Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Superconductor Science and Technology

A hot-electron direct detector for radioastronomy

Boris S. Karasik, William R. McGrath, Henry George LeDuc, M. E. Gershenson

Published Nov 1, 1999• 41 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A hot-electron transition-edge superconducting bolometer with adjustable thermal relaxation speed is proposed. The bolometer contacts are made from a superconductor with high critical temperature which blocks the thermal diffusion of hot carriers into the contacts. Thus electron-phonon interaction is the only mechanism for heat removal. The speed of thermal relaxation for hot electrons in a nanometre-size superconducting bolometer with T c = 100-300 mK is controlled by the elastic electron mean free path l . The relaxation rate behaves as T 4 l at subkelvin temperatures and can be reduced by a factor of 10-100 by decreasing l . Then an antenna- or waveguide-coupled bolometer with a time constant ~10 -3 -10 -4 s will exhibit photon-noise-limited performance at millimetre and submillimetre wavelengths. The bolometer will have a figure of merit NEP 1/2 = 10 -23 -10 -22 J -1 at 100 mK which is 10 3 -10 4 times better (i.e. smaller) than that of a state-of-the-art bolometer. A tremendous increase in speed and sensitivity will have a significant impact for observational mapping applications.

DOI
10.1088/0953-2048/12/11/316

Related papers

THz Hot-Electron Photon Counter

Boris S. Karasik, Andrei V. Sergeev

We discuss an implementation of a hot-electron transition-edge sensor (TES) capable of counting THz photons. The main need for such a THz calorimeter is spectroscopy on future space telescopes with a background limited NEP/spl sim/10/sup -20/ W/Hz/sup 1/2/. The micromachined bolometers will unlikely reach such sensitivity at temperatures above 10 mK. The hot-electron TES with sufficient sensitivity will still have a time constant /spl sim/0.1-1.0 ms that is too short for integrating a flux of THz background photons arriving at a rate of <100 s/sup -1/. The Hot-Electron Photon Counter based on a submicron-size superconducting Ti bridge with Nb Andreev contacts will be able to detect individual photons above 170 GHz due to its very low heat capacity. A discrimination of the low energy fluctuations with a threshold device would allow for realization of an NEP/spl sim/10/sup -20/ W/Hz/sup 1/2/ at /spl ges/1 THz while operating at 300 mK. With the sensor time constant of a few microseconds, the dynamic range is /spl sim/30-40 dB. A compact array of the antenna-coupled counters can be fabricated on a silicon wafer without membranes.

IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity•Jun 1, 2005•34 citations

Low-Noise Wide Bandwith, Hot Electron Bolometer Mixers for Submillimeter Wavelengths

William R. McGrath

Recently a novel superconductive hot-electron micro-bolometer has been proposed which is both fast and sensitive (D. E. Prober, Appl. Phys. Lett. 62, 2119, 1993). This device has several important properties which make it useful as a heterodyne sensor for radioastronomy applications at frequencies above 1 THz. The thermal response time of the device is fast enough, several 10's of picoseconds, to allow for IF's of several GHz. This bolometer mixer should operate well up to at least 10 THz. There is no energy gap limitation as in an SIS mixer, since the mixing process relies on heating of the electron gas. In fact, rf power is absorbed more uniformly above the gap frequency. The mixer noise should be near quantum-limited, and the local oscillator (LO) power requirement is very low: / 10 nW for a Nb device. One of the unique features of this device is that it employs rapid electron diffusion into a normal metal, rather than phonon emission, as the thermal conductance that cools the heated electrons. In order for diffusion to dominate over phonon emission, the device must be short, less than 0.5.

•Sep 1, 1995•0 citations

Record-Low NEP in Hot-Electron Titanium Nanobolometers

Boris S. Karasik, David I. Olaya, Jian Wei +5 more

We are developing hot-electron superconducting transition-edge sensors (TES) capable of counting THz photons and operating at . We fabricated superconducting Ti nanosensors with Nb contacts with a volume of on planar Si substrates and have measured the thermal conductance in the material, G=4times10-3W/K at 0.3 K, caused predominantly by the weak electron-phonon coupling. The corresponding phonon-noise NEP=3times10-19W/Hz1/2. Detection of single optical photons (1550 nm and 670 nm wavelength) has been demonstrated for larger devices and yielded the thermal time constants of 30 mus at 145 mK and of 25 mus at 190 mK. This hot-electron direct detector (HEDD) is expected to have a small enough energy fluctuation noise for detecting individual photons with v>THz where NEP~3times10-20W/Hz1/2is needed for spectroscopy in space.

IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity•Jun 1, 2007•40 citations

Superconductive bolometers for submillimeter wavelengths

John L. Clarke, G. I. Hoffer, P. L. Richards +1 more

Three types of composite superconductive bolometers are described in which the temperature-sensitive element is a superconducting film at the transition temperature, a superconductor–normal metal–superconductor Josephson junction, or a superconductor–insulator–normal metal quasiparticle tunneling junction. The temperature-sensitive element is evaporated onto a sapphire substrate on the reverse side of which is a bismuth film to absorb the submillimeter radiation. The noise limitations of each type of bolometer are calculated. The fabrication and measured performance of the transition-edge bolometer and the Josephson-junction bolometer are described. The best electrical (noise-equivalent power) NEP obtained with a transition-edge bolometer fabricated on a 4×4×0.005-mm sapphire substrate is (1.7±0.1) ×10−15 W Hz−1/2 at 2 Hz at an operating temperature of 1.27 K. This NEP is within a factor of 2 of the thermal noise limit. The effective absorptivity of the bismuth film is measured to be 0.47±0.05, and the corresponding detectivity D* is calculated to be (1.1±0.1) ×1014 cm W−1 Hz1/2. Suggestions are made for further improvements in sensitivity.

Journal of Applied Physics•Dec 1, 1977•142 citations

Noise Measurements in Hot-Electron Titanium Nanobolometers

Boris S. Karasik, Sergei V. Pereverzev, David I. Olaya +3 more

We are presenting experimental results on the electrical noise in small titanium hot-electron nanobolometers with the critical temperature above 300 mK. The noise data demonstrate good agreement with the conventional bolometer theory prediction. The noise is dominated by the thermal energy fluctuations (phonon noise) when the operating temperature is set just a few mK below the superconducting transition. The corresponding noise equivalent power (NEP) is about 3 times 10-18W/Hz1/2for the smallest measured device. The relative NEP's for the two devices measured scale roughly as the square root of the device volume as one would expect from the theory. Therefore an additional factor of 2-3 reduction of NEP may be feasible if the length and width of our device are further reduced. The demonstrated combination of the low NEP and the relatively high operating temperature is attractive for submillimeter low-background applications.

IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity•Jun 1, 2009•14 citations

Fabrication and Receiver Measurements of a Diffusion-cooled Hot-electron Bolometer at 800 GHz

J. Stodolka, Kristof J. P. Jacobs

We present a fabrication process for diffusion-cooled niobium hot-electron bolometers using a self-aligned process with gold as an initial protection layer and aluminum as an etch mask that is removed by a wet etch. This process proves to be reproducible and has a yield of ~70 % per batch. Great care has been taken to avoid processing temperatures above 120 °C to minimize degradation of the Nb film. We have performed heterodyne measurements of an HEB in a fixed tuned waveguide mixer at 804 GHz and at an IF-range from 1-2 GHz. The approximate dimensions of the bridge are 240 x 200 x 14 nm3. The Niobium bridge has a critical temperature of 6.0 K and a normal state resistance of 16.5 Ω. A standard Y-factor measurement leads to a minimum noise temperature of 1200 K at 1 GHz IF. The coupled LO-power is estimated by the isothermal method to be 21 nW. Introduction Superconducting Hot-Electron-Bolometers (HEB) utilizing thin superconducting films have become established as sensitive mixers in the THz region. The thermal response time τ can be very small if the superconductor is thin enough that only the electron gas is heated and the cooling is fast enough. The bolometers described in this paper are cooled by out-diffusion of the hot electrons in normal conducting heat sinks (diffusion-cooled HEB) rather than interactions with phonons of the lattice (phononcooled HEB) [1]. To meet the requirements for astronomical applications such as SOFIA, thermal response times down to several picoseconds are needed to get intermediate frequencies up to 10 GHz. Because of τ ~ L [1] the dimensions of the bolometer bridge have to be very small. We have fabricated diffusion-cooled HEBs with short (L<300 nm) and narrow (<200 nm) bridges consisting of thin (10-14 nm) Niobium (Nb) on z-cut quartz substrates. The normal conducting heat sinks consist of 70 nm Gold (Au). In the following paragraph 1 e-mail: stodolka@ph1.uni-koeln.de we discuss problems and merits of several approaches for the fabrication of diffusioncooled HEBs. Device Fabrication Aside from a good reproducibility, the essential requirement for the fabrication of a diffusion-cooled HEB is a good transparency of the interface between the heat sinks and the material of the bolometer bridge. A thermal resistance results in a slower out-diffusion of the hot electrons and thus increases the effective bridge length and thermal response time. Defining the bolometer bridge by lift-off with subsequent deposition of the heat sinks (Fig. 1) [2] has the major disadvantage of high requirements for the overlap accuracy of the Electron-Beam-Lithography (EBL) system to position the heat sinks on the contact areas of the bridge. A solution is offered by the self-aligned process (Fig. 2). Here, the substrate is covered with a blanket layer of Nb. The heat sinks and a metal strip of the width of the bolometer bridge are deposited in succession. The bridge is now etched out of the blanket layer by using reactive ion etching (RIE) where the heat sinks and the metal strip serve as etch masks: the spacing between the heat sinks determines the bridge length while the metal strip defines the width. The overlap between Nb and Au heat sinks is large. Fig. 1: Outline of HEB fabrication by lift off (top view) a) Bolometer bridge defined by liftoff. b) Deposition of the heat sinks. The contact area (shaded) to the heat sinks is small. bolometer bridge

