An extension of Feynman's rule, relating probability amplitudes and probabilities in two-photon interferometry, has been proposed recently [G. Jaeger et al., Phys. Rev. A 48, 1023 (1993)]. It would be interesting to analyze the validity of this rule in other physical situations not considered by these authors. In particular, we show in this paper that the extended rule cannot be applied to the gedanken two-slit experiment. This result suggests the existence of two quantum regimes, differentiated by the validity of the generalized rule. The distinguishability of one particle and the visibilities of one-particle and two-particle interferences are calculated. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
An extension of Feynman's rule, relating probability amplitudes and probabilities in two-photon interferometry, has been proposed recently [G. Jaeger et al., Phys. Rev. A 48, 1023 (1993)]. It would be interesting to analyze the validity of this rule in other physical situations not considered by these authors. In particular, we show in this paper that the extended rule cannot be applied to the gedanken two-slit experiment. This result suggests the existence of two quantum regimes, differentiated by the validity of the generalized rule. The distinguishability of one particle and the visibilities of one-particle and two-particle interferences are calculated. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
Classically, probability is considered in terms of the number of possible outcomes. For example, a die toss has six possible outcomes and a coin toss, two. Probability calculations make use of probabilities and hence of the total number of possible outcomes. Thus, they are not deterministic calculations which follow “what happens” as in Newtonian mechanics. We suggest that if free particle quantum mechanics is probabilistic, it must also involve the notion of possible outcomes in an experiment and not represent a deterministic approach. We suggest, however, that something interesting applies to quantum mechanics because we have suggested that free particle quantum mechanics arises from the Lorentz invariant A = -Et+px. We note that there exist x,t trajectory points which follow x=vt. We also note, however, that one may introduce the idea of intervals dx, dt (because Newton’s dx→0, dt→0 is an idealization) and that A is unchanged for x,t and x+hbar/p , t+hbar/E. In other words, we suggest that there are intervals with probability about each x,t trajectory point. A trajectory point is associated with deterministic physics, but probability about this point is not. In other words, one has a kind of hybrid probability scheme. Thus, exp(ipx) and exp(-iEt) really represent fluctuation probabilities about a trajectory point x and t. These ranges of possible x and t fluctuations about a trajectory point x,t allow for further probability to occur in certain interactions. We consider two examples. The first is 2-slit interference which involves a deterministic particle moving along a straight line towards a 2-slit mechanism perpendicular to its path. At the 2-slit apparatus, one considers a probabilistic calculation as the uncertainty in x, i.e. dx=hbar/p allows for possible interaction with both slits. This involves considering all possible outcomes (i.e. motion through one slit or the other which is a classical situation), but exp(i p dot r1) and exp(i p dot r2) “sit on top” of these trajectories at the 2-slit apparatus and one has interference of the probabilities linked with each classical possible outcome. Thus, there are two sets of probabilities which are intertwined, the probability range hbar/p for each path and the two possible paths which have equal probability. One must consider the possible outcomes for both sets together. We suggest that a similar analysis applies to the case of 1-D reflection-refraction for x=0 at an n1-n2 index of refraction junction. Thus, we suggest that a deterministic free particle with x=vt may encounter probabilistic interaction situations, such as a two-slit apparatus or an n1-n2 index of refraction junction. These are probabilistic only because there is a probability fluctuation scheme in x associated with each deterministic x point. It is this probability which allows for a second probability to arise due to interaction with the slits or at the 1-D n1-n2 junction. In such a case, one must consider all possible outcomes which means that one does not only consider the exp(ipx) type probabilities, but also those linked with the physical interaction, i.e. two possible paths, one from each slit, or an incident, reflected and refracted photon at x=0 (n1-n2 junction). It is a combination of all possible paths which must be used in calculations. We thus suggest that even though there is a sense of determinism, i..e free particles move as x=vt and these exist in the 2-slit case and the 1-D reflection-refraction case, in a probabilistic calculation one must consider all probabilistic outcomes consistent with these. Thus, quantum mechanical calculations are true probabilistic calculations in the sense that they involve all possible outcomes in an analysis.
