Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

Quantum jumps and classical harmonics

William A. Fedak, Jeffrey J. Prentis

Published Mar 1, 2002• 33 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We present an introduction to quantum mechanics based on the formal correspondence between the atomic properties of quantum jumps and the classical harmonics of the electron’s periodic motion. By adding a simple quantum condition to the classical Fourier analysis, we readily find the energies of the stationary states, calculate the transition probabilities between the states, and construct the line spectrum of the emitted light. We provide examples to illustrate the asymptotic, and sometimes exact, agreement between the classical-quantum results (Fourier harmonics) and the exact quantum results (Heisenberg harmonics).

DOI
10.1119/1.1445405

Related papers

The fundamental equations of quantum mechanics

P. A. M. Dirac

Abstract It is well known that the experimental facts of atomic physics necessitate a departure from the classical theory of electrodynamics in the description of atomic phenomena. This departure takes the form, in Bohr’s theory, of the special assumptions of the existence of stationary states of an atom, in which it does not radiate, and of certain rules, called quantum conditions, which fix the stationary states and the frequencies of the radiation emitted during transitions between them. These assumptions are quite foreign to the classical theory, but have been very successful in the interpretation of a restricted region of atomic phenomena. The only way in which the classical theory is used is through the assumption that the classical laws hold for the description of the motion in the stationary states, although they fail completely during transitions, and the assumption, called the Correspondence Principle, that the classical theory gives the right results in the limiting case when the action per cycle of the system is large compared to Planck’s constant h, and in certain other special cases. In a recent paper Heisenberg puts forward a new theory, which suggests that it is not the equations of classical mechanics that are in any way at fault, but that the mathematical operations by which physical results are deduced from them require modification. All the information supplied by the classical theory can thus be made use of in the new theory.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series A Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character•Dec 1, 1925•573 citations

The classical physics pathway

P. van der Straten, Harold J. Metcalf

Introduction While it might appear that the nineteenth-century physics presented in this chapter has no place in a topic as quantum mechanically oriented as atomic physics, this is simply not the case. The purpose of this first chapter is to try to convince the readers that the material learned in their early years of studying physics is not disjoint from modern topics, but in fact can provide a foundation for their further understanding. Other examples will occur later. The reader may be a bit surprised to see that the results of the classical description turn out to be so close to the quantum mechanical results. Where there are significant disagreements between classical and quantum descriptions, it is necessary to explain why these occur. The correspondence principle requires that in the limit of large quantum numbers the complete quantum mechanical description must agree with the classical one. It is always better to need fewer of these explanations and to be able to treat physics as a coherent whole instead of a collection of topics. The consequences of classical physics are intuitively familiar, and this is often most helpful in gaining deeper understanding. In fact, the approach taken in very many of the chapters in this book is to start with a purely classical description of a topic, and then transport it directly into the Schrödinger equation. Radiation from an accelerated charge, as treated here in the harmonic case, provides an ideal setting for such pedagogy. Even though classical mechanics is used in place of quantum mechanics, for the case of harmonic motion, the results are quite compatible. The early history of atomic physics contains many topics that are well worth reading about, especially the experimental facilities. For example, there were no electric motors, wire was not readily available, and making even a crude vacuum was an experimental tour de force. Very many textbooks have discussions of these topics, and so they will not be presented here. But the reader is warned that certain oft-repeated modern descriptions are simply wrong. Perhaps the most important notion to be gained from this chapter is that the classical description of a harmonically bound electron provides quite accurate results about the interaction between atoms and light. Of course, the utility of this description is limited because the classical harmonic oscillator has no internal structure, is infinitely deep, and has a continuous energy spectrum.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 31, 2015•0 citations

Transitions

P. C. W. Davies, David S. Betts

In many practical cases a stationary system is perturbed in some way, inducing it to undergo transitions between the otherwise stationary states. Perhaps the best example concerns the radiative transitions of atomic electrons in which the disturbance of an external electromagnetic field causes the electrons to jump between energy levels, emitting or absorbing photons. Equation is a statement of the classical law of conservation of energy. The stimulated emission and absorption of radiation both have close classical analogues. If a simple harmonic oscillator is driven by a sinusoidal electromagnetic field it can gain or lose energy depending on phase angles. The existence of spontaneous emission implies that all excited states of electrical systems are unstable and will eventually decay to the ground state by photon emission. Quantum systems thus comply with the fundamental principle that physical systems tend to seek out their state of lowest energy and maximum entropy.

