Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Progress of Theoretical Physics Supplement

Non-Equilibrium Phase Transitions in Cooperative Atomic Systems

Daniel F. Walls, P. D. Drummond, Saad S. M. Hassan, H. J. Carmichael

Published Jan 1, 1978• 89 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We consider N two level atoms driven far from equilibrium by a coherent driving field. The atoms may decay by a cooperative (J2 preserving) mechanism or a non-cooperative (J2 non-conserving) mechanism where J is the atomic pseudo angular momentum. We adopt a mean field theory to study the J2 non-conserving interaction. This indicates that the system displays a first order phase transition in several observables, e.g., mean field, spectrum and photon statistics. The two stable branches of the hysteresis curve are shown to be regions of cooperative and non-cooperative behaviour respectively. In the case of cooperative atomic decays we find a solution to the Fokker-Planck equation in the atomic coherent state representation. This predicts a second order phase transition in atomic observables—a cooperative fluorescent critical point.

DOI
10.1143/ptps.64.307

Related papers

Cooperative fluorescence from N coherently driven two-level atoms

Daniel F. Walls

Considers a system of N coherently driven two-level atoms contained in a volume with dimensions much smaller than a wavelength. The atoms may decay by a completely cooperative mechanism which conserves (J 2 ), alternatively they may decay by a mechanism which fails to conserve (J 2 ). The steady-state behaviour in each case is determined using the single-atom solutions together with two limiting approximations: (a) complete atomic correlation, (b) no atomic correlation. In case (a) a behaviour characteristic of a second-order phase transition is obtained while in case (b) a first-order phase transition results.

Journal of Physics B Atomic and Molecular Physics•May 28, 1980•28 citations

Hysteresis in the spectrum for cooperative resonance fluorescence

H. J. Carmichael, Daniel F. Walls

Analytic results for the fluorescent spectrum arising in the cooperative interaction of a population of two-level atoms, driven by resonant laser radiation with the electromagnetic field are presented. The bistability and hysteresis characterising single-time atomic averages are evidenced explicitly as this spectrum is viewed throughout a hysteresis cycle. In the region of bistability full support is given to the designation of a cooperative and a non-cooperative branch. Spectral features reveal linewidths associated with cooperative and non-cooperative atomic decay rates respectively. A dominant feature is strong coherent scattering throughout the cooperative region, fully supporting an identification of this problem with super-radiant phenomena. Linewidth narrowing is predicted in the vicinity of both instabilities.

Journal of Physics B Atomic and Molecular Physics•Dec 21, 1977•64 citations

Cooperative non-equilibrium dynamics in a thermal Rydberg ensemble

Christopher W. Carr

This thesis reports the investigation of cooperative non-equilibrium dynamics in a thermal Rydberg ensemble. Cooperative behaviour arises due to resonant dipole-dipole interactions between highly excited Rydberg atoms. In order to transfer atomic population from the ground state to the Rydberg state in a caesium vapour, a three-photon excitation scheme is developed. This scheme has a number of benefits over traditional two-photon Rydberg excitation as each transition utilises in- expensive high-power diode lasers. The process of developing the excitation scheme produces a number of important results, including an excited-state polarisation spectroscopy technique and the observation of coherent three-photon electromagnetically induced transparency. The optical response and atomic dynamics of the interacting ensemble can be separated into two distinct phases. When the Rydberg number density is low and the interactions are negligible, the system can be described by the behaviour of a single atom. However, when the Rydberg number density is high, resonant dipole-dipole interactions result in a significant modification of the ensemble properties. This cooperative many-body phase cannot be described by the behaviour of a single atom. In the frequency domain, the interactions produce an excitation-dependent cooperative energy shift that is observed using probe transmission spectroscopy. In the time domain, the interactions result in a cooperative enhancement of the atomic decay rate that is analysed using fluorescence spectroscopy. At the transition between the single-body and many-body phase, a first-order non-equilibrium phase transition occurs. This is observed spatially along the length of the excitation region as a sharp switch in the emitted fluorescence. The first-order phase transition is also observed in the temporal response of the ensemble through critical slowing down. The divergence of the switching time to steady state follows a universal scaling law for phase transitions and the determined critical exponent is in excellent agreement with previous work on non-equilibrium phase transitions.

