Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Comment on ‘‘Hydrogen atom in one dimension’’

H. N. Núñez‐Yépez, Carlos Alejandro Vargas, A. L. Salas Brito

Published Apr 1, 1989• 15 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In a recent paper Boya, Kmiecik, and Bohm [Phys. Rev. A 37, 3567 (1988)] discuss the one-dimensional hydrogen atom and mention what one should take if one wants to form parity eigenfunctions. In this Comment we show that such even and odd superpositions cannot represent physical states due to a superselection rule that leads to spontaneous breaking of the symmetry of inversion through the origin.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.39.4306

Related papers

Superselection rule in the one-dimensional hydrogen atom

H. N. Núñez‐Yépez, Carlos Alejandro Vargas, A. L. Salas Brito

The authors show that a superselection rule operates between the bound states of the one-dimensional hydrogen atom and they investigate some of its consequences.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jun 21, 1988•18 citations

Comment on 'Fisher information for quasi-one-dimensional hydrogen atom'

O. Olendski

A further argument is provided in the discussion on the correct form of the bound-state momentum wave function of the quasi-one-dimensional hydrogen atom; namely, considering its behavior at the large quantum indices, it is reconfirmed that the complex expression from Olendski (2017) {\it Eur. J. Phys.} {\bf 38} 038001 is a correct one. Groundlessness of other interpretations is also highlighted.

arXiv:1703.10042•Mar 26, 2017•1 citation

Comments on the one-dimensional hydrogen atom [Am. J. Phys. 2 7, 649 (1959); Am. J. Phys. 3 7, 1145 (1969); Am. J. Phys. 4 4, 1064 (1976)

C. L. Hammer, T. A. Weber

Extraneous solutions to the Schroedinger equation are discussed. (AIP)

American Journal of Physics•Mar 1, 1988•18 citations

Comment on ‘Limitations on the superposition principle: superselection rules in non-relativistic quantum mechanics’

Namit Anand

This is a comment to the paper, Limitations on the superposition principle: superselection rules in non-relativistic quantum mechanics by C Cisneros et al 1998 Eur. J. Phys. 19 237. doi:10.1088/0143-0807/19/3/005. The proof that the authors construct for the limitation on the superposition of state vectors corresponding to different sectors of the Hilbert space, partitioned by a superoperator has a flaw as outlined below.

arXiv:1507.00544•European Journal of Physics•Jun 15, 2016•0 citations

Comment on the ’’One-dimensional hydrogen atom’’

M. Andrews

See also related One‐dimensional hydrogen atom commentary Reply to ''Comment on the 'One‐dimensional hydrogen atom' ''

American Journal of Physics•Nov 1, 1981•5 citations

QUANTUM STATES OF THE ‘ENIGMATIC’ 1-D HYDROGEN ATOM: DO THEY EXIST?

Sucheta Ghosh, Shankar Prasad Bhattacharyya

The quantum states of hydrogen atom in one dimension can be obtained by a careful application of the well-known Frobenius method. The exercise is highly educative and brings to focus the subtle aspects of quantum mechanics. The allowed states turn out to be only of odd parity and non-degenerate, having energy given by E_n=-ⅇ^2/(2n^2 a_0 ) , n= 1, 2, 3,..., and a_0 being the first Bohr radius, in exact correspondence with energy levels of 3-D H-atom. In view of odd parity of all states the spectrum of 1-D H-atom is expected to be dominated by weak electric quadrupole transitions.

•Nov 15, 2023•0 citations
In a recent paper Boya, Kmiecik, and Bohm [Phys. Rev. A 37, 3567 (1988)] discuss the one-dimensional hydrogen atom and mention what one should take if one wants to form parity eigenfunctions. In this Comment we show that such even and odd superpositions cannot represent physical states due to a superselection rule that leads to spontaneous breaking of the symmetry of inversion through the origin.
The quantum states of hydrogen atom in one dimension can be obtained by a careful application of the well-known Frobenius method. The exercise is highly educative and brings to focus the subtle aspects of quantum mechanics. The allowed states turn out to be only of odd parity and non-degenerate, having energy given by E_n=-ⅇ^2/(2n^2 a_0 ) , n= 1, 2, 3,..., and a_0 being the first Bohr radius, in exact correspondence with energy levels of 3-D H-atom. In view of odd parity of all states the spectrum of 1-D H-atom is expected to be dominated by weak electric quadrupole transitions.