It is well known that the concept of spin temperature may not be used to describe a statistical ensemble if the off-diagonal elements of the density matrix are not zero. This concept does not provide a valid description of masers, lasers, or conventional NMR or electron-spin resonance (ESR). It may be used to characterize transient behavior in a spin system "prepared" by sudden reversal of the magnetic field or a saturating pulse. Spin temperature, in such cases, is well defined after a time ${T}_{2}$. In nuclear-spin systems this is generally much shorter than the time ${T}_{1}$ required to reach thermal equilibrium with the lattice. The thermodynamics of irreversible processes provides an alternate and more comprehensive theoretical model for the description of spin systems. Examples are given where it may be used when the off-diagonal elements of the density matrix are not zero. The advantages and limitations of the spin-temperature formalism have been experimentally studied, primarily by means of the techniques of NMR. It is suggested that the predictions of irreversible thermodynamics be tested by observing the steady-state heat capacity of a maser at low temperature or the rate of evaporation of liquid helium in a transient experiment on a nuclear-spin system in which heat is being delivered irreversibly to the bath.
It is well known that the concept of spin temperature may not be used to describe a statistical ensemble if the off-diagonal elements of the density matrix are not zero. This concept does not provide a valid description of masers, lasers, or conventional NMR or electron-spin resonance (ESR). It may be used to characterize transient behavior in a spin system "prepared" by sudden reversal of the magnetic field or a saturating pulse. Spin temperature, in such cases, is well defined after a time T2. In nuclear-spin systems this is generally much shorter than the time T1 required to reach thermal equilibrium with the lattice. The thermodynamics of irreversible processes provides an alternate and more comprehensive theoretical model for the description of spin systems. Examples are given where it may be used when the off-diagonal elements of the density matrix are not zero. The advantages and limitations of the spin-temperature formalism have been experimentally studied, primarily by means of the techniques of NMR. It is suggested that the predictions of irreversible thermodynamics be tested by observing the steady-state heat capacity of a maser at low temperature or the rate of evaporation of liquid helium in a transient experiment on a nuclear-spin system in which heat is being delivered irreversibly to the bath.
The quantum dynamics of spin systems is often treated by a differential equation known as the master equation, which describes the trajectories of spin observables such as magnetization components, spin state populations, and coherences between spin states. The master equation describes how a perturbed spin system returns to a state of thermal equilibrium with a finite-temperature environment. The conventional master equation, which has the form of an inhomogeneous differential equation, applies to cases where the spin system remains close to thermal equilibrium, which is well satisfied for a wide variety of magnetic resonance experiments conducted on thermally polarized spin systems at ordinary temperatures. However, the conventional inhomogeneous master equation may fail in the case of hyperpolarized spin systems, when the spin state populations deviate strongly from thermal equilibrium, and in general where there is a high degree of nuclear spin order. We highlight a simple case in which the inhomogeneous master equation clearly fails, and propose an alternative master equation based on Lindblad superoperators which avoids most of the deficiencies of previous proposals. We discuss the strengths and limitations of the various formulations of the master equation, in the context of spin systems which are far from thermal equilibrium. The method is applied to several problems in nuclear magnetic resonance and to spin-isomer conversion.
What is the meaning of the thermodynamical temperature in quantum mechanics? What is its role in the classical limit? What can we say about the interplay between quantum and thermal fluctuations? Can we impose a constant-temperature constraint within dynamical simulations of quantum systems as we do in simulations of classical systems? These questions will be reviewed here. In particular, it will be shown how a quantum version of the celebrated Nos'e constant-temperature dynamics can be defined within the phase space formulation of quantum mechanics.