•Dec 1, 2001•2 citations
A hot-electron transition-edge superconducting bolometer with adjustable thermal relaxation speed is proposed. The bolometer contacts are made from a superconductor with high critical temperature which blocks the thermal diffusion of hot carriers into the contacts. Thus electron-phonon interaction is the only mechanism for heat removal. The speed of thermal relaxation for hot electrons in a nanometre-size superconducting bolometer with T c = 100-300 mK is controlled by the elastic electron mean free path l . The relaxation rate behaves as T 4 l at subkelvin temperatures and can be reduced by a factor of 10-100 by decreasing l . Then an antenna- or waveguide-coupled bolometer with a time constant ~10 -3 -10 -4 s will exhibit photon-noise-limited performance at millimetre and submillimetre wavelengths. The bolometer will have a figure of merit NEP 1/2 = 10 -23 -10 -22 J -1 at 100 mK which is 10 3 -10 4 times better (i.e. smaller) than that of a state-of-the-art bolometer. A tremendous increase in speed and sensitivity will have a significant impact for observational mapping applications.
We discuss an implementation of a hot-electron transition-edge sensor (TES) capable of counting THz photons. The main need for such a THz calorimeter is spectroscopy on future space telescopes with a background limited NEP/spl sim/10/sup -20/ W/Hz/sup 1/2/. The micromachined bolometers will unlikely reach such sensitivity at temperatures above 10 mK. The hot-electron TES with sufficient sensitivity will still have a time constant /spl sim/0.1-1.0 ms that is too short for integrating a flux of THz background photons arriving at a rate of <100 s/sup -1/. The Hot-Electron Photon Counter based on a submicron-size superconducting Ti bridge with Nb Andreev contacts will be able to detect individual photons above 170 GHz due to its very low heat capacity. A discrimination of the low energy fluctuations with a threshold device would allow for realization of an NEP/spl sim/10/sup -20/ W/Hz/sup 1/2/ at /spl ges/1 THz while operating at 300 mK. With the sensor time constant of a few microseconds, the dynamic range is /spl sim/30-40 dB. A compact array of the antenna-coupled counters can be fabricated on a silicon wafer without membranes.
Recently a novel superconductive hot-electron micro-bolometer has been proposed which is both fast and sensitive (D. E. Prober, Appl. Phys. Lett. 62, 2119, 1993). This device has several important properties which make it useful as a heterodyne sensor for radioastronomy applications at frequencies above 1 THz. The thermal response time of the device is fast enough, several 10's of picoseconds, to allow for IF's of several GHz. This bolometer mixer should operate well up to at least 10 THz. There is no energy gap limitation as in an SIS mixer, since the mixing process relies on heating of the electron gas. In fact, rf power is absorbed more uniformly above the gap frequency. The mixer noise should be near quantum-limited, and the local oscillator (LO) power requirement is very low: / 10 nW for a Nb device. One of the unique features of this device is that it employs rapid electron diffusion into a normal metal, rather than phonon emission, as the thermal conductance that cools the heated electrons. In order for diffusion to dominate over phonon emission, the device must be short, less than 0.5.
We are developing hot-electron superconducting transition-edge sensors (TES) capable of counting THz photons and operating at . We fabricated superconducting Ti nanosensors with Nb contacts with a volume of on planar Si substrates and have measured the thermal conductance in the material, G=4times10-3W/K at 0.3 K, caused predominantly by the weak electron-phonon coupling. The corresponding phonon-noise NEP=3times10-19W/Hz1/2. Detection of single optical photons (1550 nm and 670 nm wavelength) has been demonstrated for larger devices and yielded the thermal time constants of 30 mus at 145 mK and of 25 mus at 190 mK. This hot-electron direct detector (HEDD) is expected to have a small enough energy fluctuation noise for detecting individual photons with v>THz where NEP~3times10-20W/Hz1/2is needed for spectroscopy in space.
Three types of composite superconductive bolometers are described in which the temperature-sensitive element is a superconducting film at the transition temperature, a superconductor–normal metal–superconductor Josephson junction, or a superconductor–insulator–normal metal quasiparticle tunneling junction. The temperature-sensitive element is evaporated onto a sapphire substrate on the reverse side of which is a bismuth film to absorb the submillimeter radiation. The noise limitations of each type of bolometer are calculated. The fabrication and measured performance of the transition-edge bolometer and the Josephson-junction bolometer are described. The best electrical (noise-equivalent power) NEP obtained with a transition-edge bolometer fabricated on a 4×4×0.005-mm sapphire substrate is (1.7±0.1) ×10−15 W Hz−1/2 at 2 Hz at an operating temperature of 1.27 K. This NEP is within a factor of 2 of the thermal noise limit. The effective absorptivity of the bismuth film is measured to be 0.47±0.05, and the corresponding detectivity D* is calculated to be (1.1±0.1) ×1014 cm W−1 Hz1/2. Suggestions are made for further improvements in sensitivity.
