Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Progress of Theoretical Physics

Singularity of Nonlinear Response near the Critical Field. I: Static Case

Masuo Suzuki

Published Nov 1, 1969• 9 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Phenomenological arguments are presented to clarify the singularity of static nonlinear response near the critical magnetic (or electric) field Hc. The singularity of nonlinear susceptibility χ(H) is connected with the expansion of the free energy Φ(m) as a function of a quantity (mc - m), where m is the normalized magnetization and mc its value at the critical field; i.e. if Φ(m) = a0 - a1(mc - m) + a2(mc - m)ψ…, then χ(H) ∼1/(Hc - H)γH; γH = (ψ- 2)/(ψ- 1). That is, for 1 ≪ ψ≪ 2, χ(H) is continuous, for ψ= 2, it is finite but discontinuous at H = Hc, and for ψ> 2, it is divergent. The index γH(or γE) is investigated in the one-dimensional exactly soluble magnetic systems at T = 0 and the two-dimensional ferroelectric (KDP) models at finite temperature. The value of γH is zero for a fermion system with repulsive delta-function interaction. γH is equal to 1/2 for the antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model. In the Hubbard model, γH is equal to 1/2 in the case of half-filled band, and γH is always zero other-wise. In the general two-dimensional ferroelectric models, there exists no critical electric field, though the Wu model has a critical field Ec with γE = 1/2.

DOI
10.1143/ptp.42.1076

Related papers

On the Singularity of Dynamical Response and Critical Slowing Down

Masuo Suzuki

Phenomenological arguments on the critical slowing down is presented and “similarity law” is proposed on the indices of the critical slowing down. The similarity law is confirmed in linear spin chains near the critical field and in the kinetic Ising model near the critical temperature. It is exactly shown in the linear spin chains that the critical index of slowing down is different from that of the static susceptibility and that the dynamical susceptibility has a logarithmic singularity with respect to the frequency at the critical field and at zero temperature.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Apr 1, 1970•45 citations

Quantum effects in the critical properties of the X-Y model in a transverse magnetic field: crossover scaling near zero temperature

Paul R. Gerber

The susceptibility of a quantum X-Y model in a transverse field Gamma is studied in the vicinity of the multicritical point ( Gamma c ,T=0). For dimensions d between two and four we obtain a Hartree type approximation an equation for the corresponding crossover function which is solvable analytically in three dimensions. The critical line Gamma c (T)- Gamma c (0) approximately T psi is asymptotically described by the shift exponent psi =d/2 in accord with self-consistent spin wave theory. For the variable of the crossover scaling function T/( Gamma - Gamma c (T)) phi one obtains the crossover exponent phi =(4-d)/2 which is characteristic for the Gaussian multicritical point. A dimensional-analysis argument suggests that this is valid beyond the approximation.

Journal of Physics C Solid State Physics•Dec 24, 1978•18 citations

Exponents far from Tcfor ferromagnets with second-neighbour interactions and for the Baxter-Wu model

M. Fähnle, R. Beutler, David W. Wood

The temperature dependence of the paramagnetic zero-field susceptibility chi is calculated for the second-neighbour S=1/2 Heisenberg model and for the Baxter-Wu model, from Pade approximants to existing high-temperature series expansions and by Monte Carlo simulations. The data are well represented by a power law chi T=(t')-y using the critical susceptibility exponent gamma over the whole paramagnetic temperature range when a nonlinear scaling variable t' is used; namely t'=1-Tc/T for the second-neighbour models and t'=1-(Tc/T)2 for the Baxter-Wu model.

