Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Rate-equation approximations in high-gain lasers

Lee W. Casperson

Published Apr 1, 1997• 10 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The rate-equation approximation is one of the most fundamental and universally employed simplifications in laser analyses. The accuracy and regions of applicability of this approximation are explored in comparisons with more rigorous semiclassical models. Higher-order rate-equation approximations are also developed, and these improved models can yield much better accuracy than conventional rate equations with little added complexity. The modified adiabatic elimination methods reported here would also be useful in reducing the mathematical models governing other physical systems.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.55.3073

Related papers

Rotating-wave approximation in high-gain lasers

Lee W. Casperson

Semiclassical models for lasers typically incorporate a fundamental simplification called the rotating-wave approximation. In this study the rotating-wave approximation is reexamined, and its implications for the simplest problem of a steady-state laser oscillator are considered in detail. It is found that for practical laser operating conditions the errors resulting from this approximation may not always be negligible.

Physical Review A•Jul 1, 1992•12 citations

Quantum noise VII: The rate equations and amplitude noise in lasers

M. Lax

In this paper we start from our Quantum Noise IV model of a homogenously broadened maser and specialize to the case in which the number of photons and the population difference are the slowest changing variables. In spite of the high coherence of the system, we find that by eliminating all other variables adiabatically we obtain the usual rate equations plus a set of noise sources with precisely those moments appropriate to shot noise. Thus we justify McCumber's model for amplitude noise in a laser, and after making a quasi-linear approximation obtain his amplitude spectrum. Comparison with exact calculations of Hempstead and Lax for the rotating wave van der Pol oscillator suggests that quasi-linear methods are accurate except within a factor 10 (in photon number) of threshold.

IEEE Journal of Quantum Electronics•Feb 1, 1967•89 citations

Three-level atom laser model with results and applications

Andrew M. Smith II, Crispin W. Gardiner

We present here a fully quantum-mechanical treatment of the laser using a three-level atom model. The phase-space method employed is identical to that in a previous publication of ours [Phys. Rev. A 38, 4073 (1988)] and again results in a Fokker-Planck description of the laser without any approximations. The third level only provides extra deterministic terms and, if it is regarded as a further reservoir to the lasing levels, then the resultant stochastic equations have much improved stability. These equations are suitable for extensive theoretical analysis of both the laser and optical bistability, although in this paper we have concentrated on the adiabatically eliminated limit and calculated the leading noise terms in various regimes. However, we do use the technique of direct numerical simulation to solve exactly the full system of laser equations. The results display clearly many of the known laser characteristics.

Physical Review A•Mar 1, 1990•14 citations

Derivation and application of master equation methods for semiconductor lasers

Andrea Eschmann

With the advent of the laser, an interest in the statistical properties of light was born. New theories, which required an understanding of how the lasing medium interacts quantum mechanically with incident light were developed to classify and quantify light. For many laser systems, gaining an understanding of the physical processes occurring in the medium, and translating these into a mathematical formalism has been achieved with relative speed and ease, and the resulting theories form part of the core of the field we know as quantum optics. In the case of semiconductor lasers however, progress has not been so swift, nor the description so complete. The many and complex processes occurring in a semiconductor laser are not well understood and this has led to many-body and solid-state phenomenological descriptions of the semiconductor laser rather than a quantum optical one. Although some attempts have been made at obtaining a fully quantum mechanical description, phenomenological descriptions have been resorted to to describe poorly understood or complex processes such as pumping and scattering. The work in this thesis was inspired by the lack of such a theory, and by the belief that it should be possible to give a description of the semiconductor laser in terms familiar to quantum opticians. With the continued and current interest in non-classical properties of light, such a theory could be very useful in predicting such properties of semiconductor lasers. Since semiconductor lasers have great potential for use in high speed electro-optic, or even optical communications, low-noise operation of these devices is a desired and indeed essential goal. Our first attempt at formulating such a theory was a simple single-mode description, using as a basis for comparison of results the more phenomenological work of Yamamoto and coworkers [Yamamoto 1986, Machida 1987, Yamamoto 1987]. Our work was based on a master equation description of the system however, and thus the methodology differed significantly from that of these authors.