•Jan 1, 2013•1 citation

Analytical and numerical results for the steady state in cooperative resonance fluorescence

H. J. Carmichael

The cooperative resonance fluorescence steady state is discussed within the context of an operator master equation which conserves total pseudospin. Emphasis throughout is on quantum fluctuations and their significance in relation to a background of factorised dynamics. Atom-atom correlations are shown to play a fundamental role for systems driven beyond the linear regime. Use of the atomic coherent state representation yields a Fokker-Planck description closely allied to the dynamics for a classical angular momentum oscillator. For intense incident fields the quantum-mechanical steady state is understood in terms of diffusion both around and between classical trajectories on the Bloch sphere. In the limit of infinite systems simple closed-form expressions for steady-state features are derived. Coherent and incoherent fluorescent intensities are obtained together with the second-order correlation function for fluorescent light. Specific features are illustrated by numerical results for systems of from two to fifty atoms.

Journal of Physics B Atomic and Molecular Physics•Sep 28, 1980•86 citations

Nonequilibrium transitions in quantum optical systems

P. D. Drummond

The topic of this thesis is a theoretical study of nonequilibrium transitions and quantum statistical properties of nonlinear quantum optical systems driven by an external radiation source. In certain limiting cases, a comparison is made between these transitions and the phase transitions found in equilibrium physical systems. In chapters one and two, the mathematical tools are introduced. In operator terms, the time development is described by a Markovian master equation in the interaction picture. This is equivalent to a corresponding time development equation or Fokker-Planck equation in a vector space of c-numbers. In order to deal with the type of Fokker-Planck equation that results, we introduce a quantum classical correspondence resulting in a distribution function over a complex phase-space, which is a generalisation of the Glauber-Sudarshan P-function. In chapter three this is applied to a model of a coherently driven mode with nonlinear dispersion and absorption. We find in the limit of zero temperature, that the spectrum is symmetric relative to the input frequency, and an exact solution is obtained for the distribution function. For a detuned driving field and nonlinear dispersion, optical bistability can occur. In chapter four a model of sub/second harmonic generation is introduced. This has several non-equilibrium transitions, including dispersive optical bistability, and bistable behaviour with coherent phase-locked input to both modes. Exact solutions occur in the limit of zero temperature and adiabatic elimination of one mode. In both chapters three and four, steady-state photon anti-bunching occurs with an absorptive nonlinearity. In chapter five we include interactions between the radiation mode and a fluorescent atomic system. In this case different behaviour occurs depending on the relative decay rates of the individual atoms and of the radiation mode. In the case of a high-Q interferometer, the atomic variables can be adiabatically eliminated. Both dispersive and absorptive bistability can occur. We show by analytic and numerical calculations (in the case of inhomogeneous broadening) that dispersive operation has advantages in requiring a lower atomic density and input field to observe bistability. When the input field has Gaussian (rather than coherent) photon statistics, there is no bistability, but enhanced photon bunching occurs. Finally, there is a different type of behaviour when the field mode decays rapidly and can be adiabatically eliminated. Within the cooperation lifetime the system can be described by a J²-invariant Hamiltonian, giving the special case of only collective damping. The result is a new type of critical point transition in the thermodynamic limit, with the appearance of a family of solutions like Lotka-Volterra cycles for a coherent driving field above threshold.

