Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields

Anomalies in conservation laws in quantum mechanics

Richard Samuel Ward

Published Jul 15, 1987• 6 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It has been pointed out that a simple quantum-mechanical system, involving a charged particle moving in a uniform magnetic field, can exhibit what looks like an anomaly. This note analyzes the problem, and shows that in such cases the anomaly is (in some sense) already present at the classical level.
DOI
10.1103/physrevd.36.640

Related papers

Classical and quantum mechanics of a particle on a rotating loop

Sayan Kar, Avinash Khare

A toy problem of a charged particle in a uniform magnetic field, constrained to move on a vertical rotating loop, is analyzed. After a short review of the model, we move on to its quantum mechanics. We first obtain some exact solutions of the corresponding Schrödinger equation. Thereafter, introducing the notion of instantons and bounces, we explicitly obtain such solutions in this problem. Finally, we delineate briefly the connection of this toy model with some models in field theory and statistical mechanics and mention possible extensions.

arXiv:quant-ph/9904083•American Journal of Physics•Dec 1, 2000•4 citations

Contradiction between Conservation Laws and Orthodox Quantum Mechanics

María Esther Burgos

In this paper, it showed that the orthodox version of quantum mechanics contradicts the idea that conservation laws are valid in individual processes of measurement.

Journal of Modern Physics•Jan 1, 2010•54 citations

On the action for a charged particle moving in a magnetic field

Manoj K. Harbola

Application of the Bohr–Wilson–Sommerfeld quantization condition to a charged particle in a uniform magnetic field requires knowledge of the canonical momentum of such a particle, which in turn requires students to know about the vector potential. The canonical momentum in this situation is conventionally obtained by introducing an appropriate additional term involving the corresponding vector potential in the Lagrangian. In this work, we take a different approach to this problem by analyzing it with Maupertuis's principle of least action. We show that satisfying this principle for a charged particle moving in a uniform magnetic field requires that a term proportional to the flux passing through the area enclosed by the particle's trajectory be included in its action. This additional term accomplishes two tasks. First, it facilitates applying the Bohr–Wilson–Sommerfeld quantum condition for a charged particle moving in a uniform magnetic field without using the Lagrangian approach, and, second, it gives the appropriate canonical momentum and Lagrangian for a charged particle in a general electromagnetic field in a straightforward manner.

arXiv:2506.16181•American Journal of Physics•Aug 21, 2025•0 citations

Paradoxes of quantum mechanics

J. Hrdý

A hypothesis consisting in a different view of the electron is presented.This makes it possible to explain some paradoxes of quantum mechanics.

International Journal of Physics and Applications•Jan 1, 2023•0 citations

On the classical descriptions of the quantum phenomena in the harmonic oscillator and in a charged particle under the coulomb force

Jaume Giné

Chaos Solitons & Fractals•Jun 10, 2005•12 citations

Interaction of atoms, molecules, and ions with constant electric and magnetic fields

