Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Revista Brasileira de Ensino de Física

On time derivatives for <X^> and <p^>: formal 1D calculations

Salvatore De Vincenzo

Published Jun 1, 2013• 4 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We present formal 1D calculations of the time derivatives of the mean values of the position (x) and momentum (p) operators in the coordinate representation. We call these calculations formal because we do not care for the appropriate class of functions on which the involved (self-adjoint) operators and some of its products must act. Throughout the paper, we examine and discuss in detail the conditions under which two pairs of relations involving these derivatives (which have been previously published) can be formally equivalent. We show that the boundary terms present in d{x}/dt and d{x}/dt can be written so that they only depend on the values taken there by the probability density, its spatial derivative, the probability current density and the external potential V= V9 (x) V = V(x). We also show that d(p)/dt is equal to -dv /dx=(FQ) plus a boundary term (Fq = aQ/ax)is the quantum force and Q is the Bohm's quantum potential). We verify that (fq) is simply obtained by evaluating a certain quantity on each end of the interval containing the particle and by subtracting the two results. That quantity is precisely proportional to the integrand of the so-called Fisher information in some particular cases. We have noted that fQ has a significant role in situations in which the particle is confined to a region, even if V is zero inside that region.

DOI
10.1590/s1806-11172013000200008

Related papers

Operators and bilinear densities in the Dirac formal 1D Ehrenfest theorem

Salvatore De Vincenzo

We calculate formal time derivatives of the mean values of the standard position, velocity, and mechanical momentum operators, i. e., the Ehrenfest theorem for a one-dimensional Dirac particle in the coordinate representation.We show that these derivatives contain boundary terms that essentially depend on the values taken there by characteristic bilinear densities.We do not automatically take the boundary terms to vanish (as is usually done); nevertheless, we relate the boundary terms to similar terms that must be zero if one requires the hermiticity of certain specific unbounded operators.Throughout the article, we thoroughly discuss and illustrate all these aspects, which include the relations to certain boundary conditions.To clarify, we call our approach formal because all operations involving operators (for example, some operators products) are performed without respecting the restrictions imposed by the sets of functions on which the self-adjoint operators can act.Moreover, the Dirac Hamiltonian that we consider in our calculations contains a potential that is the time component of a Lorentz two-vector; nevertheless, we also obtain and concisely discuss the Ehrenfest theorem for a Hamiltonian with the most general Lorentz potential in (1+1) dimensions.

Journal of Physical Studies•Jan 1, 2015•7 citations

Translational Properties, Velocity Field and Fisher Information in Quantum Mechanics

Francesco R. Ruggeri

A process exists in the literature (1) of creating an information term based on Fisher’s information using spatial density P and adding it to a classical Lagrangian based on a velocity field i.e. velocity=dS/dx. Maximization of S and P is performed and a differential equation in terms of spatial density and S is obtained. Finally, it is noted that a change of variables: W= sqrt(p) exp(iS/hbar) may simplify the differential equation so that it becomes the Schrodinger equation with W as the wavefunction. In this note, we consider the wavefunction as appearing “naturally” as a normalization constant when using conditional probability and argue that W is the velocity field. Given that the Schrodinger equation includes a term of the form -1/2m d/dx d/dx W (in 1-D) i.e. the first derivative is related to the average velocity and the second to the ensemble average of p*p. This follows because unnormalized conditional probability f(p,x) is the Fourier basis function i.e. exp(ipx). The second derivative term - 1/2m d/dx d/dx W may be obtained from a Lagrangian containing (d/dxW) (d/dx W), thus formally one may use maximization to obtain the Schrodinger equation at a level using W directly. The maximization form, however, is identical to the “classical translational” form (2) of Fisher’s information. Thus, it seems that the Fourier basis exp(ipx) and the maximization of classical translational Fisher’s information are linked. In this note, we wish to investigate this in further detail. We also use translational properties together with conditional probability to show that f(p,x) where P(p/x)= a(p) f(p/x) / [Sum over p a(p) f(p/x)] is exp(ipx). In particular, we obtain an equation taken from the translation of the conservation of energy equation at point x to x+delta x. This links df(p,x)/dx with -dV/dx (the force). If the force is stochastic and yields “k” momentum hits, -dV/dx= Sum over k kVk(x). We argue that df(p,x)/dx also brings out this k term i.e. is an eigenfunction of k i.e. -idf(p,x)/dx =k f(p,x) yields exp(ipx) as a solution. This f(p,x) is automatically an orthonormal basis (multiplied by an appropriate constant) and helps to show why the “momentum operator” is linked to a “translation operator” i.e. d/dx. The bound state Schrodinger equation is considered in this note.

