Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

European Journal of Physics

A note on the zero point energy of an ideal boson gas

Francis A. Deeney, J P O'Leary

Published Aug 2, 2011• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We have recently demonstrated that, when investigating the internal energy and pressure of an ideal boson gas at temperatures below the Bose–Einstein temperature, it is necessary to include the contribution from the kinetic energy of the particles in the condensate. Here we express the same requirement in terms of the constraints of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle applied to the particles confined in the condensate. The problem may be used by undergraduate students as an additional example of the connection between the ground state energy of a system and the Heisenberg uncertainty principle.

DOI
10.1088/0143-0807/32/5/l01

Related papers

Influence of the Heisenberg Principle on the Ideal Bose Gas

Hua Zheng, G. Giuliani, Aldo Bonasera A

The ideal Bose gas has two major shortcomings: at zero temperature, all the particles 'condense' at zero energy or momentum, thus violating the Heisenberg principle; the second is that the pressure below the critical point is independent of density resulting in zero incompressibility (or infinite isothermal compressibility) which is unphysical. We propose a modification of the ideal Bose gas to take into account the Heisenberg principle. This modification results in a finite (in)compressibility at all temperatures and densities. The main properties of the ideal Bose gas are preserved, i.e. the relation between the critical temperature and density, but the specific heat has a maximum at the critical temperature instead of a discontinuity. Of course interactions are crucial for both cases in order to describe actual physical systems.

arXiv:1303.6611•Mar 26, 2013•0 citations

A pair hamiltonian model of a non-ideal Boson gas

Joseph V. Pulé, Valentin Anatol'evich Zagrebnov

The pressure in the thermodynamic limit of a non-ideal Boson gas whose Hamiltonian includes only diagonal and pairing terms can be expressed as the infimum of a functional depending on two measures on momentum space: a positive measure describing the particle density and a complex measure describing the pair density. In this paper we examine this variational problem with the object of determining when the model exhibits Bose-Einstein condensation. In addition we show that if the pairing term in the Hamiltonian is positive then it has no effect

Annales De L Institut Henri Poincare-physique Theorique•Jan 1, 1993•4 citations

BEC IN NONEXTENSIVE STATISTICAL MECHANICS: SOME ADDITIONAL RESULTS

LUCA SALASNICH

In a recent paper1 we discussed the Bose–Einstein condensation (BEC) in the framework of Tsallis's nonextensive statistical mechanics. In particular, we studied an ideal gas of bosons in a confining harmonic potential. In this memoir we generalize our previous analysis by investigating an ideal Bose gas in a generic power-law external potential. We derive analytical formulas for the energy of the system, the BEC transition temperature and the condensed fraction.

arXiv:cond-mat/0101350•International Journal of Modern Physics B•Apr 10, 2001•7 citations

Condensation of an Imperfect Boson Gas

Robert H. Kraichnan

The nature of the Einstein-Bose condensation in an imperfect boson gas is discussed. It is argued that no matter how low the temperature, provided it is not zero, macroscopic second-sound waves should be weakly excited as thermal fluctuations about equilibrium. This implies that the single-particle momentum distribution must be smeared so that the state of zero momentum cannot contain a finite fraction of the particles. A microscopic mechanism which independently leads to a momentum spread is discussed. It is suggested that the actual Einstein-Bose condensation of an imperfect gas takes place in energy rather than momentum but that even in terms of this variable it becomes perfectly sharp only at zero temperature. This hypothesis is formulated analytically in terms of correlation functions of the second-quantized boson field.

The Physics of Fluids•Jul 1, 1959•1 citation

Bose-Einstein condensation for general dispersion relations

Valdir C. Aguilera-Navarro, MANUEL DE LLANO, M. A. Solís

Bose-Einstein condensation in an ideal (i.e. interactionless) boson gas can be studied analytically, at university-level statistical and solid state physics, in any positive dimensionality ( d >0) for identical bosons with any positive-exponent ( s >0) energy-momentum (i.e. dispersion) relation. Explicit formulae with arbitrary d / s are discussed for: the critical temperature (non-zero only if d / s >1); the condensate fraction; the internal energy; and the constant-volume specific heat (found to possess a jump discontinuity only if d / s >2). Classical results are recovered at sufficiently high temperatures. Applications to `ordinary' Bose-Einstein condensation, as well as to photons, phonons, ferro- and antiferromagnetic magnons, and (very specially) to Cooper pairs in superconductivity, are mentioned.

European Journal of Physics•Jan 1, 1999•22 citations

Thermodynamic properties of ideal Bose gas trapped in different external power-law potentials under generalized uncertainty principle*

Ya-Ting Wang, He-Ling Li

Abstract Significant evidence is available to support the quantum effects of gravity that lead to the generalized uncertainty principle (GUP) and the minimum observable length. Usually in quantum mechanics, statistical physics does not take gravity into account. Thermodynamic properties of ideal Bose gases in different external power-law potentials are studied under the GUP with a statistical physical method. Critical temperature, internal energy, heat capacity, entropy, particle number of ground state and excited state are calculated analytically to ideal Bose gases in the external potentials under the GUP. Below the critical temperature, taking the rubidium and sodium atoms, ideal Bose gases whose particle densities are under standard and experimental conditions, respectively, as examples, the relations of internal energy, heat capacity and entropy with temperature are analyzed numerically. Theoretical and numerical calculations show that: (1) the GUP leads to an increase in the critical temperature. (2) When the temperature is lower than the critical temperature and slightly higher than 0 K, the GUP’s amendments to internal energy, heat capacity and entropy etc are positive. As the temperature increases to a certain value, these amendments become negative. (3) The external potentials can increase or decrease the influence of the GUP on thermodynamic properties. When ε = 1 J, ε is the quantity that reflects the external potential intensity, and atomic density n = 2.687 × 10 25 m −3 , the GUP’s amendments to the internal energy, heat capacity and entropy of the rubidium atoms ideal Bose gas first decrease and then increase with the increase of X (where X ≡ Σ i 1/ t i is sum of the reciprocal of the exponents of the power function). In three-dimensional harmonic potential, the relative correction term of the GUP is 26 orders of magnitude larger than that of a free-particle system in a fixed container. (4) When ε ≈10 −31 J and n ≈ 10 20 m −3 (which are the experimental data when BEC was first verified by sodium atomic gas), the influence of the GUP can be completely ignored. (5) Under certain conditions, GUP may become the dominant factor governing the thermodynamic properties of the system.