•Jan 1, 1996•0 citations

High-intensity single-mode laser theory

Jehuda Ziegler, P. R. Berman

A high-intensity single-mode gas laser is analyzed by several mathematical methods. Exact numerical results are best obtained by solving for the coefficients of a Fourier series solution by using a backward recurrence scheme or a successive convergents method for evaluating a continued fraction. Numerical integration techniques can also be used to convert the periodic boundary conditions to initial conditions and then solve the resulting initial-value problem. Direct analytic integration leads to exact solutions in terms of Bessel functions for the special case of zero detuning, equal decay rates, and neglecting of collision broadening. For general single-mode operation, an improved analytic approximation [the second recursion relation approximation (2RCRA)] is obtained by taking an additional term in the recursion relations for the Fourier coefficients. This approximation predicts the existence of one of the secondary resonances in graphs of the spatially averaged population inversion and quadrature polarization coefficient densities and matches the exact solution from the position of the first resonance and outward independent of the intensity. The 2RCRA also matches the exact detuning curve except at small detunings. The first-order ("rate equation") approximation, by comparison, does not predict any secondary resonances and does not match the exact solution at higher intensities. A physical interpretation for the appearance of the secondary resonances is presented in terms of multiphoton interactions and a prediction for the positions of the resonances for the special case discussed above is obtained. As predicted by Greenstein the exact detuning curves show quantitatively that the Lamb dip decreases and disappears as the intensity increases for high excitations.

Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1977•11 citations

The adiabatic elimination principle

Luigi A. Lugiato, Franco Prati, Massimo Brambilla

The adiabatic elimination principle [91, 92] is universal in the area of nonlinear dissipative dynamical systems, and its importance arises from the fact that it allows one to reduce the number of the equations which govern the dynamics of the system. We introduce it at this stage in the book in order to be able to describe the optical pumping mechanisms which can be exerted to attain population inversion. However, this principle will be applied repeatedly in the following chapters for other purposes. In the first subsection we describe the principle in general, while the following subsections concern the issue of optical pumping. We show first that it is not possible to obtain population inversion between the two levels of the lasing transition if the pump involves only these two levels. Next we illustrate the three-level pumping scheme and the four-level pumping scheme. We demonstrate that, by adiabatically eliminating the probabilities of the additional energy levels, one arrives at an equation identical to Eq. (4.12), which, for appropriate ranges of values of the parameters involved in the pumping, allows one to obtain population inversion. General formulation of the principle In a dissipative dynamical system the dynamical variables undergo relaxation processes associated with suitable rate constants such as, for example, the rate γ ⊥ for the normalized atomic polarization P and the rate γ ∥ for the normalized population difference D . The inverses of these rates provide the time scales which characterize the evolution of each variable. Therefore we can distinguish a set of fast variables , which evolve over short time scales and are therefore characterized by large relaxation rates, and a set of slow variables , which display small relaxation rates. A remarkable simplification in the analysis of dynamical systems is obtained by using the technique of adiabatic elimination of fast variables, which Haken considered as a basis for the discipline which he formulated and called Synergetics [91, 92].

