Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Simple model for the detection of a particle by a point detector

Roy S. Bondurant

Published Jun 9, 2004• 4 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A model for a one-dimensional quantum particle interacting with a point detector is developed and analyzed. The analysis leads to any simple, intuitively pleasing expression for the final density operator of the particle in terms of the freely propagating particle density operator, a projection operator representing the detector volume, and a probability density for the time at which the detector fires. This probability density is found explicitly to be the presence-time density given by ${\ensuremath{\mid}{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{f}\phantom{\rule{0.1em}{0ex}}(0,t)\ensuremath{\mid}}^{2}∕\ensuremath{\int}{\ensuremath{\mid}{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{f}\phantom{\rule{0.1em}{0ex}}(0,t)\ensuremath{\mid}}^{2}dt$ where ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{f}\phantom{\rule{0.1em}{0ex}}(0,t)$ is the free particle wave function evaluated at the detector position $(x=0)$. Moreover, it is shown that the resultant density operator transformation is a nonlinear transformation, not describable as a positive operator valued measure.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.69.062104

Related papers

Quantum time of arrival distribution in a simple lattice model

Shrabanti Dhar, Subinay Dasgupta, Abhishek Dhar

Abstract Imagine an experiment where a quantum particle inside a box is released at some time in some initial state. A detector is placed at a fixed location inside the box and its clicking signifies arrival of the particle at the detector. What is the time of arrival (TOA) of the particle at the detector ? Within the paradigm of the measurement postulate of quantum mechanics, one can use the idea of projective measurements to define the TOA. We consider a setup where a detector keeps making instantaneous measurements at regular finite time intervals until it detects the particle at time t , which is defined as the TOA. This is a stochastic variable and, for a simple lattice model of a free particle in a one-dimensional box, we find interesting features such as power-law tails in its distribution and in the probability of survival (non-detection). We propose a perturbative calculational approach which yields results that compare very well with exact numerics.

arXiv:1312.5923•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Feb 25, 2015•73 citations

Time of arrival in quantum and Bohmian mechanics

C. Richard Leavens

In a recent paper Grot, Rovelli, and Tate (GRT) [Phys. Rev. A 54, 4676 (1996)] derived an expression for the probability distribution $\ensuremath{\pi}(T;X)$ of intrinsic arrival times $T(X)$ at position $x=X$ for a quantum particle with initial wave function $\ensuremath{\psi}(x,t=0)$ freely evolving in one dimension. This was done by quantizing the classical expression for the time of arrival of a free particle at $X,$ assuming a particular choice of operator ordering, and then regulating the resulting time of arrival operator. For the special case of a minimum-uncertainty-product wave packet at $t=0$ with average wave number $〈k〉$ and variance $\ensuremath{\Delta}k$ they showed that their analytical expression for $\ensuremath{\pi}(T;X)$ agreed with the probability current density $J(x=X,t=T)$ only to terms of order $\ensuremath{\Delta}k/〈k〉.$ They dismissed the probability current density as a viable candidate for the exact arrival time distribution on the grounds that it can sometimes be negative. This fact is not a problem within Bohmian mechanics where the arrival time distribution for a particle, either free or in the presence of a potential, is rigorously given by $|J(X,T)|$ (suitably normalized) [W. R. McKinnon and C. R. Leavens, Phys. Rev. A 51, 2748 (1995); C. R. Leavens, Phys. Lett. A 178, 27 (1993); M. Daumer et al., in On Three Levels: The Mathematical Physics of Micro-, Meso-, and Macro-Approaches to Physics, edited by M. Fannes et al. (Plenum, New York, 1994); M. Daumer, in Bohmian Mechanics and Quantum Theory: An Appraisal, edited by J. T. Cushing et al. (Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht, 1996)]. The two theories are compared in this paper and a case presented for which the results could not differ more: According to GRT's theory, every particle in the ensemble reaches a point $x=X,$ where $\ensuremath{\psi}(x,t)$ and $J(x,t)$ are both zero for all $t,$ while no particle ever reaches $X$ according to the theory based on Bohmian mechanics. Some possible implications are discussed.

Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1998•91 citations

Scattering Cross Section Formula Derived From Macroscopic Model of Detectors

Rashi Kaimal, Roderich Tumulka

We are concerned with the justification of the statement, commonly (explicitly or implicitly) used in quantum scattering theory, that for a free non-relativistic quantum particle with initial wave function $Ψ_0(\boldsymbol{x})$, surrounded by detectors along a sphere of large radius $R$, the probability distribution of the detection time and place has asymptotic density (i.e., scattering cross section) $σ(\boldsymbol{x},t)= m^3 \hbar^{-3} R t^{-4} |\widehatΨ_0(m\boldsymbol{x}/\hbar t)|^2$ with $\widehatΨ_0$ the Fourier transform of $Ψ_0$. We give two derivations of this formula, based on different macroscopic models of the detection process. The first one consists of a negative imaginary potential of strength $λ>0$ in the detector volume (i.e., outside the sphere of radius $R$) in the limit $R\to\infty,λ\to 0, Rλ\to \infty$. The second one consists of repeated nearly-projective measurements of (approximately) the observable $1_{|\boldsymbol{x}|>R}$ at times $\mathscr{T},2\mathscr{T},3\mathscr{T},\ldots$ in the limit $R\to\infty,\mathscr{T}\to\infty,\mathscr{T}/R\to 0$; this setup is similar to that of the quantum Zeno effect, except that there one considers $\mathscr{T}\to 0$ instead of $\mathscr{T}\to\infty$. We also provide a comparison to Bohmian mechanics: while in the absence of detectors, the arrival times and places of the Bohmian trajectories on the sphere of radius $R$ have asymptotic distribution density given by the same formula as $σ$, their deviation from the detection times and places is not necessarily small, although it is small compared to $R$, so the effect of the presence of detectors on the particle can be neglected in the far-field regime. We also cover the generalization to surfaces with non-spherical shape, to the case of $N$ non-interacting particles, to time-dependent surfaces, and to the Dirac equation.

quant-pharXiv:2601.01625•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jan 6, 2026•2 citations

Time-of-arrival probabilities and quantum measurements. II. Application to tunneling times

Charis Anastopoulos, Ntina Savvidou

We formulate quantum tunneling as a time-of-arrival problem: we determine the detection probability for particles passing through a barrier at a detector located a distance L from the tunneling region. For this purpose, we use a positive-operator-valued measure (POVM) for the time of arrival determined in C. Anastopoulos and N. Savvidou, J. Math. Phys. 47, 122106 (2006). This only depends on the initial state, the Hamiltonian, and the location of the detector. The POVM above provides a well-defined probability density and an unambiguous interpretation of all quantities involved. We demonstrate that for a class of localized initial states, the detection probability allows for an identification of tunneling time with the classic phase time. We also establish limits to the definability of tunneling time. We then generalize these results to a sequential measurement setup: the phase-space properties of the particles are determined by an unsharp sampling before their attempt to cross the barrier. For such measurements the tunneling time is defined as a genuine observable. This allows us to construct a probability distribution for its values that is definable for all initial states and potentials. We also identify a regime in which these probabilities correspond to a tunneling-time operator.

arXiv:0706.2492•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Feb 1, 2008•15 citations

