indefinitely over long distances, while the other is limited and contains a logarithmic term. This feature is peculiar to all values of the orbital angular momentums. Conclusions. On the example of the hydrogen atom, we demonstrated the mathematically correct algorithm of construction of the independent solutions for the power series method. In particular, this algorithm is important in the case of quantum systems with coupled channels which are described by two or more coupled Schrodinger equations.

Scientific Herald of Uzhhorod University Series Physics•Dec 18, 2019•0 citations

Dirac Theory and SUSYQM

The Dirac equation is the relativistic counterpart — more precisely, generalization — of the Schrödinger equation. We shall focus on calculation of the hydrogen atom fine structure, in order to understand the connection between non-relativistic and relativistic theory, and then relate the latter to SUSYQM. The calculations will comprise A perturbation calculation starting from the Schroedinger equation; An exact calculation from the Dirac equation; An exact calculation from SUSYQM.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Oct 22, 2017•0 citations

Towards a Relativistic Quantum Mechanics

J. Iliopoulos, Theodore N. Tomaras

Abstract The Klein–Gordon and the Dirac equations are studied as candidates for a relativistic generalisation of the Schrödinger equation. We show that the first is unacceptable because it admits solutions with arbitrarily large negative energy and has no conserved current with positive definite probability density. The Dirac equation on the other hand does have a physically acceptable conserved current, but it too suffers from the presence of negative energy solutions. We show that the latter can be interpreted as describing anti-particles. In either case there is no fully consistent interpretation as a single-particle wave equation and we are led to a formalism admitting an infinite number of degrees of freedom, that is a quantum field theory. We can still use the Dirac equation at low energies when the effects of anti-particles are negligible and we study applications in atomic physics.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Oct 25, 2021•0 citations
It is shown that the condition of finiteness at the origin, usually imposed on solutions to the nonrelativistic Schrödinger equation for the hydrogen atom (and some other systems) is not necessary. The quadratically integrable l = 0 “anomalous” solution which is usually excluded in this fashion is not a solution to the Schrödinger equation at the origin, and consequently does not need to be excluded by a boundary or other type condition. The relativistic generalization through the Dirac equation of this anomalous solution is not quadratically integrable. The solution generalized according to the relativistic Schrödinger equation is quadratically integrable and obeys the equation at the origin. Consequently, a boundary or other type condition may still be needed in a general relativistic theory.
We revisit the discussion about the boundary condition at the origin in the Schrödinger radial equation for central potentials. We give a transparent and convincing reason for demanding the radial part R(r) of the wave function to be finite at r = 0, showing that if R(0) diverges the complete wave function ψ does not satisfy the full Schrödinger equation. If R(r) is singular, we show that the corresponding ψ follows an equation similar to Schrödinger's, but with an additional term involving the Dirac delta function or its derivatives at the origin. Although, in general, understanding some of our arguments requires certain knowledge of the theory of distributions, the important case of a behavior R ∝ 1/r near r = 0, which gives rise to a normalizable ψ, is especially simple: The origin of the Dirac delta term is clearly demonstrated by using a slight modification of the usual spherical coordinates. The argument can be easily followed by undergraduate physics students.
We show that additional solutions must be ignored (in differences of the Schrödinger and Klein–Gordon equations) in the Dirac equation, where usually the second-order radial equation is passed, called the reduced equation, instead of a system. Analogously to the Schrödinger equation, in this process, the Dirac’s delta function appears, which was unnoted during the full history of quantum mechanics. This unphysical term we remove by a boundary condition at the origin. However, the distribution theory imposes on the radial function strong restriction and by this reason practically for all potentials, even regular, use of these reduced equations is not permissible. At the end, we include consideration in the framework of two-dimensional Dirac equation. We show that even here the additional solution does not survive as a result of usual physical requirements.
Purpose. The authors of known for us textbooks on quantum mechanics pay attention only to the first regular solution of Schrodinger equation for the hydrogen atom. To exclude the second linearly independent solution from the general solution, different textbooks give various arguments such as invalid boundary condition in the coordinate origin, the appearance of Dirac delta function or divergence of the kinetic energy in the origin. Methods. Using the power series method, we obtained an exact analytic expression for the second independent solution of Schrodinger equation for the hydrogen atom. Results. The solution consists of a sum of two parts, one of which increases indefinitely over long distances, while the other is limited and contains a logarithmic term. This feature is peculiar to all values of the orbital angular momentums. Conclusions. On the example of the hydrogen atom, we demonstrated the mathematically correct algorithm of construction of the independent solutions for the power series method. In particular, this algorithm is important in the case of quantum systems with coupled channels which are described by two or more coupled Schrodinger equations.
Abstract The Klein–Gordon and the Dirac equations are studied as candidates for a relativistic generalisation of the Schrödinger equation. We show that the first is unacceptable because it admits solutions with arbitrarily large negative energy and has no conserved current with positive definite probability density. The Dirac equation on the other hand does have a physically acceptable conserved current, but it too suffers from the presence of negative energy solutions. We show that the latter can be interpreted as describing anti-particles. In either case there is no fully consistent interpretation as a single-particle wave equation and we are led to a formalism admitting an infinite number of degrees of freedom, that is a quantum field theory. We can still use the Dirac equation at low energies when the effects of anti-particles are negligible and we study applications in atomic physics.