Routledge eBooks•Apr 27, 2018•0 citations

Introduction to Quantum Mechanics: Schrodinger Equation and Path Integral

Harald J W Müller-Kirsten

This text on quantum mechanics begins by covering all the main topics of an introduction to the subject. It then concentrates on newer developments. In particular it continues with the perturbative solution of the Schrodinger equation for various potentials and thereafter with the introduction and evaluation of their path integral counterparts. Considerations of the large order behavior of the perturbation expansions show that in most applications these are asymptotic expansions. The parallel consideration of path integrals requires the evaluation of these around periodic classical configurations, the fluctuation equations about which lead back to specific wave equations. The period of the classical configurations is related to temperature, and permits transitions to the thermal domain to be classified as phase transitions. In this second edition of the text important applications and numerous examples have been added. In particular, the chapter on the Coulomb potential has been extended to include an introduction to chemical bonds, the chapter on periodic potentials has been supplemented by a section on the band theory of metals and semiconductors, and in the chapter on large order behavior a section has been added illustrating the success of converging factors in the evaluation of asymptotic expansions. Detailed calculations permit the reader to follow every step.

•Mar 3, 2006•49 citations

A Concise Introduction to Quantum Mechanics

Mark S. Swanson

Assuming a background in basic classical physics, multivariable calculus, and differential equations, A Concise Introduction to Quantum Mechanics provides a self-contained presentation of the mathematics and physics of quantum mechanics. The relevant aspects of classical mechanics and electrodynamics are reviewed, and the basic concepts of wave-particle duality are developed as a logical outgrowth of experiments involving blackbody radiation, the photoelectric effect, and electron diffraction. The Copenhagen interpretation of the wave function and its relation to the particle probability density is presented in conjunction with Fourier analysis and its generalization to function spaces. These concepts are combined to analyze the system consisting of a particle confined to a box, developing the probabilistic interpretation of observations and their associated expectation values. The Schrödinger equation is then derived by using these results and demanding both Galilean invariance of the probability density and Newtonian energy-momentum relations. The general properties of the Schrödinger equation and its solutions are analyzed, and the theory of observables is developed along with the associated Heisenberg uncertainty principle. Basic applications of wave mechanics are made to free wave packet spreading, barrier penetration, the simple harmonic oscillator, the Hydrogen atom, and an electric charge in a uniform magnetic field. In addition, Dirac notation, elements of Hilbert space theory, operator techniques, and matrix algebra are presented and used to analyze coherent states, the linear potential, two state oscillations, and electron diffraction. Applications are made to photon and electron spin and the addition of angular momentum, and direct product multiparticle states are used to formulate both the Pauli exclusion principle and quantum decoherence. The book concludes with an introduction to the rotation group and the general properties of angular momentum.