•Jul 27, 2020•0 citations

Time Dependent Density and Stochastic Approaches to Quantum Mechanics

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In the literature, stochastic approaches employed to derive the Schrodinger equation seem to focus on the idea of a classical spatial density which depends on time and space ie. density(x,t). As a result, d/dt (partial) density appears in various equations such as the continuity and Focker Planck equations. At one point in the derivation the quantum wavefunction is introduced “mathematically” as W(x,t)=sqrt(density(x,t)) exp(i S(x,t)) where S is related to a velocity field through u(x,t)=velocity= d/dx S. From quantum mechanics, -Et becomes a term of S the velocity field. The stochastic/hydrodynamical approaches employ the term du/dt partial = d/dt (partial) d/dx S and then “pull out”” d/dx leaving d/dt (partial) S which yields -E average energy from the -Et term. In this note we argue that for a bound quantum state density(x) so d/dt (partial) density = 0, yet the statistical ideas of quantum mechanics should be present in such a case. Furthermore for the free particle wavefunction exp(ipx-iEt), density=1. In fact, the Schrodinger equation should follow for a free particle even the case of density=1. Stochastic processes seem to be based on equations which consider a change in classical spatial density at a point x in time due to flow in or out or stochastic changes. Quantum processes seem to deal with periodic probability changes from one dimension to another exp(ipx) (2 dimensions) which are somehow related to a physical process of momentum flow. Ultimately one links this process to an energy conservation which does not seem to be the same as a classical stochastic/hydrodynamical approach. In this note we argue that a free particle with a constant momentum p has periodic stochastic processes associated with it through its complex probability change in the region of its wavelength, but that these are linked to creating the momentum p. Furthermore momentum is linked to energy so we argue that the Schrodinger equation is a stochastic equation linking energy and momentum and that time and space are separated i.e. there is no situation of following a change in spatial density in time for a free particle with momentum p. For a bound state, one has a distribution of free particles, but again time is removed from the problem in the sense that it only appears in exp(-iEt) in the wavefunction to again establish a relationship between energy and average momentum and potential. There is again no nonzero d/dt (partial) density term which seems to be key in stochastic equations. Only if one takes a linear combination of energy eigenstates Sum over En an(En) exp(-iEnt) Wn(x) does one obtain the form density(x,t), but we argue that quantum features should already appear in exp(ipx) and the bound state scenario with a zero d/dt (partial) density(x,t). We argue, however, that the Schrodinger equation and fundamental stochastic ideas of quantum mechanics should already be present at the level of exp(ipx).

•Nov 2, 2021•0 citations

Time-dependent momentum expectation values from different quantum probability and flux densities

Thomas Schaupp, Klaus Renziehausen, Ingo Barth +1 more

Based on the Ehrenfest theorem, the time-dependent expectation value of a momentum operator can be evaluated equivalently in two ways. The integrals appearing in the expressions are taken over two different functions. In one case, the integrand is the quantum mechanical flux density j̲, and in the other, a different quantity j̲̃ appears, which also has the units of a flux density. The quantum flux density j̲ is related to the probability density ρ via the continuity equation, and j̲̃ may as well be used to define a density ρ̃ that fulfills a continuity equation. Employing a model for the coupled dynamics of an electron and a proton, we document the properties of the densities and flux densities. It is shown that although the mean momentum derived from the two quantities is identical, the various functions exhibit a very different coordinate and time-dependence. In particular, it is found that the flux density j̲̃ directly monitors temporal changes in the probability density, and the density ρ̃ carries information about wave packet dispersion occurring in different spatial directions.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Feb 11, 2021•7 citations