•Jan 1, 1979•0 citations

Superradiant phase transition in a large interacting driven atomic ensemble in free space

Janne Ruostekoski

Atoms strongly interacting with light constitute rich quantum-optical systems with the potential for observing cooperative effects and dissipative nonequilibrium phase transitions. We analyze the conditions under which a driven atomic array, characterized by strong dipole–dipole interactions and a large spatial extent, can undergo a superradiant phase transition, also known as cooperative resonance fluorescence. We find that the array can exhibit completely cooperative decay that conserves the collective pseudospin, resulting in a second-order quantum phase transition, with a key hallmark being an abrupt shift from total light reflection by the atoms to rapidly increasing transmission and significant quantum fluctuations. We compare the results with decay mechanisms that fail to conserve pseudospin, leading to a discontinuous first-order phase transition at a critical finite atom number.

arXiv:2404.12939•Optica Quantum•Dec 16, 2024•11 citations
We consider N two level atoms driven far from equilibrium by a coherent driving field. The atoms may decay by a cooperative (J2 preserving) mechanism or a non-cooperative (J2 non-conserving) mechanism where J is the atomic pseudo angular momentum. We adopt a mean field theory to study the J2 non-conserving interaction. This indicates that the system displays a first order phase transition in several observables, e.g., mean field, spectrum and photon statistics. The two stable branches of the hysteresis curve are shown to be regions of cooperative and non-cooperative behaviour respectively. In the case of cooperative atomic decays we find a solution to the Fokker-Planck equation in the atomic coherent state representation. This predicts a second order phase transition in atomic observables—a cooperative fluorescent critical point.
Considers a system of N coherently driven two-level atoms contained in a volume with dimensions much smaller than a wavelength. The atoms may decay by a completely cooperative mechanism which conserves (J 2 ), alternatively they may decay by a mechanism which fails to conserve (J 2 ). The steady-state behaviour in each case is determined using the single-atom solutions together with two limiting approximations: (a) complete atomic correlation, (b) no atomic correlation. In case (a) a behaviour characteristic of a second-order phase transition is obtained while in case (b) a first-order phase transition results.
Analytic results for the fluorescent spectrum arising in the cooperative interaction of a population of two-level atoms, driven by resonant laser radiation with the electromagnetic field are presented. The bistability and hysteresis characterising single-time atomic averages are evidenced explicitly as this spectrum is viewed throughout a hysteresis cycle. In the region of bistability full support is given to the designation of a cooperative and a non-cooperative branch. Spectral features reveal linewidths associated with cooperative and non-cooperative atomic decay rates respectively. A dominant feature is strong coherent scattering throughout the cooperative region, fully supporting an identification of this problem with super-radiant phenomena. Linewidth narrowing is predicted in the vicinity of both instabilities.
This thesis reports the investigation of cooperative non-equilibrium dynamics in a thermal Rydberg ensemble. Cooperative behaviour arises due to resonant dipole-dipole interactions between highly excited Rydberg atoms. In order to transfer atomic population from the ground state to the Rydberg state in a caesium vapour, a three-photon excitation scheme is developed. This scheme has a number of benefits over traditional two-photon Rydberg excitation as each transition utilises in- expensive high-power diode lasers. The process of developing the excitation scheme produces a number of important results, including an excited-state polarisation spectroscopy technique and the observation of coherent three-photon electromagnetically induced transparency. The optical response and atomic dynamics of the interacting ensemble can be separated into two distinct phases. When the Rydberg number density is low and the interactions are negligible, the system can be described by the behaviour of a single atom. However, when the Rydberg number density is high, resonant dipole-dipole interactions result in a significant modification of the ensemble properties. This cooperative many-body phase cannot be described by the behaviour of a single atom. In the frequency domain, the interactions produce an excitation-dependent cooperative energy shift that is observed using probe transmission spectroscopy. In the time domain, the interactions result in a cooperative enhancement of the atomic decay rate that is analysed using fluorescence spectroscopy. At the transition between the single-body and many-body phase, a first-order non-equilibrium phase transition occurs. This is observed spatially along the length of the excitation region as a sharp switch in the emitted fluorescence. The first-order phase transition is also observed in the temporal response of the ensemble through critical slowing down. The divergence of the switching time to steady state follows a universal scaling law for phase transitions and the determined critical exponent is in excellent agreement with previous work on non-equilibrium phase transitions.