arXiv:2002.03097•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Apr 1, 2020•0 citations
We have recently demonstrated that, when investigating the internal energy and pressure of an ideal boson gas at temperatures below the Bose–Einstein temperature, it is necessary to include the contribution from the kinetic energy of the particles in the condensate. Here we express the same requirement in terms of the constraints of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle applied to the particles confined in the condensate. The problem may be used by undergraduate students as an additional example of the connection between the ground state energy of a system and the Heisenberg uncertainty principle.
The ideal Bose gas has two major shortcomings: at zero temperature, all the particles 'condense' at zero energy or momentum, thus violating the Heisenberg principle; the second is that the pressure below the critical point is independent of density resulting in zero incompressibility (or infinite isothermal compressibility) which is unphysical. We propose a modification of the ideal Bose gas to take into account the Heisenberg principle. This modification results in a finite (in)compressibility at all temperatures and densities. The main properties of the ideal Bose gas are preserved, i.e. the relation between the critical temperature and density, but the specific heat has a maximum at the critical temperature instead of a discontinuity. Of course interactions are crucial for both cases in order to describe actual physical systems.
The pressure in the thermodynamic limit of a non-ideal Boson gas whose Hamiltonian includes only diagonal and pairing terms can be expressed as the infimum of a functional depending on two measures on momentum space: a positive measure describing the particle density and a complex measure describing the pair density. In this paper we examine this variational problem with the object of determining when the model exhibits Bose-Einstein condensation. In addition we show that if the pairing term in the Hamiltonian is positive then it has no effect
The nature of the Einstein-Bose condensation in an imperfect boson gas is discussed. It is argued that no matter how low the temperature, provided it is not zero, macroscopic second-sound waves should be weakly excited as thermal fluctuations about equilibrium. This implies that the single-particle momentum distribution must be smeared so that the state of zero momentum cannot contain a finite fraction of the particles. A microscopic mechanism which independently leads to a momentum spread is discussed. It is suggested that the actual Einstein-Bose condensation of an imperfect gas takes place in energy rather than momentum but that even in terms of this variable it becomes perfectly sharp only at zero temperature. This hypothesis is formulated analytically in terms of correlation functions of the second-quantized boson field.
Bose-Einstein condensation in an ideal (i.e. interactionless) boson gas can be studied analytically, at university-level statistical and solid state physics, in any positive dimensionality ( d >0) for identical bosons with any positive-exponent ( s >0) energy-momentum (i.e. dispersion) relation. Explicit formulae with arbitrary d / s are discussed for: the critical temperature (non-zero only if d / s >1); the condensate fraction; the internal energy; and the constant-volume specific heat (found to possess a jump discontinuity only if d / s >2). Classical results are recovered at sufficiently high temperatures. Applications to `ordinary' Bose-Einstein condensation, as well as to photons, phonons, ferro- and antiferromagnetic magnons, and (very specially) to Cooper pairs in superconductivity, are mentioned.
Abstract Significant evidence is available to support the quantum effects of gravity that lead to the generalized uncertainty principle (GUP) and the minimum observable length. Usually in quantum mechanics, statistical physics does not take gravity into account. Thermodynamic properties of ideal Bose gases in different external power-law potentials are studied under the GUP with a statistical physical method. Critical temperature, internal energy, heat capacity, entropy, particle number of ground state and excited state are calculated analytically to ideal Bose gases in the external potentials under the GUP. Below the critical temperature, taking the rubidium and sodium atoms, ideal Bose gases whose particle densities are under standard and experimental conditions, respectively, as examples, the relations of internal energy, heat capacity and entropy with temperature are analyzed numerically. Theoretical and numerical calculations show that: (1) the GUP leads to an increase in the critical temperature. (2) When the temperature is lower than the critical temperature and slightly higher than 0 K, the GUP’s amendments to internal energy, heat capacity and entropy etc are positive. As the temperature increases to a certain value, these amendments become negative. (3) The external potentials can increase or decrease the influence of the GUP on thermodynamic properties. When ε = 1 J, ε is the quantity that reflects the external potential intensity, and atomic density n = 2.687 × 10 25 m −3 , the GUP’s amendments to the internal energy, heat capacity and entropy of the rubidium atoms ideal Bose gas first decrease and then increase with the increase of X (where X ≡ Σ i 1/ t i is sum of the reciprocal of the exponents of the power function). In three-dimensional harmonic potential, the relative correction term of the GUP is 26 orders of magnitude larger than that of a free-particle system in a fixed container. (4) When ε ≈10 −31 J and n ≈ 10 20 m −3 (which are the experimental data when BEC was first verified by sodium atomic gas), the influence of the GUP can be completely ignored. (5) Under certain conditions, GUP may become the dominant factor governing the thermodynamic properties of the system.