Probability Tangles and Eigenstates of One-dimensional Potentials

Pranawa C. Deshmukh

The belief that there is only one truth, and that oneself is in possession of it, is the root of all evil in the world. —Max Born In this chapter, we build on the principles of quantum mechanics introduced in the previous two chapters to apply the same to physical situations. First, we shall address simple one-dimensional physical problems. These would involve single particles interacting with a potential. 3.1 Probability Current Density We have learned in Chapter 1 that if represents an energy eigenstate, then it is stationary and its time dependence is described by (Eqs. 1.114a,b and Eq. 1.115). The contribution of this term to the integrand in Eq. 1.109 and in Eq. 1.111a,b is essentially unity, no matter what the value of time t is. In this case, the probability density becomes independent of time. However, in other cases, the probability density, and hence the probability of finding a particle represented by the state vector within a volume element about the position, is time dependent. It then becomes necessary to determine The partial derivative with respect to time of the product of the wavefunction and its complex conjugate requires, which is available from the time-dependent Schrödinger equation. Also required is, which is readily obtainable from its complex conjugation. The result of the Solved Problem P3.1 at the end of this chapter, viz., has exactly the same form as the equation of continuity in fluid dynamics and also in electrodynamics (Eq. 10.26 and Eq. 13.71c in Reference [1]). In the above equation, or writing the same compactly, with the arguments implicit, In terms of the momentum operator, and it is called as the probability current density vector. Its integral over the whole space gives us where is the expectation value of the momentum operator at the instant t . The dimensions of the probability current density vector are L -2 T -1 . Notwithstanding the above relations, the probability current density vector at a point is not directly measurable. It would not be appropriate to equate it to the average particle flux at a point at a specific instant of time, though such an interpretation can sometimes be useful.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 14, 2023•0 citations

Consequences of a Particle at X and a Force Acting Over dx and Quantum Mechanics

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Classical Newtonian mechanics separates a particle (effect) from a force (cause). A particle has properties at a given x (and time t), but if it interacts with a force, this interaction occurs over dt and dx. Given that many forces do not change in time, we argue that a notion of a force is inseparable from the idea of dx. If one gives the value of a force at x, this value acts within a dx, which in Newtonian mechanics tends to 0. We have argued before that a particle with momentum represents a force or impulse itself, but at the same time may receive impulse hits from other sources (e.g. a Newtonian force -dV/dx). If a particle represents a force(impulse) it should be inseparable from the notion of dx, even if it has a constant p (momentum) and is traveling through space. Thus the idea of a momentum defining an internal ruler gradation through a probability distribution in x which we have presented in previous notes is compatible with the idea of describing a particle as a force. If one only considers a particle as an effect, there would be no need to worry about dx until a force(x) appears. An internal dx is not defined by an external ruler and does not need to tend to 0 as in Newtonian mechanics. Rather it is statistical in nature as p is a fixed impulse, but the probability to be at different x points within dx (called a wavelength) differ. In (1) we compared a classical Maxwell-Boltzmann gas to a quantum free particle. We argued that d/d density Pressure = RT = average pressure of a particle. We suggested this is analogous to the quantum free particle situation: (-id/dx probability(p,x) ) / probability(p,x) = p where probability(p,x) is unnormalized. In other words a change in a probability yields a deterministic value p. The notion of a deterministic value p associated with a probability distribution in what would be another deterministic variable x in Newtonian mechanics (except now one has a dx distribution because the particle is a force/impulse) has consequences. If one wishes to have a particle sit at x=0, say in an oscillator system, one needs to use a wavelength which is fairly small and centered at x=0. The wavelength, however, is associated with momentum and even being small spreads out from x=0 meaning there is potential energy .5kxx as well. Thus one may use an ensemble of forces/impulses Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) to create a “dx” about x=0, but at the same time this ensemble represents an average particle (defined at x with prms(x)) which must satisfy KE(x) + V(x) = En i.e. the classical conservation expression. In other words, one sees again that average statistical quantities may behave as deterministic ones.

