Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

The Schrödinger-Einstein correspondence and the sources of wave mechanics

Paul A. Hanle

Published Jul 1, 1979• 11 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Unpublished letters of late 1925 between Einstein and Schrödinger and the doctoral thesis of de Broglie reveal sources of Schrödinger’s inspiration to invent wave mechanics. Schrödinger saw a congenial similarity of de Broglie’s work on the stability of the atom with his own earlier speculation in relativity, which he noted to Einstein. But the last chapter of de Broglie’s thesis, on quantum statistics of gases, which is unfamiliar to many modern readers, provided Schrödinger with the method of treatment of a gas of material particles considered as a system of modes of vibration, of ’’matter waves.’’ This method especially, and other successes of de Broglie’s ’’ingenious thesis,’’ convinced Schrödinger to take seriously the first part, on the conditions of stability of the atom in a wave picture. Thus he sought and found an equation to describe the states of the electron from the matter-wave viewpoint.

DOI
10.1119/1.11950

Related papers

Schrödinger Equation and Wave Function

S. Rajasekar, R. Velusamy

During 1925 three different but equivalent versions of quantum theory were proposed, Schrodinger proposed wave mechanics; Heisenberg developed matrix mechanics and Dirac-introduced operator theory. Considering the de Broglie's matter waves Erwin Schrödinger, an Austrian physicist, argued that if a particle like an electron behaves as a wave then the equation of wave motion could be successfully applied to it. He postulated a function varying in both space and time in a wave-like manner. Schrodinger set up a linear and time-dependent wave-like equation, called Schrodinger wave equation, to describe the wave aspect of a particle taking account of de Broglie's relation for wavelength. This chapter discusses the Schrodinger equation and explores the general properties of the solution of the Schrodinger equation. It verifies the Ehrenfest's theorem in certain interesting systems and solves equation for linear harmonic oscillator and shows that their solutions are identical to the solutions of classical equation of motion.

CRC Press eBooks•Sep 29, 2022•0 citations

Schrödinger’s Derivation of the Wave Equation: Quantization as an Eigenvalue Problem

Jim Baggott

Bohr’s theory of the atom was in trouble as soon as it was formulated. Further detailed spectroscopy studies encouraged a proliferation of quantum numbers and ‘selection rules’ in what became known as the Bohr–Sommerfeld model. It couldn’t last, and by 1925 the theory was in crisis. The immediate concern was with the quantum numbers themselves. Where did they come from? Could de Broglie’s hypothesis shed any light? In October 1925 the attentions of Erwin Schrödinger were drawn to a footnote in one of Einstein’s recent papers. Intrigued, Schrödinger acquired a copy of de Broglie’s PhD thesis. Although he eventually published a more obscure derivation, Schrödinger essentially applied the de Broglie relation to the classical equation of wave motion. He applied the result to the hydrogen atom, and showed that the quantum numbers emerge ‘in the same natural way as the integers specifying the number of nodes in a vibrating string’.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jan 10, 2020•0 citations

De Broglie & Schrödinger

Jonathan Allday

In 1924, a young PhD student submitted a thesis containing the germ of an idea that would revolutionize our understanding of the material world. The student was Louis De Broglie, and for a while, he had been meditating on the wave/particle nature of light. De Broglie’s ideas were greeted rather sceptically at first. His PhD supervisor even asked for a second copy so he could send it to Einstein for his opinion. Einstein gave the work his seal of approval. News of De Broglie’s thesis spread around the physics community from 1924 to 1925. In autumn 1925, Erwin Schrodinger was visiting colleagues in Switzerland and was asked to present a summary of De Broglie’s work. Having studied De Broglie’s thesis in some detail he became an enthusiastic supporter. During the Christmas and New Year of 1925/1926, Schrodinger holidayed in the Alps with his mistress. On his return, he had a functioning wave equation worked out.

CRC Press eBooks•Sep 21, 2022•0 citations

The wave properties of matter

P. Anthony Cox

This chapter examines the wave properties of matter. Early attempts to extend the quantum ideas to the theory of matter had some limited success, but did not progress very far. Another radical idea was required before a satisfactory theory could be developed. As light has both wave and particle properties, perhaps the same is true of 'ordinary' particles such as electrons. This bold suggestion was made by Louis de Broglie in 1923, and within a few years it had been confirmed experimentally. De Broglie's wave hypothesis formed the basis for Schrödinger's equation, which was found capable of predicting the allowed energy levels in atoms and molecules, and must be regarded as one of the most important mathematical equations of modern science. Before discussing these ideas, the chapter begins by considering the classical mechanics of particles, reviewing some simple concepts that form an essential background to the quantum theory of matter.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jan 25, 1996•0 citations

Comments on the Basis of Wave Mechanics

Mohamed Ashraf Farouk

Copenhagen physicists said; The electronics that we use today-radio, televisions, computers, lasers, MRI machines GPS-communications- depend on calculations using Schrodinger’s equation plus a lot of other Mathematics and Measurements, our idea of “shut up and calculate” has worked very well for us technologically. My comment’s these technological achievements do not justify that the equation itself as (I will try show) has any true scientific basis. In 1925, Erwin Schrodinger wrote excitingly to Einstein. “I have been intensely concerned these days with Louis de Broglie’s theory [1]. It is extraordinary, exciting, but still has some very grave difficulties”. So regardless of you are consider Schrodinger’s equation is a fundamental equation (has no derivation from simples forms) or derived one, you cannot deny first that Schrodinger’s equation is a wave equation and second it is shows how (de Broglie hypothesis of) matter wave change with time. i.e. Schrodinger equation describe the evaluation of the physical system in which the quantum effects, the “Wave-particle” duality are significant.