Journal of Physics Condensed Matter•Jan 29, 1990•1 citation

Critical behaviour of the Ising model above and below the critical temperature

J W Essam, D L Hunter

Previous series expansion studies of the magnetization and susceptibility of the Ising model are extended to the higher derivatives of the free energy with respect to the magnetic field. It is found that just above the critical temperature the 2 n th derivative is given by where in two dimensions γ = 1¾, Δ = 1fraction seven-eighths and in three dimensions γ = 1¼, Δ = 1fraction nine-sixteens. In two dimensions γ is exact and Δ is correct to 0.6%; the three-dimensional indices are correct to 0.2%. Just below the critical temperature where in three dimensions 0.303 <or= β <or= 0.318 and 1·55 <or= Δprime <or= 1.65. If the even derivatives are to have the same index above and below T c , then β = fraction five-sixteens and Δprime = 1fraction nine-sixteens. The latter index lies very close to the lower limit so that, although we cannot rule out Δprime = Δ, Δprime = 1fraction five-eighths is not unlikely. In two dimensions our results are consistent with linearity of the index and, if this is assumed, then β = fraction one-eighths and Δprime = 1fraction seven-eighths exactly and there is symmetry about T c . The amplitudes C 2 n + and C n - are estimated for n = 1 to 6.

Journal of Physics C Solid State Physics•Apr 1, 1968•80 citations

Universal logarithmic temperature dependence of magnetic susceptibility of one-dimensional electrons at critical values of magnetic field

T. Vekua

We study the leading low-temperature dependence of magnetic susceptibility of one-dimensional electrons with a fixed total number of particles at the magnetic fields equal to zero-temperature critical values where the magnetic field induces commensurate-incommensurate quantum phase transitions. For free and repulsively interacting electrons there is only one such critical field corresponding to the transition to the fully polarized state. For attractively interacting electrons besides saturation field there is another critical field equal to the spin gap where zero-temperature magnetization sets in. For all cases, except for the lattice models at half filling, the magnetic susceptibility at critical values of magnetic field has a universal logarithmic temperature dependence, $\ensuremath{\chi}(T)=\ensuremath{\chi}(0)(1+2/ln\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}T+\ensuremath{\cdots})$ for $T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$.

arXiv:1402.6801•Physical Review B•Mar 25, 2014•3 citations

EXACT GROUND-STATE PROPERTIES OF ONE-DIMENSIONAL HUBBARD MODEL IN THE PRESENCE OF MAGNETIC FIELD

Chia‐Wei Yang, ARMEN N. KOCHARIAN, Y. L. Chiang

The exact phase diagram and the ground-state properties of the one-dimensional Hubbard model with arbitrary on-site interaction of electrons are calculated over a wide range of magnetic field and electron concentrations by means of the Bethe-ansatz formalism. The ground-state properties, including the total energy, the average spin (magnetization) and spin (magnetic) susceptibility are investigated for both signs of the interaction strength U/t. The critical behavior near the onset of magnetization and magnetic saturation are also analyzed. At the onset of magnetization and near the magnetic saturation the spin susceptibility χ diverges at all U/t for half-filling case n=1, whereas for n≠1 it is always finite. The reverse susceptibility χ-1(U) exhibits anomalous hump, which increases with h or n, and shows discontinuity as U/t→±0 at infinitesimal h→0. The analytical results for the ground-state properties in strong and weak interaction limits are in full agreement with our numerical calculations.