•Apr 27, 2023•0 citations
We present formal 1D calculations of the time derivatives of the mean values of the position (x) and momentum (p) operators in the coordinate representation. We call these calculations formal because we do not care for the appropriate class of functions on which the involved (self-adjoint) operators and some of its products must act. Throughout the paper, we examine and discuss in detail the conditions under which two pairs of relations involving these derivatives (which have been previously published) can be formally equivalent. We show that the boundary terms present in d{x}/dt and d{x}/dt can be written so that they only depend on the values taken there by the probability density, its spatial derivative, the probability current density and the external potential V= V9 (x) V = V(x). We also show that d(p)/dt is equal to -dv /dx=(FQ) plus a boundary term (Fq = aQ/ax)is the quantum force and Q is the Bohm's quantum potential). We verify that (fq) is simply obtained by evaluating a certain quantity on each end of the interval containing the particle and by subtracting the two results. That quantity is precisely proportional to the integrand of the so-called Fisher information in some particular cases. We have noted that fQ has a significant role in situations in which the particle is confined to a region, even if V is zero inside that region.
We calculate formal time derivatives of the mean values of the standard position, velocity, and mechanical momentum operators, i. e., the Ehrenfest theorem for a one-dimensional Dirac particle in the coordinate representation.We show that these derivatives contain boundary terms that essentially depend on the values taken there by characteristic bilinear densities.We do not automatically take the boundary terms to vanish (as is usually done); nevertheless, we relate the boundary terms to similar terms that must be zero if one requires the hermiticity of certain specific unbounded operators.Throughout the article, we thoroughly discuss and illustrate all these aspects, which include the relations to certain boundary conditions.To clarify, we call our approach formal because all operations involving operators (for example, some operators products) are performed without respecting the restrictions imposed by the sets of functions on which the self-adjoint operators can act.Moreover, the Dirac Hamiltonian that we consider in our calculations contains a potential that is the time component of a Lorentz two-vector; nevertheless, we also obtain and concisely discuss the Ehrenfest theorem for a Hamiltonian with the most general Lorentz potential in (1+1) dimensions.
A process exists in the literature (1) of creating an information term based on Fisher’s information using spatial density P and adding it to a classical Lagrangian based on a velocity field i.e. velocity=dS/dx. Maximization of S and P is performed and a differential equation in terms of spatial density and S is obtained. Finally, it is noted that a change of variables: W= sqrt(p) exp(iS/hbar) may simplify the differential equation so that it becomes the Schrodinger equation with W as the wavefunction. In this note, we consider the wavefunction as appearing “naturally” as a normalization constant when using conditional probability and argue that W is the velocity field. Given that the Schrodinger equation includes a term of the form -1/2m d/dx d/dx W (in 1-D) i.e. the first derivative is related to the average velocity and the second to the ensemble average of p*p. This follows because unnormalized conditional probability f(p,x) is the Fourier basis function i.e. exp(ipx). The second derivative term - 1/2m d/dx d/dx W may be obtained from a Lagrangian containing (d/dxW) (d/dx W), thus formally one may use maximization to obtain the Schrodinger equation at a level using W directly. The maximization form, however, is identical to the “classical translational” form (2) of Fisher’s information. Thus, it seems that the Fourier basis exp(ipx) and the maximization of classical translational Fisher’s information are linked. In this note, we wish to investigate this in further detail. We also use translational properties together with conditional probability to show that f(p,x) where P(p/x)= a(p) f(p/x) / [Sum over p a(p) f(p/x)] is exp(ipx). In particular, we obtain an equation taken from the translation of the conservation of energy equation at point x to x+delta x. This links df(p,x)/dx with -dV/dx (the force). If the force is stochastic and yields “k” momentum hits, -dV/dx= Sum over k kVk(x). We argue that df(p,x)/dx also brings out this k term i.e. is an eigenfunction of k i.e. -idf(p,x)/dx =k f(p,x) yields exp(ipx) as a solution. This f(p,x) is automatically an orthonormal basis (multiplied by an appropriate constant) and helps to show why the “momentum operator” is linked to a “translation operator” i.e. d/dx. The bound state Schrodinger equation is considered in this note.