The ability to perform quantum error correction (QEC) arbitrarily many cycles is a significant challenge for scalable quantum information processing (QIP). Key requirements for multiple-round QEC are a high degree of quantum control, the ability to efficiently characterize both intrinsic and extrinsic noise, and the ability to dynamically and efficiently extract entropy from ancilla qubits. Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) based quantum devices have demonstrated high control fidelity with up to 12 qubits, and the noise characterizations can be performed using an efficient protocol known as randomized benchmarking. One of the remaining challenges with NMR systems is that qubit initialization is normally only attainable via thermal equilibration. This results in very low polarizations in reasonable experimental conditions. Moving to electron-nuclear coupled spin systems in a single crystal is a promising solution to the ancilla qubit preparation problem. One obvious advantage of incorporating electron spins comes from higher gyromagnetic ratio of the electron which yields about three orders of magnitude larger thermal spin polarization than that of nuclear spins in the same experimental condition. In addition, fast control of nuclear spins is possible provided appropriate level of anisotropic hyperfine interaction strength. The nuclear spins can be polarized even beyond the thermal electron spin temperature using a technique Heat-Bath Algorithmic Cooling (HBAC). With theoretical ideas in hand, the next step is to develop classical instrumentations to control electron-nuclear coupled systems and accomplish high fidelity coherent control. Noise characterizations are also necessary for benchmarking the quality of control over the electron-nuclear spin system. \nI first present example applications of NMR QIP with small number of qubits: Testing a foundational question in quantum mechanics and measuring spectral density of noise in a quantum system. Then I report on our home-built X-band electron spin resonance (ESR) spectrometer and progress in achieving high fidelity coherent control of electron and nuclear spins for QIP. We focus on implementing nuclear spin manipulation via anisotropic hyperfine interaction and microwave (mw) control, but discussions also include electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) control techniques. We perform realistic algorithmic simulations to show that an experimental cooling of nuclear spins below electron thermal temperature is feasible, and to present the electron-nuclear spin systems as promising testbeds for scalable QIP.
T. Blasberg: Coherent Raman scattering for optical detecti¬ on of NMR in Pr3+:YA103. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) is a powerful and versatile spec¬ troscopic technique. However, conventional NMR requires samples, which has to consist of at least 1017 nuclear spins. One of the most promising approaches to increase the sensitivity of this method relies on the resonant interaction of laser fields with atoms. The main goal of this thesis was the investigation and the improvement of coherent Raman scattering techniques for an optical heterodyne detection of NMR. All ex¬ periments were performed at cryogenic temperatures on Pr3+-ions, which were added to the host lattice YAIO3 (YAP). The coherent Raman scattering experiments consist of two distinct stages: firstly, the transient or continuous excitation of a coherent superposition between two nuclear spin states and secondly, its optical detection through coherent Raman scattering of a resonant, frequency-tunable test laser field from this sublevel coherence. For the theoretical description of the experiments, coherent Raman scattering in multilevel atoms is discussed in detail and a common solution for the Raman heterodyne beat signal in pump-and-probe experiments is derived. The dynamics of a three-level atom that interacts with two resonant electromagnetic fields is treated making use of the density-matrix formalism. The method of Raman heterodyne detection of NMR uses a resonant radio frequency field to drive the magnetic-dipole transition between two nuclear spin states. This technique was used to determine the orientation of the nuclear quadrupole tensors of Pr3+ at its two non-equivalent lattice sites in YAP by measuring the dependence of the transition frequencies on the orientation of an external magnetic field. In the electronic ground state 3H4, the quantization axes of the nuclear spin eigenfunctions are ro¬ tated by po=±56.4° relative to the crystal b-axis. The corresponding rota¬ tion angle in the electronically excited state !D2 is Po=±105.2°. With this new value for the relative orientation of the quantization axes in both electronic states, the relative strengths of all 3H4 1D2 transitions could be calculated. The different orientation of the quantization axes in the two electronic states gives rise to a strong state mixing of the nuclear spin eigenfunctions and is the reason, why most of the optical transitions be¬ tween nuclear spin substates of different electronic states have similar oscillator strengths. Pr:YAP is therefore an ideal model system for the investigation of coherent Raman scattering. A new rf-optical triple-resonance experiment was developed that is a combination of Raman heterodyne detection of NMR and spectral holeburning. This technique allows the unambiguous determination of the ab¬ solute sign of nuclear quadrupole coupling constants. In the electronic ground state of PnYAP, the quadrupole coupling constant was found to be negative (D=-3.5289 MHz) being the result of dominant pseudoquadrupole contributions. The pump-and-probe technique, which uses a frequency-tunable test laser beam, was used to investigate the influence of an inhomogeneous broadening of the optical resonance line on Raman heterodyne detection of NMR. A hitherto unknown interference effect could be predicted and verified by the experiments. A prerequisite