Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Mathematical Physics

Heisenberg inequality and the complex field in quantum mechanics

PEKKA J. LAHTI, Maciej Mączyński

Published Aug 1, 1987• 26 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Observables A and B satisfy the Heisenberg inequality if the product of their variances has a positive lower bound independent of the state of the system. In the Hilbert space formulation of quantum mechanics it is a consequence of the Schwarz inequality that the Heisenberg-type inequality Var(A,φ)⋅Var(B,φ)≥ (1)/(4) ‖〈Aφ‖Bφ〉−〈Bφ‖Aφ〉‖2 holds for any pair of observables A and B (represented as self-adjoint operators) and for any (vector) state (represented as a unit vector). If inf{‖〈Aφ‖Bφ〉−〈Bφ‖Aφ〉‖ ‖φ∈dom(A) ∩dom(B)}≠0 then A and B satisfy the Heisenberg inequality. In the present paper the derivability of the Heisenberg-type inequality is analyzed within the general theoretical frame of a sum logic. It is shown that any real-valued non-negative function (A,α)→f(A,α) of observables A and of states α, which has a symmetry property f(A+B,α)+f(A−B,α)=2f(A,α)+2f(B,α) with respect to observables, satisfies the Heisenberg-type inequality f(A,α)⋅f(B,α)≥ (1)/(4) ‖ f(A+B,α)−f(A,α)−f(B,α)‖2 for all observables A and B and for all states α. The natural probabilistic realizations f1(A,α)=Exp(A2,α) and f2(A,α)=Var(A,α) of such functions are then analyzed. It turns out that only with the complex extension of the theory can the Heisenberg inequality be attained in the Hilbert space realization of the theory. This is used as an argument in favor of the complex field as the scalar field of quantum mechanics.

DOI
10.1063/1.527822

Related papers

Geometrical approach to the Heisenberg uncertainty relation and its generalization

John Lighton Synge

Abstract Real Hilbert space is a Euclidean space of infinite dimensionality. Complex Hilbert space is less amenable to elementary geometrical intuitions, but these do serve to give structure to the present argument. The familiar process of finding, relative to a vector x, the expectation Ā of a self-adjoint linear operator A, and then using the deviation A — Ā to obtain a dispersion ΔA, may be interpreted as a projection leading to a unit vector e orthogonal to x. If we have n self-adjoint operators Ar, we thus form n unit vectors er orthogonal to x. From a basic property of Hilbert space, the vector c1e1 + c2e2 + ... + cnen has a non-negative norm for arbitrary complex coefficients. This demands the positive-indefinite character of a real quadratic form in 2n variables; equivalently, all its eigenvalues must be non-negative. This leads to inequalities on the dispersions ΔAr, the expectations of the commutators i[Ar, As] and other expectations. For n = 2, this process leads to Schrödinger’s improvement of the Heisenberg inequality. The case n = 3 is here worked out explicitly.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A Mathematical and Physical Sciences•Nov 9, 1971•13 citations

On Some Consequences of the Functional Generalization of the Parallelogram Identity

Maciej Mączyński

Abstract The aim of this paper is to unify the partial results, which up to now, have been dispersed in various publications in order to show the importance of the functional form of parallelogram identity in mathematics and physics. We study vector spaces admitting a real non-negative functional which satisfies an identity analogous to the parallelogram identity in normed vector spaces. We show that this generalized parallelogram identity also implies an equality analogous to the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality. We study the consequences of this identity in real and complex vector spaces, in generalized Riesz spaces and in abelian groups. We give a physical interpretation to these results. For vector spaces of observables and states, we show that the parallelogram identity implies an inequality analogous to Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle (HUP), and we show that we can obtain the standard structure of quantum mechanics from the parallelogram identity, without assuming from the beginning the HUP. The role of complex numbers in quantum mechanics is discussed.

Demonstratio Mathematica•Jun 1, 2014•0 citations

Notes on some inequalities, resulting uncertainty relations and correlations

Krzysztof Urbanowski

We analyze the Schwarz inequality and its generalizations, as well as inequalities resulting from the Jensen inequality. They are used in quantum theory to derive the Heisenberg-Robertson (HR) and Schroedinger-Robertson (SR) uncertainty relation for two non-commuting observables and their generalizations to three or more non-commuting observables. Jensen's inequality, in turn, is helpful in deriving various the "sum uncertainty relations" for two or more observables. Using these inequalities, we derive various types of generalized uncertainty relations for more than two non--commuting observables and analyze their properties and critical points. We also study the connections between the generalizations of the HR and SR uncertainty relations for two and more observables and the correlations of these observables in the state of the quantum system under study. In this analysis, we pay special attention to the consequences of the generalized SR uncertainty relation for three non--commuting observables on their correlations in a given state of a quantum system and to the connections of this relation with the appropriate correlation matrix, whose matrix elements are the quantum versions of the Pearson coefficient. We show also that the SR uncertainty relation (including the generalized ones) can be written in an equivalent way using these Pearson coefficients.