In the literature, stochastic approaches employed to derive the Schrodinger equation seem to focus on the idea of a classical spatial density which depends on time and space ie. density(x,t). As a result, d/dt (partial) density appears in various equations such as the continuity and Focker Planck equations. At one point in the derivation the quantum wavefunction is introduced “mathematically” as W(x,t)=sqrt(density(x,t)) exp(i S(x,t)) where S is related to a velocity field through u(x,t)=velocity= d/dx S. From quantum mechanics, -Et becomes a term of S the velocity field. The stochastic/hydrodynamical approaches employ the term du/dt partial = d/dt (partial) d/dx S and then “pull out”” d/dx leaving d/dt (partial) S which yields -E average energy from the -Et term. In this note we argue that for a bound quantum state density(x) so d/dt (partial) density = 0, yet the statistical ideas of quantum mechanics should be present in such a case. Furthermore for the free particle wavefunction exp(ipx-iEt), density=1. In fact, the Schrodinger equation should follow for a free particle even the case of density=1. Stochastic processes seem to be based on equations which consider a change in classical spatial density at a point x in time due to flow in or out or stochastic changes. Quantum processes seem to deal with periodic probability changes from one dimension to another exp(ipx) (2 dimensions) which are somehow related to a physical process of momentum flow. Ultimately one links this process to an energy conservation which does not seem to be the same as a classical stochastic/hydrodynamical approach. In this note we argue that a free particle with a constant momentum p has periodic stochastic processes associated with it through its complex probability change in the region of its wavelength, but that these are linked to creating the momentum p. Furthermore momentum is linked to energy so we argue that the Schrodinger equation is a stochastic equation linking energy and momentum and that time and space are separated i.e. there is no situation of following a change in spatial density in time for a free particle with momentum p. For a bound state, one has a distribution of free particles, but again time is removed from the problem in the sense that it only appears in exp(-iEt) in the wavefunction to again establish a relationship between energy and average momentum and potential. There is again no nonzero d/dt (partial) density term which seems to be key in stochastic equations. Only if one takes a linear combination of energy eigenstates Sum over En an(En) exp(-iEnt) Wn(x) does one obtain the form density(x,t), but we argue that quantum features should already appear in exp(ipx) and the bound state scenario with a zero d/dt (partial) density(x,t). We argue, however, that the Schrodinger equation and fundamental stochastic ideas of quantum mechanics should already be present at the level of exp(ipx).
Based on the Ehrenfest theorem, the time-dependent expectation value of a momentum operator can be evaluated equivalently in two ways. The integrals appearing in the expressions are taken over two different functions. In one case, the integrand is the quantum mechanical flux density j̲, and in the other, a different quantity j̲̃ appears, which also has the units of a flux density. The quantum flux density j̲ is related to the probability density ρ via the continuity equation, and j̲̃ may as well be used to define a density ρ̃ that fulfills a continuity equation. Employing a model for the coupled dynamics of an electron and a proton, we document the properties of the densities and flux densities. It is shown that although the mean momentum derived from the two quantities is identical, the various functions exhibit a very different coordinate and time-dependence. In particular, it is found that the flux density j̲̃ directly monitors temporal changes in the probability density, and the density ρ̃ carries information about wave packet dispersion occurring in different spatial directions.