International Journal of Modern Physics B•Dec 20, 1999•0 citations
Phenomenological arguments are presented to clarify the singularity of static nonlinear response near the critical magnetic (or electric) field Hc. The singularity of nonlinear susceptibility χ(H) is connected with the expansion of the free energy Φ(m) as a function of a quantity (mc - m), where m is the normalized magnetization and mc its value at the critical field; i.e. if Φ(m) = a0 - a1(mc - m) + a2(mc - m)ψ…, then χ(H) ∼1/(Hc - H)γH; γH = (ψ- 2)/(ψ- 1). That is, for 1 ≪ ψ≪ 2, χ(H) is continuous, for ψ= 2, it is finite but discontinuous at H = Hc, and for ψ> 2, it is divergent. The index γH(or γE) is investigated in the one-dimensional exactly soluble magnetic systems at T = 0 and the two-dimensional ferroelectric (KDP) models at finite temperature. The value of γH is zero for a fermion system with repulsive delta-function interaction. γH is equal to 1/2 for the antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model. In the Hubbard model, γH is equal to 1/2 in the case of half-filled band, and γH is always zero other-wise. In the general two-dimensional ferroelectric models, there exists no critical electric field, though the Wu model has a critical field Ec with γE = 1/2.
Phenomenological arguments on the critical slowing down is presented and “similarity law” is proposed on the indices of the critical slowing down. The similarity law is confirmed in linear spin chains near the critical field and in the kinetic Ising model near the critical temperature. It is exactly shown in the linear spin chains that the critical index of slowing down is different from that of the static susceptibility and that the dynamical susceptibility has a logarithmic singularity with respect to the frequency at the critical field and at zero temperature.
The susceptibility of a quantum X-Y model in a transverse field Gamma is studied in the vicinity of the multicritical point ( Gamma c ,T=0). For dimensions d between two and four we obtain a Hartree type approximation an equation for the corresponding crossover function which is solvable analytically in three dimensions. The critical line Gamma c (T)- Gamma c (0) approximately T psi is asymptotically described by the shift exponent psi =d/2 in accord with self-consistent spin wave theory. For the variable of the crossover scaling function T/( Gamma - Gamma c (T)) phi one obtains the crossover exponent phi =(4-d)/2 which is characteristic for the Gaussian multicritical point. A dimensional-analysis argument suggests that this is valid beyond the approximation.
The temperature dependence of the paramagnetic zero-field susceptibility chi is calculated for the second-neighbour S=1/2 Heisenberg model and for the Baxter-Wu model, from Pade approximants to existing high-temperature series expansions and by Monte Carlo simulations. The data are well represented by a power law chi T=(t')-y using the critical susceptibility exponent gamma over the whole paramagnetic temperature range when a nonlinear scaling variable t' is used; namely t'=1-Tc/T for the second-neighbour models and t'=1-(Tc/T)2 for the Baxter-Wu model.
Previous series expansion studies of the magnetization and susceptibility of the Ising model are extended to the higher derivatives of the free energy with respect to the magnetic field. It is found that just above the critical temperature the 2 n th derivative is given by where in two dimensions γ = 1¾, Δ = 1fraction seven-eighths and in three dimensions γ = 1¼, Δ = 1fraction nine-sixteens. In two dimensions γ is exact and Δ is correct to 0.6%; the three-dimensional indices are correct to 0.2%. Just below the critical temperature where in three dimensions 0.303 <or= β <or= 0.318 and 1·55 <or= Δprime <or= 1.65. If the even derivatives are to have the same index above and below T c , then β = fraction five-sixteens and Δprime = 1fraction nine-sixteens. The latter index lies very close to the lower limit so that, although we cannot rule out Δprime = Δ, Δprime = 1fraction five-eighths is not unlikely. In two dimensions our results are consistent with linearity of the index and, if this is assumed, then β = fraction one-eighths and Δprime = 1fraction seven-eighths exactly and there is symmetry about T c . The amplitudes C 2 n + and C n - are estimated for n = 1 to 6.
We study the leading low-temperature dependence of magnetic susceptibility of one-dimensional electrons with a fixed total number of particles at the magnetic fields equal to zero-temperature critical values where the magnetic field induces commensurate-incommensurate quantum phase transitions. For free and repulsively interacting electrons there is only one such critical field corresponding to the transition to the fully polarized state. For attractively interacting electrons besides saturation field there is another critical field equal to the spin gap where zero-temperature magnetization sets in. For all cases, except for the lattice models at half filling, the magnetic susceptibility at critical values of magnetic field has a universal logarithmic temperature dependence, $\ensuremath{\chi}(T)=\ensuremath{\chi}(0)(1+2/ln\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}T+\ensuremath{\cdots})$ for $T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$.
The exact phase diagram and the ground-state properties of the one-dimensional Hubbard model with arbitrary on-site interaction of electrons are calculated over a wide range of magnetic field and electron concentrations by means of the Bethe-ansatz formalism. The ground-state properties, including the total energy, the average spin (magnetization) and spin (magnetic) susceptibility are investigated for both signs of the interaction strength U/t. The critical behavior near the onset of magnetization and magnetic saturation are also analyzed. At the onset of magnetization and near the magnetic saturation the spin susceptibility χ diverges at all U/t for half-filling case n=1, whereas for n≠1 it is always finite. The reverse susceptibility χ-1(U) exhibits anomalous hump, which increases with h or n, and shows discontinuity as U/t→±0 at infinitesimal h→0. The analytical results for the ground-state properties in strong and weak interaction limits are in full agreement with our numerical calculations.