Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

Comment on ‘‘Three perspectives on Schrödinger’s cat’’ [Am. J. Phys. 5 2, 1089 (1984)]

L. E. Ballentine

Published Oct 1, 1986• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Since the purpose of the paper1 in question was to examine the responses to Schrödinger’s cat paradox that are engendered by three particular approaches to quantum mechanics, it is appropriate to comment only on the extent to which the given responses do indeed represent the views of proponents of the various interpretations. For the cases of quantum logic and the many worlds interpretation, I believe that the author has indeed captured the essence of a response that a supporter of that interpretation would give. But I should hope that a supporter of the Copenhagen interpretation would not give the response attributed to him, for it completely misses the point.

DOI
10.1119/1.14799

Related papers

Three perspectives on Schrödinger’s cat

John G. Loeser

The resolutions to the paradox of Schrödinger’s cat engendered by three major perspectives on quantum mechanics—quantum logic, the many worlds interpretation, and the Copenhagen interpretation—are discussed. The core of each perspective is revealed in the process. Each resolution to Schrödinger’s cat has a counterpart which solves the logical paradox known as the unexpected hanging. The rather striking parallels serve to emphasize several points. First, the quantum paradox is an epistemological and not a physical one. Second, the three interpretations mentioned, unlike some others, are faithful to this understanding. And third, the pitfalls in these two paradoxes have a somewhat universal character.

American Journal of Physics•Dec 1, 1984•4 citations

Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics

F. J. Duarte

Mainly due to the EPR trio having declared quantum mechanics as ‘not complete’ and given the acid criticisms of Schrödinger, including his famous cat paradox , many physicists felt encouraged to introduce new interpretations to confront a vaguely assembled orthodox interpretation . Indeed, there are numerous interpretations of quantum mechanics, so numerous that we have decided not to even enter into the interpretational arena, leaving that to the professionals and citing their encyclopedic works instead. In this regard, we are compelled to quote Dyson: ‘We still have passionate arguments between believers of various interpretations… The reason for these arguments is that various interpreters are trying to describe the quantum world in words… and the language is inappropriate for the purpose.’ Here, a humble approach to this subject is taken whilst opting for pragmatism.

CRC Press eBooks•Apr 10, 2026•0 citations

On the Interpretation of Schodincer's Cat Paradox: the Standard Quantum Logic Approach

Wipsar Sunu Brams Dwandaru, Maskur Rosyid, D S. Palupi

This paper discusses the classical paradox of Schrodinger's cat, based on the notion of standard quantum logic. This paper does not claim that the discussion given is the right One, bUt, it will directs its points of view more towards the truth-value (given by the probability-value) of the propositions which arises from the description of the paradox under consideration.\n\nKeywords: SchrOdinger's Cat paradox, standard quantum logic\n\n\n\n\n\n\n.

Jurnal Fisika Indonesia•Jan 1, 2004•0 citations

The paradox of Schrodinger's cat

C N Villars

Erwin Schrodinger first described the thought-experiment which has since become known as 'the paradox of Schrodinger's cat' 51 years ago. In recent years, popular accounts of quantum mechanics have tended to adopt one or other of the philosophically most extreme solutions to this paradox, i.e. the consciousness hypothesis or the many worlds interpretation. The author attempts to redress the balance by describing what he takes to be the orthodox solution to the paradox which explains the paradox, without recourse to such counterintuitive notions as a cat simultaneously dead and alive or a universe continually splitting into multiple worlds, as being due to a misapplication of the quantum formalism.

Physics Education•Jul 1, 1986•8 citations

Reply to "Comment on ‘Association between quantum paradoxes based on weak values and a realistic interpretation of quantum measurements’"

Anonymous

Physical Review A•May 12, 2025•0 citations

Two Paradoxes in Quantum Mechanics

Henry Krips

The purpose of this paper is to resolve two paradoxes, which occur in quantum theory, by using the discussion of the theory of measurement presented in two earlier papers by the author [3], [4], [5]. The two paradoxes discussed will be the Schrödinger cat paradox and the Einstein, Podolski, Rosen paradox [2]. An introductory section will be included which summarizes the relevant results from the author's previous papers. Also a discussion will be made regarding the author's interpretation of the density operator.

Philosophy of Science•Jun 1, 1969•21 citations
Since the purpose of the paper1 in question was to examine the responses to Schrödinger’s cat paradox that are engendered by three particular approaches to quantum mechanics, it is appropriate to comment only on the extent to which the given responses do indeed represent the views of proponents of the various interpretations. For the cases of quantum logic and the many worlds interpretation, I believe that the author has indeed captured the essence of a response that a supporter of that interpretation would give. But I should hope that a supporter of the Copenhagen interpretation would not give the response attributed to him, for it completely misses the point.
The resolutions to the paradox of Schrödinger’s cat engendered by three major perspectives on quantum mechanics—quantum logic, the many worlds interpretation, and the Copenhagen interpretation—are discussed. The core of each perspective is revealed in the process. Each resolution to Schrödinger’s cat has a counterpart which solves the logical paradox known as the unexpected hanging. The rather striking parallels serve to emphasize several points. First, the quantum paradox is an epistemological and not a physical one. Second, the three interpretations mentioned, unlike some others, are faithful to this understanding. And third, the pitfalls in these two paradoxes have a somewhat universal character.
Mainly due to the EPR trio having declared quantum mechanics as ‘not complete’ and given the acid criticisms of Schrödinger, including his famous cat paradox , many physicists felt encouraged to introduce new interpretations to confront a vaguely assembled orthodox interpretation . Indeed, there are numerous interpretations of quantum mechanics, so numerous that we have decided not to even enter into the interpretational arena, leaving that to the professionals and citing their encyclopedic works instead. In this regard, we are compelled to quote Dyson: ‘We still have passionate arguments between believers of various interpretations… The reason for these arguments is that various interpreters are trying to describe the quantum world in words… and the language is inappropriate for the purpose.’ Here, a humble approach to this subject is taken whilst opting for pragmatism.
Erwin Schrodinger first described the thought-experiment which has since become known as 'the paradox of Schrodinger's cat' 51 years ago. In recent years, popular accounts of quantum mechanics have tended to adopt one or other of the philosophically most extreme solutions to this paradox, i.e. the consciousness hypothesis or the many worlds interpretation. The author attempts to redress the balance by describing what he takes to be the orthodox solution to the paradox which explains the paradox, without recourse to such counterintuitive notions as a cat simultaneously dead and alive or a universe continually splitting into multiple worlds, as being due to a misapplication of the quantum formalism.
The purpose of this paper is to resolve two paradoxes, which occur in quantum theory, by using the discussion of the theory of measurement presented in two earlier papers by the author [3], [4], [5]. The two paradoxes discussed will be the Schrödinger cat paradox and the Einstein, Podolski, Rosen paradox [2]. An introductory section will be included which summarizes the relevant results from the author's previous papers. Also a discussion will be made regarding the author's interpretation of the density operator.