for this interference effect is that coherent Raman scattering in different opti¬ cal transitions can contribute to the total Raman heterodyne beat signal. These optical transitions represent different 'scattering pathways', whose contributions to the total beat signal can interfere destructively with each other, since the heterodyne beat signal depends linearly on the relevant transition matrix elements. The rf-optical triple resonance technique al¬ lows to circumvent this interference effect, since the frequency-tunable test laser field can be used to select only one of the various scattering pathways. A new and efficient excitation scheme was developed, which allows the observation of coherent Raman beats in systems with arbitrary wide sublevel spectra and small oscillator strengths. The method utilizes a bichromatic laser field for the purely optical excitation of a coherent superposition between two nuclear spin substates. For the preparation of the sublevel coherence, the two frequency components couple two different nuclear spin substates of the same electronic state to a different electronic state. With the help of the density-matrix formalism, the dyna¬ mics of a three-level atom during the bichromatic excitation were calcu¬ lated. Those experimental parameters could be identified that determine the excitation efficiency. While in the purely optical method of coherent Raman beats almost 10_1 of the incident test laser photons were coherent¬ ly Raman scattered, the corresponding figure of merit of Raman hetero¬ dyne detection of NMR was less man 10-3. From the decay of hole-burning spectra in the presence of a saturating rf-field the temperature-dependence of the nuclear spin relaxation rates of Pr:YAP was determined in the temperature range 3-9 K. At low tem¬ peratures, the relaxation is dominated by mutual spin flips whereas at higher temperatures Orbach and Raman relaxation become of importan¬ ce. A simple rate-equation model allowed to calculate the entire hole-bur¬ ning spectrum of the crystal.
In dealing with systems whose eigenstates are known, such as ideal spin systems in a magnetic field, it is sometimes useful to introduce a formalism involving the density matrix. Knowledge of the density matrix operator permits the expectation values of other operators to be determined in a way that is straightforward in principle. In the presence of a magnetic field or some other polarizing mechanism, the form of the density matrix will change, and the expectation value, for example, may be nonzero. Although the situation that has been considered involves an electron beam, a related but somewhat more complicated approach is used for polarized light beams.
Explanation of decoherence and quasi-equilibrium in systems with few degrees of freedom demands a deep theoretical analysis that considers the observed system as an open quantum system. In this work, we study the problem of decoherence of an observed system of quantum interacting particles, coupled to a quantum lattice. Our strategy is based on treating the environment and the system-environment Hamiltonians fully quantum mechanically, which yields a representation of the time evolution operator useful for disentangling the different time scales underlying in the observed system dynamics. To describe the possible different stages of the dynamics of the observed system, we introduce quantum mechanical definitions of essentially isolated, essentially adiabatic, and thermal-contact system-environment interactions. This general approach is then applied to the study of decoherence and quasi-equilibrium in proton nuclear magnetic resonance ((1)H NMR) of nematic liquid crystals. A summary of the original results of this work is as follows. We calculate the decoherence function and apply it to describe the evolution of a coherent spin state, induced by the coupling with the molecular environment, in absence of spin-lattice relaxation. By assuming quantum energy conserving or non-demolition interactions, we identify an intermediate time scale, between those controlled by self-interactions and thermalization, where coherence decays irreversibly. This treatment is also adequate for explaining the buildup of quasi-equilibrium of the proton spin system, via the process we called eigen-selectivity. By analyzing a hypothetical time reversal experiment, we identify two sources of coherence loss which are of a very different nature and give rise to distinct time scales of the spin dynamics: (a) reversible or adiabatic quantum decoherence and (b) irreversible or essentially adiabatic quantum decoherence. Local irreversibility arises as a consequence of the uncertainty introduced by the coupling with an infinite quantum environment. The reversible part can be represented by a semiclassical model, similar to standard line-shape adiabatic models. By exploiting the separation existing between the time scales of the spin coherences and the irreversible decoherence, we present a novel technique to obtain the orientational molecular distribution function for a nematic liquid crystal. The procedure is based on the comparison of the observed coherence time evolution and numerical calculation under the adiabatic quantum decoherence approach. As an example, it is used the experimental free induction decay from a nematic PAA(d6) sample to extract such an orientational distribution. This is the first theoretical description of the experimental liquid crystal NMR signal in the time domain. On the contrary, the irreversible decoherence is intrinsically full-quantum mechanical, as it is governed by the commutation properties of the environment and the spin-lattice Hamiltonians. Consistently, it depends on the molecular correlation in a decisive way, since it vanishes under a mean-field model for the molecular dynamics. The results of this work can contribute to the understanding of the open question of the applicability of the spin-temperature concept in spin systems with few degrees of freedom.