Research & Development in Material Science•Nov 10, 2020•0 citations

A few reasons why Louis de Broglie discovered matter waves and yet did not discover Schrödinger’s equation

Olivier Darrigol

In 1923 Louis de Broglie arrived at a shocking notion of matter waves through reasoning so forceful that Albert Einstein and a few quantum experts took it seriously. The purpose of this paper is to analyze de Broglie's discovery and to show how some of his heuristics prevented him to introduce the equation that now bears Schrödinger’s name.

ESI lectures in mathematics and physics•Apr 11, 2013•1 citation
Unpublished letters of late 1925 between Einstein and Schrödinger and the doctoral thesis of de Broglie reveal sources of Schrödinger’s inspiration to invent wave mechanics. Schrödinger saw a congenial similarity of de Broglie’s work on the stability of the atom with his own earlier speculation in relativity, which he noted to Einstein. But the last chapter of de Broglie’s thesis, on quantum statistics of gases, which is unfamiliar to many modern readers, provided Schrödinger with the method of treatment of a gas of material particles considered as a system of modes of vibration, of ’’matter waves.’’ This method especially, and other successes of de Broglie’s ’’ingenious thesis,’’ convinced Schrödinger to take seriously the first part, on the conditions of stability of the atom in a wave picture. Thus he sought and found an equation to describe the states of the electron from the matter-wave viewpoint.
During 1925 three different but equivalent versions of quantum theory were proposed, Schrodinger proposed wave mechanics; Heisenberg developed matrix mechanics and Dirac-introduced operator theory. Considering the de Broglie's matter waves Erwin Schrödinger, an Austrian physicist, argued that if a particle like an electron behaves as a wave then the equation of wave motion could be successfully applied to it. He postulated a function varying in both space and time in a wave-like manner. Schrodinger set up a linear and time-dependent wave-like equation, called Schrodinger wave equation, to describe the wave aspect of a particle taking account of de Broglie's relation for wavelength. This chapter discusses the Schrodinger equation and explores the general properties of the solution of the Schrodinger equation. It verifies the Ehrenfest's theorem in certain interesting systems and solves equation for linear harmonic oscillator and shows that their solutions are identical to the solutions of classical equation of motion.
Bohr’s theory of the atom was in trouble as soon as it was formulated. Further detailed spectroscopy studies encouraged a proliferation of quantum numbers and ‘selection rules’ in what became known as the Bohr–Sommerfeld model. It couldn’t last, and by 1925 the theory was in crisis. The immediate concern was with the quantum numbers themselves. Where did they come from? Could de Broglie’s hypothesis shed any light? In October 1925 the attentions of Erwin Schrödinger were drawn to a footnote in one of Einstein’s recent papers. Intrigued, Schrödinger acquired a copy of de Broglie’s PhD thesis. Although he eventually published a more obscure derivation, Schrödinger essentially applied the de Broglie relation to the classical equation of wave motion. He applied the result to the hydrogen atom, and showed that the quantum numbers emerge ‘in the same natural way as the integers specifying the number of nodes in a vibrating string’.
In 1924, a young PhD student submitted a thesis containing the germ of an idea that would revolutionize our understanding of the material world. The student was Louis De Broglie, and for a while, he had been meditating on the wave/particle nature of light. De Broglie’s ideas were greeted rather sceptically at first. His PhD supervisor even asked for a second copy so he could send it to Einstein for his opinion. Einstein gave the work his seal of approval. News of De Broglie’s thesis spread around the physics community from 1924 to 1925. In autumn 1925, Erwin Schrodinger was visiting colleagues in Switzerland and was asked to present a summary of De Broglie’s work. Having studied De Broglie’s thesis in some detail he became an enthusiastic supporter. During the Christmas and New Year of 1925/1926, Schrodinger holidayed in the Alps with his mistress. On his return, he had a functioning wave equation worked out.
This chapter examines the wave properties of matter. Early attempts to extend the quantum ideas to the theory of matter had some limited success, but did not progress very far. Another radical idea was required before a satisfactory theory could be developed. As light has both wave and particle properties, perhaps the same is true of 'ordinary' particles such as electrons. This bold suggestion was made by Louis de Broglie in 1923, and within a few years it had been confirmed experimentally. De Broglie's wave hypothesis formed the basis for Schrödinger's equation, which was found capable of predicting the allowed energy levels in atoms and molecules, and must be regarded as one of the most important mathematical equations of modern science. Before discussing these ideas, the chapter begins by considering the classical mechanics of particles, reviewing some simple concepts that form an essential background to the quantum theory of matter.
Copenhagen physicists said; The electronics that we use today-radio, televisions, computers, lasers, MRI machines GPS-communications- depend on calculations using Schrodinger’s equation plus a lot of other Mathematics and Measurements, our idea of “shut up and calculate” has worked very well for us technologically. My comment’s these technological achievements do not justify that the equation itself as (I will try show) has any true scientific basis. In 1925, Erwin Schrodinger wrote excitingly to Einstein. “I have been intensely concerned these days with Louis de Broglie’s theory [1]. It is extraordinary, exciting, but still has some very grave difficulties”. So regardless of you are consider Schrodinger’s equation is a fundamental equation (has no derivation from simples forms) or derived one, you cannot deny first that Schrodinger’s equation is a wave equation and second it is shows how (de Broglie hypothesis of) matter wave change with time. i.e. Schrodinger equation describe the evaluation of the physical system in which the quantum effects, the “Wave-particle” duality are significant.