quant-pharXiv:2604.12410•Physical Review A•Apr 15, 2026•0 citations

Bell's Inequality and Heisenberg Measurements on Relativistic Quantum Systems

Ulrich Faigle

Bell's inequality plays an important role with respect to the Einsteinian question about the physical reality of quantum theory. While Bell's inequality is usually viewed within the geometric framework of a Hilbert space quantum model, the present note extends the theory of Heisenberg measurements to quantum systems with representations in general orthogonal geometric spaces and, in particular, the Minkowski spaces of relativity theory. A Feynmanian numerical example exhibits two measurements that admit a joint probabilistic interpretation in Minkowski space while they are not jointly observable in Hilbert space. The analysis shows that probabilistic interpretations of quantum measurements may depend not only on the measuring instruments and the system states but also on the geometric space in which the measurements are conducted. In particular, an explicit numerical example is given of a Heisenberg measurement with a complete set of common observables that violates Bell's inequality in Minkowski space but, mutatatis mutandis, satisfies it in Hilbert space.

arXiv:2304.12873•Apr 25, 2023•0 citations

The Schrödinger–Robinson inequality from stochastic analysis on a complex Hilbert space

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We explored the stochastic analysis on a complex Hilbert space to show that one of the cornerstones of quantum mechanics (QM), namely Heisenberg's uncertainty relation, can be derived in the classical probabilistic framework. We created a new mathematical representation of quantum averages: as averages with respect to classical random fields. The existence of a classical stochastic model matching with Heisenberg's uncertainty relation makes the connection between classical and quantum probabilistic models essentially closer. In real physical situations, random fields are valued in the L2-space. Hence, although we model QM and not QFT, the classical systems under consideration have an infinite number of degrees of freedom. And in our modeling, infinite-dimensional stochastic analysis is the basic mathematical tool.

