Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Mathematical Physics

Quantum axiomatics, representation theorem, and communicability of observations in physics

Adolf Miklavc

Published Aug 1, 1977• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

We show how a fundamental assumption in the Dirac formulation of quantum mechanics, namely that the states of a physical system at a particular time are mathematically represented by unit vectors in Hilbert space, can be deduced from certain aspects of our experimental procedures and of the observed outcome of quantum mechanical experiments. Our assumptions have clear empirical meaning and the results hold true for any dimensionality of the system, without anomalies in low dimensions which exist in the two well-known axiomatic approaches to quantum mechanics. The propositional logic approach of Birkhoff and von Neumann does not work for quantum systems of dimension less than four and requires an assumption which does not have an empirical basis. Jordan algebra axioms, on the other hand, also lead to anomalies in low dimensions and, moreover, are formal and cannot be directly physically interpreted. In our work it was possible to avoid these shortcomings.

DOI
10.1063/1.523456

Related papers

On the field of the quantum mechanical Hilbert space

Adolf Miklavc

The well-known limitations on the field of the quantum mechanical vector space, which, within the framework of the propositional logic of Birkhoff and von Neumann, can be obtained only for systems of dimension greater than or equal to four, are obtained here for all dimensions. The propositional logic fails to provide any information about the quantum systems of dimension less than four and, moreover, one does not know the empirical meaning of one of its basic assumptions. The Jordan algebra approach, on the other hand, which provides the same limitations on the field, also suffers from anomalies in low dimensions and is altogether formal rather than physical. In the present work, which is based on a recent study of the topological properties of quantum states, there are no low-dimensional anomalies and the assumptions have clear empirical meaning.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Aug 1, 1977•1 citation

Seven Principles of Quantum Mechanics

Igor Vasil'evich Volovich

The list of basic axioms of quantum mechanics as it was formulated by von Neumann includes only the mathematical formalism of the Hilbert space and its statistical interpretation. We point out that such an approach is too general to be considered as the foundation of quantum mechanics. In particular in this approach any finite-dimensional Hilbert space describes a quantum system. Though such a treatment might be a convenient approximation it can not be considered as a fundamental description of a quantum system and moreover it leads to some paradoxes like Bell's theorem. I present a list from seven basic postulates of axiomatic quantum mechanics. In particular the list includes the axiom describing spatial properties of quantum system. These axioms do not admit a nontrivial realization in the finite-dimensional Hilbert space. One suggests that the axiomatic quantum mechanics is consistent with local realism.

arXiv:quant-ph/0212126•Dec 22, 2002•19 citations

Quantum Mechanics (Revisited)

Jean Claude Dutailly

The paper proposes a new approach in the foundations of Quantum Mechanics.It does not make any assumption about the physical world, but looks at the consequences of the formalism used in models.Whenever a system is represented by variables which meet precise, but common, mathematical properties, one can prove theorems which are very close to the axioms of Quantum Mechanics (Hilbert spaces, observables, eigen values,...).It is then possible to explore the conditions of the validity of these axioms and to give a firm ground to the usual computations.Moreover this approach sheds a new ligth on the issues of determism, and interacting systems.In the third edition of this paper developments have been added about the statistical procedures used to detect anomalies in Physical Laws.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Aug 17, 2015•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics (Revisited)

The paper proposes a new approach in the foundations of Quantum Mechanics.It does not make any assumption about the physical world, but looks at the consequences of the formalism used in models.Whenever a system is represented by variables which meet precise, but common, mathematical properties, one can prove theorems which are very close to the axioms of Quantum Mechanics (Hilbert spaces, observables, eigen values,...).It is then possible to explore the conditions of the validity of these axioms and to give a firm ground to the usual computations.Moreover this approach sheds a new ligth on the issues of determism, and interacting systems.In the third edition of this paper developments have been added about the statistical procedures used to detect anomalies in Physical Laws.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Mar 1, 2010•1 citation

A Logic of Quantum Measurement

Olivier Brunet

We present a formulation of quantum mechanics based on a logic representing some aspects of the behaviour of the measurement process. With such an approach, we make no direct mention of quantum states, and thus avoid the problems associated to this rather evasive notion. We then study some properties of the models of this logic, and deduce some characteristics that any model (and hence any formulation of quantum mechanics compatible with its prediction and relying on a notion of measurement) should verify. The main results we obtain are that in the case of a Hilbert space of dimension at least 3, no model can lead to the prediction with certainty of more than one atomic outcome. Moreover, if the Hilbert space is finite dimensional, then we are able to precisely describe the structure of the predictions of any model of our logic. As a consequence, we finally show that all the models of our logic make exactly the same predictions regarding whether a given sequence of outcomes is possible or not.