In Mod. Phys. Lett. A 9, 3119 (1994), one of us (R.D.S) investigated a formulation of quantum mechanics as a generalized measure theory. Quantum mechanics computes probabilities from the absolute squares of complex amplitudes, and the resulting interference violates the (Kolmogorov) sum rule expressing the additivity of probabilities of mutually exclusive events. However, there is a higher order sum rule that quantum mechanics does obey, involving the probabilities of three mutually exclusive possibilities. We could imagine a yet more general theory by assuming that it violates the next higher sum rule. In this paper, we report results from an ongoing experiment that sets out to test the validity of this second sum rule by measuring the interference patterns produced by three slits and all the possible combinations of those slits being open or closed. We use attenuated laser light combined with single photon counting to confirm the particle character of the measured light.
We derive the intensity and fringe visibility of an N-slit quantum interference system directly from the Feynman path integral by partitioning the amplitude into slit-conditioned path classes and incorporating internal quantum states to account for distinguishability. Applying Born's rule and tracing over unobserved degrees of freedom yields the standard coherence-theoretic intensity expression, establishing an explicit equivalence between the path-integral and Dirac formulations of multi-slit interference. We show that a naive uniform-coherence model leads to unphysical visibility values for N>2, motivating a normalization-consistent decomposition into indistinguishable and distinguishable photon populations. The resulting visibility relation depends explicitly on the relative populations of coherent and incoherent photons and reproduces the standard two-slit limit while exhibiting the correct fully coherent and fully distinguishable limits. These results connect path-integral interference directly to experimentally measurable coherence properties and provide a normalization-consistent description of multi-slit visibility.
We derive the intensity and fringe visibility of an N-slit quantum interference system directly from the Feynman path integral by partitioning the amplitude into slit-conditioned path classes and incorporating internal quantum states to account for distinguishability. Applying Born's rule and tracing over unobserved degrees of freedom yields the standard coherence-theoretic intensity expression, establishing an explicit equivalence between the path-integral and Dirac formulations of multi-slit interference. We show that a naive uniform-coherence model leads to unphysical visibility values for N>2, motivating a normalization-consistent decomposition into indistinguishable and distinguishable photon populations. The resulting visibility relation depends explicitly on the relative populations of coherent and incoherent photons and reproduces the standard two-slit limit while exhibiting the correct fully coherent and fully distinguishable limits. These results connect path-integral interference directly to experimentally measurable coherence properties and provide a normalization-consistent description of multi-slit visibility.
This paper is based on work published in [1]. It describes a triple slit experiment using single photons that has been used to provide a bound on one of the most fundamental axioms of quantum mechanics i.e. Born’s rule for probabilities [2]. In spite of being one of the most successful theories which describes various natural phenomena, quantum mechanics has enough intricacies and “weirdness” associated with it which makes many physicists believe that it may not be the final theory and hints towards the possibility of more generalized versions. Quantum interference as shown by a double slit diffraction experiment only occurs from pairs of paths. Even in multi‐slit versions, interference can only occur between pairs of possibilities and increasing the number of slits does not increase the complexity of the theory that still remains second‐order. However, more generalized versions of quantum mechanics may allow for multi‐path i.e. higher than second order interference. This experiment also provides a bound on the magnitude of such higher order interference. We have been able to bound the magnitude of three‐path interference to less than 10−2 of the expected two‐path interference, thus ruling out third and higher order interference and providing a bound on the accuracy of Born’s rule.
The Young’s single- and double-slit experiments are explained using six-component quantum and one-component quasi-classical photon wave functions in the coordinate representation, which are modeled by different mechanisms of photon diffraction on slits or simultaneous emission of two photons by (two) independent sources. This explanation is compared with the well-known statement about the interference of a particle with itself when passing through both slits simultaneously in the Young’s experiment on the basis of the postulated Feynman amplitudes. It is argued that these amplitudes cannot be wave functions, in the literal sense, describing some states of quantum particles. In all cases, under the assumption of the linear polarization of photons, a pronounced interference pattern has been obtained, which suggests that the coordinate wave function of a photon can explain the phenomena of the one- and two-photon interference. This conclusion, in turn, makes it possible to associate the coordinate wave function of a photon (two photons, in the entangled state) measured in some recent experiments with the quasi-classical wave function of a photon (two photons), although it does not take into account its (their) polarization properties.