Physica Scripta•Feb 11, 2013•0 citations

Observables and the Field in Quantum Mechanics

Stanley Gudder, C. Piron

Corresponding to any irreducible proposition system L in general quantum mechanics there is a division ring D with an anti-automorphism * and a vector space (V, D) over D with a definite sesquilinear form φ such that L is isomorphic to the set of φ closed subspaces of (V, D). The main task remaining in connecting the general quantum mechanics to the conventional quantum theory in a complex Hilbert space is to give physical arguments which force D to be the complex field. In this paper it is shown that if L admits a certain type of observable (together with other structure which seems to be physically justified), then D contains the real field as a subfield. Steps are then indicated that can be taken to move from the reals to the complexes or quaternions.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Aug 1, 1971•27 citations
Observables A and B satisfy the Heisenberg inequality if the product of their variances has a positive lower bound independent of the state of the system. In the Hilbert space formulation of quantum mechanics it is a consequence of the Schwarz inequality that the Heisenberg-type inequality Var(A,φ)⋅Var(B,φ)≥ (1)/(4) ‖〈Aφ‖Bφ〉−〈Bφ‖Aφ〉‖2 holds for any pair of observables A and B (represented as self-adjoint operators) and for any (vector) state (represented as a unit vector). If inf{‖〈Aφ‖Bφ〉−〈Bφ‖Aφ〉‖ ‖φ∈dom(A) ∩dom(B)}≠0 then A and B satisfy the Heisenberg inequality. In the present paper the derivability of the Heisenberg-type inequality is analyzed within the general theoretical frame of a sum logic. It is shown that any real-valued non-negative function (A,α)→f(A,α) of observables A and of states α, which has a symmetry property f(A+B,α)+f(A−B,α)=2f(A,α)+2f(B,α) with respect to observables, satisfies the Heisenberg-type inequality f(A,α)⋅f(B,α)≥ (1)/(4) ‖ f(A+B,α)−f(A,α)−f(B,α)‖2 for all observables A and B and for all states α. The natural probabilistic realizations f1(A,α)=Exp(A2,α) and f2(A,α)=Var(A,α) of such functions are then analyzed. It turns out that only with the complex extension of the theory can the Heisenberg inequality be attained in the Hilbert space realization of the theory. This is used as an argument in favor of the complex field as the scalar field of quantum mechanics.
Abstract Real Hilbert space is a Euclidean space of infinite dimensionality. Complex Hilbert space is less amenable to elementary geometrical intuitions, but these do serve to give structure to the present argument. The familiar process of finding, relative to a vector x, the expectation Ā of a self-adjoint linear operator A, and then using the deviation A — Ā to obtain a dispersion ΔA, may be interpreted as a projection leading to a unit vector e orthogonal to x. If we have n self-adjoint operators Ar, we thus form n unit vectors er orthogonal to x. From a basic property of Hilbert space, the vector c1e1 + c2e2 + ... + cnen has a non-negative norm for arbitrary complex coefficients. This demands the positive-indefinite character of a real quadratic form in 2n variables; equivalently, all its eigenvalues must be non-negative. This leads to inequalities on the dispersions ΔAr, the expectations of the commutators i[Ar, As] and other expectations. For n = 2, this process leads to Schrödinger’s improvement of the Heisenberg inequality. The case n = 3 is here worked out explicitly.
Abstract The aim of this paper is to unify the partial results, which up to now, have been dispersed in various publications in order to show the importance of the functional form of parallelogram identity in mathematics and physics. We study vector spaces admitting a real non-negative functional which satisfies an identity analogous to the parallelogram identity in normed vector spaces. We show that this generalized parallelogram identity also implies an equality analogous to the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality. We study the consequences of this identity in real and complex vector spaces, in generalized Riesz spaces and in abelian groups. We give a physical interpretation to these results. For vector spaces of observables and states, we show that the parallelogram identity implies an inequality analogous to Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle (HUP), and we show that we can obtain the standard structure of quantum mechanics from the parallelogram identity, without assuming from the beginning the HUP. The role of complex numbers in quantum mechanics is discussed.
We analyze the Schwarz inequality and its generalizations, as well as inequalities resulting from the Jensen inequality. They are used in quantum theory to derive the Heisenberg-Robertson (HR) and Schroedinger-Robertson (SR) uncertainty relation for two non-commuting observables and their generalizations to three or more non-commuting observables. Jensen's inequality, in turn, is helpful in deriving various the "sum uncertainty relations" for two or more observables. Using these inequalities, we derive various types of generalized uncertainty relations for more than two non--commuting observables and analyze their properties and critical points. We also study the connections between the generalizations of the HR and SR uncertainty relations for two and more observables and the correlations of these observables in the state of the quantum system under study. In this analysis, we pay special attention to the consequences of the generalized SR uncertainty relation for three non--commuting observables on their correlations in a given state of a quantum system and to the connections of this relation with the appropriate correlation matrix, whose matrix elements are the quantum versions of the Pearson coefficient. We show also that the SR uncertainty relation (including the generalized ones) can be written in an equivalent way using these Pearson coefficients.
Bell's inequality plays an important role with respect to the Einsteinian question about the physical reality of quantum theory. While Bell's inequality is usually viewed within the geometric framework of a Hilbert space quantum model, the present note extends the theory of Heisenberg measurements to quantum systems with representations in general orthogonal geometric spaces and, in particular, the Minkowski spaces of relativity theory. A Feynmanian numerical example exhibits two measurements that admit a joint probabilistic interpretation in Minkowski space while they are not jointly observable in Hilbert space. The analysis shows that probabilistic interpretations of quantum measurements may depend not only on the measuring instruments and the system states but also on the geometric space in which the measurements are conducted. In particular, an explicit numerical example is given of a Heisenberg measurement with a complete set of common observables that violates Bell's inequality in Minkowski space but, mutatatis mutandis, satisfies it in Hilbert space.
We explored the stochastic analysis on a complex Hilbert space to show that one of the cornerstones of quantum mechanics (QM), namely Heisenberg's uncertainty relation, can be derived in the classical probabilistic framework. We created a new mathematical representation of quantum averages: as averages with respect to classical random fields. The existence of a classical stochastic model matching with Heisenberg's uncertainty relation makes the connection between classical and quantum probabilistic models essentially closer. In real physical situations, random fields are valued in the L2-space. Hence, although we model QM and not QFT, the classical systems under consideration have an infinite number of degrees of freedom. And in our modeling, infinite-dimensional stochastic analysis is the basic mathematical tool.
Corresponding to any irreducible proposition system L in general quantum mechanics there is a division ring D with an anti-automorphism * and a vector space (V, D) over D with a definite sesquilinear form φ such that L is isomorphic to the set of φ closed subspaces of (V, D). The main task remaining in connecting the general quantum mechanics to the conventional quantum theory in a complex Hilbert space is to give physical arguments which force D to be the complex field. In this paper it is shown that if L admits a certain type of observable (together with other structure which seems to be physically justified), then D contains the real field as a subfield. Steps are then indicated that can be taken to move from the reals to the complexes or quaternions.