Spatial statistics of single-quantum detection

Jonathan Schonfeld

In a single-particle detection experiment, a wavefront impinges on a detector but observers only see a point response. The extent of the wavefront becomes evident only in statistical accumulation of many independent detections, with probability given by the Born rule. Drawing on concepts from quantum optics, we analyze a simple model to reverse-engineer how this behavior can come about in terms of wave mechanics alone without a measurement axiom. The model detector consists of many molecules, each of which can be resonantly excited by the incoming particle and then emit a detection signature (e.g., localized flash of light). Different molecules have different resonant energies because local conditions (proximity of other molecules, Doppler shifts, etc.) vary. The detector is thus a quasi-continuum, and the incoming particle preferentially excites the molecule that it matches most closely in energy. (In actuality, molecules can be so numerous that many could closely match the incoming particle in energy; but in that case only one will be the first, and there will be nothing left for the others by the time the first match resonates and then emits. The model does not explicitly take into account the temporal advance of the particle wave packet through the detector medium.) The excited molecule can emit a detection signature, but that process competes with fluctuation-driven dephasing. We estimate the probability that a given molecule is resonantly excited, and we also estimate the probability that a detection signature is produced before being overwhelmed by fluctuations in the detector medium. The product of these two probabilities is proportional to the absolute-square of the incoming wavefunction at the molecule in question, i.e. the Born rule. We discuss ways to probe these mechanisms experimentally, and check the model with numbers from a neutron interference experiment.

arXiv:1706.07788•Jun 20, 2017•0 citations

Detection-time distribution for several quantum particles

Roderich Tumulka

We address the question of how to compute the probability distribution of the time at which a detector clicks in the situation of $n$ nonrelativistic quantum particles in a volume $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}\ensuremath{\subset}{\mathbb{R}}^{3}$ in physical space and detectors placed along the boundary $\ensuremath{\partial}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}$ of $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}$. We previously [Tumulka, Ann. Phys. (NY) 442, 168910 (2022)] argued in favor of a rule for the one-particle case that involves a Schr\"odinger equation with an absorbing boundary condition on $\ensuremath{\partial}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}$ introduced by Werner; we call this rule the ``absorbing boundary rule.'' Here, we describe the natural extension of the absorbing boundary rule to the $n$-particle case. A key element of this extension is that, upon a detection event, the wave function gets collapsed by inserting the detected position, at the time of detection, into the wave function, thus yielding a wave function of $n\ensuremath{-}1$ particles. We also describe an extension of the absorbing boundary rule to the case of moving detectors.