Morgan & Claypool Publishers eBooks•Feb 1, 2018•4 citations

The Relation between Classical Mechanics and Wave Mechanics

Yoshio Nishiyama

Introducing a dimensional unit \hbar into classical mechanics, we make classical wave functions √ρ1exp (iS1/\hbar)-√ρ2exp (iS2/\hbar) for a one-particle system in the configuration space where √ρ1exp (iS1/\hbar) corresponds to the incident path (or one half) of an orbit and √ρ2exp (iS2/\hbar) to the outgoing (or another half), and ρ's and S's are densities and actions respectively. These classical wave functions are compared with the corresponding wave functions of solutions of the Schrödinger equation for three one-particle systems, the scattering by a Coulomb potential, the linear harmonic oscillator and an electron bound by a Coulomb potential. From the essential correspondence between them it is concluded that the Schrödinger wave function describes the steady, causal but a little imaginary motion of the one-particle system as √ρexp (iS/\hbar) in the configuration space where ρ is a density and S an action, and that the states which the wave equation describes exist continuously (not discrete) and the (discrete) stationary states are the ones where √ρexp (iS/\hbar) is uniquely determined throughout an orbit. The Dirac equation shows that an electron of optics (or the electromagnetic wave equation) can be considered as the Schrödinger (or Dirac) equation for the motion of a photon, a particle, in a potential. A quantum-electrodynamical wave equation which is composed of the Dirac equation with a Coulomb potential and the electromagnetic wave equation is constructed for the steady motion of a one-electron system without recource to the so-called second-quantization method. It gives finite energy shifts. A line shift is calculated: ΔE(2S1/2 →2P1/2) \cong709 Mc/s.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Nov 1, 1963•1 citation
We present an introduction to quantum mechanics based on the formal correspondence between the atomic properties of quantum jumps and the classical harmonics of the electron’s periodic motion. By adding a simple quantum condition to the classical Fourier analysis, we readily find the energies of the stationary states, calculate the transition probabilities between the states, and construct the line spectrum of the emitted light. We provide examples to illustrate the asymptotic, and sometimes exact, agreement between the classical-quantum results (Fourier harmonics) and the exact quantum results (Heisenberg harmonics).
Abstract It is well known that the experimental facts of atomic physics necessitate a departure from the classical theory of electrodynamics in the description of atomic phenomena. This departure takes the form, in Bohr’s theory, of the special assumptions of the existence of stationary states of an atom, in which it does not radiate, and of certain rules, called quantum conditions, which fix the stationary states and the frequencies of the radiation emitted during transitions between them. These assumptions are quite foreign to the classical theory, but have been very successful in the interpretation of a restricted region of atomic phenomena. The only way in which the classical theory is used is through the assumption that the classical laws hold for the description of the motion in the stationary states, although they fail completely during transitions, and the assumption, called the Correspondence Principle, that the classical theory gives the right results in the limiting case when the action per cycle of the system is large compared to Planck’s constant h, and in certain other special cases. In a recent paper Heisenberg puts forward a new theory, which suggests that it is not the equations of classical mechanics that are in any way at fault, but that the mathematical operations by which physical results are deduced from them require modification. All the information supplied by the classical theory can thus be made use of in the new theory.
Introduction While it might appear that the nineteenth-century physics presented in this chapter has no place in a topic as quantum mechanically oriented as atomic physics, this is simply not the case. The purpose of this first chapter is to try to convince the readers that the material learned in their early years of studying physics is not disjoint from modern topics, but in fact can provide a foundation for their further understanding. Other examples will occur later. The reader may be a bit surprised to see that the results of the classical description turn out to be so close to the quantum mechanical results. Where there are significant disagreements between classical and quantum descriptions, it is necessary to explain why these occur. The correspondence principle requires that in the limit of large quantum numbers the complete quantum mechanical description must agree with the classical one. It is always better to need fewer of these explanations and to be able to treat physics as a coherent whole instead of a collection of topics. The consequences of classical physics are intuitively familiar, and this is often most helpful in gaining deeper understanding. In fact, the approach taken in very many of the chapters in this book is to start with a purely classical description of a topic, and then transport it directly into the Schrödinger equation. Radiation from an accelerated charge, as treated here in the harmonic case, provides an ideal setting for such pedagogy. Even though classical mechanics is used in place of quantum mechanics, for the case of harmonic motion, the results are quite compatible. The early history of atomic physics contains many topics that are well worth reading about, especially the experimental facilities. For example, there were no electric motors, wire was not readily available, and making even a crude vacuum was an experimental tour de force. Very many textbooks have discussions of these topics, and so they will not be presented here. But the reader is warned that certain oft-repeated modern descriptions are simply wrong. Perhaps the most important notion to be gained from this chapter is that the classical description of a harmonically bound electron provides quite accurate results about the interaction between atoms and light. Of course, the utility of this description is limited because the classical harmonic oscillator has no internal structure, is infinitely deep, and has a continuous energy spectrum.
