Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Mathematical Physics

Must quantum theory assume unrestricted superposition?

Herbert Joseph Bernstein

Published Oct 1, 1974• 17 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A conjecture that the (n −1)2 independent moduli and (2n −1) unphysical phases completely specify all n-dimensional unitary matrices is shown to be true in two and three dimensions, but false in four or more. The implications for quantum theory are discussed.
DOI
10.1063/1.1666523

Related papers

Quantum Galois Machine: Exact Rational Dilations and Denominator Costs

Hutan Ashrafian

When a quantum operation is specified exactly, irrational amplitudes in its unitary description can disappear from its action on density matrices, leaving an operation with rational coefficients whose implementation still requires additional resources. I develop a Quantum Galois Machine that determines whether an algebraically specified quantum channel can be executed using rational matrices and a finite environment initially prepared in a computational basis state. For every unitary channel with rational coefficients, the minimum dimension of an environment that may be discarded is exactly the least number of rational squares needed to represent a positive rational parameter extracted from the channel. This gives a complete classification with possible dimensions one, two, three and four, each attained by an explicit example. The associated square class multiplies under parallel and sequential composition, so two identical operations admit a joint implementation without an environment even when one operation requires four dimensions. Returning the environment to its initial basis state or retaining a specified coherent control imposes different arithmetic obstructions. Although unrestricted approximation removes this exact environment requirement, a bound on rational denominators restores a quantitative obstruction: a nonsquare output probability with reduced denominator S forces diamond-norm error at least 2/(SB^2) when every entry denominator of an environment-free implementation is at most B. A constructive Householder approximation supplies a complementary upper bound, giving logarithmic denominator bit cost in inverse precision for each fixed channel with nonsquare parameter. These results provide finite certificates that account for the coefficient field, phase convention, auxiliary systems and numerical description size.

•Oct 29, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Theory as the Representation Theory of Symmetries

P. P. Divakaran

It is proposed that an unconstrained quantum system is completely specified by its configuration space $C$ and its group of symmetries $G$. It is then shown that the theory of projective unitary representations of $G$ on a certain Hilbert space determined by $C$ and $G$ leads to a definitive resolution of supposed ambiguities relating to superselection rules, choice of wave functions, topological properties of $G$ and $C$, anomalies, etc.

Physical Review Letters•Sep 22, 1997•7 citations

Reflection-symmetric diagonal synthesis: resolving a conjecture of Huang, Kosugi, Nishi and Matsushita

Haobo Ma, Wenlin Zhang

Combined with the upper bound of Huang, Kosugi, Nishi and Matsushita [J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 93, 054002 (2024); arXiv:2310.06676v2], this resolves their Section 6 conjecture that 2^(2n-1)+2n-2 CNOTs are optimal in the worst case for exact ancilla-free CNOT/R_z synthesis of reflection-symmetric diagonal unitaries on 2n qubits. The explicit hard instance has phase pi/2 at the all-zero and all-one strings. Multiplicative characters force every nonzero even parity; birth-span dimension and return conservation give the linear term. The same substitution gives the unrestricted 2dn-wire count, but not depth optimality or radial-potential optimality.

•Nov 2, 2026•0 citations

Quantum phase and quantum phase operators: some physics and some history

Michael Martin Nieto

After reviewing the role of phase in quantum mechanics, I discuss, with the aid of a number of unpublished documents, the development of quantum phase operators in the 1960's. Interwoven in the discussion are the critical physics questions of the field: are there (unique) quantum phase operators and are there quantum systems which can determine their nature? I conclude with a critique of recent proposals which have shed new light on the problem.

arXiv:hep-th/9304036•Physica Scripta•Jan 1, 1993•61 citations

Unitary braid matrices: bridge between topological and quantum entanglements

B. Abdesselam, A Chakrabati

Braiding operators corresponding to the third Reidemeister move in the theory of knots and links are realized in terms of parametrized unitary matrices for all dimensions.Two distinct classes are considered.Their (nonlocal) unitary actions on separable pure product states of three identical subsystems (i.e., the spin projections of three particles) are explicitly evaluated for all dimensions.This, for our classes, is shown to generate entangled superposition of four terms in the base space.The 3-body and 2-body entanglements (in three 2-body subsystems), the 3 tangles, and 2 tangles are explicitly evaluated for each class.For our matrices, these are parametrized.Varying parameters they can be made to sweep over the domain (0, 1).Thus, braiding operators corresponding to over-and undercrossings of three braids and, on closing ends, to topologically entangled Borromean rings are shown, in another context, to generate quantum entanglements.For higher dimensions, starting with different initial triplets one can entangle by turns, each state with all the rest.A specific coupling of three angular momenta is briefly discussed to throw more light on three body entanglements.

