In frustrated magnetic systems with a subextensive number of classical ground states, quantum zero-point fluctuations can select a unique long-range ordered state, a celebrated phenomenon referred to as order by quantum disorder (ObQD). For frustrated spin-1/2 models, unbiased numerical methods able to expose ObQD are necessary. We show that ObQD can be identified from exact diagonalization calculations through an analysis akin to the Anderson tower of states associated with spontaneous symmetry breaking. By defining an effective quantum rotor model, we describe the competition between ObQD-induced localization of the rotor and its tunneling between symmetry-related ground states, identifying the crossover length scale from the finite-size regime where the rotor is delocalized to the infinite system-size limit where it becomes localized. This rotor model relates the characteristic splittings in the exact diagonalization energy spectrum to the ObQD selection energy scale, providing an estimate that can be compared to spin wave calculations. We demonstrate the general applicability of this approach in one-, two-, and three-dimensional frustrated spin models that exhibit ObQD.
In magnetically ordered systems, the breaking of SU(2) symmetry in the thermodynamic limit is associated with the appearance of a special type of low-lying excitations in finite-size energy spectra, the so-called tower of states (TOS). In the present work, we numerically demonstrate that there is a correspondence between the SU(2) tower of states and the lower part of the ground-state entanglement spectrum (ES). Using state-of-the-art density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) calculations, we examine the ES of the 2D antiferromagnetic
J1-
J2 Heisenberg model on both the triangular and kagome lattice. At large ferromagnetic
J2, the model exhibits a magnetically ordered ground state. Correspondingly, its ES contains a family of low-lying levels that are reminiscent of the energy tower of states. Their behavior (level counting, finite-size scaling in the thermodynamic limit) sharply reflects TOS features, and is characterized in terms of an effective entanglement Hamiltonian that we provide. At large system sizes, TOS levels are divided from the rest by an entanglement gap. Our analysis suggests that (TOS) entanglement spectroscopy provides an alternative tool for detecting and characterizing SU(2)-broken phases using DMRG.
The ground-state parameters of the two-dimensional
S=1/2 antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model are calculated using the stochastic series expansion quantum Monte Carlo method for $L\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}L$ lattices with
L up to
16. The finite-size results for the energy
E, the sublattice magnetization
M, the long-wavelength susceptibility ${\ensuremath{\chi}}_{\ensuremath{\perp}}(q=2\ensuremath{\pi}/L)$, and the spin stiffness ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{s},$ are extrapolated to the thermodynamic limit using fits to polynomials in
1/L, constrained by scaling forms previously obtained from renormalization-group calculations for the nonlinear $\ensuremath{\sigma}$ model and chiral perturbation theory. The results are fully consistent with the predicted leading finite-size corrections, and are of sufficient accuracy for extracting also subleading terms. The subleading energy correction $(\ensuremath{\sim}{1/L}^{4})$ agrees with chiral perturbation theory to within a statistical error of a few percent, thus providing numerical confirmation of the finite-size scaling forms to this order. The extrapolated ground- state energy per spin is $E=\ensuremath{-}0.669437(5)$. The result from previous Green's function Monte Carlo (GFMC) calculations is slightly higher than this value, most likely due to a small systematic error originating from ``population control'' bias in GFMC. The other extrapolated parameters are
M=0.3070(3), ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{s}=0.175(2)$, ${\ensuremath{\chi}}_{\ensuremath{\perp}}=0.0625(9)$, and the spin-wave velocity
c=1.673(7). The statistical errors are comparable with those of previous estimates obtained by fitting loop algorithm quantum Monte Carlo data to finite-temperature scaling forms. Both
M and ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{s}$ obtained from the finite-
T data are, however, a few error bars higher than the present estimates. It is argued that the
T=0 extrapolations performed here are less sensitive to effects of neglected higher-order corrections, and therefore should be more reliable.
Using results for the 4 × 4 and 6 × 6 lattice, we produce the first finite-size scaling analysis of the frustrated Heisenberg model in two dimensions. The results indicate a continuous phase transition from the ordered phase into an intermediate phase without long-range magnetic order, as for the (2 + 1)-dimensional nonlinear sigma-model. The intermediate phase is stable for 0.4 < J2/J1 < 0.65 and exhibits either dimerization or broken chiral symmetry. The transition to the collinear phase at J2/J1 0.65 is apparently of first order.
Elementary excitations of ordered quantum magnets are harmonic spin waves. Yet, when ordering breaks a continuous symmetry, excitations at zero momentum cannot really be treated as harmonic, because they correspond to the Goldstone mode that restores the symmetry in finite-size systems. Here, the authors show that zero-momentum excitations can be treated in a fully nonlinear way in terms of a macroscopic spin variable (the rotor): its spectrum reconstructs the so-called Anderson tower of states, a hallmark of continuous-symmetry breaking systems. The rotor variable can be considered as nearly separate from finite-momentum spin waves, leading to a quantitative reconstruction of the low-energy excitation spectrum of finite-size systems.