The belief that there is only one truth, and that oneself is in possession of it, is the root of all evil in the world. —Max Born In this chapter, we build on the principles of quantum mechanics introduced in the previous two chapters to apply the same to physical situations. First, we shall address simple one-dimensional physical problems. These would involve single particles interacting with a potential. 3.1 Probability Current Density We have learned in Chapter 1 that if represents an energy eigenstate, then it is stationary and its time dependence is described by (Eqs. 1.114a,b and Eq. 1.115). The contribution of this term to the integrand in Eq. 1.109 and in Eq. 1.111a,b is essentially unity, no matter what the value of time t is. In this case, the probability density becomes independent of time. However, in other cases, the probability density, and hence the probability of finding a particle represented by the state vector within a volume element about the position, is time dependent. It then becomes necessary to determine The partial derivative with respect to time of the product of the wavefunction and its complex conjugate requires, which is available from the time-dependent Schrödinger equation. Also required is, which is readily obtainable from its complex conjugation. The result of the Solved Problem P3.1 at the end of this chapter, viz., has exactly the same form as the equation of continuity in fluid dynamics and also in electrodynamics (Eq. 10.26 and Eq. 13.71c in Reference [1]). In the above equation, or writing the same compactly, with the arguments implicit, In terms of the momentum operator, and it is called as the probability current density vector. Its integral over the whole space gives us where is the expectation value of the momentum operator at the instant t . The dimensions of the probability current density vector are L -2 T -1 . Notwithstanding the above relations, the probability current density vector at a point is not directly measurable. It would not be appropriate to equate it to the average particle flux at a point at a specific instant of time, though such an interpretation can sometimes be useful.
Classical Newtonian mechanics separates a particle (effect) from a force (cause). A particle has properties at a given x (and time t), but if it interacts with a force, this interaction occurs over dt and dx. Given that many forces do not change in time, we argue that a notion of a force is inseparable from the idea of dx. If one gives the value of a force at x, this value acts within a dx, which in Newtonian mechanics tends to 0. We have argued before that a particle with momentum represents a force or impulse itself, but at the same time may receive impulse hits from other sources (e.g. a Newtonian force -dV/dx). If a particle represents a force(impulse) it should be inseparable from the notion of dx, even if it has a constant p (momentum) and is traveling through space. Thus the idea of a momentum defining an internal ruler gradation through a probability distribution in x which we have presented in previous notes is compatible with the idea of describing a particle as a force. If one only considers a particle as an effect, there would be no need to worry about dx until a force(x) appears. An internal dx is not defined by an external ruler and does not need to tend to 0 as in Newtonian mechanics. Rather it is statistical in nature as p is a fixed impulse, but the probability to be at different x points within dx (called a wavelength) differ. In (1) we compared a classical Maxwell-Boltzmann gas to a quantum free particle. We argued that d/d density Pressure = RT = average pressure of a particle. We suggested this is analogous to the quantum free particle situation: (-id/dx probability(p,x) ) / probability(p,x) = p where probability(p,x) is unnormalized. In other words a change in a probability yields a deterministic value p. The notion of a deterministic value p associated with a probability distribution in what would be another deterministic variable x in Newtonian mechanics (except now one has a dx distribution because the particle is a force/impulse) has consequences. If one wishes to have a particle sit at x=0, say in an oscillator system, one needs to use a wavelength which is fairly small and centered at x=0. The wavelength, however, is associated with momentum and even being small spreads out from x=0 meaning there is potential energy .5kxx as well. Thus one may use an ensemble of forces/impulses Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) to create a “dx” about x=0, but at the same time this ensemble represents an average particle (defined at x with prms(x)) which must satisfy KE(x) + V(x) = En i.e. the classical conservation expression. In other words, one sees again that average statistical quantities may behave as deterministic ones.