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 28, 2015•1 citation
The rate-equation approximation is one of the most fundamental and universally employed simplifications in laser analyses. The accuracy and regions of applicability of this approximation are explored in comparisons with more rigorous semiclassical models. Higher-order rate-equation approximations are also developed, and these improved models can yield much better accuracy than conventional rate equations with little added complexity. The modified adiabatic elimination methods reported here would also be useful in reducing the mathematical models governing other physical systems.
In this paper we start from our Quantum Noise IV model of a homogenously broadened maser and specialize to the case in which the number of photons and the population difference are the slowest changing variables. In spite of the high coherence of the system, we find that by eliminating all other variables adiabatically we obtain the usual rate equations plus a set of noise sources with precisely those moments appropriate to shot noise. Thus we justify McCumber's model for amplitude noise in a laser, and after making a quasi-linear approximation obtain his amplitude spectrum. Comparison with exact calculations of Hempstead and Lax for the rotating wave van der Pol oscillator suggests that quasi-linear methods are accurate except within a factor 10 (in photon number) of threshold.
We present here a fully quantum-mechanical treatment of the laser using a three-level atom model. The phase-space method employed is identical to that in a previous publication of ours [Phys. Rev. A 38, 4073 (1988)] and again results in a Fokker-Planck description of the laser without any approximations. The third level only provides extra deterministic terms and, if it is regarded as a further reservoir to the lasing levels, then the resultant stochastic equations have much improved stability. These equations are suitable for extensive theoretical analysis of both the laser and optical bistability, although in this paper we have concentrated on the adiabatically eliminated limit and calculated the leading noise terms in various regimes. However, we do use the technique of direct numerical simulation to solve exactly the full system of laser equations. The results display clearly many of the known laser characteristics.
With the advent of the laser, an interest in the statistical properties of light was born. New theories, which required an understanding of how the lasing medium interacts quantum mechanically with incident light were developed to classify and quantify light. For many laser systems, gaining an understanding of the physical processes occurring in the medium, and translating these into a mathematical formalism has been achieved with relative speed and ease, and the resulting theories form part of the core of the field we know as quantum optics. In the case of semiconductor lasers however, progress has not been so swift, nor the description so complete. The many and complex processes occurring in a semiconductor laser are not well understood and this has led to many-body and solid-state phenomenological descriptions of the semiconductor laser rather than a quantum optical one. Although some attempts have been made at obtaining a fully quantum mechanical description, phenomenological descriptions have been resorted to to describe poorly understood or complex processes such as pumping and scattering. The work in this thesis was inspired by the lack of such a theory, and by the belief that it should be possible to give a description of the semiconductor laser in terms familiar to quantum opticians. With the continued and current interest in non-classical properties of light, such a theory could be very useful in predicting such properties of semiconductor lasers. Since semiconductor lasers have great potential for use in high speed electro-optic, or even optical communications, low-noise operation of these devices is a desired and indeed essential goal. Our first attempt at formulating such a theory was a simple single-mode description, using as a basis for comparison of results the more phenomenological work of Yamamoto and coworkers [Yamamoto 1986, Machida 1987, Yamamoto 1987]. Our work was based on a master equation description of the system however, and thus the methodology differed significantly from that of these authors.
A high-intensity single-mode gas laser is analyzed by several mathematical methods. Exact numerical results are best obtained by solving for the coefficients of a Fourier series solution by using a backward recurrence scheme or a successive convergents method for evaluating a continued fraction. Numerical integration techniques can also be used to convert the periodic boundary conditions to initial conditions and then solve the resulting initial-value problem. Direct analytic integration leads to exact solutions in terms of Bessel functions for the special case of zero detuning, equal decay rates, and neglecting of collision broadening. For general single-mode operation, an improved analytic approximation [the second recursion relation approximation (2RCRA)] is obtained by taking an additional term in the recursion relations for the Fourier coefficients. This approximation predicts the existence of one of the secondary resonances in graphs of the spatially averaged population inversion and quadrature polarization coefficient densities and matches the exact solution from the position of the first resonance and outward independent of the intensity. The 2RCRA also matches the exact detuning curve except at small detunings. The first-order ("rate equation") approximation, by comparison, does not predict any secondary resonances and does not match the exact solution at higher intensities. A physical interpretation for the appearance of the secondary resonances is presented in terms of multiphoton interactions and a prediction for the positions of the resonances for the special case discussed above is obtained. As predicted by Greenstein the exact detuning curves show quantitatively that the Lamb dip decreases and disappears as the intensity increases for high excitations.
The adiabatic elimination principle [91, 92] is universal in the area of nonlinear dissipative dynamical systems, and its importance arises from the fact that it allows one to reduce the number of the equations which govern the dynamics of the system. We introduce it at this stage in the book in order to be able to describe the optical pumping mechanisms which can be exerted to attain population inversion. However, this principle will be applied repeatedly in the following chapters for other purposes. In the first subsection we describe the principle in general, while the following subsections concern the issue of optical pumping. We show first that it is not possible to obtain population inversion between the two levels of the lasing transition if the pump involves only these two levels. Next we illustrate the three-level pumping scheme and the four-level pumping scheme. We demonstrate that, by adiabatically eliminating the probabilities of the additional energy levels, one arrives at an equation identical to Eq. (4.12), which, for appropriate ranges of values of the parameters involved in the pumping, allows one to obtain population inversion. General formulation of the principle In a dissipative dynamical system the dynamical variables undergo relaxation processes associated with suitable rate constants such as, for example, the rate γ ⊥ for the normalized atomic polarization P and the rate γ ∥ for the normalized population difference D . The inverses of these rates provide the time scales which characterize the evolution of each variable. Therefore we can distinguish a set of fast variables , which evolve over short time scales and are therefore characterized by large relaxation rates, and a set of slow variables , which display small relaxation rates. A remarkable simplification in the analysis of dynamical systems is obtained by using the technique of adiabatic elimination of fast variables, which Haken considered as a basis for the discipline which he formulated and called Synergetics [91, 92].