Bruce R. Johnson, Joseph O. Hirschfelder, Kuo‐Ho Yang

A thorough unified treatment is given of the quantum-mechanical operators and wave functions for a molecular system (composed of $N$ moving charged particles) in static uniform electric and magnetic fields $\mathit{E}$ and $\mathit{B}$. The treatment is rigorous within the nonrelativistic approximation. The system may either be neutral or charged. The fields may have arbitrary intensities and orientations. Close correspondence is maintained between the classical and quantum-mechanical treatments. The wave functions are expressed both in the time-independent energy representation and in time-dependent wave packets. Three types of momentum play important roles. For single-particle systems they are the canonical momentum $\mathit{P}$, the mechanical momentum $\mathit{\ensuremath{\Pi}}=\mathit{P}\ensuremath{-}(\frac{e}{c})\mathit{A}=M\stackrel{\ifmmode \dot{}\else \.{}\fi{}}{R}$, and the pseudomomentum $\mathcal{K}=\mathit{\ensuremath{\Pi}}\ensuremath{-}(\frac{e}{c})\mathit{R}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}\mathit{B}\ensuremath{-}e\mathit{E}t$. The pseudomomentum is a constant of the motion. Except in the absence of magnetic fields, not all of the components of either $\mathit{\ensuremath{\Pi}}$ or $\mathcal{K}$ commute. This complicates the quantum-mechanical formalism. The components of the pseudomomentum have simple classical interpretations, and in quantum mechanics they are related to the operator which performs a boost to a reference frame moving with constant velocity $\mathit{v}$. In this moving frame, the electric field intensity is ${\mathit{E}}^{\ensuremath{'}}=\mathit{E}+(\frac{\mathit{v}}{c})\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}\mathit{B}$. Thus, in a frame moving with the drift velocity ${\mathit{v}}_{d}=(\frac{c}{{B}^{2}})\mathit{E}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}\mathit{B}$, the components of the electric field intensity perpendicular to $\mathit{B}$ vanish. In this paper, the velocity boost operators are used to show the relationships between wave functions expressed in reference frames moving with repsect to each other. The dynamics of the $N$-particle systems are simplified by making the Power-Zienau-Woolley transformation (which reduces as a special case to a unitary transformation used by Lamb) and by using center-of-mass and internal coordinates. Generalizing previous works, it is shown how the pseudomomentum is involved in separating these degrees of freedom for $N$ particles in both $\mathit{E}$ and $\mathit{B}$. For neutral molecules, the Schr\"odinger equation is "pseudoseparated" and the internal degrees of freedom are coupled to the center of mass motion only by the "motional Stark Effect," which involves the constant of motion $\mathcal{K}$. For ionic systems, only one component of the center of mass is coupled to the internal motion. Quantitative estimates of the weak center-of-mass coupling are made for both neutral and ionic $n=1$ and $n=2$ quantum states of two-body systems by perturbation expansions in powers of the field strengths. In the usual nonrigorous treatments of systems in magnetic fields, no distinction is made between $\mathit{\ensuremath{\Pi}}$ and $\mathcal{K}$ and both are approximated by $M\stackrel{\ifmmode \dot{}\else \.{}\fi{}}{R}$, where $M$ is the mass of the molecule and $\mathit{R}$ is taken to be the classical orbital position of a single particle having the same mass and charge. This is an excellent approximation for ground-state molecules and ions in weak fields. However, the resulting errors can be much larger if the system is in either intense fields or high-lying states (e.g., Rydberg levels). These are the conditions under which the rigorous formalism should be most useful. The determination of the wave functions and energy levels for many-particle ionic systems is complicated due to the coupling with the center of mass. The suggestion is made that it might be useful to boost the reference frame so that it moves with the velocity $\stackrel{\ifmmode \dot{}\else \.{}\fi{}}{R}$ of a single classical particle. The Schr\"odinger equation in this frame could serve as a more suitable basis for perturbative or variational treatments.