We are presenting experimental results on the electrical noise in small titanium hot-electron nanobolometers with the critical temperature above 300 mK. The noise data demonstrate good agreement with the conventional bolometer theory prediction. The noise is dominated by the thermal energy fluctuations (phonon noise) when the operating temperature is set just a few mK below the superconducting transition. The corresponding noise equivalent power (NEP) is about 3 times 10-18W/Hz1/2for the smallest measured device. The relative NEP's for the two devices measured scale roughly as the square root of the device volume as one would expect from the theory. Therefore an additional factor of 2-3 reduction of NEP may be feasible if the length and width of our device are further reduced. The demonstrated combination of the low NEP and the relatively high operating temperature is attractive for submillimeter low-background applications.
We present a fabrication process for diffusion-cooled niobium hot-electron bolometers using a self-aligned process with gold as an initial protection layer and aluminum as an etch mask that is removed by a wet etch. This process proves to be reproducible and has a yield of ~70 % per batch. Great care has been taken to avoid processing temperatures above 120 °C to minimize degradation of the Nb film. We have performed heterodyne measurements of an HEB in a fixed tuned waveguide mixer at 804 GHz and at an IF-range from 1-2 GHz. The approximate dimensions of the bridge are 240 x 200 x 14 nm3. The Niobium bridge has a critical temperature of 6.0 K and a normal state resistance of 16.5 Ω. A standard Y-factor measurement leads to a minimum noise temperature of 1200 K at 1 GHz IF. The coupled LO-power is estimated by the isothermal method to be 21 nW. Introduction Superconducting Hot-Electron-Bolometers (HEB) utilizing thin superconducting films have become established as sensitive mixers in the THz region. The thermal response time τ can be very small if the superconductor is thin enough that only the electron gas is heated and the cooling is fast enough. The bolometers described in this paper are cooled by out-diffusion of the hot electrons in normal conducting heat sinks (diffusion-cooled HEB) rather than interactions with phonons of the lattice (phononcooled HEB) [1]. To meet the requirements for astronomical applications such as SOFIA, thermal response times down to several picoseconds are needed to get intermediate frequencies up to 10 GHz. Because of τ ~ L [1] the dimensions of the bolometer bridge have to be very small. We have fabricated diffusion-cooled HEBs with short (L<300 nm) and narrow (<200 nm) bridges consisting of thin (10-14 nm) Niobium (Nb) on z-cut quartz substrates. The normal conducting heat sinks consist of 70 nm Gold (Au). In the following paragraph 1 e-mail: stodolka@ph1.uni-koeln.de we discuss problems and merits of several approaches for the fabrication of diffusioncooled HEBs. Device Fabrication Aside from a good reproducibility, the essential requirement for the fabrication of a diffusion-cooled HEB is a good transparency of the interface between the heat sinks and the material of the bolometer bridge. A thermal resistance results in a slower out-diffusion of the hot electrons and thus increases the effective bridge length and thermal response time. Defining the bolometer bridge by lift-off with subsequent deposition of the heat sinks (Fig. 1) [2] has the major disadvantage of high requirements for the overlap accuracy of the Electron-Beam-Lithography (EBL) system to position the heat sinks on the contact areas of the bridge. A solution is offered by the self-aligned process (Fig. 2). Here, the substrate is covered with a blanket layer of Nb. The heat sinks and a metal strip of the width of the bolometer bridge are deposited in succession. The bridge is now etched out of the blanket layer by using reactive ion etching (RIE) where the heat sinks and the metal strip serve as etch masks: the spacing between the heat sinks determines the bridge length while the metal strip defines the width. The overlap between Nb and Au heat sinks is large. Fig. 1: Outline of HEB fabrication by lift off (top view) a) Bolometer bridge defined by liftoff. b) Deposition of the heat sinks. The contact area (shaded) to the heat sinks is small. bolometer bridge