•Feb 17, 2015•0 citations

Operational Axioms for Quantum Mechanics

Giacomo Mauro D’Ariano

The mathematical formulation of Quantum Mechanics in terms of complex Hilbert space is derived for finite dimensions, starting from a general definition of "physical experiment" and from five simple Postulates concerning "experimental accessibility and simplicity". For the infinite dimensional case, on the other hand, a C*-algebra representation of physical transformations is derived, starting from just four of the five Postulates via a Gelfand-Naimark-Segal (GNS) construction. The present paper simplifies and sharpens the previous derivation in version 1. The main ingredient of the axiomatization is the postulated existence of "faithful states" that allows one to calibrate the experimental apparatus. Such notion is at the basis of the operational definitions of the scalar product and of the "transposed" of a physical transformation. What is new in the present paper with respect to quant-ph/0603011 is the operational deduction of an involution corresponding to the "complex-conjugation" for effects, whose extension to transformations allows to define the "adjoint" of a transformation when the extension is composition-preserving.

arXiv:quant-ph/0611094•Nov 8, 2006•8 citations
We show how a fundamental assumption in the Dirac formulation of quantum mechanics, namely that the states of a physical system at a particular time are mathematically represented by unit vectors in Hilbert space, can be deduced from certain aspects of our experimental procedures and of the observed outcome of quantum mechanical experiments. Our assumptions have clear empirical meaning and the results hold true for any dimensionality of the system, without anomalies in low dimensions which exist in the two well-known axiomatic approaches to quantum mechanics. The propositional logic approach of Birkhoff and von Neumann does not work for quantum systems of dimension less than four and requires an assumption which does not have an empirical basis. Jordan algebra axioms, on the other hand, also lead to anomalies in low dimensions and, moreover, are formal and cannot be directly physically interpreted. In our work it was possible to avoid these shortcomings.
The well-known limitations on the field of the quantum mechanical vector space, which, within the framework of the propositional logic of Birkhoff and von Neumann, can be obtained only for systems of dimension greater than or equal to four, are obtained here for all dimensions. The propositional logic fails to provide any information about the quantum systems of dimension less than four and, moreover, one does not know the empirical meaning of one of its basic assumptions. The Jordan algebra approach, on the other hand, which provides the same limitations on the field, also suffers from anomalies in low dimensions and is altogether formal rather than physical. In the present work, which is based on a recent study of the topological properties of quantum states, there are no low-dimensional anomalies and the assumptions have clear empirical meaning.
The list of basic axioms of quantum mechanics as it was formulated by von Neumann includes only the mathematical formalism of the Hilbert space and its statistical interpretation. We point out that such an approach is too general to be considered as the foundation of quantum mechanics. In particular in this approach any finite-dimensional Hilbert space describes a quantum system. Though such a treatment might be a convenient approximation it can not be considered as a fundamental description of a quantum system and moreover it leads to some paradoxes like Bell's theorem. I present a list from seven basic postulates of axiomatic quantum mechanics. In particular the list includes the axiom describing spatial properties of quantum system. These axioms do not admit a nontrivial realization in the finite-dimensional Hilbert space. One suggests that the axiomatic quantum mechanics is consistent with local realism.
The paper proposes a new approach in the foundations of Quantum Mechanics.It does not make any assumption about the physical world, but looks at the consequences of the formalism used in models.Whenever a system is represented by variables which meet precise, but common, mathematical properties, one can prove theorems which are very close to the axioms of Quantum Mechanics (Hilbert spaces, observables, eigen values,...).It is then possible to explore the conditions of the validity of these axioms and to give a firm ground to the usual computations.Moreover this approach sheds a new ligth on the issues of determism, and interacting systems.In the third edition of this paper developments have been added about the statistical procedures used to detect anomalies in Physical Laws.
The paper proposes a new approach in the foundations of Quantum Mechanics.It does not make any assumption about the physical world, but looks at the consequences of the formalism used in models.Whenever a system is represented by variables which meet precise, but common, mathematical properties, one can prove theorems which are very close to the axioms of Quantum Mechanics (Hilbert spaces, observables, eigen values,...).It is then possible to explore the conditions of the validity of these axioms and to give a firm ground to the usual computations.Moreover this approach sheds a new ligth on the issues of determism, and interacting systems.In the third edition of this paper developments have been added about the statistical procedures used to detect anomalies in Physical Laws.
We present a formulation of quantum mechanics based on a logic representing some aspects of the behaviour of the measurement process. With such an approach, we make no direct mention of quantum states, and thus avoid the problems associated to this rather evasive notion. We then study some properties of the models of this logic, and deduce some characteristics that any model (and hence any formulation of quantum mechanics compatible with its prediction and relying on a notion of measurement) should verify. The main results we obtain are that in the case of a Hilbert space of dimension at least 3, no model can lead to the prediction with certainty of more than one atomic outcome. Moreover, if the Hilbert space is finite dimensional, then we are able to precisely describe the structure of the predictions of any model of our logic. As a consequence, we finally show that all the models of our logic make exactly the same predictions regarding whether a given sequence of outcomes is possible or not.
The mathematical formulation of Quantum Mechanics in terms of complex Hilbert space is derived for finite dimensions, starting from a general definition of "physical experiment" and from five simple Postulates concerning "experimental accessibility and simplicity". For the infinite dimensional case, on the other hand, a C*-algebra representation of physical transformations is derived, starting from just four of the five Postulates via a Gelfand-Naimark-Segal (GNS) construction. The present paper simplifies and sharpens the previous derivation in version 1. The main ingredient of the axiomatization is the postulated existence of "faithful states" that allows one to calibrate the experimental apparatus. Such notion is at the basis of the operational definitions of the scalar product and of the "transposed" of a physical transformation. What is new in the present paper with respect to quant-ph/0603011 is the operational deduction of an involution corresponding to the "complex-conjugation" for effects, whose extension to transformations allows to define the "adjoint" of a transformation when the extension is composition-preserving.