The cooperative resonance fluorescence steady state is discussed within the context of an operator master equation which conserves total pseudospin. Emphasis throughout is on quantum fluctuations and their significance in relation to a background of factorised dynamics. Atom-atom correlations are shown to play a fundamental role for systems driven beyond the linear regime. Use of the atomic coherent state representation yields a Fokker-Planck description closely allied to the dynamics for a classical angular momentum oscillator. For intense incident fields the quantum-mechanical steady state is understood in terms of diffusion both around and between classical trajectories on the Bloch sphere. In the limit of infinite systems simple closed-form expressions for steady-state features are derived. Coherent and incoherent fluorescent intensities are obtained together with the second-order correlation function for fluorescent light. Specific features are illustrated by numerical results for systems of from two to fifty atoms.
The topic of this thesis is a theoretical study of nonequilibrium transitions and quantum statistical properties of nonlinear quantum optical systems driven by an external radiation source. In certain limiting cases, a comparison is made between these transitions and the phase transitions found in equilibrium physical systems. In chapters one and two, the mathematical tools are introduced. In operator terms, the time development is described by a Markovian master equation in the interaction picture. This is equivalent to a corresponding time development equation or Fokker-Planck equation in a vector space of c-numbers. In order to deal with the type of Fokker-Planck equation that results, we introduce a quantum classical correspondence resulting in a distribution function over a complex phase-space, which is a generalisation of the Glauber-Sudarshan P-function. In chapter three this is applied to a model of a coherently driven mode with nonlinear dispersion and absorption. We find in the limit of zero temperature, that the spectrum is symmetric relative to the input frequency, and an exact solution is obtained for the distribution function. For a detuned driving field and nonlinear dispersion, optical bistability can occur. In chapter four a model of sub/second harmonic generation is introduced. This has several non-equilibrium transitions, including dispersive optical bistability, and bistable behaviour with coherent phase-locked input to both modes. Exact solutions occur in the limit of zero temperature and adiabatic elimination of one mode. In both chapters three and four, steady-state photon anti-bunching occurs with an absorptive nonlinearity. In chapter five we include interactions between the radiation mode and a fluorescent atomic system. In this case different behaviour occurs depending on the relative decay rates of the individual atoms and of the radiation mode. In the case of a high-Q interferometer, the atomic variables can be adiabatically eliminated. Both dispersive and absorptive bistability can occur. We show by analytic and numerical calculations (in the case of inhomogeneous broadening) that dispersive operation has advantages in requiring a lower atomic density and input field to observe bistability. When the input field has Gaussian (rather than coherent) photon statistics, there is no bistability, but enhanced photon bunching occurs. Finally, there is a different type of behaviour when the field mode decays rapidly and can be adiabatically eliminated. Within the cooperation lifetime the system can be described by a J²-invariant Hamiltonian, giving the special case of only collective damping. The result is a new type of critical point transition in the thermodynamic limit, with the appearance of a family of solutions like Lotka-Volterra cycles for a coherent driving field above threshold.
Atoms strongly interacting with light constitute rich quantum-optical systems with the potential for observing cooperative effects and dissipative nonequilibrium phase transitions. We analyze the conditions under which a driven atomic array, characterized by strong dipole–dipole interactions and a large spatial extent, can undergo a superradiant phase transition, also known as cooperative resonance fluorescence. We find that the array can exhibit completely cooperative decay that conserves the collective pseudospin, resulting in a second-order quantum phase transition, with a key hallmark being an abrupt shift from total light reflection by the atoms to rapidly increasing transmission and significant quantum fluctuations. We compare the results with decay mechanisms that fail to conserve pseudospin, leading to a discontinuous first-order phase transition at a critical finite atom number.