arXiv:1601.03871•Physical Review A•Oct 24, 2022•20 citations
A model for a one-dimensional quantum particle interacting with a point detector is developed and analyzed. The analysis leads to any simple, intuitively pleasing expression for the final density operator of the particle in terms of the freely propagating particle density operator, a projection operator representing the detector volume, and a probability density for the time at which the detector fires. This probability density is found explicitly to be the presence-time density given by \ensuremath∣\ensuremathψf(0,t)\ensuremath∣2∕\ensuremath∫\ensuremath∣\ensuremathψf(0,t)\ensuremath∣2dt{\ensuremath{\mid}{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{f}\phantom{\rule{0.1em}{0ex}}(0,t)\ensuremath{\mid}}^{2}∕\ensuremath{\int}{\ensuremath{\mid}{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{f}\phantom{\rule{0.1em}{0ex}}(0,t)\ensuremath{\mid}}^{2}dt\ensuremath∣\ensuremathψf​(0,t)\ensuremath∣2∕\ensuremath∫\ensuremath∣\ensuremathψf​(0,t)\ensuremath∣2dt where \ensuremathψf(0,t){\ensuremath{\psi}}_{f}\phantom{\rule{0.1em}{0ex}}(0,t)\ensuremathψf​(0,t) is the free particle wave function evaluated at the detector position (x=0)(x=0)(x=0). Moreover, it is shown that the resultant density operator transformation is a nonlinear transformation, not describable as a positive operator valued measure.
Abstract Imagine an experiment where a quantum particle inside a box is released at some time in some initial state. A detector is placed at a fixed location inside the box and its clicking signifies arrival of the particle at the detector. What is the time of arrival (TOA) of the particle at the detector ? Within the paradigm of the measurement postulate of quantum mechanics, one can use the idea of projective measurements to define the TOA. We consider a setup where a detector keeps making instantaneous measurements at regular finite time intervals until it detects the particle at time t , which is defined as the TOA. This is a stochastic variable and, for a simple lattice model of a free particle in a one-dimensional box, we find interesting features such as power-law tails in its distribution and in the probability of survival (non-detection). We propose a perturbative calculational approach which yields results that compare very well with exact numerics.
In a recent paper Grot, Rovelli, and Tate (GRT) [Phys. Rev. A 54, 4676 (1996)] derived an expression for the probability distribution $\ensuremath{\pi}(T;X)$ of intrinsic arrival times T(X)T(X)T(X) at position x=Xx=Xx=X for a quantum particle with initial wave function $\ensuremath{\psi}(x,t=0)$ freely evolving in one dimension. This was done by quantizing the classical expression for the time of arrival of a free particle at X,X,X, assuming a particular choice of operator ordering, and then regulating the resulting time of arrival operator. For the special case of a minimum-uncertainty-product wave packet at t=0t=0t=0 with average wave number 〈k〉〈k〉〈k〉 and variance $\ensuremath{\Delta}k$ they showed that their analytical expression for $\ensuremath{\pi}(T;X)$ agreed with the probability current density J(x=X,t=T)J(x=X,t=T)J(x=X,t=T) only to terms of order $\ensuremath{\Delta}k/〈k〉.$ They dismissed the probability current density as a viable candidate for the exact arrival time distribution on the grounds that it can sometimes be negative. This fact is not a problem within Bohmian mechanics where the arrival time distribution for a particle, either free or in the presence of a potential, is rigorously given by ∣J(X,T)∣|J(X,T)|∣J(X,T)∣ (suitably normalized) [W. R. McKinnon and C. R. Leavens, Phys. Rev. A 51, 2748 (1995); C. R. Leavens, Phys. Lett. A 178, 27 (1993); M. Daumer et al., in On Three Levels: The Mathematical Physics of Micro-, Meso-, and Macro-Approaches to Physics, edited by M. Fannes et al. (Plenum, New York, 1994); M. Daumer, in Bohmian Mechanics and Quantum Theory: An Appraisal, edited by J. T. Cushing et al. (Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht, 1996)]. The two theories are compared in this paper and a case presented for which the results could not differ more: According to GRT's theory, every particle in the ensemble reaches a point x=X,x=X,x=X, where $\ensuremath{\psi}(x,t)$ and J(x,t)J(x,t)J(x,t) are both zero for all t,t,t, while no particle ever reaches XXX according to the theory based on Bohmian mechanics. Some possible implications are discussed.
We are concerned with the justification of the statement, commonly (explicitly or implicitly) used in quantum scattering theory, that for a free non-relativistic quantum particle with initial wave function Ψ0(x)Ψ_0(\boldsymbol{x})Ψ0​(x), surrounded by detectors along a sphere of large radius RRR, the probability distribution of the detection time and place has asymptotic density (i.e., scattering cross section) σ(x,t)=m3ℏ−3Rt−4∣Ψ^0(mx/ℏt)∣2σ(\boldsymbol{x},t)= m^3 \hbar^{-3} R t^{-4} |\widehatΨ_0(m\boldsymbol{x}/\hbar t)|^2σ(x,t)=m3ℏ−3Rt−4∣Ψ0​(mx/ℏt)∣2 with Ψ^0\widehatΨ_0Ψ0​ the Fourier transform of Ψ0Ψ_0Ψ0​. We give two derivations of this formula, based on different macroscopic models of the detection process. The first one consists of a negative imaginary potential of strength λ>0λ>0λ>0 in the detector volume (i.e., outside the sphere of radius RRR) in the limit R→∞,λ→0,Rλ→∞R\to\infty,λ\to 0, Rλ\to \inftyR→∞,λ→0,Rλ→∞. The second one consists of repeated nearly-projective measurements