arXiv:0911.0906•Journal of Physical Mathematics•Jan 1, 2010•3 citations

On the Generalized Correspondence Principle

J. Manjavidze

It is noted that quantum theory includes the correspondence principle which is independent of the value of quantum corrections. Some consequences of this generalized correspondence principle are considered. For example, it is discussed how the symmetry constraints can be taken into account.

arXiv:1106.6181•Jun 30, 2011•1 citation
When a quantum operation is specified exactly, irrational amplitudes in its unitary description can disappear from its action on density matrices, leaving an operation with rational coefficients whose implementation still requires additional resources. I develop a Quantum Galois Machine that determines whether an algebraically specified quantum channel can be executed using rational matrices and a finite environment initially prepared in a computational basis state. For every unitary channel with rational coefficients, the minimum dimension of an environment that may be discarded is exactly the least number of rational squares needed to represent a positive rational parameter extracted from the channel. This gives a complete classification with possible dimensions one, two, three and four, each attained by an explicit example. The associated square class multiplies under parallel and sequential composition, so two identical operations admit a joint implementation without an environment even when one operation requires four dimensions. Returning the environment to its initial basis state or retaining a specified coherent control imposes different arithmetic obstructions. Although unrestricted approximation removes this exact environment requirement, a bound on rational denominators restores a quantitative obstruction: a nonsquare output probability with reduced denominator S forces diamond-norm error at least 2/(SB^2) when every entry denominator of an environment-free implementation is at most B. A constructive Householder approximation supplies a complementary upper bound, giving logarithmic denominator bit cost in inverse precision for each fixed channel with nonsquare parameter. These results provide finite certificates that account for the coefficient field, phase convention, auxiliary systems and numerical description size.
It is proposed that an unconstrained quantum system is completely specified by its configuration space CCC and its group of symmetries GGG. It is then shown that the theory of projective unitary representations of GGG on a certain Hilbert space determined by CCC and GGG leads to a definitive resolution of supposed ambiguities relating to superselection rules, choice of wave functions, topological properties of GGG and CCC, anomalies, etc.
Combined with the upper bound of Huang, Kosugi, Nishi and Matsushita [J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 93, 054002 (2024); arXiv:2310.06676v2], this resolves their Section 6 conjecture that 2^(2n-1)+2n-2 CNOTs are optimal in the worst case for exact ancilla-free CNOT/R_z synthesis of reflection-symmetric diagonal unitaries on 2n qubits. The explicit hard instance has phase pi/2 at the all-zero and all-one strings. Multiplicative characters force every nonzero even parity; birth-span dimension and return conservation give the linear term. The same substitution gives the unrestricted 2dn-wire count, but not depth optimality or radial-potential optimality.
Braiding operators corresponding to the third Reidemeister move in the theory of knots and links are realized in terms of parametrized unitary matrices for all dimensions.Two distinct classes are considered.Their (nonlocal) unitary actions on separable pure product states of three identical subsystems (i.e., the spin projections of three particles) are explicitly evaluated for all dimensions.This, for our classes, is shown to generate entangled superposition of four terms in the base space.The 3-body and 2-body entanglements (in three 2-body subsystems), the 3 tangles, and 2 tangles are explicitly evaluated for each class.For our matrices, these are parametrized.Varying parameters they can be made to sweep over the domain (0, 1).Thus, braiding operators corresponding to over-and undercrossings of three braids and, on closing ends, to topologically entangled Borromean rings are shown, in another context, to generate quantum entanglements.For higher dimensions, starting with different initial triplets one can entangle by turns, each state with all the rest.A specific coupling of three angular momenta is briefly discussed to throw more light on three body entanglements.