In many practical cases a stationary system is perturbed in some way, inducing it to undergo transitions between the otherwise stationary states. Perhaps the best example concerns the radiative transitions of atomic electrons in which the disturbance of an external electromagnetic field causes the electrons to jump between energy levels, emitting or absorbing photons. Equation is a statement of the classical law of conservation of energy. The stimulated emission and absorption of radiation both have close classical analogues. If a simple harmonic oscillator is driven by a sinusoidal electromagnetic field it can gain or lose energy depending on phase angles. The existence of spontaneous emission implies that all excited states of electrical systems are unstable and will eventually decay to the ground state by photon emission. Quantum systems thus comply with the fundamental principle that physical systems tend to seek out their state of lowest energy and maximum entropy.
This text on quantum mechanics begins by covering all the main topics of an introduction to the subject. It then concentrates on newer developments. In particular it continues with the perturbative solution of the Schrodinger equation for various potentials and thereafter with the introduction and evaluation of their path integral counterparts. Considerations of the large order behavior of the perturbation expansions show that in most applications these are asymptotic expansions. The parallel consideration of path integrals requires the evaluation of these around periodic classical configurations, the fluctuation equations about which lead back to specific wave equations. The period of the classical configurations is related to temperature, and permits transitions to the thermal domain to be classified as phase transitions. In this second edition of the text important applications and numerous examples have been added. In particular, the chapter on the Coulomb potential has been extended to include an introduction to chemical bonds, the chapter on periodic potentials has been supplemented by a section on the band theory of metals and semiconductors, and in the chapter on large order behavior a section has been added illustrating the success of converging factors in the evaluation of asymptotic expansions. Detailed calculations permit the reader to follow every step.
Assuming a background in basic classical physics, multivariable calculus, and differential equations, A Concise Introduction to Quantum Mechanics provides a self-contained presentation of the mathematics and physics of quantum mechanics. The relevant aspects of classical mechanics and electrodynamics are reviewed, and the basic concepts of wave-particle duality are developed as a logical outgrowth of experiments involving blackbody radiation, the photoelectric effect, and electron diffraction. The Copenhagen interpretation of the wave function and its relation to the particle probability density is presented in conjunction with Fourier analysis and its generalization to function spaces. These concepts are combined to analyze the system consisting of a particle confined to a box, developing the probabilistic interpretation of observations and their associated expectation values. The Schrödinger equation is then derived by using these results and demanding both Galilean invariance of the probability density and Newtonian energy-momentum relations. The general properties of the Schrödinger equation and its solutions are analyzed, and the theory of observables is developed along with the associated Heisenberg uncertainty principle. Basic applications of wave mechanics are made to free wave packet spreading, barrier penetration, the simple harmonic oscillator, the Hydrogen atom, and an electric charge in a uniform magnetic field. In addition, Dirac notation, elements of Hilbert space theory, operator techniques, and matrix algebra are presented and used to analyze coherent states, the linear potential, two state oscillations, and electron diffraction. Applications are made to photon and electron spin and the addition of angular momentum, and direct product multiparticle states are used to formulate both the Pauli exclusion principle and quantum decoherence. The book concludes with an introduction to the rotation group and the general properties of angular momentum.
Introducing a dimensional unit \hbar into classical mechanics, we make classical wave functions √ρ1exp (iS1/\hbar)-√ρ2exp (iS2/\hbar) for a one-particle system in the configuration space where √ρ1exp (iS1/\hbar) corresponds to the incident path (or one half) of an orbit and √ρ2exp (iS2/\hbar) to the outgoing (or another half), and ρ's and S's are densities and actions respectively. These classical wave functions are compared with the corresponding wave functions of solutions of the Schrödinger equation for three one-particle systems, the scattering by a Coulomb potential, the linear harmonic oscillator and an electron bound by a Coulomb potential. From the essential correspondence between them it is concluded that the Schrödinger wave function describes the steady, causal but a little imaginary motion of the one-particle system as √ρexp (iS/\hbar) in the configuration space where ρ is a density and S an action, and that the states which the wave equation describes exist continuously (not discrete) and the (discrete) stationary states are the ones where √ρexp (iS/\hbar) is uniquely determined throughout an orbit. The Dirac equation shows that an electron of optics (or the electromagnetic wave equation) can be considered as the Schrödinger (or Dirac) equation for the motion of a photon, a particle, in a potential. A quantum-electrodynamical wave equation which is composed of the Dirac equation with a Coulomb potential and the electromagnetic wave equation is constructed for the steady motion of a one-electron system without recource to the so-called second-quantization method. It gives finite energy shifts. A line shift is calculated: ΔE(2S1/2 →2P1/2) \cong709 Mc/s.