of (approximately) the observable 1∣x∣>R1_{|\boldsymbol{x}|>R}1∣x∣>R​ at times T,2T,3T,…\mathscr{T},2\mathscr{T},3\mathscr{T},\ldotsT,2T,3T,… in the limit R→∞,T→∞,T/R→0R\to\infty,\mathscr{T}\to\infty,\mathscr{T}/R\to 0R→∞,T→∞,T/R→0; this setup is similar to that of the quantum Zeno effect, except that there one considers T→0\mathscr{T}\to 0T→0 instead of T→∞\mathscr{T}\to\inftyT→∞. We also provide a comparison to Bohmian mechanics: while in the absence of detectors, the arrival times and places of the Bohmian trajectories on the sphere of radius RRR have asymptotic distribution density given by the same formula as σσσ, their deviation from the detection times and places is not necessarily small, although it is small compared to RRR, so the effect of the presence of detectors on the particle can be neglected in the far-field regime. We also cover the generalization to surfaces with non-spherical shape, to the case of NNN non-interacting particles, to time-dependent surfaces, and to the Dirac equation.
We formulate quantum tunneling as a time-of-arrival problem: we determine the detection probability for particles passing through a barrier at a detector located a distance L from the tunneling region. For this purpose, we use a positive-operator-valued measure (POVM) for the time of arrival determined in C. Anastopoulos and N. Savvidou, J. Math. Phys. 47, 122106 (2006). This only depends on the initial state, the Hamiltonian, and the location of the detector. The POVM above provides a well-defined probability density and an unambiguous interpretation of all quantities involved. We demonstrate that for a class of localized initial states, the detection probability allows for an identification of tunneling time with the classic phase time. We also establish limits to the definability of tunneling time. We then generalize these results to a sequential measurement setup: the phase-space properties of the particles are determined by an unsharp sampling before their attempt to cross the barrier. For such measurements the tunneling time is defined as a genuine observable. This allows us to construct a probability distribution for its values that is definable for all initial states and potentials. We also identify a regime in which these probabilities correspond to a tunneling-time operator.
In a single-particle detection experiment, a wavefront impinges on a detector but observers only see a point response. The extent of the wavefront becomes evident only in statistical accumulation of many independent detections, with probability given by the Born rule. Drawing on concepts from quantum optics, we analyze a simple model to reverse-engineer how this behavior can come about in terms of wave mechanics alone without a measurement axiom. The model detector consists of many molecules, each of which can be resonantly excited by the incoming particle and then emit a detection signature (e.g., localized flash of light). Different molecules have different resonant energies because local conditions (proximity of other molecules, Doppler shifts, etc.) vary. The detector is thus a quasi-continuum, and the incoming particle preferentially excites the molecule that it matches most closely in energy. (In actuality, molecules can be so numerous that many could closely match the incoming particle in energy; but in that case only one will be the first, and there will be nothing left for the others by the time the first match resonates and then emits. The model does not explicitly take into account the temporal advance of the particle wave packet through the detector medium.) The excited molecule can emit a detection signature, but that process competes with fluctuation-driven dephasing. We estimate the probability that a given molecule is resonantly excited, and we also estimate the probability that a detection signature is produced before being overwhelmed by fluctuations in the detector medium. The product of these two probabilities is proportional to the absolute-square of the incoming wavefunction at the molecule in question, i.e. the Born rule. We discuss ways to probe these mechanisms experimentally, and check the model with numbers from a neutron interference experiment.
We address the question of how to compute the probability distribution of the time at which a detector clicks in the situation of nnn nonrelativistic quantum particles in a volume $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}\ensuremath{\subset}{\mathbb{R}}^{3}$ in physical space and detectors placed along the boundary $\ensuremath{\partial}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}$ of $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}$. We previously [Tumulka, Ann. Phys. (NY) 442, 168910 (2022)] argued in favor of a rule for the one-particle case that involves a Schr\"odinger equation with an absorbing boundary condition on $\ensuremath{\partial}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}$ introduced by Werner; we call this rule the ``absorbing boundary rule.'' Here, we describe the natural extension of the absorbing boundary rule to the nnn-particle case. A key element of this extension is that, upon a detection event, the wave function gets collapsed by inserting the detected position, at the time of detection, into the wave function, thus yielding a wave function of $n\ensuremath{-}1$ particles. We also describe an extension of the absorbing boundary rule to the case of moving detectors.