Reviews of Modern Physics•Jan 1, 1983•227 citations
A toy problem of a charged particle in a uniform magnetic field, constrained to move on a vertical rotating loop, is analyzed. After a short review of the model, we move on to its quantum mechanics. We first obtain some exact solutions of the corresponding Schrödinger equation. Thereafter, introducing the notion of instantons and bounces, we explicitly obtain such solutions in this problem. Finally, we delineate briefly the connection of this toy model with some models in field theory and statistical mechanics and mention possible extensions.
Application of the Bohr–Wilson–Sommerfeld quantization condition to a charged particle in a uniform magnetic field requires knowledge of the canonical momentum of such a particle, which in turn requires students to know about the vector potential. The canonical momentum in this situation is conventionally obtained by introducing an appropriate additional term involving the corresponding vector potential in the Lagrangian. In this work, we take a different approach to this problem by analyzing it with Maupertuis's principle of least action. We show that satisfying this principle for a charged particle moving in a uniform magnetic field requires that a term proportional to the flux passing through the area enclosed by the particle's trajectory be included in its action. This additional term accomplishes two tasks. First, it facilitates applying the Bohr–Wilson–Sommerfeld quantum condition for a charged particle moving in a uniform magnetic field without using the Lagrangian approach, and, second, it gives the appropriate canonical momentum and Lagrangian for a charged particle in a general electromagnetic field in a straightforward manner.
A thorough unified treatment is given of the quantum-mechanical operators and wave functions for a molecular system (composed of NNN moving charged particles) in static uniform electric and magnetic fields E\mathit{E}E and B\mathit{B}B. The treatment is rigorous within the nonrelativistic approximation. The system may either be neutral or charged. The fields may have arbitrary intensities and orientations. Close correspondence is maintained between the classical and quantum-mechanical treatments. The wave functions are expressed both in the time-independent energy representation and in time-dependent wave packets. Three types of momentum play important roles. For single-particle systems they are the canonical momentum P\mathit{P}P, the mechanical momentum $\mathit{\ensuremath{\Pi}}=\mathit{P}\ensuremath{-}(\frac{e}{c})\mathit{A}=M\stackrel{\ifmmode \dot{}\else \.{}\fi{}}{R}$, and the pseudomomentum $\mathcal{K}=\mathit{\ensuremath{\Pi}}\ensuremath{-}(\frac{e}{c})\mathit{R}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}\mathit{B}\ensuremath{-}e\mathit{E}t$. The pseudomomentum is a constant of the motion. Except in the absence of magnetic fields, not all of the components of either $\mathit{\ensuremath{\Pi}}$ or K\mathcal{K}K commute. This complicates the quantum-mechanical formalism. The components of the pseudomomentum have simple classical interpretations, and in quantum mechanics they are related to the operator which performs a boost to a reference frame moving with constant velocity v\mathit{v}v. In this moving frame, the electric field intensity is ${\mathit{E}}^{\ensuremath{'}}=\mathit{E}+(\frac{\mathit{v}}{c})\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}\mathit{B}$. Thus, in a frame moving with the drift velocity ${\mathit{v}}_{d}=(\frac{c}{{B}^{2}})\mathit{E}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}\mathit{B}$, the components of the electric field intensity perpendicular to B\mathit{B}B vanish. In this paper, the velocity boost operators are used to show the relationships between wave functions expressed in reference frames moving with repsect to each other. The dynamics of the NNN-particle systems are simplified by making the Power-Zienau-Woolley transformation (which reduces as a special case to a unitary transformation used by Lamb) and by using center-of-mass and internal coordinates. Generalizing previous works, it is shown how the pseudomomentum is involved in separating these degrees of freedom for NNN particles in both E\mathit{E}E and B\mathit{B}B. For neutral molecules, the Schr\"odinger equation is "pseudoseparated" and the internal degrees of freedom are coupled to the center of mass motion only by the "motional Stark Effect," which involves the constant of motion K\mathcal{K}K. For ionic systems, only one component of the center of mass is coupled to the internal motion. Quantitative estimates of the weak center-of-mass coupling are made for both neutral and ionic n=1n=1n=1 and n=2n=2n=2 quantum states of two-body systems by perturbation expansions in powers of the field strengths. In the usual nonrigorous treatments of systems in magnetic fields, no distinction is made between $\mathit{\ensuremath{\Pi}}$ and K\mathcal{K}K and both are approximated by $M\stackrel{\ifmmode \dot{}\else \.{}\fi{}}{R}$, where MMM is the mass of the molecule and R\mathit{R}R is taken to be the classical orbital position of a single particle having the same mass and charge. This is an excellent approximation for ground-state molecules and ions in weak fields. However, the resulting errors can be much larger if the system is in either intense fields or high-lying states (e.g., Rydberg levels). These are the conditions under which the rigorous formalism should be most useful. The determination of the wave functions and energy levels for many-particle ionic systems is complicated due to the coupling with the center of mass. The suggestion is made that it might be useful to boost the reference frame so that it moves with the velocity $\stackrel{\ifmmode \dot{}\else \.{}\fi{}}{R}$ of a single classical particle. The Schr\"odinger equation in this frame could serve as a more suitable basis for perturbative or variational treatments.